In February, Pagliacci had a promotion specifically on Wednesdays: buy-one-get-one-free for any of their 11-inch (small) pizzas. Of course, we had to take advantage of this deal! We've purchased slices from this location before, but this is the first time we ordered full pizzas. After placing our order online, we watched the tracker and drove over once it said the prep had started. Our pizzas were ready about five minutes past the estimated time, but we didn't mind the wait. The team was understandably busy with the promotion, yet the staff remained incredibly friendly and didn't seem to let the extra workload phase them. Pricing for an 11-inch ranges from approximately $23 to $28 depending on the combination of toppings, with the meaty ones being pricier, as expected. Four of us shared two pizzas which was the perfect amount! We only had three slices leftover. + 12th FAN PRIMO ($27.99 for 11"): Pepperoni, salami, chicken, Mama Lil's peppers, olives and mozzarella on their seasoned tomato sauce base. This one had a spicy edge to it between the peppery chicken and Mama Lil's (marinated) peppers. The tang from the peppers and brininess from the black olives cut through the richness of the otherwise meaty toppings. Any carnivore will love this one! + BROOKLYN BRIDGE ($27.99 for 11"): Pepperoni, Cascioppo's Italian sausage, mushrooms, olives, green peppers, onions and mozzarella over their seasoned tomato sauce. Considering the savory sausage, bold pepperoni, slight sharpness of the onion and the mildly bitter bite of the green peppers, this hit all the flavors and textures for me. Combo pizzas are typically my favorite and this one is no exception. This Pagliacci is generous with their toppings; almost no cheese was left uncovered! That said, while I wouldn't call the price of a small-sized pizza cheap, at least I can see the value in it for an occasional pizza night. As a couple other notes, I enjoyed their fresh bright tomato sauce and the crust was on the thinner crispy side, which I prefer! Since I don't love crust in the first place, I appreciated that theirs is not the doughy type and that the toppings remain the focus. Thanks for the delicious pizzas, Pagliacci! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Brooklyn Bridge - Pizza Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

See all

45 minutes for dine in pizza. The same queue for dine in and take out , best to take out . Avoid

Ordered the pizza with their app. Fairly easy. Then the pizza was ready for pickup on time We got one Hawaiian pizza ( Canadian bacon and pineapple) and one south Philly ( sausage, onions and mushrooms $ Both were very tasty. Would definitely order from them again. read more

See all

Me and the family got our redemption pizza from Pagliacci. We ordered to go my favorite, vegan margarita. we also tried their new mushroom pizza with vegan cheese. Ordering online was very easy. Pizzas are ready to go when we went to pick them up. We were all pleased with how delicious our pizzas were. Love the crust. Lots of melted vegan cheese. They're back on top as my local favorite! read more

See all

I absolutely love this place. We go here often after soccer practice, ballet or even a school event. There are always so nice and have food out quickly! Even if you go with the group they always accommodate. There are seasonal pizzas are the best but cheese is always a hit for the kids. Also their pasta is spot on! read more

I went by to buy a slice for lunch. There was a female and male worker there. She said "I'll be right there", then she left to go into the back after which both came out front. They left me standing there while they looked thru paperwork. After standing in the store for 5 minutes and not being helped, I left. Poor customer service! You never should leave a customer standing there while doing something else. To make it worst, I was the only customer they had to take care of. read more

Came here due to my son saying he's eaten here before. Place is huge. It was empty when we came around 6;20pm but all of the tables were dirty and there was like 8 people behind the counter. I was going to order from the red headed guy at the register. We got no hi. No welcome in. No offer to join their rewards. No ask if we've been here before or offer of what's great. After we visited the restrooms we asked if someone could clean our table. It seemed as if the guy didn't want to do it. We placed our order for a large pepperoni and 3 drinks. It took about 30 minutes for our pizza to come out. It was good. For the price I expected more. It seems they do a lot of delivery in this area. As the drivers were whizzing in and out the entire time we were there. I may come Back in the future but with 2 other pizza joints in proximity maybe not. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

Great pizza place! Plenty of seating areas and friendly staff. The place was clean and well-maintained. We look forward to going back! read more

See all

I have always loved Pagliacci Pizzas, the myriad of choices, the seasonal offerings, fresh ingredients and more. In Sunday I ordered a seasonal pizza online for a tailgate I was attending. When I picked it up, I was informed by Colin that he was trying to call me because they ran out of sage and asked me if I wanted to wait. I couldn't so I ordered a 12th man pizza. To my surprise Colin gave me an extra 17" pizza free of charge. That was a very special gesture Colin, and much appreciated. read more

Pretty good pizza, often has different selections depending on the season. Good place to stop for a quick meal, much better that other chain pizza locations in the area. Decently priced. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pepperoni and Rosemary Potato Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

Yummm! It took come convincing for my daughter to finally agree to pagliacci but she was so happy she did! We typically order a veggie pizza and then something with pepperoni for her and my husband. They also have an order by the slice option with rotating daily pizzas on deck. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

I got a couple pieces to go and the counter person heated them up for me. When I got out to the car and my aunt and I bit into it it was perfect! Crispy crust all the way through, so happy. read more

Great, hot, tasty pizza. Nice ambiance, easy parking, friendly staff. We'll be coming back!

Overall pizzeria is good, Price a little bit high for me, I'm not telling is expensive, but for me is high. Talk about pizza is difficult, cause each person like from different pizzeria. I took few times to go, I believe everyone liked their pizza. read more

Wow! It was my fist visit to this place and my friend brought me here to try this place out. I was not disappointed and I was totally impressed! Since I loved thin crust pizza it sure made my experience up on the notch! We tried their special which has figs on it and it was totally delicious! Since I was here on a mini vacation, I wasn't able to come back again which I would love if given a chance! Would I recommend? Absolutely!!! Place is clean with good vibes! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Fig pizza .. sooooo delicious ! - Pizza Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

See all

Pagliacci's Pizza is probably my favorite chain pizza and it is consistently delicious. I love the chicken primo and their Pagliacci salad. The restaurant ambiance is nothing special but again, it is always consistent across all their locations. Service is good. No complaints! read more

Dropped by with my granddaughters this afternoon and they enjoyed good quality New York style cheese pizza. Premises were clean and staff were helpful and efficient. Decor is a little sterile and ambiance somewhat industrial, but overall a good experience. read more

I love Pagliacci and I haven't had it since I moved out of state. So while I was visiting for the holidays, I was in the Issaquah area and decided to pick some up for the Seahawks game! I ordered 2 large pizzas and 1 small, and it came out to almost $100 after tax and tip. That is WAY steep for 3 pizzas, seriously - even for Pagliacci standards. I called in the order and they had the pies ready when they said it was going to be ready. *Agog - I ordered a small of this one cause it was recommended to me. Goat cheese and veggies and lots of roasted garlic. I thought the goat cheese would be overwhelming but it wasn't. I did enjoy this pizza quite a bit and thought the creamy goat cheese complimented the roasted garlic really well. Taking my first bite reminded me of why I loved Pagliacci so much - that crust is crispy, chewy and fantastically flavored - nevermind the toppings! 5/5 *I also ordered a large Veggie Pizza and a large Hawaiian. The boxes the pizzas came in were nostalgic and pretty cool. The Sasquatch and the Sonics colors - I loved it. Though if it were to lower the costs of the pizzas for less fancy boxes, I think I would pass on the fancy boxes. The pizzas were great and everyone in the fam really enjoyed them! Minus the steep prices, I would definitely order from here or dine-in again! Staff was quick and super friendly and they definitely aren't frugal about giving out cheese and peppers! Nice, clean, new location! read more

See all

Pizza delivered ! great tasting. Efficient telephone ordering where they remember all your past orders etc. timely and reliable

First time here. It was packed and short staffed. The Cesar salad was surprisingly good and fresh. The pizza was decent too.

The price is outrageous. $42 for a large 3 topping pizza. $26 for a "party" sized Caesar salad (it's realistically for 2 people). Their quality is not high enough to justify such prices. read more

I've been waiting two years to have a Pagliacci closer to home and it's HERE!! Thank y'all for the slices, they're so delicious and fresh and full of flavor! I love the freshness of the ingredients and I'm so glad we have one in Sammamish now. We ate it all so fast we didn't get any photos. If I ever needed more reason to drive up the hill, this one is worth it. *I have now been a few times and they've done a great job of creating the pizza I love and providing great service in a clean environment. The wild mushroom is the pizza of my dreams! The Caesar salad has a great anchovy (aka proper) flavor and not too heavy coating, which is just the way I love it. I needed help with the app and Jamie took time to show me how to order half and half and where to access my card for points. read more

See all

My only complaint is that I live too far from this place! Pizza is always delicious! Love the grand salami primo and I like trying the specialty pizzas they have every month. read more

This pizza place is on time and very delicious!! Everyone that complains is a joke be nice people sometimes it just takes a bit longer to make your pizza right. If u want fast go to Dominos. What they complain about is a joke. Give people time to make your pizza right. Anyway: My experience there has been great! Pizza comes out nice and toasty and my salad was perfect. The decor is beautiful. For the quality and service they are perfect with their pricing. If you want people to kiss your ass go pay double somewhere else. For those who just want great pizza please check them out. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Spicy Chicken and Pagliacci salad-my favorite salad in the world!! - Pizza Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

Nice place, good pizza and service is fast and friendly. Yes, I would recommend this restaurant. I believe in supporting our local businesses.. read more

This location... it's not up to the standard set by their other restaurants. The pizza quality here is excellent, although I've had a few pizzas undersized by an inch or two. The great product is what saves their rating from being a 2 or a 1. They are very busy on Friday nights and that's understandable. What's not understandable is that the estimated pickup time quoted by their system is often very wrong - I've had it off by 15 minutes in either direction, meaning the pizza is either ready very early (so I get a cold pizza) or 20 minutes late (meaning I have to wait around along with a bunch of other people). When a 2-topping pizza is $36 and it's either cold or very late, at the very least you kind of expect a "sorry" from the staff. Even the chain pizzerias will give you an apology, but I've never gotten one here. The staff at this specific location give off the "we know our product is better, take it or leave it" vibe which... sucks as a customer. I will give corporate Pagliacci credit - they survey after every transaction and make it right with a gift card when things go south. I've only filled it out once although in retrospect I probably should have a couple of times. read more

This review applies 2 both CapitolHill & Sammamish. My husband and I visited CapitolHill this past Saturday afternoon and then we visited Sammamish last nite (Tues) - 2 locations within 4 daze?!?! We ordered the exact same 3 pizzas (smalls) both times. Flawlessly identical! PAGLIACCI is a sleek-positively-vibed-well-oiled machine. We have lived in Snoqualmie for 5 years from SanDiego & we had been passing by the CapitolHill locale once a month on "salon day" @ Bowie which is a short stroll away. The staff treated us like rock stars knowing it was our maiden-voyage-visit. They have a coupla rotating specialty pizzas. We fell madly&deeply in love w/ the PEACHZA PRIMO: thinly sliced peaches/roasted pork loin/balsamic drizzle/arugula tossed in olive oil and sea salt. YUMMY!!! Also, best veggie pizza of our lives and perhaps best pepperoni of our lives. So many scattered locations (21) - seemed like both places had mostly regulars who engaged in spirited exchanges w/ staff as they awaited their full pies. Definitely set aside some time, this is not some "churn&burn" chain pizza. Also, eating everything freshly outta the brick oven in the dining room is my humble advice. There must B something unicorn-like going on w/ their breadsticks?!?! We R totally gonna give those breadsticks a whirl the next time I plan 2 create a massive Italian feast in my own kitchen. Salads looked substantial. Also available: calzones/pastas/cookies/gelato/etcetera. Bottled MexicanCoke&Sprite/OrangeFanta soda-pops sure make pizza taste even better plus root beer/flavored SanPellegrino/cream soda/ginger beer... Off-the-beaten-track beer&wine options. PizzaByTheSlice seems 2 fly outta the door. Pleeze click on their website and behold: about a billion types of pizza 4 y'all 2 choose from - really JUST 29 and that is a heckuva lot in my book. Lastly, this place ain't cheap. Grand example of: UGetWhatUPay4... BRAVO!!! read more

Love their selection, especially the alt crust and vegan cheese options. However. we ordered online and they gave us a time. I waited and showed up but seems they forgot our order and I had to wait for them to make it fresh. The cashier was courteous and apologized but really didn't do anything out of the ordinary to make it right (discount or other dispensation). Meanwhile other online orders came and went. Need to work on customer service. read more

The Roman pizza was so good! I want to try other kinds but this one hit the spot. It has artichoke, sausage, mushroom and olive oil.

Food is good. But ordering pizza should be easy. I should be able to order something on my way home from work to pick up without having to stop the car to use an app. How do you use the app if you're driving. Then I should not be coerced into paying a tip for an order I'm picking up at the counter. Overall, the pizza is good and better than most in the area but the experience is poor. read more

Absolutely breathtaking. Best pizza in the Seattle area. Great service and dedicated to repeat customers. Delicious and FIRST CLASS!!!!

Pizza was bland and tasteless, pasta dishes were burned, clearly reheated in a pizza oven, Caesar salad was soggy. Never ordering from here again. How this chain even exists is a mystery. So many better options. read more

This is our go to pizza spot. Order is always correct & on time. We love the slice bar but often order the Brooklyn Bridge & it's delicious. Our son likes the Margherita. Amazing crust & fresh produce. Must try! read more

Delicious pizza! This place is really close to my house so I get to enjoy the pizza here every 1 or 2 weeks! The pizza is delicious! The crust has a good texture, and the sauces are really good! The agog and margarita are probably my favorite! I would highly recommend any of the Pagliacci Pizza locations! read more

One word WOW! if I could eat Pagliacci pizza every day I would! The quality of the food is off the charts, and they use primarily fresh locally sourced ingredients. The service is spectacular, you can get a whole pizza within 15-20 minutes, the employees are absolutely WIG at their jobs and are masters at tossing out the dough. I love the fall decorations it makes for a nice ambiance, super clean and simple, but overall, will definitely continue to eat here, also TIP YOUR PAGLIACCI EMPLOYEES! They deserve it! read more

Zach and Blane were closing down shop when we walked in at 10:50 PM. Zach served us a couple of beers with a big ol' smile and literally ran to and from the kitchen to serve us pizza and beer. These are the exact guys I'd hire to run my pizza place. Even right before closing, pizza was fresh and tasty as always. read more

Used to be awesome. Something has changed in the last couple of weeks and the pizza just doesn't seem to be cooked right. Crust is too chewy compared to what it used to be read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

Very disorganized. There is nothing saying where to order a pizza or pick up. Two long lines one horizontal and one vertical. Asked two people where do I go to order just slices. No one knew. Then a nice girl allowed me to skip the line and when I went to order my two slices the cash register girl told me I need to go at the end of the other line after I waited for other people to order in front of me. I said NO THANK YOU and left. Please place signs there is a mess in the ordering logistics. Very confusing. BLEH read more

Awesome must have pizzas. I have no idea which Mozzarella they manage to get, it tastes great. Pizza base is thin with a reasonable edge. Pizza sauce is fantastic. Right amount of toppings. Tastes best right out of oven. Didn't like it after it got cold, but a quick reheat in a small OTG did the trick. Overall, this in in my list of top 3 pizza places to go to. read more

We used to love the pizza but were shocked at how downhill it has gone. Heavy, partially cooked crust.... Barely edible. So disappointed.