Pleasantly surprised on a lunchtime visit excellent service food was excellent. Service was excellent. The lunch was excellent as well The meat lovers pizza was excellent as well as the mac & cheese was over the top. Always loved the ambience even on a Saturday afternoon. The wait staff always makes our visits pleasant read more

Paisanos - Grilled chicken sandwich with sweet potato fries - Pizza Near Me - Southampton, Massachusetts

See all

Super quick and the veggie pizza is awesome. This place is a hidden gem. They also have a good buy one, get one deal.

I called and ordered a chicken Parmesan sub. My expectation was for slices of breaded chicken cutlets (perhaps deep-fried or oven baked) with cheese on a toasted grinder roll. I was asked if I wanted cheese peppers and onions and sauce. I thought it was odd about the option of peppers and onions, but of course I wanted sauce and cheese. When I opened the sandwich, there was no breading on the chicken. It was just chicken, sauce and cheese. The bread was soggy and the chicken was slipping out of the roll. And the cheese was waxy. When i called to inquire if I received someone else's order, I was told that that was how their chicken Parmesan comes. I'm just absolutely confused because nowhere have I ever heard chicken Parmesan is without breading. I was also told that if I wanted a chicken parm there "would be an up-charge". At that point I was even more confused because I had never been given that as an option nor it listed in the menu. There was also no offer by the staff rectify the situation. Needless to say, the grinder went uneaten. Tonights experience ($15 soggy slippery grinder) coupled with my husband's opinion of a very unsatisfying pizza (the last time we ordered from Paisano's) is enough yo seek out other places. It's just not worth it. read more

As always, we had a perfect experience last night. Chelsea was our server and she was friendly, attentive.., and the food was the best. The four of us each had a different meal and we were all impressed. The best chicken parm. I have ever had, the sauce is out of this world. We will continue to go back! 3/1/26 read more

The service was outstanding and the food was excellent. The decor of the restaurant was unique, and helped make this a wonderful first visit! read more

A very classic American Italian restaurant. The staff is very welcoming. Most of the food is made to order and you can taste it. The consistency of the sauce and texture of the pasta were amazing. The portions here are really big so be prepared to eat. This is a great place to bring your family for dinner! read more

Paisanos - Chicken Carbonara with Zitti - Pizza Near Me - Southampton, Massachusetts

See all

Love the pizza here. Best pizza in Southampton by far. The tomato sauce is great, cheese is great, good crust. Staff are friendly.

I have eaten here so many times, I cannot believe I have not written a review yet! This is actually a favorite of my boyfriend's kids, and it has become a family favorite of mine. They always have great table service and are super efficient even when they are at full capacity. Not that this a great time to discuss this, but they have an amazing side room if you have a family event. Although grim, this seems to be the place of choice for post-funeral gatherings. It is pretty much agreed by everyone in the house that they have a fantastic sauce. They have gluten-free pizza, and great options for kids meals. We ordered here for Yelp! Big Night Out, And everyone in the family got something good to eat. By chance, it was buy one large pizza get one large pizza with one topping free. Unfortunately, we did not need another pizza and they gave us the breadsticks at no charge. Thank you thank you. Tonight's meal was a large pizza which everybody loves, breadsticks, eggplant Parm, and the camel, no ham:) . read more

Treated another couple last Sunday afternoon - I chose this place bc I remember it being very good ten years ago. Firstly the waitress took our order, brought out the soups and salads, less than 5 minutes into it- I wasn't even half way through the soup and out comes our meals-- I guess no one taught her about spacing out the meal. By the time I took my first bite my entire meal was cold. It pisses me off the way she tried to push us through bc the restaurant was not at all busy. When you spend $150+tip you usually like a relaxed meal, visiting with company. The food was just mediocre, I remember it to be better. Breadsticks were dry and gross (took 2 bites) the French onion and the eggplant parm/ chicken parm had more mozzarella than anything, was kinda gross it was so over cheesed ( enough to choke a person) really was nothing special, won't return read more

Paisanos is super good!! I will say 7 out of 10 times they get my dad's sandwich wrong, but everything else is sooo good! There clam chowder is good. The only thing is when adding speciality toppings on a pizza it $10, we just go to Big Y and pick up my pineapple for it. Lol read more

Always consistent, good food great price. Service always good and consistent. Love the pizza specials. Dinners large portion easy to make two meals out of it. read more

Had roast beef grinder. Edible, nothing to get really excited. Somewhat skimpy on the fixings. The full size grinder is much bigger then expected! Spouse had BLT grinder, just average read more

We went a 3:30 PM. The place was empty. The waitress brought over bread sticks. They were warm but hard and stale. I ordered chicken Parm. The chicken was rubbery, dry and hard around the edges. Pasta sauce tasted like Chef Boyardee. I won't go back. read more

We normally love Paisanos but had a horrible experience tonight, treated like garbage, and will never go again. Ordered 2 pizzas and salad for delivery at 6pm. By 730pm nothing so we called to see what was up, knowing it's a Friday and being patient. We were told they would be here shortly. 8pm still nothing so we called again and was told it was delivered to a "woman in a yellow shirt smoking a cigarette" which does not describe anyone here. We told them as such and we're basically told we were liars. We went in person to address the situation and ensure we get refunded to be told again it was delivered and not their fault. We were given our money back but no offers to remake or rectify the fact that it's 2+ hours later and we still haven't eaten. No recognition that they made a mistake. The customer service was horrid and a joke. We frequently order/patronize Paisanos and were made to feel like we are liars and trying to scheme them out of something, which is the farthest from the truth. So terribly disappointed. read more

Pizza at this place is excellent, they brown the cheese to perfection, something a lot of pizza joints fail to do, they also give a free large cheese pizza if you buy any other large, only catch is you have to order to go, that deal doesn't apply if you eat there, which makes no sense at all, because you actually will spend more if you eat inside, drinks etc. read more

Food is good, their pizza is great. Pasta is good but will caution you not to reheat the Alfredo in the microwave unless you want to eat oily pasty pasta. Have heard some sketchy things about the cooks and that they treat the female staff pretty grossly but a rumor is a rumor. read more

best Italian pizza ever and great service it was so good I would come back its so goooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooood read more

Love their pizza I've been going here for years. The pasta sauce they make is also delicious. I know I'll continue going there in the years to come. read more

Got the Chicken Vodka Rigatoni. That was good. Ordered a chicken parm sub to go and it was made with grilled chicken. Never heard of that in my life. WTF Goose? Other than that the restaurant's interior was nice and service was good but still can't get over the grilled chicken. read more

I am a long-time customer of Paisano's, having eaten at this restaurant off and on for over 20 years. Recently, my wife, daughter, and I visited Paisano's for a sit-down lunch. I ordered the roast beef grinder and a side of fries, despite a hefty upcharge of $1.50 for adding American cheese to the sandwich. When my meal arrived, I told my wife that I was surprised by how few fries were on my plate. At the same time, I overheard another customer speaking to the owner, who was standing several tables away behind the cash register. She was complaining to the owner about how few fries came with her takeout order. As I turned around to look at the customer and owner, the owner stared at me and blurted out loud, "Do you have a problem?" So I said, "Yes! I have the same problem as this customer. There are hardly any fries on my plate." The owner proceeded to walk over to my table and entered into a heated discussion with me as my wife and daughter looked on dumbfounded. In an elevated voice with the entire restaurant overhearing, he proceeded to educate me on how higher food prices forced him to shrink meal portions. I told him that as a customer, this is no concern of mine and that he should raise prices if necessary. I then asked him, "Do you really think that after speaking to me in this manner that I will ever return to Paisano's?" Needless to say, I have never gone back and suggest that any consumer who values their hard-earned money do the same. read more

Don't let the outside fool you! Stopped here with family after hearing so many good things about it. I got the 10oz cut steak, and others in my family got chicken parm, steak on salad, and chicken tenders. The steak was beautiful, cooked perfect, and tasted amazing! And the sauce on the chicken parm was the best my mom ever had she said. Will be returning! Also... the sinks in the bathroom are the coolest I've seen. read more

See all

I usually like going here but whomever worked takeout on Sept 10 2021 was awful. I ordered a simple wedge salad with chicken and a lobster ravioli dinner. I picked up the order and came home to eat with my wife. The salad had no chicken. I called to let them know and the person on the phone told me in a completely fake apologetic tone "oh no, can you come back and get a chicken? Or should I credit you $2.95 for the chicken?" Such a condescending piece of shit tone that I am pissed beyond belief. You have to be careful who you hire. I know it's tough now but this girl is a bitch. I want to return but it will be a while- shouldn't be long until she's fired. read more

Haven't been here in a few years and stopped in with the missus. I ordered the meatball grinder and she had a calzone. Both of our meals were delicious and came out in a reasonable time and the waitresses was very friendly and attentive. read more

Great food, generous portions, and fair prices. The service was excellent, both speedy and attentive. Great seafood, pasta, and pizza. read more

Paisanos - New wedge salad. Delicious - Pizza Near Me - Southampton, Massachusetts

Such a fun local joint. The staff is hilarious, warm, friendly and helpful. They work hard so treat them right! Their pizza is just 'eh.' They use what tastes like spaghetti sauce instead of pizza sauce. The crust is pretty barf, too. And they put way too much cheese on my cheese pizza! But it was served nice and hot. My go-to is the greek salad which is SO GOOD! the dressing is unparalleled and the salad serving is huge! Only bad part is that it's iceberg lettuce. A nice alternative to chain restaurants if you want decent food and local flair. read more

See all

We have been going to this restaurant for over twenty years. Haven't been in a while due to Covid but we stopped in last friday for dinner. Wow!! What a disappointment it was. We each ordered a cocktail and the price was outlandish!! The food was dry and overcooked with little to no flavor. We ordered stuffed mushrooms for an appetizer and they were slightly cold on the inside. My seafood combo platter was awful. My husband had the gyro platter, the gyro had one to two strips of beef in the pita. What a shame, we won't ever be going back there again. It sure wasn't packed like it used to be either. Perhaps others were just as disappointed! read more

Best Osso Bucco around! Carbonara was amazing. Waitress was very attentive. Amazing value everyone brought home leftovers for tomorrow. Kids were really pleased with the ravioli and fish and chips. read more

I am not an expert on Italian cuisine but I know that there's nothing authentic about this place. To begin, there's nothing fresh. We had fried mozzarella sticks that tasted like they came from a box. My wife ordered the chicken marsala and we had to return it. The sauce tasted like flour and butter, it was slimy thick. The mash were definitely from a box. She ordered a burger instead and it tasted old and frozen. I ordered the chicken parm from the house specialties, it was not much better. The sauce was watered down and bland, the chicken was rubbery, and they covered it with a pound of mozzerella. I am not fond of chain restaurants, but I have had better meals at OG. I will not return... not even for a free meal. read more

This place has some of the best eggplant parm you will ever find/ eat. The food all around is great, as long as you are eating in the dining room or getting takeout. Their bar is a entirely different story. The bar just doesn't seem to have the attentiveness of the rest of the business. You get a lot of food for your money here. Often 1 meal is enough for 2 people. read more

Tried it and it's like every other cut and paste Italian restaurant. Nothing was bad persay but it wasn't great either.

Outstanding philly cheese steak best we have had since leaving philly!! Perfect bread and excellent meat we will go back!

What a great find. A patient of my husbands suggested this place. The waitress was super friendly and made awesome recommendations. My hubby had the clam chowder to start and I had a salad to start, The main course was really good. I had the chicken and broccoli alfredo, my husband had the sea scallops. Very very good! read more

Absolutely the nastiest order of boneless wings ever. Burned to a char, allllll day old if not older and served fresh out of the microwave within 4 minutes. Couldn't cut any of them with a knife they were so dry and chewy like bad jerkey they pulled apart like week old pork butt. The accompanying people at the bar were definitely friends of the bartender and had the who are you attitude. All in all I'd rather go anywhere else to grab a bite or a beer. Good luck to everyone who stops in. You'll need it. read more

Ok first of all, WHY are there 3 different places to check in for the SAME RESTAURANT?? Dammit Yelp, get it together! I went here last night for my birthday dinner. Boyfriend swears by it and since he knows I love italian food (originally from Jersey) he wanted to make sure I had some he knew was going to be good. For a Thursday night around 6, this place was packed. Good sign. We managed to get a table and ordered drinks pretty quickly. The decor is a little meh but that's what a lot of italian places do in my experience. We started with the calamari. Our server suggested the spicy calamari and as far as I understood, the only difference was that it came with jalapenos. But still I wanted to try it. We put in our dinner orders at the same time and both came with either a soup or salad. I ordered salad, he ordered soup. Here's where I got a little annoyed. Our calamari came out at exactly the same time as our soup and salad. I would have appreciated maybe 10 minutes in between to enjoy the salad then the app. I ordered the house greek balsamic dressing and it was excellent. Feta is a welcome addition to anything I'm about to eat. Calamari was good. Not too greasy, lots of garlic (yay!) and the jalapenos, while unconventional, were a nice addition. Again we hadn't even finished our appetizer when our entrees were brought out by the food runner who didn't even offer a smile, hello, drop dead, NOTHING. Just put the plates down and walked away. Slightly rude but he was young. He will learn I hope. I ordered the chicken vodka rigatoni and the boy had chicken neptuno. His was good, creamy like an alfredo. Mine was good but significantly lacking in the vodka sauce realm. I'm a vodka sauce aficionado. I've had some of the best penne vodka in Jersey and had high hopes for here. Unfortunately, I found a more tomato based sauce than cream. No prosciutto and no peas. I liked the sauce. It was sweet with a nice flavor but it wasn't vodka in my opinion. The chicken was cooked perfectly though. Overall, I really liked this place. It had a good vibe, our server was very sweet (she brought over house made baklava from the owner for my birthday with a candle in it. So nice!), and the food was good. I'll definitely be back to try something else in the future. read more

Go in hungry, still leave with leftovers! The portions here are huge! Sometimes when I think large portions I think they are trying to make you forget about flavor by distracting you with how much food your getting, not the case here!!!! Veal parm and Alfredo primavera we're both delicious you get either soup or salad with each entree my bf choose the lobster bisque which not being near an ocean or a seafood restaurant would sometimes make you worry but no it was delicious!! If your in Southampton check it out! read more

My daughter & I were touring colleges in the area and stopped in for dinner. We had the mussels & calamari to start. Both were delicious! The mussels were the best I've ever had. The drinks were also yummy! And the pasta was great too! The waitress was great & very friendly! Highly recommend in if in the area! read more

We have been coming here for years. I thought in the past that I had put a review up for this place. In the past, the review would have been very positive. Tonight however, we are disappointed. The past 3 or so times we have ordered delivery the food has gotten worse and worse. The first time we noticed a difference, there was little vegetables and cheese on my pizza and the crust was very skimpy. The next time the fries were cold, half cooked, and beyond greasy. We had to put them in the toaster oven for them to be edible which shouldn't be the case as this isnt a TV dinner factory. Tonight, I ordered fettuccine alfredo with light sauce. But light sauce does not mean zero cheese and literally all grease and butter. I swear there is no cheese in this "alfredo" sauce tonight. It is so bland and dripping in its oil. I am a vegetarian and the fettuccine alfredo meal on the menu says it comes with broccoli and chicken. Usually we just say no Chicken. But there was no broccoli. Although my mom said that it comes without anything and you have to add. But from what I remember it is different unless they changed their menu. But either way, we ordered grinders and fries as well. The fries were just as bad as last time and this time I didnt try any because they looked the same and were described the same. They made my stomach hurt last time due to the amount of grease soaked up. I didnt even finish my pasta because of how much grease. I hate to say it, but we may need to find a new place for sandwiches and pasta. It is a shame because we have been coming here for years. read more

I've only been there once so my only judge of their food is the one Italian sub I had and the interaction I had with their staff. The Italian sub is, in my estimation, the litmus test of an Italian restaurant: screw it up and I'm done. They didn't. I came in looking for something delicious and that's exactly what I left with. I was so impressed with my sub, I felt the need to take a picture of it. Just the right amount of meat and veggies, toasted to perfection. And you want to go to Subway? The folks working there were very friendly and accommodating and I wouldn't hesitate to come back for another meal again. read more

Paisanos - Italian sub at Paisano's - Pizza Near Me - Southampton, Massachusetts

It's good, solid food, The help is nice. The Ambiance is decent. It's a bit expensive for what it is. It looks a bit dated... Lots of paneling. But not a bad place at all. I wouldn't call it a first choice for dinner or a date out, but it's certainly not a poor dining experience. I feel badly not loving it, honestly. But it is what it is. It's ok. Not terrible at all. But not fabulous and happy making. read more

We've eaten here many times and they are generally reliable. Tonight ordered scallop and shrimp carbonara, prime rib and chicken franchise. Server a bit slow to greet us and take order. She couldn't remember the specials. Prime rib end cut cooked well. Not crowded which is unusual on a Saturday night. We will be back again. read more