SNAP-SHOT: The absolute best Gyro's in Mayport, FL!! Also, don't sleep on their pizzas. 4.5 Stars THE REVIEW: I typically eat chicken, beef, or lamb gyros (10/10). The pita bread is soft but durable enough not to fall apart because of the delicious tzatziki sauce lathered around the lettuce. The pizza was solid (8/10) for the area, given that some authentic Italian spots are minutes from this place. The fries were good (8/10), and the wings were okay (7/10). MY RECOMMENDATIONS: The competition for Italian and American food is too steep to invest much effort into improving pizza and fries. For the wings, master the cook to avoid the chewiness, and they should hold up fine against the other major pizza franchises (Pizza Hut, Domino's, Papa John's). read more

This place was pumping out business on a Saturday afternoon. When we arrived, there was somebody in line but nobody seated. I think maybe they do most of their service as takeout or delivery based on our experience. I got the chicken Gyro. It was large and tasty but nothing to rave about. I would definitely be down to go back and try more off their menu. Fries were delicious. Decent parking ! read more

See all

The pizza was way overcooked and the spinach pie was mushy...spent 33$..very disappointed. I had ordered extra cheese..so overcooked there was no pull of cheese. read more

I've ate here a couple times. Gyros were pretty good. Today, I tried the Philly cheesesteak...honestly the absolute WORST one I've EVER had my whole life. Bread was hard and burnt, they used lamb instead of beef, and the provolone cheese just made it that much more worse. I guess I learned a lesson not to go to a Mexican restaurant for Italian food lmao (just trying to make a point) Please Just take my word and do not trust getting anything from here besides a gyro. read more

Horrible food. We have gone here many times in the past and food was inconsistent with a few reliable items. Tonight our " reliable items" were horrible. Sausage pizza was cardboard with practically zero cheese and minimal sausage. Dry as a bone. Overcooked. The Greek sandwich which came with fries on previous orders, now cost an additional $. Too bad. I like to support local small businesses. We won't be back. read more

The wife and I have been looking for good Greek food. We've found it. It's a hole in the wall sort of. The gyro platter is wonderful and the pita bread and hummus is the best I've ever had. I'm looking forward to trying everything on the menu. read more

See all

Growing up in Tarpon Springs, always had great Greek food so now every time we visit other cities we try local Greek offerings. The gyro cone at Olympia, the meat didn't have any charring and that translated to the sandwich. Was almost as if the meat wasn't cooked all the way and the chicken souvlaki meat was so dry. Fries and tzatziki were good. The Greek salad mediocre. read more

Got a pizza and Greek salad takeout and they were fast & courteous! The spinach pie & Greek salad were an excellent value for the price and my kids gobbled the pizza super fast! Great value for the money! read more

Craving authentic Greek gyro? Head to Olympia Grill for the real deal! Large portions of meat paired with delicious tzatziki sauce make it a winner. For a great no-frills meal, stop by and try the lamb and chicken gyro combo, pictured read more

See all

The gyros was great, service was fast and courteous, place was clean, will definitely be back and recommend to my family and friends

We went for some gyros, and the lamb def was 5 star but the chicken - sub par and it had no flavor. We will go back to try chicken Parmesan sub soon as I saw those look amazing!! read more

Incredible food One of favorite spots. Best gyros great service go here all time have to check it out

Delicious! I tried Olympia for the first time tonight and I am not disappointed. I got the spinach pie platter. Spinach pie is so good and the Greek salad is very light and fresh. I love the dressing. I also got an order of fries. They are crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside and perfectly seasoned. I will definitely be back! read more

So good! A staple in our household. The Gyro and Gyro platter are not only delicious but a great value! They also offer great burgers and pizza by the slice which is great for picky eaters when the adults have their Greek food craving. read more

This is a solid place for a casual meal. Nothing special from an ambiance standpoint but comfortable and clean. We had lunch here on a Saturday and the gyros were delish. There were 6 of us and everyone liked their food. Pizza was pretty good. Prices are reasonable and the guy behind the counter, maybe the owner, was really helpful. I'd go again if back in the area. read more

One of my local favorites. Their gyro salad is generous, flavorful and really hits the spot. Their gyro sandwich on pita is also recommended. read more

Fantastic service and food. First time in and won't be last. Value meal is truly a value and everything was flavorful and hot and fresh! read more

Olympia Cafe - Gyro Value Meal - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Great customer service, flavorful fresh ingredients, inside has about 6/7 tables, reasonably priced, and very friendly employees. Ordered the chicken gyro platter (meat, pitas, fries, and Greek salad) everything was perfect, and the salad was a big portion size. Give this place a shot, you won't be disappointed. read more

Olympia Cafe - Gyro Platter - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

This place is a hole in the wall joint. All the food is excellent. I have not eaten at the establishment as I always get delivery. My favorite food is the spaghetti here! read more

Excellent Gyros!! great service and fast! I usually order to pick up and they are always ready. I am looking forward to trying other items on the menu that look delicious but I love the Gyros so much I keep getting them! read more

Visited this place and got take out while visiting Jacksonville! The food was delicious!! We ordered 2 gyros, a pizza, and a chicken Parm sandwich! The gyro meat was delicious! The portions were huge! The pizza was good! The only thing I can say needed tweaking was the chicken parm sandwich ( was good ) but would definitely order with the sauce on the side! Way too much! Sorry no pics for this review.... We we're hungry read more

I have been 20x and order the same thing... Gyro. It's the Best in town and I have to drive a bit for it but worth every mile. Pizza and wings are good too. read more

My daughter took me there a few months ago and I'm hooked now. I originally had a Gyro with lamb and a side and it was delicious. My wife and i order takeout a bit and we always include a Greek salad with chicken. Their Greek dressing is the best I've ever had and salad has good leafy lettuce not iceberg crap. Loads of grilled chicken on top. Also, you can order pizza by the slice which is great since we can't eat a whole pizza. Takeout is always ready as quoted. read more

The menu seemed a bit overpriced to me at first but once I saw the portion sizes, I believe they were fair. We ordered the turkey club, spaghetti and chicken Buffalo wrap. Everything was delicious! But the customer service was dreadful. The menu doesn't say the sandwiches/wraps come with a side so I asked if they had chips and the gentleman's facial expression immediately changed to this disgusted, possibly annoyed, look and all he said was "no". I said okay, can I just add a side of fries. A few moments later my husband asked if we could add cheese to the turkey club because again, it is not listed on the menu with the other ingredients that comes on it, and his face made the same annoyed look and he said "it had cheese". Anyways, the food comes and sure enough there was 3 sides of French fries because he couldn't be bothered to tell me the meal came with sides. The establishment itself was pretty dirty throughout. The condiments table was a mess and the containers they were stored in were unclean. I probably wouldn't return for another meal. read more

See all

Me and my wife ordered the gyro value meal, we usually go here when we crave their gyros. We found hair entangled in the meat of the gyro about 3-4 inches long light brown to blondish color. My wife brought it up with the cashier and he said "thats your hair" mind you my wifes hair is about 2 foot long black colored hair and she had it in a bun. We left shortly after having it remade, but the cashier said as we walked out the door "watch your hair next time huh?". The cashier's hair is about 3-4 inches long, mine is about 2 inches. Stupidly rude comment, especially when it was probably his hair. I dont know if ill go back. read more

Don't let the exterior fool you. Olympia's has some of the best Greek food and pizza you'll find (I know, interesting combo). Tbh, I love routine and almost always get the gyro combo. For $12 you get a gyro, fries, and fountain. Gyro is perfect and PACKED with meat. Meat forward in all the best ways. Fries are solid too. Recommend getting a side of Tzatziki sauce to dip them in. read more

Olympia Cafe - Don't judge the book by it's cover - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

That hit the spot that I didn't know needed to be hit. Staff was friendly. Gyro was enormous and the lamb was perfect. read more

Free delivery, friendly staff, bomb food... well what are you waiting for?! We ordered a gyro and a Philly last night and they were delivered in less than 30 minutes and were delicious!!! The only thing I wasn't impressed with were the fries, but that's okay!!! Great local spot! read more

Olympia Cafe - Philly!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Incredible Gyro Platter at this place. All for about 14 bucks you get a bunch of gyro, fries, pita, and a full salad with tzatziki and caesar dressing on the side. Totally hit the spot after a week out to sea. Navy recommended, Navy approved! read more

Olympia Cafe - Incredible Gyro Platter - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

One of the only places in Jax that serves up a proper gyro... none of that pre-packaged lamb meat. Theirs is shaved right off the spit. Great tzatziki sauce and a descent Greek salad read more

My father decided to get two burgers with fries and when the delivery driver left the house, he decided to give himself an $8.30 tip. This business should not have people that operate like this. I do not recommend you get delivery. It's best to get it in person that way you don't have to worry about people stealing your hard earned money. But the funny thing is, they just got a war from yelp for outstanding service and this happens. I do not think that is how a business operates in any way shape or form. read more

Take out order Greek salad and gyro platter. Guess salad ok as no comment but platter was poor. Taziki flavor very unappealing, meat was like shoe leather and fries were raw inside the "golden" finish. Not some place I'm anxious to repeat as had looked forward to the meal but so disappointed. read more

Had the salad with the lamb omg it was everything ate it on lunch break man with was goood will be back to try gyro

Olympia Cafe has, by far, the best gyros and buffalo wings in town hands down. The gyro meat is juicy and flavorful. I tried the Gyro platter yesterday and it was amazing. The salad with the greek dressing is wonderful. The sauce that comes with the gyro is also delicious. The wings are just the right size, crispy, and the buffalo sauce is amazing. I've never had a sauce like this in the Jacksonville and beaches areas. I highly recommend it. They also have unique eats like falafel and hummus and they were delicious. The owners and staff are very friendly and welcoming. Prices are very reasonable and affordable on every budget. We will be back often, this is hands down my favorite causal little-known eatery with the best food. read more

See all

Stopped in late. Wasn't expecting much but that's an understatement. The young man working the register was polite and informative. He gave suggestions. The place is spotless and the menu is huge for a pizza place. I ordered the 8.95 gyro special. It was huge and delicious. Ordered wings and they too were very very good. I highly recommend. read more

Olympia Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Not bad. Wings use the generic buffalo sauce, but are cooked just right. They're not super big, but they're not too small either. Fries have that nice crisp on the edges. Bottle of ketchup on the table. The wrap on the gyro is thick and soft. The meat has good flavor and decent seasoning. It uses a good amount of tzatziki sauce. read more

Olympia Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

The food was fresh, delicious, and reasonably priced. The service was top notch. The ascetic need a little work. Overall I would recommend!!! read more

Absolutely amazing fast deliveries the two delivery drivers that come to my house to deliver our funny quick and respectful.

Food- Fantastic. Brought Family of 7 in and all items were delicious. Philly cheesesteak, fresh hummus and pita, cheeseburgers, pizza and salads were all Legit and I can't wait to go again. Service- Also awesome, real "up north pizza place" vibe. Atmosphere- 10/10 would recommend it's a pizza joint nothing fancy but all you need. Long story short place was slammed with phone orders pick ups and eat ins (ate here right after jax airshow ended) and the food and service didn't take a hit with how busy it was they just kept it rolling business as usual which is impressive and tells me they aren't new to the business and we all know it takes good food to stay around a while so quit wasting your time going elsewhere and check this joint out. read more

Honestly, I do love this places food. But the staff? Thumbs down. They accidentally delivered food to me. Went and asked my neighbors if they ordered food, they all said no. Oh well, not much else I could do. 10/15 mins or so go by, I start eating it. Then some lady calls me up yelling saying I either need to pay for it or bring it back. I told her I already started eating it, why would I bring it back. She continued to yell at me, so I told her to come pick it up. I'm not gonna pay for something that was their mistake? The owner then calls asking what I'm going to do? Bro, it's not my mistake. Already told her to come pick it up. So at the end of the day, I will no longer order from here. Not when some crazy lady can't do her job right and so the company puts it on the customer to make it right. It's a no from me. read more