We have been going to Old Fields for many years (since it was Old Fields Inn) and would love to give it 5 stars. Their food is great, service very attentive, nice comfortable decor-all good. The first small issue is their beer selection, many craft beers on tap-but where are the local brews or some more well known beers? Not everyone is a fan of craft beer. The bigger problem is more of a management issue. On a recent visit we were seated in the back room. Already seated was a large group of adults and children-so you would expect the noise level to be a bit louder. However, when the middle school aged kids got up from their seats and began to play hand-slapping games (with each other and a parent) the management should have intervened. I realize that it was not a busy night but there were other diners in that room. Fortunately, just as we were discussing whether to finish our first drink and go down the block to another restaurant (rather than be aggravated while eating my $45 steak in a middle school cafeteria setting) the group left. While I understand that this is a family friendly restaurant, and that the blame lies with the parents who behaved as though they had a private room, I do feel that the management should have spoken to the adults. Or perhaps they shouldn't seat parties of 2 in the back room with such a large group. Yes, we could have complained, and we did contemplate doing that but I can't help but feel that the wait staff and management had to have realized the noise level was over the top without other customers having to tell them. When two people spend $150 for drinks and dinner, they shouldn't have to shout in order to be heard. We will definitely go to Old Fields again, but will ask to not be seated in the back room. read more

My family and I just had dinner at Old Fields and LOVED it! There was no wait for a table. The service was friendly and fast. Everybody loved their meal. They were delicious and such large portions! The dessert was amazing. We will definitely go back often! They had a the straciatella mozzarella appetizer was unbelievable and so was the roasted corn on the cob! Great mojotos too! We are so happy! read more

Great service and very attentive staff. The food needs some serious help though. The appetizers are basically for one person and impossible to share. I am not feelin' their entrees either. Just overcooked and not appealing. I hope they try a little harder to get things right for the future. read more

This place is exceptional. The food is incredible! The staff is beyond any expectation. No matter what I eat the food is unreal! I highly recommend you try this place, from the atmosphere, to the service, to the delicious food. Try the flat iron steak, it's phenomenal! Trust me this place will be your number one spot once you try it! read more

I think the reviewer who wrote that the food was top notch must be an owner or family member and realizes her inherence is in Jeopardy. The food was below average and the service was awful, I'm wondering when the good people of Greenlawn Long Island will realize what it means to eat good food. Do yourself a favor and continue walking to the end of the block. read more

My go to place. Everything on the menu is good and the staff is friendly. They have a great selection of beers as well. I tuna burger and skirt steak are my favorites. read more

Great food for a local spot.Fantastic hamburgers and seafood. The bar is great too. It's busy and very LOUD. Not the most romantic spot in Greenlawn read more

Great venue. Solid staff. Food has been excellent every time only complaint is bar area very poor setup. Will continue to frequent.

I've been coming here for decades. The place has been updated and it's much nicer. It's a mostly younger crowd now. Very busy bar. Very busy place. Front rooms can be very loud. A good place to meet friends. Food is very good. read more

The hype far exceeds the reality for this over-priced burger bar. We were seated quickly and the staff was friendly. I ordered the roasted chicken with rice pilaf. I wasn't really in the mood for a burger because we came expecting a steak restaurant. It was served in a skillet, in a tomato sauce that made it more like a stew. The rice was hard and crunchy and clearly under-cooked. The chicken was actually raw in the middle when I cut into it. When I showed it to the waiter, he offered to "fix it", but I declined and just sent it back. My partner ordered the fillet cubes on a skewer. They tasted ok, but the cubes were cooked unevenly- anywhere from medium well to nearly mooing (she ordered medium rare). The fillet was served with fries. When she asked to substitute fingerling potatoes (being served with the special), she was informed that they did not permit substitutions. Then the waiter back-tracked and said she could have mashed potatoes instead. Although the price of my meal was removed from the bill, no one came over to apologize for my poorly cooked meal or ask if they could bring me anything else. The atmosphere was casual. All the tables were full while we were there. So many wait staff were wandering around looking lost, we started wondering what was going on. We counted one person who passed our table 4 times within a 10 minute period and didn't pick up an empty plate or refill empty water glasses. She just kept walking back and forth. Needless to say, it was very disappointing and we won't be going back again. Total bill (for 1 entree, salad, and 1 glass of wine- $35 without the tip). read more

Been coming here since I was a kid! Different type of place now that the new owners took over still love it!

Not what I expected based on the reviews. Everyone raves about the skirt steak. I must have gone on an off night. Both my father and I had it and thought it was terrible. It was tough and had no flavor. When my Dad leaves half his meal something isn't right. Despite the large amount of help, when we wanted to pay our bill we waited ten minutes, asking three servers to take our credit card and they kept saying "we'll get your waitress". I can't say we will try them again based on our experience. read more

I've been there in the past, but the last few times I've visited was enough to make me not want to visit again. On my last and final visit... first, after asking for a booth, they attempted to seat us in between 2 large families that had spread out so much that you couldn't see that there was a tiny 2 seater table there....only to then be taken to an almost empty back room that was much nicer. I guess a 2 person party doesn't deserve to sit in a nice section. Then we were confused about which burger was marinated because neither tasted like it. Some man came out to the table, bent over, looked at my burger then turned to the server to tell her that I did indeed have a marinated burger. The fact that he couldn't be bothered to address me and spoke about me in front of me was pretty rude. Since he "said so" nothing else was done, not even a word from the server who walked away with this rude man/chef without even a word to me? Later, the server came and reached over to take my husbands plate away without asking him if he was done. He wasn't, and when she had his plate in her hand I asked her to let him finish at which time she held it there for him to stab the last piece with his fork. No apologies and she couldn't even put the plate back down on the table..So, whether it be the hostess, the server, the food quality or even the chef's rudeness, I would say that the customer service is really lacking across the board. Upon telling this story to a friend, he proceeded to tell me about his bad experience there recently too. I guess the new owners don't teach their employees how to treat customers. read more

Had a really nice dinner . Top rate service and the food was exceptional. Went on a Tuesday night and we were seated right away. For a great night out, go here. read more

Great atmosphere and service. Staff Went above and beyond for my guest and I. Highly recommend. We will be back for sure.

Having recently moved to Greenlawn and based on the Yelp reviews, we tried out Old Fields. To say we were disappointed would be an understatement. Let me start out by saying that our waitress was amazing and the front of the house is spot on in terms of speed and service (it would have been one star if not for the service). Its the back of the house where things fell apart on us. Wife ordered a wedge salad to start that she thought was ok, I ordered french onion "soup." It wasn't so much soup as a wet piece of bread (which what little there was tasted good), that was covered in so much cheese that it can hardly be called a soup. All of which would have been forgiven if not for the disaster of the entree. We ordered the skirt steak (Medium-rare) and hamburger (medium), the steak arrived medium-well and according to my wife was ok. Unfortunately the hamburger came out so burnt (as in so far beyond well done) as to be like a hockey puck. Our waitress noticing the issue did a great job whisking it back to the kitchen, unfortunately by the time a new one arrived (which was also over-cooked, but at least edible) my wife was already done. Our waitress and the manager did everything they were supposed and were incredibly apologetic, and because of that we hope to give Old Fields a second shot at some point, with hopefully a better result. read more

Such a great restaurant! It's tiny and has a very cozy feel, perfect for a date night. Our server was very kind and helpful with any questions I had since it was my first time there. I had one of the specials for the night which was a Salmon Burger and truffle fries. Salmon was cooked to perfection. We also had the calamari which was very tasty. Cannot wait to come back! read more

We live in the area and were looking for a family friendly place to take our kids (6 & 8, kind of like skippers, but with better food) and we were pleasantly surprised to find a fun place to go with friends. The food was excellent, freshly prepared and tasty. They have no kids menu per se, but the main menu itself is kid friendly (just a little pricey for my picky non-eaters) My kids shared the popcorn chicken ($7) and fries ($7), and while this was enough for them, the portions were smaller than I expected. We had the mussel appetizer (delish), ceaser salad appetizer (just ok),mushroom burger (yum), two glasses of wine (good), soda, 2 milkshakes (very good), tea and the chocolate ice box cake (very good, light and not too sweet) and our bill was $89 excluding tip. The service was very good and non-intrusive, I did not feel rushed despite the restaurant being totally full (on a weeknight, so they must be doing something right). About the ambiance -- I think the atmosphere is charming and inviting. The new owners kept the retro feel, keeping what I think were many of the original fixtures, but painting and updating this establishment to make it feel retro. The overall makeover is spot on and strike the right balance of blending old and new. Sorry, we avoided the old place -- thought it somewhat rundown, dark and uninviting, but this new place is a welcome addition to the neighborhood and we will definitely be back. I would recommend stopping by, it is worthwhile -- try and get a seat by the fire. read more

Had been to the old place and wasn't impressed. Now that Old Fields is under new ownership, we decided to try it out and were very pleased. Had marinated skirt steak which was a very nice size portion, and delicious. It came with a vegetable and potato and was still under $20. Mixed baby field greens salad and mussels appetizer were also very good. While we were eating dinner I noticed the brunch specials which sounded awesome so we came back the next morning - pumpkin pancakes - YUM and eggs benedict. Big portions and not expensive. The waitstaff was very nice and accomodating. Good prices and very comfortable. If you are looking for a romantic quiet restaurant as one reviewer was, this is not it. But if you are looking for a comfortable place with good food at reasonable prices where the tables aren't all on top of one another, this is it. read more

I've been here to eat several times and it's usually consistently good. Never great but always good... until tonight. Our server was overwhelmed and probably forgot to put in our dinner order because we waited for about 45 minutes for our food and he told us there was a back up in the kitchen. I used to be a server so I know the many different ways to blame it on "the kitchen" instead of saying I messed up. After that we ordered peach cobbler for dessert, which I've had a couple of times before and is absolutely Amazing..until tonight! It came out ice cold when the two other times it was served warm. So I tell my server I don't want this it's ice cold. He says nothing and takes it away. No sorry about that.. Nothing! After paying he proceeds to tell me that it's never served warm and it must've been a mistake in the kitchen the other times I've had it! Haha I couldn't believe it! Needless to say it was the most disappointing service I have ever received and I will not be returning anytime soon! read more

The food is awesome. The ambiance is cozy and welcoming. It is a family favorite. Highly recommend the Mac and cheese fir kids. The wings and burgers are delicious. The pork tacos are to die for. read more

Food is fair, wine list is average and I think it's all a little over priced compared to better restaurant in the area. Bartenders are great and make great cocktails. Staff is professional and courteous. read more

We tried the monk fish and filet mignon. The fish was good but the steak was awesome,

Sadly we encountered what appears to be discrimination or selective seating. We requested a booth and were first escorted to a table but asked to wait instead. 745pm on a Tuesday. When asked to sit in the waiting area , we watched one large booth turnover that was cleaned after three people left, and then sat for another 15 minutes while the other booths remained empty. When approached about availability of the booths the waitress put us off,then Seated several other groups and smirked as she walked away. The manager said that they do not seat three in these booths, which we know is not the truth as evidenced this evening and from other times that we have been to the restaurant. We talk about patronizing our small businesses. This is one place that clearly is not worth the trip or needs the Business as they can clearly afford to leave booths open. read more

Old Fields has incredible food, superb service and phenomenal drinks. I have dined here several times and have never been disappointed. The food is so flavorful and the appetizers are creative! This restaurant is so good that I often return instead of trying new places on "my list" because it's never a miss. read more

We went here for a lovely New Year's Eve dinner. We got the macaroni and cheese and the mussels to start, both delicious. One of the best restaurant mac and cheese I've had. For entrees, the short ribs with risotto and mushroom tortellini were both fantastic. The skirt steak was also good. Overall, a very well-priced and delicious meal! read more

Love this place. Consistently good food, great beer selection and atmosphere. Highly recommend.

Food is OK. Loud music on weekends if you're into that. Liked it much better with the old owner.

Used to be my favorite placein town until they took the Vegan burger off the menu and didnt offer an option. Nothing Vegan on the menu. Amazing that I can get just about anything I want when I travel out of state, but nothing available in NY. read more

Good service and drinks, but the food has quite a bit of room for improvement. I've been here a few times over the past couple years and have vowed every time to not return, only finding myself back when with less scrutinizing friends who insist on going. I consistently find myself disappointed with my entree. One entree in particular was a duck sandwich that was suggested by the waiter. Duck was overdone, tasteless, and dry and on a dry bun to boot. Quite unpleasant. Food on Long Island is pretty terrible overall, and this place is no exception. Will not be back. read more

Ambiance was better than I was expecting (rustic-looking, dimly-lit, dark wood), cocktails and beers were lovely, server was helpful and very nice. Fries were great, but the cheeseburger (I forget which) was one of the BEST I've ever had. read more

Went for the first time on a Saturday night. Good food, great service and cozy place. Wasn't loud and obnoxious like some restaurants on weekends. We had the wings, which were crispy and delicious, and shrimp cocktail for apps. I had the short rib risotto, which was excellent and my husband had steak, which he said was good. Good dirty martinis too. Would definitely go back. read more

I love this place! Tonight we went to the old fields in Huntington and it was a great experience! We were able to share all different types of BBQ side and meats! The brisket and ribs were great read more

Have been here 8 times and it just gets better every visit.

Great old school steak and burger place. The decor is warm and inviting and the service is excellent.

never felt more disrespected in restaurant in all my life everywhere we sat we were in the way the owner moves my chair so i,m sitting out of the way , he tells my friend to keep his hands off the tables just made use fell like 2 scolded school children was really looking forward to eating there but after that experience i would never set foot in that place again! read more

What a lovely and cool place in the middle of Greenlawn. Thank you, Mike, for being such a wonderful host and rescuing us from the line at the bar. Food was most excellent and generous beer selection ensured a Saturday night to remember. What's missing? Grilled chicken sandwich. I had the ahi tuna burger and it was supreme. We will be back here again. Great alternative to the chaos in Huntington. read more

Love it here. The food is great, reasonably priced. They have a great beer list, and the vibe is really cool.......classy but relaxed. My favorite is the skirt steak. read more

Clearly, the other reviewers work at this restaurant. Don't bother. They don't know the difference between rare and cremation. They also lie about their marinade; I know BOTH former chefs, and their marinades were secret. Even the owner didn't know what was in them. Food is too pricey for it's poor quality, and there's an error in every takeout order. I like the new decor, but the food was 100times better at the old place. read more

Just ate here last night. The mint hills cocktail of the day was delicious and refreshing. I really enjoyed the spinach and artichoke dip in the cast iron skillet. I ordered the 56 burger. I asked for well meaning no pink. It came a little charred. The bun was very dry. The burger itself was supposed to be marinated. It did not taste marinated plus it was supposed to come with grilled onions. It had two tiny pieces on it. It wasn't a very beefy burger. Lame. I ordered onion rings instead if steak fries. They were onion straws not rings. The menu should be more specific. Service was great. Atmosphere was nice. I would go here again but I hope the burger is improved. Great beer and drink menu. read more