If you're looking for a good old school pizza joint, check this place out. We stopped by with some hungry baseball players. We ordered buffalo wings, cheese, pepperoni, meat lovers and taco pizzas all so good. On the thinner end for crust which we like. Taco came with salsa, sour cream and guacamole. Also got a small salad bar. Bowl is small but I packed quite a bit in and the lettuce was very fresh and crisp which is rare. The service was great she did an amazing job and was very attentive. Would recommend read more

Nothing beats the salad bar from Magic's. Service is always amazing and helpful. The breakfast is always a great option as well....the hash browns are so crispy. True staple in Selah! Also love the daily specials and the riddles they have on their whiteboard inside. read more

Very good food. Cheap & fast. I always get to go when I'm in town. I call ahead of time to put in my order. Very Delicious

Fantastic food. Beer selections is pretty decent for the area. Has a rustic traditional feel to the place. Service staff were extremely helpful and friendly. read more

Great service and the pizza was ready when expected. I ordered a pepperoni pizza large to go! I can't fully give 4 stars as I haven't dined in at the establishment. read more

This place has a Famous salad bar. But no bacon bits? You're completely absolutely insane

I love coming here for their salad bar! Great selection of toppings to choose from and I've never had awful service or attitude from any of the employees. That goes a long way in my book! Keep it up! read more

Absolutely terrible service and the food was disgusting. We all got food poisoning. Definitely do not recommend

We love Magic's! Pizza is consistently good, great crust and plenty of good toppina, the salad bar is awesome too! Great atmosphere for families, a local gem! read more

The service at this local pizza spot is amazing and the salad bar was ample and fresh. If you like thin, New York style crust with great taste, this is your place. We are still looking for great buffalo wings. Their sauce was sparce and mild but the wings were huge for the price and did need more cooking to be tender off the bone. The rustic, comfortable atmosphere made it a unique dining experience. read more

See all

I am not sure why we are always told they are not going to make any deliveries on the night we call? When we have someone else call and they are told yes they can deliver. We have gone in there and ordered quite a few times. I guess we need to find another place for our business. At one point the owner was so nice to us and really made my husband smile. We are not sure why the turn around? Going to miss the pizza.. The Hudson's read more

One of my favorite salad bars and yummy pizza. I get one not baked and take it camping for a great dinner.

June 17th 2023 my boyfriend my two grown daughters and their families we all went to magics this evening to celebrate my two granddaughters High School graduation we ordered pizza and three of us ordered a salad bar I was just going to get the small salad bar the waitress brought me the bowl and I could not believe my eyes the bull was the size of a small baby Bowl $6.95 my boyfriend told me to upgrade it so I upgraded it to a large sound which we got a plate I went to the salad bar and I could not believe my eyes there wasn't hardly anything to choose from there was green lettuce peas garbanzo beans carrots shredded cheese cucumbers dressing and macaroni salad there was no tomatoes no potato salad it was good but the price is ungodly way too high the larger salad was $10.75 and not much to choose from we ordered pizzas I was very very disappointed the crust of the pizza on the upper half of the Pizza was a little burnt we also ordered several sodas I ordered root beer the root beer was not root beer it was very light colored and it was not mixed properly there was no carbonation I told the waitress she went into the kitchen area supposedly she told somebody and they all said that it was fine no it was not fine so she offered to bring us some more soda which was fine at no charge I will not order pizza there again I will not order the salad bar there again the salad was fresh and very good but the price way too much they have wonderful sandwiches and wonderful hamburgers I do not recommend their Pizza and to top it all off my oldest daughter was overcharged from what she told me she ordered two pizzas two pictures of soda and a large salad her bill was $90 so she either got overcharged or she told me the wrong price I don't like to give bad reviews but they are only getting a three star do to the pizza and the soda the place is exceptionally clean and you get good service and everybody is friendly for the good service and the friendliness I give them five stars for the soda and the pizza I only give them between a two and a half to a three-star sorry people but we will not order pizza from you again read more

1 star for clean bathrooms, BUT after hearing all the hype about thos place I decided to take my family out there for lunch from union gap!!! Bad mistake, so salad bar is very minimal, and we got the mini pizza and salad bar, the bowls were like a small fruit dish so we decided to upgrade to all u can eat salad bar and mini pizza. The price went from 7.99 on their website to $14. Ok inflation food is expensive I get it, the to upgrade to just the salad all u can eat it went up $8 so became like $22 pp, ok that's ok whatever small business I don't mind giving a little more. BUT THEN we got the mini pizzas, they weren't a homemade crust like the bigger pizzas they were the premade frozen little pizzas like u buy in the store, with toppings added to it. Ot was 1/2raw still, no flavor, it was terrible for $22 pp I was upset. The staff there are not friendly in anyway they don't even check on u after getting ur meal, employees child run ING all around grabbing cups and cookies out of serving container, spilled stuff all over floor and mom didn't even bother to clean ot she got it more and left it to girl working!!! Cottage cheese was warm, other salads on bar were just thrown in there, salad bar was messy from everyone servi g themselves and was never wiped up. I don't recommend this place at all,and the bigger pizzas have no flavor in them. read more

I've been here a few times in the past and the food and salad bar were wonderful, too bad I can't say that anymore. The pizza was bland and very overpriced. The salad bar was nothing like it used to be. Food looked like it was already a few days old when put out. The worst part was the Italian dressing, in a plastic container at the end, tasted and smelled like, what I assume plastic would taste like and I had poured it on my salad. It was so gross, like it had been in that container for a very long time. We completely understand how Covid has impacted businesses, but a lot of this was just a lack of effort and it came through in the food. On top of this, the bill was ridiculous for what we got. Won't be eating there again any time soon. read more

there the best owners there could be and I would come here any chance I would get because the food was amazing

Love this local pizza place!! Always the best salad bar and pizza! A great local business to support!

Best salad on the planet. Pasta salad is unbeatable. And pizza is amazing. Service is great too. Good people and great food. I could eat it every day!!! read more

This is a pizza place in Selah. I have lived in Selah all my life and this has always been the best that I can find they put just enough of everything on there pizza and they have amazing mod sticks (breadsticks). They have a salad bar to die for. My dad used to work here. That is not the only reason I am giving this place 5 stars. I am being totally honest. I have known the owners for a very long time. I would totally recommend coming here!! read more

Great food, great service. I eat here often with my grandparents. My grandpa and I always split a bbq chicken pizza. I love those things read more

This is the hometown pizza shop in Selah. The decor inside is older but is not a turn off by any means. They have a pretty good salad bar that is very popular there'll be a good line at the salad bar anytime you come here at lunch, and at dinner time I suspect, although I've never eaten dinner here. Their menu consists mostly of different pizzas they'll make but they also have a pretty extensive cold or hot sandwich menu that you can basically build your own sandwich with. The service is quite a bit faster than most lunch places; you can get in and out of here in 20-25 minutes. read more

Pizza was gross. The sauce tasted so strongly of peppers you couldn't taste anything else. Toppings were sparse, the cheese etc was so thin you could see the crust on more than 2/3rds of the pizza. Of the nearly $50 in food our family of 4 purchased, we ate 4 bites. Won't go back. read more

Well I'll go 3 stars for ambiance and service. The pizza, though, not so much. I stopped in for lunch and got a personal size Canadian Bacon and pineapple with one trip to the salad bar. The salad bar was kinda sparse, plus the cucumbers and tomatoes were half slices, which is no problem if you have a knife, but trying to cut in quarters with a fork doesn't always work so well. I got my usual pizza choice. It was only fair in my opinion. I really was not impressed with the crust at all. It was very dry, no yeast flavor at all, and while thin (which I like) it was a bit too soggy. Very nice service, and a few guys from the plant I was working on were there (thought I recognized them, then when one slapped me on the shoulder and asked "how's our compressor running?" I knew it was them). I think a larger size pizza might have a better crust. read more

Friendly small town service. Pizza was proportionatly out of whack. way too much meat normally not a bad thing. Not enough cheese so other toppings dont stay on the pizza. The other thing was and always been the sauce it just taste wierd very very wierd. For that reason I stay away. read more

Always fresh salad bar. Nice people good pizza . Little outdated decor but would recomend.

We went there for a family members birthday party. We a party of 13. The pizza was really good. They staff was incredible. The salad bar was small but good. They held out cake and ice cream in the fridge for us until we were ready for it. The kids played at the mini arcade off to the side. Good times! read more

They customer service is great, and even though the pizza isn't fabulous, the mozzarella cheese sticks with Alfredo sauce, are AMAZING. I crave them weekly!!! read more

It's been years since I've been here for pizza and I have to say I was not disappointed. My husband and I ordered the magic combo not greasy at all loved the thin crust. The service was top notch. read more

Their pizza is a little bit different but I love it. Not nearly as greasy as other places such as Pizza Hut. What also makes this place so fantastic is their salad bar. They have the freshest lettuce and a great topping selection. If you go I recommend getting the salad and mini pizza special so you get a taste of both! read more