When they opened a second Fiori's I made the mistake of comparing it to the first one. The food is delicious (same as the original), but the atmosphere and the staff could not be more different from the first location. The staff is always happy and friendly, and the restaurant is very clean and has a fresh feel. It's a nice place to eat in. Somehow, both Fiori's locations pull off their ambiance well. I took my co-workers here after a meeting once, and they liked it so much that we've been back 2x since. Whenever I'm south of Pittsburgh and looking for a place to eat, it's rare that this isn't one of the options. read more

Best pizza around. Old skool Italian. Beautiful crisp and chewy crust and sweet sauce. Friendly wholesome people. read more

Love the slightly sweeter sauce. Great service. Very attentive. Love their pizza. Wine available as well.

Fioris is my favorite pizza but something has changed. The last three times Ive gone to the McMurray location the pizza is not fully baked. The crust is gummy and gooey and severely underbaked. If this happened once I would chalk it up to one mistake but it's been an ongoing occurrence. Hope they correct this or they will lose a lot of business read more

We've ordered Fiori's takeout many times, but this was our first time in the dining room, and we had a great experience! All of the staff, from the register to pizza deliverers, were so friendly and accommodating. The dining area isn't too big, but we had no wait for an early dinner on a weeknight. You order at the desk when you walk in, and they give you a number to put on your table for your food to be delivered. In addition to apps, calzones, salads, and pizza (of course), they also have a decent selection of pop, beer, and wine. Pro tip - order your pizza with the cold cheese on the side! read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Gotta get the cold cheese! - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Had be lunch here yesterday.We always order a small salad big enough for 2 with garlic bread.The salad is always fresh and loaded with pepperoni and mozzarella cheese with homemade Italian dressing.Always delicious.We each got one slice of pizza.The slices are so big you only need one slice to be satisfied.This is my husband's favorite pizza in all of Pittsburgh.The crust is very good and the whole pizza is very flavorful and generous with toppings.Servers are also great.They come around to ask if you need anything.I highly recommend dining here.Price is very reasonable. read more

New to this restaurant, but not to the pizza. I've had the pizza in Dormont if it was very good, this restaurant is nice clean servers are great atmosphere is wonderful TVs enough for people to see if they wanted to you order at the counter and they bring the food to you. We tried the new cheesesteak hoagie with red sauce. I'm sorry, but I wasn't impressed. I really didn't like it. Maybe others will maybe others do but it wasn't for me. The pizza was good as always.. Highly recommend, and we might return. I can't really give it five stars, I just really didn't care for the hoagie at all. I hear the meatballs are great I have the pasta is good, but I don't care for red sauce on my cheesesteak as well as lettuce, and tomatoes, Cheesesteaks just do not come with lettuce and tomato read more

See all

OMG. My young cousin and I go there when I go over to USC. This pizza is the best. The employees are amazing

I'm a big fan of the other location, but this was my first visit to this location. Overall I must admit it was slightly underwhelming- the sauce was MUCH sweeter here and while the pizza was still ok, it wasn't on the level of the one on Capital Ave. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Large pepperoni pizza - take out The pizza I picked up today was not even similar to their usual pizza. The crust was different and there was only one piece of pepperoni on each slice. What happened? read more

Walked in, made our order, sat down. Ate some house salad delicious with a side of onion rings. Excessive... not for a Sunday! Restaurant was full but moved swiftly through the 5 o'clock hour. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Small cheese pizza. small. - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Not a cheap place, but you get top ( I mean TOP) quality food. My buddy and I split a large pizza with extra cheese and sausage, and it was so good we fought over who got the last slices. Since then I have gone there at least once a week and got excellent food. Also, service animal friendly, clean, and lots of food and drink choices. I have gone to the original Fiori's just outside the tunnels and the food is just as good there. read more

Good pizza and clean. Service is great. The pizza is one of the top pizza's in pittsburgh area. Sauce to on the sweet side which is what we like. read more

Pizza was average at best. Crust was doughy and sauce was bland. After seeing reviews online expectations were higher.

Love the pizza sauce which is on the sweeter side. Steak hoagie is excellent!!!! We always buy extra cheese on the side too. Salads are excellent! read more

Beware and stay away. I haven't been to the McMurray location in a couple of years and the pizza was always tasty and good. Tonight not so much. I paid $23 for a small pepperoni and sausage pizza for which I had to search for when I got home. Not only that there was hardly any cheese and the pizza sauce was so sweet I thought I was eating a sweet roll. Won't ever go back again and will visit Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza or Harry's in McMurray. read more

Fiori's is our pizza mecca...The pizza shop that very few other shops have ever compared to. Fiori's isn't in the easiest location to reach, but it is worth the visit. Our family gets a plain cheese, with a cup of mozzarella cheese, and barbecue wings (the sauce is amazing). Their sauces are amazing as dippers and you can get them in to go size containers to keep in your fridge. The shop is old school pizzeria with the staff cooking right there in the main room as the restaurant, making it all about the pizza experience. This place is always busy but call ahead. You can't go wrong! read more

Simply delicious pizza! Worth the wait or travel time to get there. I've only had the plain pizza but it's sooooooo good!!

Something about their cheese pizza! The sweet sauce, the best cheese around. This is my go to pie. With Anthony's Coal Fired, and Harry's within a mile, you're in pizza heaven. You can't go wrong but there is something about Fioris's that I just love. Their cheese sticks are incredible... not cheap, but worth every penny! read more

My family's favorite pizza is from Fiori's. We also love the onion rings, Italian hoagies, wings, Italian salad and calzones are huge and delicious! Everyone that works there is always friendly and nice. People seem to enjoy eating in, but we live so close we always do take out. read more

10 out of 10...battles for the best in Pittsburgh! I love it!! It's a Pittsburgh staple that lives UP to It's legend! If ya haven't had...treat yourself!!! read more

There are some really great spots for a slice of 'Zza in the 'Burgh, and Fiori's Pizzaria is consistently recognized as one of the best. Growing up we always visited the Fiori's Pizzaria location on West Liberty Ave, and this was my first visit to the McMurry location since it opened. The restaurant has a much different vibe than the original location as it's quadruple the size. The tall ceilings and ample seating feel so spacious in comparison to the older location. Based on the exterior I was expecting a "fancy" pizzaria, and was slightly surprised when the inside felt much more like an Italian gramma's kitchen. Fiori's Pizzaria was very bright and had TV's (can't miss the Steelers!) Fiori's Pizzaria offers a wide variety of toppings, but personally I like to keep it somewhat basic. We ordered a large salad and a large pepperoni pizza, which both came out at the same time. The salad had handfuls of pizza cheese and savory Italian dressing. The lettuce was crisp and fresh and fed three people. Fiori's pizza is magical. The crust is thin and chewy with a slight hint of cornmeal or something. Whatever cheese blend they use on their pies is divine. While the pepperoni sometimes makes the cheese greasy, that's something I really like. You are sure to always leave stuffed and content when you dine at Fiori's Pizzaria. read more

See all

Best Pizza In Pittsburgh! Best eaten in, fresh/hot with fork and knife on the metal plates.

Take just like Brookline! Ample parking - comfy interior and delicious food!!! Ordered a few items to start - chicken fingers and meatballs ( delicious delicious delicious!) We also ordered an Italian salad ( put a couple chicken tenders on it), steak salad and a large pizza! All so good... The sauce is a little sweeter then other pizza places - but everyone at the table was happy with how it tasted! Overall -- I have one close to home but if out this way again - would definitely stop again! Enjoy! read more

See all

You walk up to the counter and order. We got greeted right away! They will give you a number and will bring your food out when it's ready. They were efficient with coming around and asking if we needed a refill and cleaning the tables off when people left. We got the salad to start. I assumed their Italian salad was the same as a antipasto salad but it wasn't. It only had pepperoni on it for meat. Although it was a huge salad! As always the large cheese pizza is always the best way to go with Fioris. Not sure if it's the same recipe as the one on Capital but we thought it was a little sweeter then the one we normally get on Capital. Maybe we are biased! I do like that this Fioris has a huge seating area and even a back room for the over flow and it's alittle quieter back there. Also like that we were able to get beer here too. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Large cheese - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

See all

Very good pizza for a great price. They even offer pizza by the slice. Doesn't that sound delicious and nice? Give it a try it's better than plain rice. I know I know, the rhyme might be corny , and you're asking why. Maybe I just got high off of a good pizza pie. read more

Love Fiori's! Fresh ingredients. Fun folks working there. Don't think I would ever eat there-but it is a great take-out pizza. They must be terrific-getting there is sometimes tricky. But, we will definitely be back time and time again! read more

Service is very efficient and friendly. However... the pizza was a massive disappointment, especially considering that Fiori's is supposed to be the best or one of the best in the region. I ordered a pepperoni pie for pickup and it was very undercooked with almost no pepperoni on it - I counted half a dozen pieces on a 16" pie. Sauce was tasty but very skimpy. Cheese was okay. I've heard the the McMurray location is not as good as the original Fiori's, but this pie was such a letdown that I'm probably not going to bother to try the O.G. read more

The have the most unique flavored sauce and it's definitely a favorite of mine! The one in Mcmurray has plenty of dining area and it's always been pretty clean. Love me some Fioris read more

This place is amazing there is a lot of options all of the food is great I definitely recommend getting a large cheese pizza definitely eat in and call ahead over all it is amazing service if you are driving past it definitely stop there 10000stars read more

This is likely our favorite pizza! The sauce is a little sweet and I always order extra sauce on the pizza because it is that good. We picked up a mushroom pizza and their 2 small Italian salads. The salads were so HUGE that I only had room for one slice of pizza. They cover it in cheese and pepperoni and not to mention it comes with garlic bread. I end up giving my pepperoni to my husband since I don't eat meat and let's just say he was happy. There Italian homemade dressing is also delicious Yummy!! I was so hungry that I forgot to take pics. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Half order Italian Salad - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

See all

Not a fan of Fiori's. Ordered an Italian hoagie and there was about 4 pieces of deli meat that was cut so thin, I could see through it. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Italian hoagie with one morsel of a sliver of meat.... Sad. - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Love Fiori's! If you're looking to must have pizza in Pittsburgh, put this place on the list! They're always busy but always worth the wait!

Just got off of work with my SO and we were hungry and tired. Never been to this place before and decided to give it a try. It was 9pm on a Saturday so we were a little worried. The place was nice and clean inside (bathrooms too) and it wasn't overly crowded. At first I thought the menu was expensive (no deals or anything) but then I saw the size of the portions! We got a small salad (almost got the big one but got talked into a small by an employee) and a large pepperoni pizza. Got a soda too. It was about $30 for all of it. Omg! The small Salad was huge and delicious!! It had olives, cold pepperoni, onions, lettuce, lots of cheese,huge delicious tomatoes and bell pepper. I've never had a salad like this. The bell peppers worked really well. I'm usually very picky but this was perfect. The pizza! We got a large and it was 16 inches. The sauce is very sweet but it works. It's almost like having pineapple as a sauce but it worked. The employee who took our order was very nice and gave me a water. I wasn't feeling too good and was wearing sunglasses due to having a migraine. We saw other people's orders and understood the prices. HUGE and delicious portions! We will absolutely be back!! And they were open til midnight! Also wait time was fast despite a semi full area. read more

This our local go to. Loved by EVERYONE in the household. Crust is always perfectly cooked. Sauce is well seasoned. Cheese is a great flavor. We enjoy ordering from here at least once a week. read more

Everyone I know LOVES fioris. I have to admit its pretty good pizza. I tried it for the first time the other day and it was a great experience. You can order to go or sit down. The sauce on the pizza is very sweet, almost like they add sugar to it. This is what makes them so unique and what people can't stop talking about. If you order a salad you get a very generous portion, I would recommend splitting one! Fioris has 2 different locations and the staff is so friendly and quick at both of them. You can order whole pizzas or pizza by the slice, along with salads, pasta, apps etc. Definitely order fioris for your next pizza night! read more

Hello. This is the first time I had ever been here. Was very pleased. The place is very clean, very bright and cheery. You place your order at the counter and they bring it to you. The staff is very friendly and helpful. Now the food. so many people recommended this place. So glad we tried it the pizza is awesome they use a sweet red sauce ,( t die for). We will definitely go back. If you get a chance to go please do , you won't be disappointed. read more

I had dined here a few times in the past and although it's not my favorite pizza place, I always thought it was good. After tonight however, I am pretty disappointed. We ordered take out and they said it would take an hour, which was fine, it's a Friday night. We ordered an Italian hoagie, a steak bogie, a large pizza, and buffalo wings. A few moments later we called back to add an order of BBQ wings and they were very accommodating to our request. One of the biggest problems with ordering is their large pizza is 12 cuts, which seemed like a medium to me, but it was fine. First I tried the BBQ wings and was skeptical because it looked like an orange/red sauce on the wings. Well I tried it and it reminded me of orange chicken. It didn't taste bad, but I was nothing like bbq sauce, it was super sweet. As for the buffalo wings, some were really chewy and the skin was stringy, and others were fine. Next I tried the steak hoagie, there was a red sauce dripping all over it, I tried it by itself and I tasted exactly like the sauce on the bbq wings. Again it wasn't bad but what steak hoagie comes with sauce? Probably the most unimpressive steak hoagie I've ever had. Anyways I tried a little of the Italian hoagie and it was what you would expect, it wasn't the best and it wasn't the worst. As for the pizza, that was really the only thing I enjoyed. After dinner my stomach was upset the rest of the night. I am in absolutely no hurry to go back and really wouldn't recommend it to someone, simply because there are plenty of other pizza places in he area. If you decided to go, I would only suggest getting pizza. Also be aware that there were plenty of customers in there without a mask, so if you are worried about COVID this won't be the place for you. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

I've always got my Fioris from the well hidden Brookline location but I'll admit it's been years. I remember the grease runoff from the pepperoni. This new fancy joint with lots of seating in Posh Peter's has just what the family ordered. We started with a small salad and there's enough in one for both of us. If you don't like chopped onion and green peppers then make sure you request them off. The salads are loaded with greens and pepperoni and cheese plus some other salad usuals. Great salad. We then dug into a large pizza and took most of it home because the salads were so big. After a couple drinks our bill was $32. A bit pricey but worth it as it was a great casual on the fly meal. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Smelled so delectable and I was starving so I inhaled 4 pieces of white cheese pizza and holy smokes it was so freaking good i died. service great. ambiance was my couch so it was good. read more