Walked in to order so food to take to the bar around the corner. Was disappointed that there was not a meatball sub available. We tried the Italian instead which was a good size and had nice flavor. read more

Panzera's Pizza - Italian Sub - Pizza Near Me - Upper Arlington, Ohio

Absolutely love there pizza! It's as good as anybody's in town. It's a little bit of a drive for me and I'm out if the delivery area or I would get it more often it's definitely one of my favorites. Perfectly cooked everytime I love how they put the toppings under the cheese so you have hot melted cheese covering your toppings. Just delicious! read more

Panzera's Pizza - Great Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Upper Arlington, Ohio

See all

Purchased a large Pizza on 2/11/23 at the UA location and it was awesome. Tastes just like I remember from the 70's at the Grandview location. Watch out Tommies Pizza! Great crust, no skimming on the toppings, awesome cheese. Definitely going back. I seem to remember a Leonardo's pizza being at this location long, long ago. 60's? read more

This pizza is always the best! No matter how often we order every single time it's the same great taste. We highly recommend Panzeras Pizza.

Came here for the first time ever tonight. I was quoted 25-30 minutes so I showed up at the 30 minute mark and had to wait another 6 minutes. Whatever, it's fine. Fortunately for them I had snacked beforehand so I wasn't a hangry monster. The pizza was okay. I wasn't a huge fan of the crust, as the middle seemed too soft and doughy. It almost seemed like it needed to be cooked for a little longer. Not sure if maybe they pulled it out of the oven prematurely since they were running behind schedule. The end pieces had the best crust since it was slightly crispy. For what it is, I think it's a little pricey ($15 for large 1 topping). I'd be a way bigger fan of the pizza if it were closer to $10. That being said, this place is only a 2 minute drive from home with decent enough pizza so I'd come back out of convenience alone. Plus, I like to support local when I can. read more

Lg., 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 sausage. I usually prefer sg. a bit over pp., but in this case their pp. is better, but still a better sg. than the chains. Thin crust from homemade dough that doesn't seem to have any rise in it baked in a Blodgett oven with quality ingredients that beat any chain pizza around here. If anything, I'd have finished the pizza straight on the deck for the last 30 seconds to get it as well done as the top. Reheated very nicely later (425, 6 minutes on metal tray to crisp it), maybe even better than straight out of oven. Easy to miss & hidden on the side/back of a plaza, appears to be carryout only. The owner and other guy working were nice dudes. Maybe straighten up some of the magazine clutter on the front counter, but otherwise, a pizza I'd gladly eat again. read more

THE BEST PIZZA IN UPPER ARLINGTON... Carry out or delivery only (delivery on selected nights during the week - call and ask); no dine-in. Thin crust. Crispy pepperoni. Really good cheese. Acidic tomato sauce like my Italian grandmother used to make. Tasty toppings. I'm surprised by the inconsistent mix of reviews about this place on Yelp - we've ordered here dozens of times and always had great pizza and a friendly experience. A few things worth noting: DELIVERY - they only have a delivery guy certain nights (Wednesday - Saturday night?), and it costs $3.00. If you've been drinking on Friday or Saturday nights, definitely spend $3 instead of $10,000 on a DUI ... LOCATION - funny location "around back" in the little shopping center at the northeast corner of Fishinger & Riverside Drive. Literally around back - use your GPS or just drive around back and you'll see what I mean. Good stuff... read more

Pizza: It has a cracker crust, and generous amounts of toppings. Of all of the pizza places in the area, Panzera's is in my top 3! Location: It is around back of a shopping center- the pizza is takeout only. We've gone to the daily growl and enjoyed a beer (or 3) with the pizza. The business owners there are totally open to bringing pizza in. Personally, that's my favorite way to enjoy Panzera's. Service: This is a very small business. Every time I've picked up pizza from here, the owner is so friendly and shows genuine interest in his customers. I greatly appreciate how friendly he has been to his customers. read more

Very friendly owner, quality pie at an affordable price. Location is a little hard to find if you don't know where to look, but easy to access. read more

Great local pizza , great sauce and fresh toppings , dough is rolled fresh daily . Simple menu ! Exactly what a pizza shop should have . Got the deluxe salad and was not disappointed !! read more

2 1/2 stars. The pizza is fine. It's convenient if you're headed to the daily growler. I wouldn't go out of my way to get this pizza. They don't have fresh mushrooms and sausage is not crumbled. Sauce is okay. The hot peppers taste fresh read more

Love this place. The owner is always over the top in customer service. Really, the friendliest pizza owner I have ever met. Great, simple pizza, just the right cheese/sauce and baked to give you a chewy crust. Give them your business, you won't regret it! read more

Panzera's Pizza - Ham pizza - Pizza Near Me - Upper Arlington, Ohio

We Are Long Time UA Residents & I'm Not Sure How We Missed This Local Gem! I ordered a Fresh Garlic & Tomato Pie & my husband got A Pep & Sausage Pie w/extra Cheese.... They Are Excellent Pizzas! They were ready quickly & the customer service rep was friendly and went above & beyond for us! Offered to customize the handmade dough in the future ( I like mine thin). We will be back next weekend, For Sure! Thanks! Everyone should try'em! You won't be sorry!! LA Hodge:) read more

Panzera's Pizza - Excellent Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Upper Arlington, Ohio

See all

This Panzera's is small. Around the back side of a strip plaza in Upper Arlington. A big group of friends met at The Daily Growler for a birthday party. We got the munchies. Looked on Yelp, and this was the winner by distance. No Tables and chairs inside - it's an order/pick-up situation. The large Sausage/mushroom/green pepper had extra cheese. Good sauce - almost a hint of sweeter tomatoes. Good, sturdy crust. Hot and fresh out of the oven. A good price for the end results! read more

Panzera's Pizza - Sausage, shroom and green pepper! - Pizza Near Me - Upper Arlington, Ohio

Arrived from Chicago and tried it for the first time last week. Good pizza. I prefer a little crispier crust but taste and quality of ingredients was good. Owner was friendly when I went in and pizza was fresh and hot on the pick-up. I'll definitely order from them again. read more

Wow dinner was really bad tonight and we were really looking forward to it we went early Drove around Grandview for 15 minutes til they opened . my rigatoni was OK but my hubby's lasagna Was so bad he could not eat it . meatballs with sauce were so rubbery they bounced I'm not sure but I think they give us bocce balls by mistake so normally I love panzeras I don't know what happened tonight but such a complete disappointment read more

Panzera's earned a try for my weekly Friday night pizza. This location is hidden on the backside of a strip mall off of Riverside Dr right at the intersection of Fishinger. So note: Parking can get crazy.. especially with the opening of Daily Growler.. You may be driving around for a quick minute. The inside is so tiny... This is a carryout only, so not dine in spots for locals looking to chill. Not that pizza places need to have ambiance or anything, but man this place almost felt like it was falling apart. We ordered a Cheese pizza and a meatball sub. The Ugly: The Meatball sub had this weird sweetness to it. They claim they make the meatballs in house, which Kudos to them, but I totally did not dig it. Another Ugly: Infamous yelper BBJ once explained a pizza to be "White as a baby's a**" at another pizza establishment.....And this pizza unfortunately was just that. It was a tad undercooked for my likings crust wise. Yelpers may want to request "well done" when ordering, because that was my main disappointment. Other than that.. The toppings, sauces and everything was spot on perfect. I'd definitely return.. I know this place can do better from the other reviews I am reading, which is why I'm keeping the stars at "A-OK!" Another time, Panzera's! read more

Thin crust pizza with 5 star taste / consistency / aroma Have been a client for25 years and have never been disappointed Great management --- user friendly This Pie is literally worth the wait... BUON APPETITO read more

Worst pizza I have ever had from Panzera's, ordered extra cheese, so much for that and I think they ran out of sauce also. All of our employees said the same thing. Called and spoke with Carlo and he was not considerate that I/we were very unhappy customers. Last time for Panzera's read more

I've found my go-to pizza joint in UA. This place is as tucked away as you've read on other reviews, but it's well worth the effort to try to find it. The pizza was delicious. Don't have a suggested improvement to make. 1) Call to place your order 2) Go pick up your pizza 3) Take pizza home and eat it. 4) Congratulate yourself for getting a great pizza. read more

My wife and I ordered from Panzera's in Grandview for years. We moved about three miles from the UA location so we decided to try it. The pizza was awful and we were shocked. When my wife picked the pizza up, the employee first told her he put extra cheese on the pizza (which would normally be a great thing) and then proceeded to tell my wife that she ordered a lot of food. We ordered a large pizza and an Italian sub. When I opened the pizza, all I saw was an edge to edge brown layer of cheese. It had been over cooked on top but the bottom was under cooked. You could literally peel the entire layer of cheese off the pizza to show the toppings sitting in the sauce. We always over order so we have leftovers. We never finished the pizza. We threw it away. The sub was a soggy mess and barely edible. Next time I will remember to take a photo. Terrible experience and very disappointing. read more

My favorite pizza shop in the Upper Arlington area. Great pizza, super friendly service.

The pizza tasted very good. You could tell the dough, and sauce were homemade, with fresh toppings. Family owned business!!

My favorite is the Italian sub and the chef salad with the homemade dressing. You can go wrong with the pizzas either!

Love this pizza. Always hot, cooked perfectly and tastes great! proportions of crust/sauce/cheese/toppings match too.

Horrible customer service for a pizza place that is WAY better in Grandview. The guy that runs this place under-estimates on times, when you call for delievery he suggets you come pick it up instead, etc. Not worth it. read more

Gave our pizza away to wrong customer. Replaced it with a new one and then still made the complete wrong order. Pizzas were cold and staff was rude. I called and complained and the man raised his voice to me and hung up the phone. DO NOT support this "local" business. Hey do not take care of their customers and refuse to make anything correct. read more

First pizza in Columbus, moved here a month ago. So glad we chose Panzera's! Amazingly great pizza, plenty of toppings. The crust and sauce are homemade and delicious! No dining in, so we went down the mall to The Growlers for a been while we waited. The pizza was ready in 30 minutes as promised. One of the best pizzas I've had. Yum, yum. read more

Yummy! This small pizza joint is run by a friendly hard working local family. can't go wrong with the pepperoni as others have reviewed. Great quality for the price. Expect thinner rectangle cut pizza with fresh tasting sauce and nicely crisp crust and cheese. Will be back, its always nice to find a nice local small business establishment to support! read more

The pizza actually wasn't that bad, but I won't be ordering from here again so I can't give it high stars. While the pizza wasn't bad, it wasn't good enough to justify the price point. I also received the wrong pizza. When I called because my sausage pepperoni turned into a green olive mushroom they apologized and offered a refund. read more

Shows order online on Yelp, give it a shot no menu items available. Don't list yourself as order online if its not true!

Excellent pizza. I mainly go for the pepperoni. Never disappointed. Not always the fastest or cheapest, but way better than any of the chains. read more

Tried to order online via Yelp but no menu items are available for delivery. Headed to original Panzeras in Grandview, by car. Bummer

We decided to go back to Panzera's in UA, a favorite of ours from the past after getting awful pizzas from two other established UA places. We had a perfect pizza tonight from Panzera's, served by a friendly guy who cares about customer service and serving great pizza. If you are looking for delicious pizza and like to support small businesses instead of those huge pizza chains, Panzera's of UA is the place to go. Other reviews mentioned parking problems, but they have parking places clearly marked for Panzera's less than five feet from the door! read more

Great local UA pizza. Guy who owns it is super nice and works his ass off. Always in a great mood

I picked up our pizza & sub -- and saw that the shop is messy and not very clean. But hey, great food can come from a dive, right? Not this dive. The pizza and sub were both bland. And even though the friendly clerk asked if I wanted my crust crispy, it was very soggy and limp. Even though it's close to home, we'll keep driving further for better food. read more

The best pepperoni pizza around! Every time I call they are able to have my order ready in under 30 minutes and are spot on with their timing. I have never had to wait longer than expected. The staff are nice, attentive, and quick. The pricing is great for the quality you get. The only downside is the sometimes the parking is limited. Just thinking about this pizza makes my mouth water!!! read more

We love going here because the owner lives down the street from us. He is very friendly and always gives us great subs and pizza! My dad Pat loves going to him and supporting a wonderful local business. We highly recommend you try it! read more

The pizza is good and the owner is just a great guy who is always willing to talk to you on any subject.

Good food, great price, and great service. Say hello to Mr. Panzera if he is in. This will be your next choice of pizza places to go.