An amazing bar! They…read moredon't serve food. That means dogs are welcome! ONLY WELL BEHAVED DOGS! Bartender was nice. Went through the list of tequila options for me and got me setup in no time. Pool table and darts are available to play. Big round bar so there is plenty of room to get a drink.

The afternoon bartender is the man. I come here twice a year and somehow he remembers me and my…read moredrink. The evening bartender seems to not care about anyone there. Don't bother playing the juke box and he won't turn it up for you. Only bar where you can hear it over the patrons when there is less than 20 people here.

Came here for a low key valentines day and it did not disappoint. We got there around 7pm and we're…read moreable to get a seat at the bar. It was pretty quiet until around 10pm when we left. We ordered wings, fries, fried pepperoni and many drinks. The wings were solid. We got everything and bbq. The everything is spicy. The rest of the food waa great. I liked the fried pepperoni that were recommended to me. Im recommending them to you. You also get marinara sauce for dipping. Downside. I think my gluten allergies are getting worse because this is a shared fryer and I had small reactions that I wasn't expecting. Bartenders were fun and friendly. It was a great time! Highly recommend for a low key night and solid wings with a bunch of different flavors.

Got to love a dive bar but the help in here wasn't the best! 1st at a Sunday at 2 O'clock in the…read moreafternoon with 5 people in the place and the doorman asked my daughter for ID she is 40 then me!!!! I'm clearly a seinor woman why ask!! He had no personality when I tried to talk to him. We ordered our drinks sex on the beach and vodka and ice tea. He made my daughter's 1st she wanted a large then was doing mine and was almost done with making it and said ' that was a large right ' I said guess it is now! 2 strikes. Didn't stay long enough for a 3rd. The menu sounds good great prices just enough on there for a snack while drinking. I do love a good dive bar and I did like Mr.Goodbar back in the day maybe I'll try again and might have a different experience

We live in New York City so have never experienced this sort of racism. The lady who was the…read morebartender was horrible to my husband and I. It starts off with us calling out to her she for our drinks which she ignored. Not only that, when my husband asked her to remove the ice she removed the whole drink. We decided to leave it at that, I thought I could speak to her kindly to change it. When I went there, she said "you made me remove the ice that's why this is like this, and I can't give people like you free shit" I was honestly just shocked and a little bit drunk from the place we went before so I couldn't process it, looking at my shocked face she goes "I can make you another drink but you'll have to pay for it" I say yes do that please. She shows me quantity mocking me, "this is what is used and the amount of quantity I'm not gonna do this again so I'm showing you" I still say thank you When she comes back with the new drink, i was about to take it and then go back to our seat where my husband is and get money to pay her, returning her my old drink, she goes "nah I'm not giving it to you until you pay it" since I'm tipsy I say please keep my drink too I'll give you the money, while I'm giving her back the drink she doesn't hold the glass and it tips off and falls and she makes a nasty face I say sorry and proceed to get the money from my husband. By then husband saw me at the waiting at the bar too long and was heading towards me to help me out. When he comes I tell him to give me money and he gives it to me, again at the bar we're trying to catch her attention, she comes back are you paying for the drink? I say yes with the 20$ in my hand reaching out to give it to her, and asked the drink you spilled I already paid for that, are you gonna give me that back? She proceeds to not give the new drink I say can I have my drink back, she screams I'm not serving you lady, get off! I was still calm and didn't say anything cuz I was tipsy, my husband right next to me while this happened. (He was confused as he didn't know what happened in the first half of the conversation as he wasn't there) We were absolutely shocked and ended up leaving, I ended up crying the whole night. Waited for the alcohol to wear off to understand what I've truly been through. Saw the timings of the bar so we could go and talk to the manager/owner about it, I called the number present in google, waited for someone to pick up, the cleaner picked up after I called multiple times, it opens at 3pm on Sunday we would've left Buffalo by then to start for home, so we went at 1pm to see if anyone was there, same cleaner. Left him our numbers, he said he will let his manager know but didn't help (as apparently he didn't know anything else, didn't even know the name of the tall female bartender, who was so ugly to me) Since then I've emailed, called, there has been no response. I'd not have posted this had there been any response since then. I've been affected by this humiliation horribly, my mental health got messed up cuz I'm still questioning as to how can someone behave like this with me, what did I do wrong, because surely the color of my skin cannot be the only reason you hate me, we were celebrating 6 months of our marriage, seeing Niagara Falls was so immensely beautiful, but this experience changed my whole perspective about human behavior, all I can say is Please donot spend your hard earned money there that is my only request. PS: I keep posting the review on Google but they keep removing it somehow I just posted it again. But they removed it. I'm gonna keep posting until it's there.

Came here for the dive bar vibe to watch the hockey game last night and it did not disappoint…read more(unlike the Sabres). Always such a fun place to chill, or play a few bar games if you're into that. Ordered the Rhody sandwich which was fantastic. The two bartenders were very attentive and offered great service. Will totally be back for the cheeseburger quesadilla- I need to try it!

Such a wonderful variety of tasty and delightful food! The atmosphere is welcoming, eclectic and…read morevery entertaining.

Stopped in on Sunday on the Labor day weekend there were a few costumers at the bar area.They just…read moreput up the fall drink menu had to get the pumpkin spice martini ! Boy was it delicious had to order another! It had vanilla vodka,Irish cream, pumpkin spice and whipped cream on top. I want one now! My daughter had a sex on the beach and ordered a Italian sausage sandwich to go. Its her favorite here with great crusty bread and plenty of peppers and onions. Talked to the bartenders and the costumers a little was a nice way to spend a afternoon on labor day Sunday.

This trip was much better than last!…read more Cecilia is a gem and wayyyyyyy better server than the girl last time. Shout out to Cecilia!!!!!! Food was amazing. We ordered the burger because it was so good last, but we also ordered the Rueben tonight as well. The Rueben was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had... completely next level! Place was busy and loud but it didn't mind. We lucked out on parking and found a spot right in front. The 40 sauce wings were spot on as always!!!

We had lunch at Forty Thieves, and the food was fine. Unfortunately, our experience after leaving…read morewas very concerning. When we got home, our credit card company alerted us to two fraudulent charges on the credit card we had used for lunch. This was the only business where our credit card was taken out of our sight and returned to us that day, so naturally it raised concerns. What has been even more disappointing is the complete lack of response from management. We have called four separate times, each time being told there was no manager available. We left our name, phone number, and a detailed message on every call, yet no one has returned our calls. We understand that fraudulent charges can happen for many reasons, and we're not accusing anyone of wrongdoing. However, when a customer experiences something this serious, the least a business can do is respond promptly and take the concern seriously. The lack of communication has been extremely disappointing.

One of the best neighborhood pubs in Buffalo. We've been coming here for 4 decades and it has never…read moredisappointed. The menu is classic Buffalo fare from Hot Pepper dip to French Onion Soup and they do the critical Buffalo items (Wings, Weck, and Friday Fish Fry) right and proper. If you only have a few days in Buffalo, do not miss this place. Dinner with a cocktail and a beer is a surefire hit. Bartenders are excellent.

I have been going here for years! But this past week was…read morevery disappointing. We had a large table, a few from out of town but have been before and wanted to go back. Service: The waiter was not knowledgeable about the menu and seemed to be in a bit of a hurry, like he had somewhere to be and we were his last table. One person sat without an entry and he came and asked the customer what dish he was waiting for. The server served a French onion soup that was charred across the top, the cheese was black, and only offered "I have had it like that and liked it"! Two of us got mussels, the portion was smaller than usual ( I have gotten the several times before) the bread was way over toasted, and when we asked for a bit more of the jus, he came after a while with a cup of what looked like buttered water. My point is, the cooks were not up to usual par, and the waiter did not care about serving. We still gave a 20% tip, on a $500. + bill. But it was not deserved. This review is for the owner, Jay may need to check on the food end once in a while on a busy Friday night.

Crazy, authentic dive bar with table shuffleboard. And cheap beer. I love cheap beer. I love…read morethis bar. A woman flashed me on my way out. xoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxo KT

Wow. So let me tell you a story about my first time at Hillikers Pastime…read more It was late on a Wednesday, and my friend and I were leaving a gig at the Sportsmens Tavern, when a girl came by on her bike and said "are you guys going to the party down the block?" We told her we hadn't heard of any party, and she said "Well you should come, they're playing music and having a good time." We got our instruments and followed her lead, but she was too fast, and disappeared, leaving us in front of a barn-looking building with a sign that read "Hilliker's Pastime." We should have gone home, but we felt an auspicious pull inward. We went in, and were transported to another realm. We drank $2 beers and were taught shuffleboard by our enormous bartender. We were hit on - hard - by 45 year old woman who kept asking us to play our instruments (we did.) We witnessed a near bar fight and listened in as an old timer in a 90s-era Buffalo Bills jacket argued about something that I can't remember. We stumbled into the back room and .. well.. around this point the memory gets fuzzy. And I can't tell if I liked Hilliker's pastime or loved Hilliker's pastime. But I will be going back.

My husband and I always come for Jeopardy and a couple of beers and something to eat. The service…read moreis good and the bartender always remembers us. It's a cool vibe and everyone is always looking like they're having a good time. I like Milkie's.

Good food great drinks. Very comfortable spot to enjoy the Lance Diamond tribute on July 4th &…read morefriendly staff

Me and my family were out celebrating my Mothers Birthday and it was amazing from the food to the…read moreambiance that provided us with a more intimate settling for a celebration of life. Our waiter was amazing and did a great job despite the size of our party at the time of ordering our entrees.

There was not one dish I was served that I feel was worth the price…read more We had focaccia and tuna tartare as appetizers. The Margherita focaccia was by far the worst of the night, soggy and flavorless, the focaccia was nothing like a normal one. The tuna had a nice presentation though it was quite mediocre, the rice was hard in some parts and seemed quite old, the tuna itself was fine but the dish as a whole was maybe on par with sushi you'd get at a wegmans. As my entrée I got the carrot papardella, everything seemed overcooked, hardly any lobster and what little was happened to be tough and rather flavorless, of course it was the same with the shrimp and crab. The pasta was overcooked and stuck to itself and the sauce was quite sweet and far too hot, twenty minutes into the meal and it was still steaming, continuing to turn the dish into mush. The meal was for three people and came out to be $240 after tax and tip, the service was nice but considering the praise this restaurant got I'm sure it's went downhill. The highlight of the meal was the complementary bread at the start.

Always enjoyable!! Music and musicians are talented and make you want to sing and dance!!read more

Once again another great concert, great service & food we love this place for live music! The…read moretalent is top notch we saw Eileen Jewel and Big Sandy & his Fly Right Boys.