I went to dinner with some out of town work friends who were in Richmond. They picked this place based on the menu and good reviews. I've lived in Richmond for almost three years and had never been to Bookbinders, so I was excited to try it. We had a 6:30pm reservation and the lot across the street was pretty full by the time I arrived, but thankfully was able to get a spot. We started off with the seared Cajun tuna and crabcakes appetizers. The tuna was delicious and melted in your mouth. The crabcakes were tiny and just ok, so I wouldn't go out of my way to order those again. I ordered the Japanese Hokkaido Pan Seared Scallops, which came with asparagus risotto. This was by far the tastiest scallops I have ever had, and growing up in New England, I've had my fair share of scallops. They were so flavorful and melted in your mouth. We ordered a side of the Lobster Mac and Cheese, which was so cheesy and chock full of lobster. So good! For desert (which I got to go because I was so full), I got a piece of their key lime pie, which came with an oreo cookie crust, and was really tart and tasty. The manager stopped by our table several times to check on us and our waitress was also really attentive. This is definitely a place for special occasions and I'd recommend skipping a few meals as their portions are nicely sized. I can see why this restaurant has been around so long. read more

Really good experience at Old Original Bookbinder's. The place has a nice classic feel and the service was solid from start to finish. Everyone was attentive without being overbearing. The food came out fresh and well prepared. The seafood tasted clean and the steak was cooked just right. Nothing felt rushed and everything had good flavor and presentation. Overall it's a great spot in Richmond if you want a nice dinner whether it's a date night or just a solid meal out. I'd definitely go back. Thanks Neighbor read more

We loved the cuisine. We had been happy patrons of the Philadelphia original Bookbinders years ago, and we were happy to learn that a beloved restaurant we thought to be defunct was no longer. Bookbinder's was pretty empty at 5pm on a spring evening; I had expected and feel it deserves more of a following / crowd. Perhaps it builds later. While both of us thoroughly enjoyed what we ate (the halibut special and pork chop), we did find the portions and the prices both bigger than necessary and the menu options more limited than expected. Healthier faire, and options constituting better value, are a suggested improvement. Service was prompt and courteous; Ian served us with rock-solid aplomb. He is a professional and it showed. All of that said, including that we would return if in Richmond again, I feel that the business would be better positioned for the fickle post-pandemic market with a greater number of smaller entrees constituting healthier and more economical choices too. read more

I came to Bookbinders for a work event and had a great time! The service was really impeccable, and we seated in a side room for the event. We were treated to a three course meal, with a really generous selection of options. I personally opted for the ribeye steak, which is massive, so deliciously seasoned, and cooked perfectly, medium rare. I definitely was not able to finish this, and took some home to eat the next day. The sides of the mashed potatoes and green beans that came with it were also delicious, and the side salad that we started with it added some freshness to the menu. I do feel as though the sides were a little plain for a fancy steakhouse, but still good. I was so full at the end of this, that I took the chocolate cake to go home, but really enjoyed it even as leftovers. The service was impeccable, with plenty of wine to go around, and I thoroughly enjoyed myself here. Bear in mind that this place has a business casual dress code, and I definitely think it's a place worth dressing up for. Parking can be a bit of a pain, as it seems like there's only street parking, but I was luckily able to snag a spot out front. read more

See all

Every time I come to this restaurant it's always a great experience. I was celebrating a birthday and of course they put my partner's name on the menu. I absolutely love this gesture which makes for a more personal experience! I started with a peach and bourbon drink and it was well balanced and flavorful. I also tried the escargot and loved the presentation. For the entree, I got the steak and crab with lobster macaroni and cheese and loaded mashed potatoes. The steak was cooked to the correct temperature and the Crabcake was filled with lump crab which I definitely appreciate. The macaroni and cheese and mashed potatoes were nice and creamy. The waiter was very attentive and made our needs were met. I couldn't not have asked for a better experience and I would definitely recommend this restaurant! read more

See all

My mother and I came to Bookbinders for Christmas dinner, and it was a great experience especially since she hadn't been before. Everything went smoothly the staff was welcoming, attentive, and made us feel taken care of without being overbearing. Given it was the holiday, the menu was a bit limited, but the food was still excellent. They're definitely on the pricier side with or without their limited menu with a great selection of poultry and seafood options, but for good reason everything was good and the overall experience made it worth it. The ambiance was really chill and relaxing, which made the night even better. On top of that, the seasonal drinks were amazing and added a fun, festive touch to the dinner. Overall, it was a memorable Christmas dinner, and I'm already looking forward to coming back to try more of what's on their menu. For those looking for a spot to celebrate a special occasion or when you're in the mood for a quality meal and great atmosphere this is one spot I would recommend. read more

See all

Absolutely phenomenal food & customer service that was out of this world! Celebrated our elopement ceremony dinner here. When making the reservation, we noted that. We were pleasantly surprised when we received a phone call confirming our reservation & a staff member congratulating us! They said they had a complimentary keepsake for us, which turned out to be a personal menu saying "Just Married". We were absolutely thrilled, what a cute detail! & complimentary glasses of champagne! The food was phenomenal. The bread was crispy and warm. We ordered the prosciutto mozzarella, and wow was it good. The ancho-rubbed cowboy cut ribeye was perfect. The best thing we got was the LOADED MASHED POTATOES! Best thing ever. We also got an entree-enhancement of fried shrimp which was amazing. My dessert was the mixed berry bread pudding, which was a perfect way to end the meal, especially with a scoop of my favorite ice cream brand Gelati Celesti. My husband got the crème brûlée, which he said was delicious. I highly recommend this spot for a fancy date night. Prices can be a bit high for even small portions, but everything was a 5/5 for us and filled us up. Upscale atmosphere with a cozy warmth. We loved it here! read more

See all

It's a "special occasion" kind of place because most people don't make going out for $150/pp dinner a weekly routine. The restaurant makes efforts to create the experience. I have no idea about Chesapeake style cuisine but I could sum up the experience to be traditional American, with the Chesapeake Bay seafood specialty. Lots of heavy cream, hiding the greens on offer. We started with half dozen of half shell oyster. Very fresh, plumb and fairly priced. Then we tried the New England chowder. It was a bit salty, very creamy, and they didn't skim on the clams! For main I had the petite filet with Oscar Style which is grilled asparagus with crabmeat in thick hollandaise sauce. My dining partner had the jumbo crab linguini. I ordered my steak rare which by Bookbinder standard warm in the center. The meat is very tender and the cut has few tendons. A bit more like medium rare in my opinion but still very tasty. The enhancement was poured over the filet and very creamy. I should've asked for it to be on the side had I know it would overpower the steak. For dessert we had the crème brûlée and the raspberry sorbet. They are quite standard but well done. Overall they try to give a good service. But our waiter keeps mixing up our orders. He double checked our entree order after the soup and something else still showed up at our table. My dinner wine came way too late and I didn't get a steak knife until asked. He swapped our deserts and asked how we were doing way too many times which makes me think he's trying to close the tap. I think it's still a good restaurant but when the ticket price is so high and they didn't hire the service staff up to par, it really impacts the value. read more

Old Original Bookbinders - 1/2 Dozen Oysters on the 1/2 Shell - Seafood Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

See all

Came for a work dinner and as always it was delicious. Have dined several times since my last review. Steak is always on point as are the fresh sides. The owner is kind and if he's there he will come by to check in on how your visit is going. Wonderful place! Always a pleasure. read more

See all

Bland food and only cost $600. Salmon dry and flavorless. Steak, well another place that doesn't know how to cook meat. Shrimp and crab cakes bland. Yes bland describes this place best. Service was good. read more

I have not dined at this restaurant in 22 years and it did not disappoint! Joe was our server, and he provided excellent service and recommendations for our anniversary dinner. They offered us complimentary champagne for the occasion! We started with the Oyster Rockefeller and it was phenomenal. The oysters had just the right amount of cheese and spinach to complement the appetizer. We shared the 8-ounce filet and lobster entree with a loaded baked potato. The filet was cooked to the perfect temperature of medium. The lobster tail was well seasoned and served with drawn butter. I must say that was the best baked potato I've ever tasted. The potato was soft and tender and the topping was a perfect addition for flavoring. read more

Great spot for a fancy dinner, client meeting or the like. Been several times. Good quality food. Portions are maybe too huge. I went with the ancho rubbed ribeye with chimmicurry and the flavor was great we had a big party multiple stakes multiple seafood dishes. Every steak was cooked as ordered. Seemingly rare in a big party, but Bookbinders nailed it. Tried several sides, loaded, baked potato was the one for me. My only complaint is that I was too full for their extensive dessert menu maybe next time I'll order dessert first! Service again was mediocre. But I tend to be there with a big parties. They try to pull it off with one person every time and it just doesn't work well. read more

Went there for Mother's Day. The food was delicious! Enjoyed the service and the atmosphere. Surroundings were fantastic. Flowers on every table, hanging baskets all around, and big urns at the entrances. The waitstaff were very welcoming and attentive. What can I say...a perfect place to go! read more

This one's been on the list for awhile and last night me and Nowuh bear finally tackled it. Let me start off by saying .... you are going to spend so much money here. They have a lot of poultry and seafood dishes that are decent mid range prices (30-70), but once you enter steak territory things get evil (my dish was $97 alone). HOWEVER. it was VERY good. the BEST filet ive ever had. it was so soft. every dish that came out tasted so so good, the servers were fantastic, and the ambience was so romantic and rustic ... i felt like i was in one of those "christmas in new york" ambience youtube videos. 9/10. only -1 point bc of my wallet's pain read more

See all

Went here for our last supper during our return to Richmond getaway. We got the cowboy ribeye, the mac n cheese and the shrimp scampi. The food was amazing! For drinks, we had an old fashioned and a lavender martini - both were delicious. I wish I'd had room for dessert, but we had to pass. I loved the lobster tank when you enter (90's baby!) and how spacious the booths were. The music was nice, not too loud and the restaurant was so clean. Even the restrooms were spotless, and I hate public restrooms with a passion. The booths were sticky, and there was no dust anywhere. If I chose two things to not like, it'd be that the scampi had only 3 shrimp for $20 and that I indicated that it was our anniversary during the reservation and it was not acknowledged- though I heard other guests be acknowledged by their servers. We also wanted to sit on the porch, but our server told us it hasn't been open consistently due to the high pollen count. read more

Old Original Bookbinders - lavender lemon drop martini - Seafood Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

Amazing service! The scalloped risotto was delicious! All in all, great first time experience

Our single dinner here turned out to be one of the best meals we experienced on our cross-country trip. After being deposited in a plush booth Diane and I began with a very good Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail that featured shrimps that were not really jumbo in size. Moreover, the original platter had to be replaced because the shrimps were embedded in Cocktail Sauce even though a request had been made by us not to serve the dish this way because of Diane's aversion to this particular type of sauce. The replacement dish was prepared properly as requested. Next we were served a Bowl of fine New England Clam Chowder and an excellent Caesar Salad with tasty requested Brown Anchovies, along with delicious crusty Ciabatta Bread and Butter. For our mains Diane and I shared 3-1/2 pounds of fine live Lobsters. It was just the right amount of food, artistically presented like a crouching animal on a plate. A side of Johnnie's Potatoes added great-tasting balls of fried potato. And this memorable meal was further enhanced by a sweet and unusual New York Chocolate Blackout Layer Pudding Cake ala Mode, a real treat. Service by Joe H. was exemplary. Brick walls, white tablecloths, and black booths resulted in an elegant and upscale steakhouse ambiance. And I felt honored that restaurant owner John Taxin stopped by to present us with a unique Bookbinder's challenge coin in recognition of Diane's military service, and joined us in our booth to chat for a few minutes and pose for a photo at my request. It was a leisurely and very enjoyable meal. I only wish this restaurant was situated much closer to where we live, so we could visit it often. read more

See all

We came here for my mother's birthday. As we walked up we saw the owner outside tending to the flowers out front and was very nice. We were sat promptly for our reservation. Our server was very patient and informative, he even gave my son some fish food for the coy pond they have out back. We started off with appetizers: raw oysters, clam chowder soup, and arugula salad; my mom loved her seafood picks and my salad was very good. For our dinners I ordered the cowboy ribeye. I was disappointed with the flavor and the meat itself. I feel it lacked flavor and the cut of meat wasn't the best for a $66 price tag. My son and mom had the salmon which was good. My husband had the crab linguine; that was ok it wasn't the best he has had and not the worst. Overall my mom would go back for the oysters and soup but I wouldn't go back for the ribeye. read more

We Tried Bookbinders for the first time, Anniversary treat. Yea us! Place is beautiful and easily located in Richmond. Service was epic, Thank You David. Prices were a bit high but expected in this area. This is why I gave 4 stars. Wedge salad was $ 25 (?) Started with a few glasses of wine and I had an Ol Fashion and we tried the shrimp cocktail. Both were great. My wife had the wedge salad w/crab, she didn't care for the Louis dressing, but the balsamic was amazing. I had the scallops with asparagus risotto. This dish was fantastic and it had 5 nice size scallops, perfectly cooked. Risotto was good. Definitely be back for the NY strip! Thank You for the amazing service David! read more

See all

My husband made reservations here for our wedding anniversary. We were seated inside and we got a customized menu that said "Happy Anniversary" which was special. Our waitress Petra was wonderful - kind and attentive. We got a complimentary champagne toast which was yummy. For drinks, I did the huckleberry fin and my husband did the Bouchard Pinot Noir - both delicious. The sourdough bread was great paired with olive oil & butter. We both got the petite filet cooked medium rare which was amazing, smooth as can be. We shared the Johnnie potatoes which were delicious. For dessert, we shared the chocolate chip brownie which was rich and topped with vanilla ice cream. All in all so yummy! Highly recommend for a special occasion. read more

See all

Best food and service our family has had in a very long time! 9 1/2 out of 10! A gift package from our Son, the outstanding one he is. Thanks! read more

What a disturbing restaurant, for 5 stars, I wouldn't give it one? I paid $225.00 for a bottler of wine and left starving. The grill exhaust fan had an issue, not my fault. I had appetizers and wine. I will never go back to this shithole again! The waiter was less than average, the manager had no customer service skills. There is no way this place should be rated at all !!!!!!!! read more

Amazing dinner at Bookbinders this evening. We've been coming to Bookbinders for years and now that we live in Charlotte - we bring my in-laws every time we visit. Matthew gave outstanding service - the Kona Coffee filet, twice baked potatoes, the broccolini were all outstanding. The brownie ala mode was the cherry on top of it all. Already, can't wait to come back. Such a great spot. Thank you read more

If you've ever wondered what it feels like to spend $240 for a full comedy experience, Book Binder's Seafood is the place. We walked in and the restaurant was completely empty, which really made it feel like we had rented out a very quiet, very expensive museum of disappointment. We asked for small oysters and were served oysters so big I briefly considered measuring them in feet instead of inches. I didn't order a seafood entrée, I ordered a challenge. The Shirley Temple came without cherries, which feels illegal on a spiritual level. The calamari, however, was the real star. I'm pretty sure I was chewing on it for a solid 10 minutes. By the end, I felt like I deserved a jaw workout badge or a certificate of endurance. The jumbo crab linguine was aggressively lemony and somehow cold, which is an impressive feat for a hot pasta dish. The salad didn't seem to know what it wanted to be in life. Wilted lettuce, wrong dressing, and the overall vibe of "airport food if you're blindfolded and emotionally unprepared." All of this came out to over $200, and about $240 with tip. For that price, I expected a seafood experience. What I got was a very expensive stand-up routine, starring my plate. read more

Wonderful spot with excellent steaks and interesting cocktails! Don't miss the goat cheese mushrooms either. One of the best appetizers in Richmond. read more

i brought my husband here for his birthday and it definitely DIDNT disappoint! everything we ate was so good and the service was wonderful AND my husband was very happy and surprised to see his name on the menu so i wanted to thank them for that as well it made him feel very special we loved the christmas decor and they took our picture for us and the owner took one with us as well read more

See all

Random steakhouse in Richmond, Virginia turned out to be an amazing night. The food was amazing but the service was even better. The owner John came over to introduce himself and gave me a challenge coin when he found out I was former NYPD/FDNY. If you ever drive through this town, stop by and talk to the owner. The bartenders were amazing as well. Tyler and Kel. read more

See all

The restaurant has an old world feel making it a perfect date night or special occasion spot. Servers were knowledgeable about the menu and made nice suggestions on what to get. The price is reasonable for the highly quality meals served! read more

See all

Bookbinders is definitely one of the better steakhouses in the area. It's a little pricey but the quality is great. The service was meh, and the ambiance was ok but I didn't get to see much as we were sitting by the door. The fromage topping in the steak was amazing! read more

See all

First, the good: Our server (Garrett, I think) was extremely attentive and came often. Our water glasses were never empty and Garrett was very polite. The wine list was very good and had an excellent selection from most regions. The spirits list was also good, with many pours and cocktails to choose from. The menu itself was very much par for the course for this kind of seafood and steakhouse. Two of us started with selections from the raw bar: a shrimp cocktail and oysters on the half-shell. Both tasted fine. For the main course, the scallops looked the best of the four dishes at our table and were apparently amazing. The rockfish special was also delicious and my steak was a perfectly cooked medium-rare. The red mashed potatoes were excellent as well. The table shared two berry bread puddings with ice cream and the bread pudding tasted good. The restaurant was pretty empty, as it was early dinner on a Tuesday. Our table by the window was perfect and we were able to talk and hear each other very well (until the end when a loud table was seated next to us). When we left, the owner was outside offering to take pictures of us with a phone. He had a ring light, posed us nicely, and we got to take home some nice photos, which was a nice touch. Now, the not so good: Although Garrett was super nice and attentive, I'm not sure they listened very well. My béarnaise sauce never arrived and Garrett looked at me oddly when I mentioned it, so I don't think he heard when I ordered it. Also, Garrett forgot my cousin's coffee at the end of dinner, and because we were headed to a show, he had to pass on the coffee due to time constraints. Although the wine list was very good, some wine bottles were marked up 400% or more from what you can purchase them for in the store. I understand when you order a glass of wine, the first glass needs to pay for the bottle, so by the glass is one thing. However, for the bottles to be so expensive I thought was a little excessive. I'd bring your own bottle and pay the cork fee if they allow it. As mentioned, the spirit list was good, but it would have been nice to see some more special whiskeys as well as some varied bourbon choices from Buffalo Trace distillery. When I got my shrimp cocktail, I have to say we were all rather shocked at how small the four shrimp were for $22! I order shrimp cocktail whenever it is on the menu and when it's that expensive, it's usually four to five colossal shrimp that could almost be considered a meal unto itself. These four shrimp were your normal run of the mill large shrimp that you could buy already cooked at your local grocery store for $2-$3 tops. It was really laughable. I don't mind paying a lot for it, but make it worth my while man. Our biggest complaint across the board is that all of the food that was supposed to be served hot was on the warm to even cold side. As mentioned earlier, I ordered a medium-rare filet, which I know is not going to be super hot due to how it's cooked, but it had hardly any temperature whatsoever. A little hot oil would have been an easy fix. Also, I couldn't taste any salt, so I'm not sure anything was done other than cooking it to how it was ordered (ever watch the Food Network, guys?). When I reminded them that I ordered béarnaise sauce (because I know that restaurants can serve steaks cold and with little taste, lol) it came quickly, so of course it too was cold. The thing that was supposed to warm and provide taste to my steak, did neither. Considering the price of things at Bookbinders, this is pretty unacceptable. To cap things off, when the berry bread pudding came out for the two ladies at our table, it was also served cold. One could say it was slightly warm, but it wasn't warm enough to melt the ice cream it was served with and was cold in the center. Although it tasted OK, it just wasn't enjoyable cold. Overall, a cold dinner that costs you over $500 isn't quite worth it. read more

Bookbinders is a fantastic fine dining experience in Richmond, especially for seafood. I've never ordered a dish here that wasn't great. Service is very attentive and friendly. read more

Celebrated my birthday here and it was a great time! The food was good, but I wasn't amazed (I think I had set my expectations too high). The highlight of my meal was definitely the crème brûlée! The ambiance was upscale and the service staff were friendly and attentive. I would like to come back to give them another try. read more

See all

First time visit and was extremely satisfied. Our server was knowledgeable and friendly. The food choices on the menu were fantastic and the food tasted wonderful. Really nice atmosphere inside and of course it's right next to the river for ambience. Terrific place for a date night or special occasion. read more

See all

This is a fantastic place for a special occasion! I ordered the crab-stuffed lobster, and it was absolutely incredible. The cocktails were spot on, and everything was delicious. Our server was also great. read more

See all

Came for an anniversary and they pulled all the stops to make it special. The waiter was amazing and attentive, he came back often to check on us and make sure everything was okay. Also gave us recommendations as well. The food was absolutely amazing, my favorite was the ancho-rubbed ribeye steak, the portion size is so good. The portions for everything are so generous. In addition, we also got the clam chowder and it was delicious, genuinely best clam chowder I've ever had. The bread is also so crispy and good, we ate two loaves. Overall the restaurant is beautiful and I will be going back. read more

See all

One of the best steakhouses I have been to! A bit pricy but worth it! I'd recommend the prosciutto wrapped beacon, petite filet & the red bliss mashed potatoes! Their bread they give in the beginning is also so good with their butter. I asked for medium and they cooked it more on the rare side but they were super nice and took it back to cook it more! Every other time I've been has been cooked perfectly. Great service. If it's warm outside I highly recommend sitting outside in their patio. It is so well decorated and reminds me of being in Italy. Their desserts and drinks are also amazing! My boyfriend and I went for our anniversary last year and they are able to customize the menu and wrote "happy 2 year anniversary" for us that we were able to take home. It was amazing all around! read more

Old Original Bookbinders - 8 oz. Petite Filet Mignon - Seafood Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

See all

We had another excellent dinner at Bookbinder's last night. The service was top-notch, and the food was cooked and presented exactly as ordered. When one of the entrees I ordered was sold out, our waiter apologized profusely, and proceeded to give us a detailed description of similar choices. The "second" choice was delicious, and then he comped dessert because the first choice wasn't available.. I told him that wasn't necessary, but he insisted. It's a class act with great food and ambiance. read more

Came here for a business dinner recently I like the vibe of this place a lot more than your typical chain steak houses like Ruth Chris Morton's or capital Grille. You can tell this place has been a local institution for a long time for very good reason. The service was top-notch, super attentive, and the fillet I had was absolutely delicious. Sometimes fillet can be a little bland and flavorless but the kitchen did a phenomenal job of putting a nice sear on the fillet, putting a nice little bit of crunch and every bite. I apologize for not posting pictures of the food, but I think that's weird to pull up my phone to snap amongst a bunch of business contacts. Trust me when I tell you it's delicious. read more

We came here Saturday night to celebrate my boyfriend's birthday. As special as this occasion is, we don't expect royal treatment but atleast the bare minimum, especially for the price I paid. I'm talking about not getting a refill for water, having to point out that the diet coke needs a refill towards the end of the dinner because the server never even looked at the empty glass and having to wait for so long to even know who our server was. I won't mention his name here but I ask management to have a word with the server who took care of the table under my reservation, Saturday at 8pm. Mind you, there were tables but it was NOT that busy, definitely not if he kept on going back to the table that ordered alcohol. I still was polite about it but he keeps on giving excuses why he could not tend to us right away. Thankfully the entrees we ordered were good, but I have to say I regret spending $200 for such service, it's unacceptable. It took away the enjoyment of the experience, celebrating a birthday at that. read more

Went here to celebrate my son's birthday. Price is expected. Food is always good! Drinks are great! Staff is always a treat from the hostesses to the waiters. Ambience is a romantic type of vibe. read more

Old Original Bookbinders - Personalized birthday menu - Seafood Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

See all