Came here on our way thru town, was on a road trip so I was with my brother and nephew. They chose this spot, I actually had eaten during my work meeting so I had a shake and watched them enjoy lunch. Parking is in back, no issues there. It's a cool spot- restaurant on the ground floor, and upstairs they sell different things made locally, and also clothes. It was fun to walk around while the food was being made. Our server was Kara, and she was awesome! My nephew has a peanut allergy so she was checking in on the entire order and sides to be sure we were in the clear! She was so helpful and friendly, even when there was an issue it wasn't a giant deal. My nephew and I started out by looking at the protein shake menu. I chose the green goddess protein shake, and he went with the cocoa Berry. Let me just say that mine was so good I finished it quickly. Nephew ordered the garlic sweet chili hummus appetizer to start. It came with freshly cut pita quarters, carrots, and strips of yellow and red peppers. Fresh, crunchy, hummus was absolutely addictively delicious and more than enough to share! He then got the pesto panini, my older brother ended up landing on the Italian panini (they sold out of the corned beef). He also got the soup special, stuffed cabbage soup and that looked really delicious and piping hot. Lots of cabbage and meat along with the broth. I had FOMO for sure. One panini came with a side salad, the other chose the tomato, onion, and cucumber salad that came with balsamic. So tasty I tried it later bc we took it to go, and I ate it all! Really great atmosphere and concept. On our way out we had a conversation with the manager/owner, and it was really pleasant. The weather was awful, but our stop here was a bright beacon and a memorable stop. Support small owned businesses! read more

See all

Very cute inside and friendly service. Wasn't able to make it up to the shops to take a look. There's also only a few tables for eating. The food was good and they had nice options on the menu and specials available, including wine specials. Small parking lot in the back. read more

Olive's Eatery was a great experience! I went there for lunch with my dad & my grandparents. We were able to be present, have a tasty meal (highly recommend the French onion soup) & then just walk around the little shops upstairs. The service was friendly & attentive. The space was cute in the way that if MacKenzie-Childs's this would be a space you'd enjoy. read more

See all

December's monthly brunch for a girl's Xmas exchange. I had never been here before, wow, What a cozy, girlie (in the best way) spot! I feel like homes as restaurants is a dying art. We HAD to start with the $16 bottomless mimosas * yum. I got a simple order of avocado toast with added eggs, which hit the spot for an easy meal, and the others got the breakfast burger & a panini. The ladies were super kind and it was a great spot. Our friend had her baby shower here, and from what I heard it was BEAUTIFUL!!! we didn't, but check out the Two Twisted Sisters shops! read more

See all

Such a quaint spot! There is outdoor seating in warmer weather as well. They have a coffee and smoothie bar as well as a pretty amazing gift shop upstairs. You can park across the street in the church parking lot of on the street and walk over. Or use the Baldwinsville main park lot and cross over the bridge by foot. They do have a small parking lot, but I don't count on it having spots all the time. The staff has super friendly every time I've been in. If they have the mousse it's a must!! read more

See all

This is the cutest place! Very friendly and experienced staff. My group stopped to do "blind date with a book" and grab dinner. I got the steak salad which my steak was not medium as asked but the flavors were amazing! Overall, wonderful experience read more

Olive's Eatery - Steak salad - New American Near Me - Baldwinsville, New York

Been going for decades. Fun place, mainly in the summer, beautiful garden atmosphere. The fountain outside is very relaxing

I've been here before but I heard they have new Owners and wanted to check it out. The main floor has been changed to all seating and a small bar. I love it! The upstairs now has all the vendors with jewelry, clothes, candles, soaps, baby items... many cool things. We were greeted by Claire our server and seated. She was very friendly and put on a fresh pot of coffee for us. My sister & I didn't want a whole panini so we split the chicken salad panini with a side of black bean salad. We also had a cup of soup. I had the special of stuffed pepper and my sister the french onion. Both were served with toasted garlic bread (yum). The sandwich was split for us and we each got a generous side of that black bean salad. We finished with a slice of homemade coconut cream pie. Everything was delicious and service was amazing! I will definitely be back and take advantage of the outdoor seating in the better weather. They have longer hours now with evening seatings. read more

See all

What a lovely little restaurant, locally owned and operated. My hubby and I had our Valentine Day lunch here and thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. I made reservations, and upon arrival, was led to a table with a small decorative chalk board with my name. I advise making recommendations because the dining rooms are small.The menu contained many cocktails, wines and craft beer in addition to a nice selection of non-alcoholic drinks. I ordered a white sangria which tasted more like a mimosa, with orange juice, fruit and something sparkling. If I received the wrong drink, I didn't care. I started with a cup of tomato bisque soup, the daily special. This was full bodied and contained some texture with veggies and tomatoes. For a main I had the tuna panini. Delightful! Sandwiches come with the side and I chose a small side salad, which was lovely. Because it was Valentine's Day. I decided to order dessert. And was so glad I did. The carrot cake was awesome. Service is great, and the food was delivered promptly though I never felt rushed. The interior of the restaurant is very homey with two small dining rooms. There is a gift shop as you enter and throughout the restaurant, you can also see various items for sale. It very much has a tea shop feel to it. Seemed to me that there were a number of "regulars" enjoying this home made food. read more

See all

Upon entering today we were greeted by the owner Tia, we were right away shown to our table outside by Jenny, our server. She was attentive, friendly and knew the menu well. I have a gluten issues and Olives caters to this with no problem with delicious options. I had the Chubby chicken panini and my daughter had the roast beef panini. The food is so wonderful and they are now starting up a brunch on weekends. Tia has redesigned the interior which includes a bar that serves wine. The atmosphere is so inviting and intimate. It's right up there with the restaurants in Baldwinsville with its own uniqueness and should not be overlooked! It's my favorite. read more

This is one of my favorite spots for lunch! They make everything fresh and it taste amazing! The staff is always super friendly, the atmosphere is cozy and relaxing and the decor is adorable! It's a beautiful little gem in baldwinsville, I highly reccomend! My favorite is their paninis and the trio of warm dips, they are all spectacular! The flavor is outstanding and you can taste that everything is made fresh! The trio of warm dips is large enough to be a meal for 3 people! It's oh so tasty and there is a spinach artichoke dip, Buffalo chicken dip and a white bean dip served with fresh warm tortilla chips, pita bread and toasted French bread. If you don't finish it all you'll have a wonderful snack to take home for later! Even my two young boys loved the food here and they are picky. I normally come here with girlfriends for lunch, we celebrate birthdays and more, but recently I treated my boys to lunch and all the staff were sweet to my boys! A nice bonus upstairs they sell locally handcrafted items from candles, jewelry, scarfs to decor; even my boys loved shopping. On a warm day they have a lovely spot to eat outside and enjoy the fresh air. I have yet to do this, but it looks wonderful. They are located right in the heart of baldwinsville so you could make an afternoon of it to get lunch and take a walk over the bridge to see the Seneca river. read more

Olive's Eatery - Mediterranean turkey panini and salad with a raspberry balsamic vinaigrette - New American Near Me - Baldwinsville, New York

See all

You can order lunch and while waiting you can shop! The sandwich and salads as well as the appetizers are delicious! A quaint spot in bville

We stopped in here after dress shopping. It is such a cute place, with a beautiful patio, tons of little stores inside, and the quaint little restaurant. I was pleasantly surprised with the gluten free options! I ordered the caprese gf sandwich with the French onion soup. Everything was so full of flavor and delicious! The gluten free bread was soooo good! Our server was a little brash, but did what she needed to do. I would definitely return! read more

Olive's Eatery - Caprese sandwich with French onion soup - New American Near Me - Baldwinsville, New York

Wonder place for lunch. My wife and I go frequently. In the nice weather there is outdoor seating. Good downtown spot walking distance to everywhere. Great menu and friendly staff. Never a disappointment. read more

Walked in just before closing and owner was still very welcoming and did not make us feel rushed. This is typical cafe food done well. The courtyard is very cute! read more

Olive's Eatery - Panini - New American Near Me - Baldwinsville, New York

See all

Service is always excellent! Really nice place to share a delicious meal! I just love it here!!!

Delicious choices. Good service. Fun atmosphere. Also fun looking through the boutique items for sale.

Such a fun places and always busy but the ladies do a great job of handling a crowd! I definitely recommend this place the food is delicious

Very good food and a friendly atmosphere. Great for lunch. Staff is very professional and attentive.

The soup Italian wedding was incredibly good I recommend and the little store attached is cute.

My wife ask me let's go to a place for different food. So let's go to Olives in Baldwinville . Cool place shopping and good food. My wife had the wine special she enjoyed. Two grilled sandwich and I enjoyed a cup of mushroom soup . Let's start the soup very good broth, mushrooms great taste but not over cooked with a little cream . Sandwiches we finished them both later that night. Large and great taste. No dessert to full next time soup and dessert good thought . Service great long term summer staff person. My wife shopping good , nice afternoon. I left a four star perhaps it should have five ? Next time four star is great for me. Looking forward to next lunch ! read more

This is the perfect lunch spot right near the Seneca River. It's connected to Two Twisted Sisters boutique which has the cutest knickknacks and jewelry. Perfect spot for a summer lunch outside read more

We went to Olives today for lunch. We are from California and found this place on Yelp. We had lunch on the cute front porch as it was nice weather. We had a chicken salad with mandarin oranges and a Italiano panini which was amazing. Service was friendly and speedy. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Olive's Eatery - New American Near Me - Baldwinsville, New York

Fantastic place to eat. The food was absolutely delicious and the staff were great too!!! One of the owners stopped at the table and asked how everything was, she was so pleasant !!!!! Alot of really nice shops inside the building too with clothing, purses, jewelry and many many other things. Had a great time shopping and eating. read more

That was easy...Yummy, Fresh, Clean , Healthy and just down right great . Must try for a nice relaxing evening. Service was great , other patrons polite, owners and advisor were fantastic at dinner and attached Twisted Sister great little cozy shop for gifts! All Run by great people. Park across from the restaurant on street very simple. I could have stayed all night. I'll be back . Definitely a must. Side bean salad was killer must try, got their Mediterranean Salad , with tuna ( you can choose other toppings) with balsamic vinaigrette just awesome, and they have Paninis which you can put in a wrap or on your salad ! Glass of Red and all set! read more

This is one of my favorite restaurants. The patio is beautiful and so is the food. It is all very fresh and delicious. I can't wait to come back again! read more

Olive's Eatery - New American Near Me - Baldwinsville, New York

Charming. Great service. Great food!! Was so disappointed when we moved to Baldwinsville a couple months ago when I looked around and all the Resturant's were chains. So thankful that's not actually the case. Olives is by far nothing like the chains on RT 31. It is unique and charming and everything you'd want in a local spot. I had their special mocha mint coffee. It was amazing. Can't wait to see if they'll have it again...maybe next Christmas at the very least?! I also ordered the soup and sandwich special. Both delicious. It was a wonderful experience and I'm looking forward to going back as soon as possible. read more

Olive's Eatery - New American Near Me - Baldwinsville, New York

Me, my wife and son stopped here on vacation when we were visiting my nieces new baby. It is an awesome place for lunch that is very cute. We are vegetarian so we had the mushroom panini and the caprese panini. Both were soooo good. The sides were coleslaw which was very good, and the black bean salad which was really good. We all had desert which was great. The mousse was awesome. It was a great find. Very relaxing. We sat on the porch and enjoyed the weather. read more

Great food, friendly staff and amazing atmosphere. The outdoor seating is cute in the summer, and the owners are friendly and generous. Good prices too! Will visit again if I'm ever in town. read more

Absolutely a delightful place to go with your friends for lunch. The food is so fresh and the owners are extremely personable and accommodating. Before or after your lunch you will want to make sure you do some shopping in the adjoining room to peruse the unique and beautiful accessories they have for sale. read more

Weird location but great food. Perfect for like a girls day out. I had a flat bread sandwich and it was really good and it came with a nice side as well. read more

The best place to get lunch in the area. Smaller menu but everything is wonderful. The trio of dips is one of the best appetizers from any local place. The owners and staff are amazing and the ambiance is great! read more

A cute and delicious eatery with a warm beautiful heart. My wife and I wanted to bring her family out to celebrate our daughter's second birthday and decided on Olive's so they could enjoy a different experience. Little did we know at that time, we too would be in for a pleasant surprise. My wife called them the day before on our way in from NYC and made the reservation. Sue was really accommodating as it was 10 of us and not everyone could wanted to sit outside in the heat. A little bit later we get a call back from Sue asking about the birthday girl so she could make it a bit special for her. How nice! The next day, we all arrived with the table really nicely set up - pink and white ribbons everywhere, and a little placard wishing here a happy birthday and a card signed by everyone at Olive's!! So very thoughtful! Everyone was really touched then the food started rolling in - every dish from appetizers to the main course was amazing. All of us had such a wonderful time and we will be back for sure! Thank you Suzy and the team for making this so memorable. An absolute must visit!! read more

I'm on vacation from North Carolina and had driven through Canada and exited through Northern New York coming down the highway it was about lunch time so I thought well I'll try to find something interesting on Yelp for lunch. I put in restaurants near me and up popped Olive's Eatery and I thought okay let's give it a try. So I followed the directions and I really enjoyed the little ride through the Syracuse Countryside found the little. Eatery and went in the back way of course the wrong way and found my way to the front. I was greeted by a nice lady who said you know I could sit anywhere and the place was absolutely the cutest thing. I thoroughly enjoyed looking at it and getting ideas and it took a little while for the waitress to come over because she she came over and brought me and on the back was the menu very cute I picked out to have the Popeye it's called it was a panini with turkey and cheese and a side of side dish it was very good. While they were bringing me or getting me my lunch I took a minute to walk around two sisters and it is a cute Boutique with hats and jewelry and bags and just anything a lady would like and upstairs they had Christmas stuff and it was just a lovely place for ladies to lunch. So if you're driving through Syracuse be sure to stop there and enjoy your afternoon. read more

Olive's Eatery - #anniesadventure2018 - New American Near Me - Baldwinsville, New York

Great little cozy & romantic spot in Baldwinsville. Their outdoor seating transports you to a little jungle - with the exception of the noise from cars on the main st. oops! But still A for ambience. Love their paninis. My fav is the popeye - How can you go wrong with Turkey and Bacon! read more

This is such a cute charming restaurant. We were greeted with a warm welcoming smile from when we arrived to when we left. Everyone made me feel like I was right at home. The food was amazing. There are cute shops upstairs where there are antiques, clothing, jewelry, soaps, scarves, homemade decor... it was all so beautiful. We definitely come back again. read more

Ate here for breakfast for the first time the other day. Good food and service was excellent. Loved the outdoor seating. We will definitely be back read more

Best panini I've had! I had the VV. Turkey, Brie, green apples, and cranberries. So good and the service was great as well. I had the white sangria which had peaches and strawberry and it was equally delicious! The environment is very quaint and cute and it makes it feel homey, it's nice. read more

Love everything about this place. Try the creative different sounding apps. They are always the best. read more

Olive's Eatery - New American Near Me - Baldwinsville, New York

See all

Loved our entire experience. Small intimate location, and extremely friendly service. Ownership is present and periodically making sure you're enjoying your meal. Nothing over the top but exactly what you'd want out of a restaurant like this. Went for dinner on a Friday night and was seated immediately, as their business is slower during the winter months. Can not wait to try again when the weather is warmer and sit outside. Don't look any further than this. Get the chocolate mousse for dessert. Shareable and absolutely amazing. Make sure you have the time to look at the various items for sale in the front and upstairs portion of the house! read more