I grew up on this pizza. It's definitely different and it's either a love or a hate for people. In my case it's a love. Don't knock it til you try it! Extra cheese, mushrooms, and onions - that's the order I'll never go without getting! A core memory spot for me! read more

See all

I had a store next to them and their hoagies are fantastic and the NY pizza is very good I didn't care for the PM pizza great people too I would recommend !!! read more

Fake Recipe I ate this pizza at this location since the mid 1950's through 2004. I don't eat it anymore because when it opened under new ownership in 2008, the recipe is fake. Let me be clear that the owners are good people trying to make an honest buck. My problem is with the people who say 1) it's the original 2) it's equal to Phillippi's who own the original Mooney & Lefty Martz recipe. The fake P&M recipe is not even close to Phillippi's (the original). It doesn't taste the same, the cheese isn't the same, the sauce isn't the same, the crust isn't the same, it doesn't smell the same. They resemble each other from a distance.... IF you need to get your vision checked. I've posted a link and some photos of the real pizza and the fake (P&M). I've also posted a link (and screen shots) of the original owners living relatives more or less saying that it's fake. If you like it, great. I don't. I will only eat the original provided by Phillippi's in Natrona Heights now named the Birdville Pie. https://phillippis.com/ https://archive.triblive.com/news/pm-legend-not-true/ read more

Great local pizza shop. Cool staff and a very unique pizza that everyone should try at least once! This one I tried was the original. I'll be back to try the NY style. Thanks definitely recommend! read more

P & M Pizza - The Original P & M Thin Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arnold, Pennsylvania

I have to give it a three because my grandmother loved it. She was used to it. It tasted like Kraft cheese on crust. Not my kind of pizza but some people love it. It's just the back of a bar that you go and pick out pizza. I do t remember how much it cost but I'd bet it was reasonable. read more

Best damn pizza in the Valley! tThe Sicilian is soo good extra cheese and mushroom's AWESOME!!!!! Nice environment, full bar if you need a cold on with your pizza. Friendly people who work there and fun. Do yourself a favor go have a pie! read more

Was craving pizza, and my dad suggested this was a good place in the area that had really unique pizza. We ordered cheese pizza, pepperoni and onion, and steak bacon and jalapeño pizza. The pizza was a little slow to get out but the service was friendly none the less. I've never seen a steak bacon and jalapeño pizza offered before and it sounded very enticing so i ordered it and was very pleased with how it tasted. More places should offer that combination because it hit the spot. The cheese is definitely unique but it tastes good. I'd give the pizza overall a solid 7/10 and the steak, bacon, and jalapeño an 8.5. P and Ms is a solid, unique pizza place with really good speciality pizza options and friendly service l read more

P & M Pizza - Half cheese (right) and half pepperoni and onion (left) - Pizza Near Me - Arnold, Pennsylvania

See all

Before saying anything else, this spot is CASH ONLY, so if you're like many folks, you may need to hit an ATM. This place was a pretty big spot to hit during high school and this is the first time I've gone back since then. I asked for the pizza to be well done and I did enjoy the pizza. They didn't skimp on the toppings, the pizza had some char on it, and I do think that they serve an above-average pie. The only issue I had is that it that the cheese is a mix. By the looks and the taste, it looks like they add in some American cheese with the mozzarella and I wasn't a huge fan of that. This is once again just my own personal tastes. I know people that do like different cheeses added, and if you're one of those folks, there's a good chance that you'll enjoy the pizza. I do want to also say that if you're ordering a pizza from here and you're feeding several folks, or you're just really hungry, I'd try to keep in mind that it is a very thin pie so you may want to step up a size. read more

P & M Pizza - Pepperoni, onions, black olives, and a request to have it well-done. - Pizza Near Me - Arnold, Pennsylvania

Because P&M was highly recommended by my boyfriend.. I was so intrigued to learn of this pizza .. since I am no doubt a huge NY style thin crust pizza fan. I had to find out what was so special about this pizza.. I have heard you either "love it " or "hate it" well folks.. the verdict is in and I in fact love it! The pizzeria is located in downtown Arnold.. off the beatn path no less. I got a warm vibe just walking into the restaurant. We sat at a cozy booth in the back part of the restaurant. Started off with red ribbon "cherry" sodas which were totally appropriate (bottled Natrona Bottling Co) and so delicious and refreshing. Plenty of options to the menu but we were interested in the "original thin crust P&M pizza". It arrived piping hot .. and within a few minutes was cool enough to enjoy. The cheese is what makes the pizza so good.. and lack of dough too. I love the combination of the pepperoni and cheese. The cheese blend is a big secret and their specialty. I think its nacho cheese or similar type cheese. It's no doubt good and worth the trip to get the pizza. $10.00 for a large - original" thin crust pizza.. totally the right price. Its not typical pizza.. its unique.. and definitely worth it. Cash only folks.. no credit cards accepted. Bravo P&M !! read more

See all

Fantastic place , Family owned. Craig, Dawn, Phil, are fantastic, they know what they are doing and run a great pizza business. Me and my wife go very often, its very enjoyable, Arnold is a big sketchy, just don't venture further than from your car and into the restaurant and vice versey. :) read more

Delicious pizza!!! Definitely will keep coming back! crunchy delicious crust and cheese just on point!! Worth every penny!!

It used to be really good back in the day, but the last couple times I had their pizza, it just wasn't the same. The birdville pie at Phillipiis Family Dining in Natrona Heights is the same recipe, but better quality. It's a different kind of pizza, but I'm sure those who eat here know this. I'm not sure what kind of cheese that they put on top, but it's really good. It's different, but delicious. Give it a shot if you want something different. read more

One of my favorites places to get pizza. You can't beat the P&M original one. But the New York style pizza is also very good. Dawn and the boys do a great job in making you welcome. read more

P&M is a bit of a local legend with the unusual cheese that they use on their pies. It's sort of a yellow cheese tasting something like Velveeta on a very thin crusted pizza. People seem to either love it or hate it. I love it personally. If that's not your thing, they also make more traditional pizzas. Check out their pizza of the month as they have done some interesting things with those. read more

Give it a shot, the cheese is amazing. There's nothing like it! It took me 2 trips to win me over. But now it's a must when I'm in the area. Service is always pleasant & good! read more

Just about the best pasta and bolognese sauce that I've eaten ever. Great meatballs. I live a couple of blocks away and delivery is almost always at my door in less than 20 minutes. Always courteous. They don't always get to the phone in time to answer on the first call. They always pickup on the second try. Definitely worth redialing. read more

Great pizza and the owners and staff are great people! Their pizza has a nice sauce... Love their bread sticks too! If you're in Arnold this is an excellent place to stop and eat... Also has a bar of you want a beer. Definitely recommend this place! read more

The same thin pizza has been made here for many years. My Sicilian grandfather would take me here to eat pizza when I was just 6 years old. So many stories and memories at the P&M Pizzeria!!! read more

Not the best pizza. They specialize in a thin cracker like pizza. The pizza I don't care for unless its their regular traditional without the weird processed cheese. The crowd at times is uppity uppity which is odd. Parking is horrible and be sure to lock your doors. Pizza is one of my all.time favorite foods, their is expensive and not great. Phillipies has something like it call the birdville taste WAYYYY BETTER! Seating is cold and uncomfortable and not good for families. Id say pass this place up for much cleaner, cheaper, and delicious alternatives. read more

P&M Pizza is awesome. The Original P&M is unique to this area. It has some crazy cheese blend that is really tasty. It's worth trying. If you don't like the Original P&M, you should try the New York Style pizzas. Their NY Style is some of the best pizza I've had in the area, and I've had a lot of pizza from the "best" in the Burgh. read more

I like how it's a hole on the wall, that's part of the charm. Now their NY style is pizza is damn good. But their original is some of the worst tasting burned pizza I have ever had. I would rather melt velveeta on cardboard. Avoid like the plague. read more

This is a love it or hate it hole in the wall place. My wife and I love it. Pizza is different as it has American cheese on it. Neighborhood isn't the best but they keep it clean inside. read more

I love this pizza. I grew up on it, I had made wedding rehearsal dinner here, and my kids love it. I love the family that owns it now. Great people. read more

The strange pizza in P&M is a New Ken delicacy, but loses points because the location is in a shady neighborhood. Go in the afternoon only. The pizza has to be tried to be believed, and even then most people can't stand it. P&M pizza needs to be tried twice. An acquired taste. Partly burned, cheese that everyone says is government surplus, but there's something fun and weird about it. Truly a local treasure. read more

I ordered the thin crust and it was burnt. The cheese was that strange consistency somewhere between liquid and solid and had no recognizable taste. Overall, edible only because I was quite hungry and wheat thins with a side of pickles wasn't going to do it. read more

The pizza is not bad the cheese if certainly different, but what i found bothersome, was after ordering by phone for pick-up i got there to find they only accept cash with the only atm nearby located in their bar for a $1.75 fee in increments of 20.00. Add to that, the pizza was WAY overpriced for the size i'm just not feeling like going there often. read more

Their pizza is the best! If you don't like it- you didn't grow up on it!!! Nothin quite like it!

Their original pizza is so horrible we could not eat more than a bite! It has no sauce and I'm pretty sure they use some sort of spray on cheese product in lieu of it. Neither the menu nor the server explained the very nontraditional style of pizza it was.We fell prey to the thought that the house original would be the best option. When the server came and saw we didn't eat it and didn't want a box to take it to go, she said "well it's not for everybody" and rushed to get our check without even offering any compensation or even to refill our drinks. She actually ran past us and dropped the check on our table after that. The service is poor and the pizza is poorer and the neighborhood is risky at best. If you are considering this place, go to the grocery store and pick up a frozen pizza to make at home. It's less expensive, less risky and tastes a whole hell of a lot better. read more

Very bad this,was absolutly discusting. No flavor and a mushy discusting texture. This is also a bar not a pizza place in all my years this Is the WORST PIZZA EVER Do not waste your time a dumpster pizza would of been better. We threw it out OMG the after taste is really rough. Very bad. Im from Buffalo, NY i know pizza this,was NOT pizza read more

Like someone else said love it or hate it. Cheese is different thin pizza but the best out there. It's a little dive bar usually take it to go. read more

When I heard P&M Pizza in Arnold was open again We had to run right over and grab some pizza. The pizza was just like I remember with the orange cheese. It was so good we went back two days later to get more. This is the best pizza ever. They also have regular pizza that looked really good. Next time we go were going to also get one of those And anybody who has not made it there yet. They opened in January 2008 and remodled the whole place to include hardwood floors. I know what your thinking hardwood floors in Arnold the place looks like it should be in foxchapel. I also took my kids there. This is definitely a family place like it used to be. There is nothing better than fresh dough pizza and beer. read more

As people have said, it's a "love it or hate it" pizza. My daughter is a picky eater and loves it. I've been eating it since the early 80's and always have liked it a lot. It's a dive bar/restaurant. Clean enough. Going with a big group makes it fun. Give it a try. read more