If you're looking for a good old school pizza joint, check this place out. We stopped by with some…read morehungry baseball players. We ordered buffalo wings, cheese, pepperoni, meat lovers and taco pizzas all so good. On the thinner end for crust which we like. Taco came with salsa, sour cream and guacamole. Also got a small salad bar. Bowl is small but I packed quite a bit in and the lettuce was very fresh and crisp which is rare. The service was great she did an amazing job and was very attentive. Would recommend

Nothing beats the salad bar from Magic's. Service is always amazing and helpful. The breakfast is…read morealways a great option as well....the hash browns are so crispy. True staple in Selah! Also love the daily specials and the riddles they have on their whiteboard inside.

FAKE POKEMON CARDS I…read morewent to one dollar wing Wednesday on September 16, 2026. Granted the food was delicious and it Was worth the six dollars but this fucking place is fucking fake Pokémon cards don't buy them

I passed this place by last time I was in town in favor of MOD…read more Back again, I figured I owed this place a shot. Service: The evening I came in, there was only person working. Taking orders, making food, boxing to go orders and dropping off when prepared. You can imagine this delayed the process. So 25 min to get my wings and another 5 for the pizza. The kid was calm, cool and collected; so he had it all under control, but it was just too slow to be a one man operation with a limited menu. Food: This is just shameful. You have wood burning oven and you are putting out thick crusted, no taste pies! The sausage was frozen brought in, no better than any other chain or competitor. The saddest part was the crust: way too think to properly cook in such an oven. Then we move to wings. Chicken or pigeon? Could be eithe, since they were so small. Tossed in a nice sauce, but cooked in the oven as well? Overall: I gave it a shot. Prices are fair for the pizza. Pizza is better than MOD, but not a truly authentically prepared wood fire pizza. Fix the prep, add staff and some fresh ingredients! You can't buy fresh sausage at the local market?

Loved that they have MTO pizza by the slice. Crispy crust, sauce and cheese was perfect. Well worth…read morethe stop.

We stopped here after a quick hike to Umtanum Falls. This wouldn't necessarily be a place to take a…read morelarge family as space is limited, but it was just fine for the two of us. It's not a fancy place by any means, but the pizza we ordered, called the Snicklefritz, was excellent!! The crust was thick and just the right degree of crispiness. The toppings included chicken, Alfredo sauce, green peppers, red onions, and cheese. It was tasty! And it went well with a nice cold can of Rainier. You have to take a key and walk a short distance outside to use the toilet, but it was clean. :) The pizza is definitely worth making a stop off of Hwy 12 whether you're heading in or out of town.

It's a good pizza, little spendier but so much more worth it ! Yum yum yum…read moreWestside !!!

We started out with a build your own pizza and realized it would be cheaper if we ordered a regular…read morepizza off of their menu and take away and add things that we wanted. We got the two medium special. The pizza was delicious. I am grateful for the fact that they had nondairy option for cheese. The staff was very friendly. He also helped us navigate through the menu to realize that we should go the route of getting the two medium special. We ate inside they provided cups togo boxes. Overall the atmosphere was amazing welcoming and the food was delicious .

Went to Kiln after my grandson's baseball game. There were lots of cars in the parking lot but…read morestill empty tables inside. We ordered the Dad Bod pizza, a salad, a Dark Persuasion stout , and a Guava cider. Everything was delicious. I also tried the RRR brown ale, but is was too hoppy for me. The staff was friendly and helpful with our beverage selections, This place is larger than it looks. Although there were lots of cars, there were still empty tables. There is a large outside patio area but it was a chilly evening do we opted for indoors. The setting is a modern chrome and black look. It was suite noisy. I think feed was a band outside but we couldn't hear it. All in all a pleasant experience.

Let me tell you how fucking disgusted i am with this establishment. My name is Michael Shultis. I…read moream an orthopedic physician assistant in yakima....have been for 14 years. Recently i started going through a breakup with my wife. I am also an artist andca writer. So....to relax after seeing 22 to 24 patients a day or replacing a shoulder or a knee in surgery....i enjoyed having a pint or two at the kiln. But....after playing a few games of pool tonight with some insecure little boys.... One of these boys accosted me after identifying himself as an employee of the kiln and screamed in my face repeatedly that "everyone in the kiln knows you are creep and are taking pictures of girls." Repeatedly at the top of his lungs. Somewhat slandering a highly respected medical provider in this community that is beyond reproach. So.....the entire crew at the kiln talk shit about the patrons paying their wages. Like going to a barber who talks lies behind your back. Or better yet.....a little baby's sandbox. I have seen this before many times. Owners no longer present and the staff think they own the place. Believe me......my lawyer will be in contact. Peace out.

I pick up Doordash orders here every now and then. They have wonderful customer service. They also…read morehave me a pizza bag to ensure their customers get hot food. Thanks for all you do.

Horrible I will never order again over priced pizza with no toppings. Delivery time is terrible and…read morepizza is always cold and shitty. Do no order from this place

We called in our order to pick up in the way into town. The pizza was delicious. We got a large…read moreto have leftovers & we only had 2 pieces left.

I went in person. This place was small but the staff were super friendly. It is a small family run…read morebusiness. The cashier was warm, friendly and very welcoming. Pricing was super reasonable - I ordered a small Hawaiian and a large fountain drink. The pizza was hot and freshly made while I waited. Pizza looked great and tasted decent. Overall 5 stars for customer service. And the food was decent. The sauce was a too bland to receive a 5 star but overall an amazing value for the price.

Had a big family gathering here to celebrate a couple birthdays. Wish I could tell you that the…read morepizza was good, but I didn't have any--I ate from the salad bar, which was super delicious! You'll just have to go and try the pizza yourself. What stood out the most was the young lady who took our order--Kayla. Kayla, your enthusiasm when greeting us and your genuine zest for making us feel welcomed made for the absolute best customer service! Keep it up!

Loved the veggie pizza. Large veggies versus tiny pieces. Great taste. Loved the salad bar. Great…read moreromaine mixture with lots of toppings to choose from. The cinnamon iced sticks are super good. Very nice staff.

We've been meaning to try this place out for quite some time and finally had a chance to. This is…read morean absolute little diamond in the rough in the spot we will be heading back to soon! They share space with the sportscenter bar, but effectively function separately in a space adjacent to it. They've got a small footprint with 3 or 4 total tables, about half a dozen taps and some higher proof options. The pizzas they serve here were really really good - Like way better than we expected them to be good! We grabbed a couple pizzas including the Avenue and a mona Lisa. And as previously stated, my expectations were for it to be good, but not incredible... And these were incredible! The crust was done really nicely, there were plenty of toppings, and overall it was just really nicely done pizza. Perhaps the biggest showstopper were the fried cheese curds. You need only take a two second look at me to understand that the love of cheese runs very deep. He's cheese curds for about as good as anything that I had back in the Midwest. The only place that I may have had better cheese curds is in Wisconsin, basically where cheese was born! We are excited to go back and try some of the other pizzas that are creative in name and topping. They've also got plenty of other good looking pizza alternatives. It's rather impressive and was more than I expected to see. This is a worth your trip spot to check out!

We had read their reviews and thought we would try out their pizza. The pizza was the toughest…read morepizza we have had, two of the pieces were burnt as this pizza was left in the oven too long, The pizza did not have a lot of flavor either. The price for a sixteen inch pizza was over $33.00, and that was the only item we purchased. Very disappointed! Too much money for a very tough pizza!