A regular spot for us, as they serve delicious food and late! Just a neighborhood watering hole…read morethat has bands on the weekends and specials most days of the week. Love basically the entire menu. They are very nice about any customizations to their food. Service is great considering the bartenders wait the tables too!

We love their food and have never had a bad meal. The staff are so friendly, welcoming, and down to…read moreearth. The Buffalo chicken Sammy is amazing!

First time here and we had a ball!…read more Place was open late, great food and nice beers on tap. The staff was friendly n cool, service was good as well The ambiance is your usual bar, loud music and people talking and having a good time. Def will go back

The hubs ended up at the Tap House after a day of shopping and adventure. The hubs had several…read morebeers and we shared a giant pretzel and some Jamaican Jerk chicken tenders. There were good enough for me to order a second order! The bartender was great with taking orders and beer recs for the hubs. The Tap House had a great atmosphere. There was a local hockey match that night so it felt a little like what you'd see on tv or in the movies. It was a lot of fun!

The burger was great I ask for it be medium and it was. It was put together very neatly and tasted…read morevery fresh. It came with hand cut French fries which are always my favorite over frozen fries. Service was very attentive . Atmosphere was excellent. It seemed like there where regulars in their. Sabres game was on so a lot of people were cheering good place to go to watch a game and get a good meal.

Went for wing night and the wings were just cooked enough to be called cooked. I attempted one wing…read moreand had the rubbery skin instead of a nice crispy skin. That did it for me. My boyfriend ate a few more, but also agreed they were subpar. I actually haven't had wings anywhere since this visit. The happy hour drink specials were good though.

Sons in town from Lexington Kentucky and he wants wings so we stopped here. They are high on the…read moreBuffalo Chicken Wing Trail and now we know why. The ambiance is great as it's a nice throw back to an Irish Pub. The service was excellent! The wings were done perfectly! We tried three different flavors and they were all delicious! An incredible array of craft beers as well as we ha a couple on tap and they were ice cold! We both agreed that we would definitely return in the future and we would really this establishment to one and all!

Ambiance 5/5 - divey, fun, charming. I liked the woodsy and dark interior, the graffiti covered…read morewalls with beer labels. There is an outdoor patio to enjoy during warm weather, which I will be sure to check out again this summer. Village of Williamsville favorite and I'm glad I finally tried it. Food 4/5- it's not a place that you come for dinner. But if you'd like to have a side with your beer or cider, there are a few selections. I ordered from the daily special menu a grilled cheese sandwich with buffalo chicken inside with chips $5.00 not bad. You really come here for the alcoholic drink so keep that in mind. I had a glass of white wine since I'm not a beer drinker. Service 5/5- bartender was friendly and took our orders right away.

Living in Buffalo several years now, I've never been out to Hertel Ave to grab food and drinks -…read moreSurprising, I know! Thanks to a Yelp Elite event on Hertel Ave., I FINALLY changed that with a fantastic late dinner at The Burning Buffalo Bar & Grill. One of the main reasons I don't like to go out in Buffalo is parking - I'm always anxious about finding a spot that's close to where I'm going, as well as not having to pay for it. It was 7:45pm on a Tuesday, so street parking was free so one obstacle down, and amazingly, I managed to park right in front of The Burning Buffalo Bar & Grill, but across the street - I'll take it! Upon walking inside, there were a few tables outside full of people having dinner and drinks with one waitress managing all of it. I walked in and was surprised how big, spacious it was. First order of business though was hitting the restroom, which was on the small side, but clean. After that, I grabbed a seat at the bar. The bartender was a young, pretty woman who was very personable. Unsure of what to grab for a drink, she asked what beers I usually go for and with that, she was fired off a few beers on draught I might like. I settled on the Jack's Abby Post Shift Pilsner and enjoyed sipping on that the rest of the night. She handed me the food menu and took care of a few other customers while I figured out what I wanted. I got it down to two items and I asked her for her recommendation, which was excellent and how I'd order, if and when I make it back. But similar to what other reviews on Yelp say, the atmosphere was very much like a neighborhood bar and grill, where everyone knows each other and if they don't know you, they're still more than willing to let you hop in and out of the conversation. I felt very comfortable sitting and listening to the "regulars" chat, watching a baseball game on the TVs behind the bar. So for dinner, I decided on ordering their Southern Fried Chicken Sandwich which is topped with lettuce, tomato, sriracha mayo, and cheddar cheese, with pickles underneath between a soft, brioche bun with a side of hand cut fries and a pickle spear on the side. The bartender recommended swapping out the cheddar cheese with pepperjack cheese, an awesome swap! The size of the fried chicken breast was HUGE by itself! I was so impressed how the well the sandwich held together as I devoured it. The chicken was hot, not greasy at all. The lettuce and tomato tasted fresh and looked crisp, there was plenty of that pepperjack cheese on top the chicken and pickles underneath. The sriracha mayo was excellent, albeit I would've liked more of it, I think more would've made the sandwich messy and hard to handle, so it really was the right amount on there. The hand cut fries were great as well; Crispier on the ends and softer in the center but plenty hot and not over seasoned. If you've seen other reviews of mine, you'll get the sense I have a pretty big appetite so I was able to demolish the sandwich but I couldn't finish all my fries, so that should be enough to tell you the portions here are HUGE and AWESOME! At first glance, the prices look expensive but I think they're justified as the quality and portions are phenomenal, I certainly felt I got my money's worth. I'm so happy that after several years of living in Buffalo, I made it over to Hertel Ave. finally! I'm also glad I chose The Burning Buffalo Bar and Grill for dinner. The quality and quantity of food, the friendly neighborhood atmosphere, the personable staff, what more can you ask for? I can't wait to come back and grab another Southern Fried Chicken Sandwich or maybe give their North Buffalo Cheesesteak a try!

I came here on a Thursday night and my experience was alright. We had to order at the bar so I…read morecan't blame the bartender for taking a long time as he was tending the bar and grabbing everyone's food. I ordered the burning buffalo club which included smoked turkey, bacon, stuffed banana pepper spread, lettuce, tomato, and cajun remoulade on grilled sourdough. It was overall pretty tasty and the portions were huge.

I hadn't been here in years, but we had a great time last night! The highlight of the evening was…read moredefinitely the live band. I don't know their name, but they were fantastic and really elevated the atmosphere. If there's a band performing when you visit, it's worth checking out. The service was a bit slow, likely because they seemed to be short-staffed. It took a while to receive our drinks and appetizers, and a few items were missed during our visit. That said, the staff was friendly, there was plenty of seating available, and the jukebox was a fun touch. One thing to note: they had several fans running throughout the space, so it got a little chilly at times. Overall, though, it's a fun late-night spot with a lively vibe, and we'd definitely consider coming back.

My friend and I met up to watch the Sabres game . Great atmosphere for a low key sports bar,…read moreattentive friendly bartenders. Reasonable drink prices, not sure on how the food was, as I just drank, and watched the game. My friend ordered an open face turkey, he said was a bit bland. Fun decor for Buffalo Sabres, pizza was served after they won, and looked like loaded nachos when we arrived. Overall, perfect local bar and atmosphere for sports watching.

Came here for a low key valentines day and it did not disappoint. We got there around 7pm and we're…read moreable to get a seat at the bar. It was pretty quiet until around 10pm when we left. We ordered wings, fries, fried pepperoni and many drinks. The wings were solid. We got everything and bbq. The everything is spicy. The rest of the food waa great. I liked the fried pepperoni that were recommended to me. Im recommending them to you. You also get marinara sauce for dipping. Downside. I think my gluten allergies are getting worse because this is a shared fryer and I had small reactions that I wasn't expecting. Bartenders were fun and friendly. It was a great time! Highly recommend for a low key night and solid wings with a bunch of different flavors.

Got to love a dive bar but the help in here wasn't the best! 1st at a Sunday at 2 O'clock in the…read moreafternoon with 5 people in the place and the doorman asked my daughter for ID she is 40 then me!!!! I'm clearly a seinor woman why ask!! He had no personality when I tried to talk to him. We ordered our drinks sex on the beach and vodka and ice tea. He made my daughter's 1st she wanted a large then was doing mine and was almost done with making it and said ' that was a large right ' I said guess it is now! 2 strikes. Didn't stay long enough for a 3rd. The menu sounds good great prices just enough on there for a snack while drinking. I do love a good dive bar and I did like Mr.Goodbar back in the day maybe I'll try again and might have a different experience

Castaway's participated in the Angola on the lake music festival on Saturday with a band Redine was…read morea young group but played good . It was upstairs and got a bit crowded looks like the band had its whole family there . Had to go downstairs after about half hour too crowded. Was a great to catch a few bands in the area cant wait for next year

Nice little spot facing the beach. The magic of this place is looking at a Lake Erie sunset in the…read morewinter. Fun atmosphere that could probably use an updating but it's got that old school kind of piratey feel. The fish was great but the fryers probably could be cleaned more often. Felt like the fryers oil was a bit old. Service was good the wait staff was really nice