Wonderful in every way! Just a heads up that they no longer have avocado toast, etc although they do have some pastry items and delicious smoothies. Best coffee in Cape May! :) read more

Awesome coffee maybe best in Cape May! Just found this place after years sojourning in CM. In the afternoon tried their London Fog, hands down the best I ever had! read more

Believe the hype. The dark chocolate mocha is perfection. Cinnamon swirl cake is delicious. I tried to go every day.

Loved the choices and such a chill vibe with the sweet smell of fresh coffee brewing licking your nose was a treat. Ordered a double espresso that was so bold and delicious and mocha latte that was creamy not so sweet and exquisite. Love this place and wish we had coffee shops like this one back home, it's a must try if you enjoy a well brewed coffee read more

It was one of the best cappuccinos and iced Chai lattes we have had in a very long time. People are so nice as well

What a great coffee shop! I eat GF/DF and they had a fairly healthy snack that was delicious as well, it was a ball with oats, almond butter and cranberries (plus a few other ingredients too). I also got a cortado with oat milk and it was very good. My husband got a coffee with sweetned condensed milk (forgot what it was called) and asked about adding a shot of espresso, they thought that would be a good idea so they did that for him and he loved it. The next day we ordered a vegan smoothie that was delicious and we wanted more of the GF/ DF balls but there was only one left so she made up a new batch while we waited and ended up not charging us for the other one, how nice! We would totally go back if we ever are back in Cape May. read more

Such a cute place! My girlfriend and I stopped in earlier with the intention of grabbing a quick coffee (which was amazing!) and then began shopping for friends. The owner was so incredibly accommodating even though she was visibly busy. We kept telling her we could wait, but she insisted on helping us decide on what we wanted. Her husband eventually helped us decide which coffee roast to purchase for our friend, we don't know too much about coffee, but he still took the time to explain his recommendation choices to us. Overall, amazing experience. Love the vibe, love the family. read more

Coffee is very good and tasted excellent. Got nothing special, just their medium roast and it hit the spot. Been back twice and will return in the morning. read more

A new coffee shop since our last visit to Cape May in 2019 and our new favorite! It is not even a close comparison to the other coffee stops. Most expansive variety of coffee options I have seen. Small selection of baked goods is made up for in quality. The blueberry muffins are packed with blueberries! Sorry we won't be able to stop in before we leave tomorrow. Definitely our favorite for early morning walks. read more

Drove out of the way for great coffee here. Owner and staff are so kind and we loved the apple cider donuts!

Went here on President's Day Weekend 2020. The coffee was amazing and the toast with almond butter & bananas was.....well....bananas!

I'm surprised there aren't more reviews for this place! I only had their cold brew on my trip but it was GOOD. The staff were friendly and the shop itself has a cool atmosphere and definitely Covid-prepared. I'd go back next time I'm in the area read more

We were headed to Wawa,,,,,,, BUT found them first and quickly pulled over to grab a cup of coffee & hot chocolate on our way out of town today. And we are so glad we did, We had a great experience! The owner/manager was training a few new girls and was super helpful and you could tell really loves the shop. We enjoyed being present and interacting with the trainees. Took their recommendations for the coffee I believe was called Pappa New Guinea low acidity and I was really happy with it! Definitely try them out and shop local! read more

Stopped into this coffee shop based on reviews on Yelp. It by far exceeded our expectations. Having a gluten sensitivity can make it difficult to find options for the morning which usually results in me bringing my own. The gluten free crumb cakes were moist and delicious, a hard feat with many gluten free products. I did try the lavender organic syrup shot, and was quite impressed. We will be going back to Cape May for sure, and this shop has made the list for places to return! read more

One of my favorite coffee shops in Cape May! They have plenty of options on their menu for coffee, smoothies, and wellness drinks. I love that they offer many dairy free alternatives as well. The staff is always very friendly and the service is fast! read more

The best avocado and egg toast ever :) and the latte was great too. Nice and friendly staff and very welcoming.

This place has raised the standard of all lattes for me. Great taste, perfectly frothed.

Fantastic addition to Cape May. Great coffee and tea. They have gluten and dairy free pastry options as well. Craig and Nikki are lovely people. Go there now for your caffeine addiction. read more

Grew up here in Cape May and when I come back to visit family, I always try to find good coffee. Well, it's here! The cold brew is great, and I have NEVER been a cold coffee fan. I would love to give a 6 star rating. My daughter and I have been gluten and dairy free for over a year now and rarely are we able to find pastries to satisfy this need. Craig and Nikki have found a baker that provides them with a varying array of GF/DF items in addition to other delightful baked goods. They stock not just milk but a variety of non-dairy milks for those that choose to dilute their coffee. The owners are wonderful and can satisfy just about any caffeine requirements. They bring a breath of freshness to the wonderful ambiance that is Cape May. Go get your coffee, I'll wait here. Seriously, go now. read more

AMAZING. I am a serious coffee dude and this is the only shop in town to deliver an exceptional cup. The employees were stellar and educated. Cape May finally has a great coffee shop!! Plus they are super eco-friendly read more

Way way way good coffee! Awesome gluten free and other goodies. Wonderful owners. Beautiful woodwork and very nice place to be!

This place has some of the best coffee and smoothies I've ever tasted I 10/10 recommend the peach smoothie. They are also very echo friendly. You can purchase a metal straw, a rubber tip for the straw, and a cleaner for it. I love that place so much. They have such a nice staff that works there. Their one boy who works there I think the owners son is very sweet and always has a smile on his face. It was such a nice smile it made me smile. This is one of the best Coffee shops I've ever been to. I really recommend going there!! read more

If you're serious about coffee like I am, search no further because Out There Coffee is the Mt Everest of coffee shops! Truely artisanal in every respect, the owners of this cafe are passionate and skilled at making the very best coffee - hands down. Importing only the finest raw beans from around the world, every batch is freshly roasted and exquisitely brewed to perfection. The head barista is as knowledgeable about coffee as Einstein was on his own theory of relativity. Even their lattes and specialty drinks are crafted with organic ingredients. Let me not forget to mention the Super Food Lattes on their menu! As one coffee guru to another, I simply can not recommend a better coffee shop. Out There Coffee is simply unmatched, unrivaled, and for any other cafe to compete would be like climbing Mt Everest in a bathing suit! A coffee affectionado's dream come true, Out There Coffee has hit it way, way out there! read more

Out There Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

I'm a bit of a coffee geek ( I roast my own at home ) and I've been vacationing in Cape May for a long time. I have always had to make do with the barely adequate coffee available in town, or bring my own. No more. Not only is this the best coffee place in Cape May, but one of the best I've ever tried anywhere in the world (and I've tried a LOT). If you can appreciate expertly sourced and freshly roasted coffee you MUST give this place a try. read more

They have. Delicious ns traditional match within any sugar added. It is so delicious. Rach time inform to visit cape may. I have to make sure I stop by to sip my match. read more

This is by far the best coffee in Cape May my vacations now revolves around coming here twice a day for coffee

I got a delicious piece of gluten-free lemon and blueberry cake, almond cake and a smoothie. The cakes were delicious as was the smoothie. Nothing was overly sweet, which I loved. read more

Had a fishing trip to get to and needed my cup of coffee. Most places are closed at 7 am. But not Out There Coffee! I walked in at 7:05 am nice young tall skinny lady welcomed me in. I got a nice hot cup of coffee and she helped me pick out my almond bread which was delicious! Thank you! read more

Best coffee in Cape May. Spoke with the owners who live in town. They buy their own beans and make sure they're roasted how they want. Great coffee and great local business to support. They have a growing menu and options. Hope they add pour overs soon. read more

Great lattes. Cool people. They were pleasant and helpful. Recommended a good breakfast place as well. I'll definitely come back the next time I'm in town. read more

Just went to out there coffee for the first time and absolutely loved it! I consider myself a coffee snob and I am usually drawn to smaller coffee houses. This place did not disappoint. Not only was the coffee delicious but we got a mini education on the different blends which we found out are custom roasted. The baked goods were outstanding and are also gluten-free for the most part, they certainly tasted delicious. We will be back many times over! read more

What an awesome spot. Great people, fantastic drinks and totally reasonable prices. OTC was part of the daily routine during our time in Cape May and it will be again next year. read more

Super nice owners! Great coffee/espresso! Literally just left had 2 drinks each (bf and I) before even leaving the place, that's how good it was! Would come here 2x a day if we lived nearby. Seriously check it out read more

Great coffee and great service! The employees were so helpful, they even helped me create my very own protein cold brew creation! Will definitely be back! read more

One smoothie every day for the week!! Every one as good as the last. A ton of options for dairy free milk. Very relaxed employees take good care to keep a laid back beach vibe even when busy. The "matchanana" was a brilliant green yet didn't taste at all like a liquefied salad. It was delicious. Had a lot of fun mixing and matching. Strawberry banana with soft serve ice cream anyone? They also had great gluten free baked goods home cooked by Mom. As a bonus, it sits right at the north end of an outdoor mall so you can stroll and window shop (or people watch) while you sip your smoothies. read more

Great coffee, people, and environment!! Definitely going to come back! The owner (cashier when I came in) has a ton of energy and great to talk to. A great place to stop in quickly for coffee or get breakfast and eat in the window seat or on a bench outside. The great location is perfect for a coffee any time of day any time of the year. Would 100% recommend! read more

I come to Cape May every year for a few days of r&r. I have been waiting a long time for a coffee shop like Out There Coffee: organic, fair trade coffee; yummy & healthy snacks, all organic; and a business based on being environmentally responsible with compostable plates, cups, etc. Excellent and friendly service to top it off. Now I hope they can get a few tables, either inside or outside, to fully enjoy this delightful place. read more

Great find!!! We were heading to another shop and happened across this spot...lucky we did! Great coffee, good atmosphere, friendly service! Ask Craig about the name, good story!!! read more

Absolutely the best coffee in Cape May, and right next to the Washington St., Mall across from the church so it is very easy to get to. Lots of variety, well roasted cofffee, and careful attention to your order. Great food as well and really wonderful friendly people, they also care a lot about recycling and environmental quality. If you go at night you can drink your coffee and see the horse drawn carriages that park in front of the store! Don't miss it! read more