Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Old Timey Eats

    4.0 (4 reviews)
    Closed Closed
    Updated 1 week ago

    Old Timey Eats Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Old Timey Eats

    Recommended Reviews - Old Timey Eats

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    21 days ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Jennifer M.

    Jennifer M.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Old Timey Eats

    B J Bull Bakery - Beef mushroom

    B J Bull Bakery

    4.7(192 reviews)
    14.2 mi
    $

    Best Bread Pudding on the Planet Earth. Get it, you will thank me…read more On top of the best savory and fruit pies.....but don't forget the damned bread pudding!!!!!

    I stopped by after their normal Saturday business hours, expecting them to be closed, so I was…read moredelighted to find them open. The service was warm, welcoming, and genuinely caring. The dough maker, whom I believe was named Aliza (apologies if I have the name wrong), was there preparing fresh dough, which was wonderful to see. I was fortunate to find a few pastries still available, including the Chile Verde and Beef with Cabbage. The Beef with Cabbage pastry was flavorful and especially enjoyable with their homemade "Hot & Spicy" sauce. While I would have preferred the pastry dough to be a bit crispier, I purchased it after hours and was still very pleased with the quality and taste. Overall, it was a delightful surprise and a very enjoyable experience. I also picked up one Chocolate Brownie with walnuts and a slice of their homemade Carrot cake. I had the carrot cake and it was outstanding! Fresh, flavorful, and loaded with carrots and walnuts, it was everything a great carrot cake should be. I've enjoyed desserts at five-star restaurants and have family members that easily ranks among the best bakers and this cake was delicious!!! Every mouthful was pure deliciousness, and my taste buds were extremely happy. I would gladly order it again!

    Photos
    B J Bull Bakery - Easy counter service with premade, take home pasties!

    Easy counter service with premade, take home pasties!

    B J Bull Bakery - The beef and mushroom pastie. I will be back for more of these delicious delights.

    The beef and mushroom pastie. I will be back for more of these delicious delights.

    B J Bull Bakery - The beef and mushroom pastie. I will be back for more of these delicious delights.

    See all

    The beef and mushroom pastie. I will be back for more of these delicious delights.

    The Star Hotel - Filet Mignon

    The Star Hotel

    4.1(457 reviews)
    14.1 mi
    $$

    My son recommended this place to my wife and I. As we were traveling back from a great vacation we…read more Are spending the night in Elko, NV so we decided to go and try it out. It not only did it meet our expectation, it exceeded our expectations! The service was amazing, fast and very smooth! The food was served fast, hot and very appealing! The staff was very friendly and best of all the price was very cheap for the amount of food that was provided! The Star Hotel Basque Dining may be the best kept secret in Nevada, best not in Elko, the line was very consistent but the staff were seating guests dry fast and smooth! The Star Hotel Basque dining also had a bar as you walked in and they had two TV''s on with the soccer games, and the guess were having a great time! Thank you for a wonderful experience, and a delicious dinner!!

    I've heard about The Star Hotel from friends, but we'd not traveled through Elko. Alas, we had our…read moreoppotunity. In sum, we really liked it and will be back. In reading reviews from others, one needs to know the style and intent of the place. People looking for sophisticated, fancy meal will be disappointed. People looking for a family style meal, with the warm and engaging people, with honest, real, good food, will be thrilled. We were there for a late lunch. Our server was extremely kind and explained the menu, process, and local favorites The Pico Punch had a touch of Vicks 44, but that's exactly what it should taste like. The quantities are huge. Cabbage soup broth was delicious. Italian bread would be better if warmed, but still good. The salad was robustly tossed and the dressing had a nice touch of garlic. The steak sandwich was tender and had an excellent marinade/flavor. Fries: very greasy and not their finest moment. We have family in Iowa and this all felt similar: Midwest friendliness, warmth, and good food. We were leaving at 445 and the line had grown to 20 for dinner! Appeared to be locals/regulars. As another noted, yes, there are brothels just down the street. Hey, it adds to the local charm!

    Photos
    The Star Hotel
    The Star Hotel - Porterhouse Steak at The Star Elko

    Porterhouse Steak at The Star Elko

    The Star Hotel - Petite Lamb chop The the Star

    See all

    Petite Lamb chop The the Star

    Old Timey Eats - foodtrucks - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...