Their selection of pastries, cookies, breads is wide. Everything we've tried has been delicious!

I came across this spot while out in the field for work and decided to stop in. The selection was a bit overwhelming at first, so I asked the staff for their recommendations. I ended up trying a chocolate chip cookie, lemon bar, mini confetti cookies, and a boysenberry pocket--which was my favorite. The cookies were decent, but the boysenberry pocket really stood out: flaky, held together perfectly, and full of flavor. The ambiance was inviting, and I was pleasantly surprised to see they also offer a variety of sandwiches and other menu items. I'd definitely come back to try more of those, along with additional desserts and pastries. I even picked up some dog treats while I was there--always love discovering places like this! read more

See all

Absolutely terrible and rude customer service. My wife called to ask if they had a certain cake and the girl on the phone was the rudest person we ever had on a phone call. Had a terrible attitude and didn't try and answer our simple question at all even though we were being courteous and polite the entire time. She ended up just abruptly hanging up on us. If these are the kind of employees that this business employs then nobody should go to this place. We will never be back and tell everyone we know. Especially since I work at the local power company. That will be a lot of people. read more

Adj: Tasty! This is an old fashion traditional bakery that makes this really delicious pastries and cookies. I've but tried the custom order cakes so I can't speak on those, but they sure look pretty. Specifically, the Pineapple cream cheese cake is what is we really like. It's more like a coffee cake style cake, or like a giant pull apart filled pastry than like a cake. Definition: Pineapple cream cheese cake: a giant pull apart pastry filled with gooey sweet and savory goodness! We also like certain of their seasonal cookies. Overall, this place is a wonderful source of sweet treats and generally the staff is friendly and the store gives off warm, sweet smelling aroma that create a lovely ambiance. read more

See all

Been going here for a while and service has been getting worse. Ladies just stare at you while you're just waiting to get help. Racial profile you and don't help you until you ask them. read more

Everything was beautiful and everyone raved for the carrot cake and red velvet cupcakes. My daughter's favorite were the little chocolate mice. We moved here 2 years ago, so I was not aware of what y'all exactly sold, but now I know...Everything was delicious! We will definitely be back for other occasions. read more

See all

Amazing pastries! We went to a birthday party and had the Best cake. Not a huge surprise that it was from Olde Tyme Pastries. Just amazing every time. I haven't been disappointed by anything from here. Anywhere else I'm a pie guy but OTP gets me going cake. The service is okay. The ambiance is nice. All that really matters is that the deserts are the best. Pro tip- stop by Oak Barrel Ice and Creamery to pick up some vanilla ice cream and pop a scoop onto your cake slice....Nothing better! read more

Olde Tyme Pastries - Amazing cake - Bakeries Near Me - Turlock, California

See all

I was not impressed by the service here. When I arrived, I was told to take a number but ended up walking back and forth between the deli and bakery with no direction. After waiting 15 minutes, I finally went up to the bakery counter since others who came after me were being helped. Only then did someone ask if I had been helped. When I said no, I was told I had to order my sandwich at a different counter. I ordered a breakfast sandwich and a chai apple pie drink. The sandwich itself was fine, but pressing a croissant on a panini grill made the bread hard and unpleasant--if you order a breakfast sandwich, I'd skip the press. The drink was where things really went downhill. I asked for less apple juice and more chai, but the remake tasted exactly the same. When I asked for clarification, I was finally told the drink is made with apple juice as its base, so it was never going to taste different. As someone who works in customer service, I feel the barista should have explained this upfront rather than remaking the same drink. On top of that, the barista seemed annoyed when handing it to me. The gal who made my sandwich was friendly, but overall the service felt unorganized and frustrating from start to finish. Sadly, this was my first and last visit. read more

Olde Tyme Pastries - Apple Chai iced latte more like apple juice with a cold foam - Bakeries Near Me - Turlock, California

See all

We came here for sandwiches for lunch and let me tell you the garlic focaccia bread (used for my Turkey Cobb sandwich) was amazing! I rarely finish the bread on my sandwich but I simply couldn't resist! Additionally, let me tell you, their staff works nonstop to assure everyone is well taken care of! We live on the other end of Modesto and we'll definitely be back! read more

Service was AWFUL!! Not one person greeted us or smiled at us. Absolutely terrible. The girl that helped us seemed so miserable and she was rude. We had never been in before and weren't sure what the process and she was annoyed when we asked her about a menu item. The girl making coffee never made eye contact with a single person and the wait was long! Lastly, the same rude girl that took our order, didn't wash her hands after helping someone else and then proceeded to make sandwiches. The place was very busy but the service was embarrassing. Definitely could use some help. The coffee and breakfast sandwich my husband got was ok. But we'd never go back. read more

Olde Tyme Pastries - Breakfast sandwich with a pickle & a cupcake?? Ok...sure...? - Bakeries Near Me - Turlock, California

The one good place Turlock has to offer. The rest is POOP (thanks for all the selections and great atmosphere) Prices were good too read more

Okay so the owner replied, I didn't know fresh strawberries came brown. I also did let my cake sit for 3hrs at room temp before we cut into it but I guess yes this was user error. The quality does speak for itself. I also did order fresh strawberries and jam not butter cream in every layer. So I guess this is all the customers fault. read more

Olde Tyme Pastries - Dry old tasting cake - Bakeries Near Me - Turlock, California

See all

I love their homemade cakes here the food is spectacular. Service is great atmosphere is great because of the hometown feeling.

My son was craving cheesecake, and after looking up places online, he decided to order a raspberry cheesecake from Olde Tyme Pastries. When we went to pick it up, the place was pretty busy, so we had to take a number to get helped. The wait wasn't too bad, though, and the price seemed reasonable considering the cake was a good size. I'm not a fan of cheesecake myself, but to me, it looked dry, and the jelly or topping on it didn't seem very appealing--it looked dry as well. Because of that, I wasn't even tempted to try it. My son, on the other hand, was super excited since the place has a lot of good reviews. Unfortunately, he wasn't thrilled after tasting it. He's had two slices, and the rest is still sitting in the fridge waiting to be thrown out. Unfortunately, I don't think we'll be going back--at least not for cheesecake. read more

See all

Husband and I stopped in here on a whim when and were amazed that we have lived in this area for several years and never heard of his place. Everything we had was great. We split a sandwich and order of potato salad and left with a few pasties. We had the chocolate mice, a mini cheesecake and a crème brûlée. The English muffin bread is also amazing! We purchased a cake for my mom's birthday and the lady helping us was kind enough to write a birthday message on it. Will definitely be back! read more

We have been long time customers over the years. Overall their quality and service go above and beyond. The cafe inside is super cute and vibe is relaxed. To be fair we only order cakes and desserts. This weekend we ordered a cake for my sister's birthday gathering. We had to provide the cake decoration. We specifically asked for whipped frosting because generally buttercream is too sweet. My family usually scapes it off. We picked up the cake before they closed on Saturday evening and it was covered in buttercream. It was too late to do anything. That was a specific request that was missed. Pro tip: get your order in early and be prepared to bring your own decorations if you have a specific theme. read more

See all

Very disappointed with the quality of the pastries. Most of them are very old and it tasted very bad. We went there with huge expectation but the bakery failed us badly. We bought eclair, Chocolate mice, bee hive and some other pastries, everything was equally bad. I will never visit again. read more

wish I could write a better review. I went in store to try their sandwiches because people bring the pastries to work and they are good. The food is yummy, unfortunately the service is terrible! Especially for the price point. I have tried at lunch time and breakfast and There is a huge wait for them to take your order and get your food...even in the am when there was no line really. They have one person taking phone orders, making the food and taking walk in orders. One girl is just over there making coffees ignoring everything else around her. For a $13 breakfast sandwich, you would think they could actually hire more workers. read more

Pastries were amazing! Delicious and flavorful in every bite. Texture was perfect and mouth watering by just looking at them. Definitely recommend and give more than 5 Stars if can. read more

It was very nice to see people lined up before the doors open. It shows how this place has its staple in the community and met another Mantecan outside waiting like myself .... So shows how people come and stop in and enjoy from all around the valley read more

Imma be honest the pastries were not that good and really overpriced for what it is i was extremely disappointed and the lady whom helped me was very rude and rushing me but the place its self is very cute and aesthetic. read more

Have been coming here for years and years. Great food and pastries, etc. But, ssslllloooooooowwwwwwwwww service and not as friendly as they were with previous ownership. I order treats for my office a couple times per month and last few times I thought it was a fluke..........no, it is their typical M.O. now, very disappointing. read more

I wouldn't come back for a custom order. I asked for a cake from here (because of the yelp reviews) for my birthday. We asked for a chocolate cake with whip frosting and cream cheese filling but the frosting and filling were both buttercream so the only thing right was the chocolate cake. It was just way too sweet but too far to return because we live on the further end of Modesto. read more

Olde Tyme Pastries - Bakeries Near Me - Turlock, California

Having been a OTP fan for over 20 yrs , I've noticed that the quality of their pastries isn't what it used to be. Their apricot cheese pockets and carrot cakes for example taste like they have substituted lard instead of real butter so everything now is lacking the buttery, scrumptious taste OTP was famous for. Please don't sacrifice taste over profits read more

Oh my god there was so many delicious treats to pick for all are amazingly delicious there focaccia bread is to die for it reminds of the focaccia I used to get as a kid in San Francisco north beach!!! I'm definitely going back !!! Ten stars for me !!!! read more

We have been coming to Old Tyme Pastries since the last century. I would frequently drive my family over 30 miles each way to get their wonderful pastries and cookies. I haven't been by for a few years as my kids are now grown, but I went there today. I was very much disappointed. The pastries and cookies are smaller than they used to be and cost more. I get ht3 cost more, but come on, the cookies were small. The croissant was micro. The pastries we ordered were stale. We don't understand how that could happen as we ordered at 8am on a Monday. It used to be that the stale items were pulled from behind the glass and put out at a bargain price. The pastries were definitely either baked and prepared poorly or were stale, or both. For five bucks for a tiny croissant, I expect better. read more

My daughter wanted a very trendy heart cake for her 24th birthday which was red with gold lettering. Inside was chocolate with fresh strawberries. This place did exactly what she asked for. They did not just listen to her they heard her. Old Tyme pastries listens to their customers and goes above to help with their experience.Old Tyme Pastery store was clean with the smell of fresh bread baking. read more

Olde Tyme Pastries - Dessert - Bakeries Near Me - Turlock, California

They are the best customer service and quantity. I will go nowhere else for our pastry needs and want

There has not been one time where I have left here displeased! I have been coming here since before I can even remember. The desserts are always fantastic and usually the staff are very nice and helpful. The fruit basket cake(which isn't really a cake but more of a tart), the beehive cake and the napoleon are some of my family's favorite, though I'm more of a cheesecake kinda girl. Every flavor of cheesecake they have is delightful! The one thing I don't like about here is the lines lol, they are so popular that they are usually very busy. Though the line goes quickly as you look at all your options, just make sure you grab your ticket to be helped! Mom and pop vibes are very cozy in here!!! read more

Olde Tyme Pastries - Raspberry cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Turlock, California

Oh this place is great! My bestie introduced me to this place years ago. Now I find myself stopping here before or after visiting her. It's a pretty big place. Tons of seating. Friendly staff. You can get everything from coffee to a sandwich to a cookie and a cake. Everything I've had here is really good. There's tons to choose from so it can be a difficult decision, but I assure you that it will taste delish. I live in a different state and I had to order a cake. They were so helpful, the process was super smooth. This place is definitely a go-to spot when in the area and I highly recommend them. read more

This bakery is near and dear to my heart . We been customers since the early 80's when they had a bakery in Ceres, off Whitmore avenue. My mom would take me there for treats and to pick my half sheet cake for my birthday every year until they closed the ceres location. My favorite cake was and still is the white cake with fresh strawberry filling. Every-time I walk in I'm instantly transported back in time to my childhood, as soon as the sweet smell of the bakery hits me. The cookies, cupcakes, the chocolate mouse that hit my eyes as if I was a child again. The instant happiness that embodies my soul is like no other. I now buy my babies their special birthday cakes and take them to pick a special treat for special occasions. I hope one day they can look back and feel as happy and joyful as I know feel going there . They are truly a gem of the community. read more

We love old tyme pastries. We ordered this chocolate cake that was already made in the case. The cake was chocolate with some Carmel in the middle with whip cream frosting and a drizzle of caramel on top. It was so moist and delicious. The whip cream was so light and fluffy. The taste was amazing. The time that I went in it was busy, but just take a number and wait a bit while you look around and it was my turn in no time. read more

Olde Tyme Pastries - Chocolate cake - Bakeries Near Me - Turlock, California

Our favorite bakery on the 99! Today, we bought two favorites: apple nests and coffee cake. We tried three new items: salted caramel chocolate chip bar, walnut bar/slice, and million dollar bar. Both of us voted the walnut bar to be most excellent!!! Everything they make here is delicious! I enjoyed the million dollar as I love shortbread and chocolate! It's a winner! read more

Wonderful job again, strawberry cake for the win!! A few changes needed but bakery department was able to Rectify those changes during pickup, which we're so grateful for. Everything ended up beautiful, we're so appreciative and it was all delicious ! Highly recommend that strawberry cake + carrot cake cupcakes ! Thank you !!! read more

Olde Tyme Pastries - Strawberry cake + cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Turlock, California

See all

Whoever is managing this place is not doing a good job. They are inconsistent with their food. Their prices are too high. The pastries often have a freezer burn taste, and they constantly have new employees who do not know what they are doing. This place used to be good now it's just overpriced and frustrating. read more

Bakery: Delicious pastries. Love their seasonal cupcake flavors and designs. We have gotten cakes here on multiple occasions, and most of them are good. Overall the cakes and cupcakes are moist and have a good amount of sweetness. But this place isn't perfect, so some things can be hit or miss. Food: the soups and sandwiches are good. They aren't anything spectacular. A little on the pricier side, but the homemade bread makes it worth it for the most part. The sandwiches come with a cookie and a pickle. They also have redbull infusions and other caffeinated beverages. Service: hit or miss. I always make sure to greet the workers and treat them kindly. But some of the younger women have somewhat of an attitude. Which is annoying because no one wants to deal with that. If they don't want to answer questions about cake flavors, maybe they should have place cards with the dessert names and flavors. On the hand, The older lady that always seems to be there is always sweet and doesn't mind answering questions about the cakes. Side note- I don't think Prepaid orders should have to wait in line. I've ordered custom cakes from here on 3 separate occasions, fully paying the amount due each time. On my pickup dates, I'm always told I have to get a number and wait for my turn. Which is frustrating because sometimes the wait is an upwards of 25 minutes, just to pick up an order I already paid for. They should have a separate checkout for prepaid items. read more

The service is always excellent - especially when ordering a custom cake. Unfortunately, their baked goods and pastries are barely edible. read more

Having a nice local bakery so close to the house is amazing! It's actually right down from my kids school, so I can easily pick up treats. The girls like to go in and see what's new in the case. Themed cupcakes, glittered cake pops, treats that look like creatures. It's a lot of fun! One of my favorite items is the lemon cheesecake. I always buy a whole one and it doesn't last very long in our home. It's prefect creamy and just enough tartness from the lemon. Another favorite is the pineapple cream cheese coffee cake. It's sooooo good and another thing that I usually pick up when I go in. Once, I was waiting to help chaperone a field trip and ran over and discovered they have them in individual sizes! Grabbed one and a delicious glacier (blended iced coffee) and was all set for breakfast. We had a birthday cake made for my daughter and she wanted a mermaid theme. It came out super cute and was light and fluffy. Love that we can go in and have a cake done the way we want it. Christmas time, I wanted to try something new and discovered they had an eggnog mousse cake! It was so yummy! I love eggnog. The flavor was light and the mousse made this cake so creamy and light. One of my favorite things about having so many options is, they made our at home afternoon tea so easy. They offer a variety of scone flavors and I picked up some adorable macarons, petit fours, mini cheesecakes and the little cute mouse treats. My girls were over the moon! I could go on and on about all the other things I've gotten, but this review would be soooo much longer. If your looking for something different and yummy, go check then out! read more

See all

Thank you for the most delicious marble and coffee cream filled wedding cake. It was delicious! read more

Olde Tyme Pastries - Cake my Olde Thyme Pastries and Floral by Bloom and Forage Farms. - Bakeries Near Me - Turlock, California

I wasn't able to order my recent birthday cake, so I gave my SO a picture of what I wanted and he was able to go and pick it up. Their truffles are literally amazing! The pizza bread is drool worthy and their deli items are amazing. Only place I want to go to when I'm craving great bakery items. read more