When the New York style crispy pepperoni pizza arrived, we took it to the table, anxious to eat. When we opened the box, we noticed all the cheese and toppings had slid all off to one side and was collected in the side of the box. We were very disappointed, but from past experiences when they've left things off the order at this store, it takes an eternity to get your stuff and we were starving. My wife said the pizza look like someone vomited on it and she said that I kind of agree, but I scraped the toppings out of the corner of the box and tried to spread the melted cheese back onto the pizza. Again, we were very hungry then I noticed the pizza was barely cut, and I had to get my pizza cutter and guess where to cut the pizza because the toppings had all slid off and you could not see any cut lines in The crust except for maybe two or three. The pizza was not good at all thank God I ordered cheese sticks, or we would not have had anything to eat. It's also Horrible that after a crappy experience, you can't even go back and take the tip off that you left so not only that I spend money on a pizza we could not eat 3/4 of I also left the person a tip for destroying my pizza. This is the third or fourth time I've had issues with this store and it has just about ruined Papa John's for me. Even if you do in-store pick up, there's always a problem with the order.
I wish I would've thought to take a picture of the darn thing because it was crazy. read more