Holy smokes, probably the best steak I've ever had. I took my son in law for a nice lunch and we weren't disappointed. Been to all the big named steakhouses, in Manhattan and on Long Island. And I have to admit,Paces was absolutely fantastic. The service was fantastic and so was the food. Can't say enough about the joint other than I will absolutely be back. 5 stars. read more

Just went to Pace's Steakhouse for maybe the second time. The first was so long ago I barely remember so it might as well be the first. The bartender Glen was great, lots of good stories made the experience that much better. The NY strip I ate at the bar was very good. My baked clams were ok, just a little on the dry side. The ambiance is classic steakhouse which I like although the plumbers were working on a clogged sink at the bar right in front of me while I was eating my dinner so that wasn't great. Management should of arranged to have that done before 5pm read more

Pace's Steakhouse - NY Strip - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

Went to Pace for a dinner with friends on a Friday night. We had a reservation so we got seated right away. It was busy night but the service was quick, friendly, and made great recommendations. The apps were big enough to order a few to share, the same with our entrees, and side dishes which are family styled. Great NYC styled atmosphere in the heart of Suffolk county. Would recommend getting your steak medium rare the correct way to order it. read more

Pace's Steakhouse - Whole table got steaks - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

See all

The food was great! The service was great! How do you let a wheel chair user in and not tell them they do not have an accessible bathroom. It's the law! read more

Made reservations on a Friday at noon for the same day 730pm. Parking is a nightmare, we parked next door and walked over. Waited a few minutes to be seated. Waiter Brian was good, had a female server as well I can't remember her name. Both pleasant. God the baked clams, porterhouse for two, cream spinach and garlic mash. Also came with two side salads. Food was great, plenty of leftovers. Didn't feel rushed in anyway. Would recommend! Very dark ambiance, small restaurant but cozy experience. read more

Ambiance (5/5): The inside reminds me of a nicely decorated home-- walls lined with mirrors and paintings, nice ceiling lighting, mood lighting, moderately fancy dining setting. The inside is moderately loud with the establishment divided into 3 different areas, one shared with the bar. We sat in a booth which proved to be a fairly tight space and dimly lit. Service (5/5): We visited during Father's Day. I'm not sure if it is typical or not, but we had two dedicated servers (Sarah and Conor?) throughout our whole dining experience. As such, we felt attended to 100% throughout our entire experience. Both were delightful in providing us not only prompt but also courteous treatment. Other bussing services came around to refill waters and clear out tables appropriately as well. Manager came to check in toward the end of the experience too! Food Table Bread (5/5): The toasted buttered and seasoned bread was phenomenal. It was fresh and not too toasted that it was soft yet crispy. There were also some included crackers along with a small side of whipped butter. Side of salad (5/5): The choice of variety of dressings. The creamy cucumber dressing (recommended by our server) did not disappoint. I was very happy that the salad was generous in the variety in all kinds of fresh vegetables. Our table opted for 2 of the day's specials: 1 appetizer: Pace's Slab Bacon (5/5) had a very smoky taste and the taste was not the same without all elements presented on the plate: tomato, white onion, and tomato spread. Enjoyed together, the bite was delicious. Stuffed Salmon (3/5): The salmon was very tender and the stuffed component has a very mushy texture. With the sauce providing a very creamy and buttery aftertaste to the meal. It was so rich that without a base of starch (like rice or pasta) or any vegetables for that matter, I need something to soak up the rest. However, very filling and deliciously seasoned. The lack of any sides kind of left me wanting more even for an entrée. Porterhouse for 2 (3/5): The biggest disappointment for us was the porterhouse. I think we were at least expecting it to be cooked to our liking which was supposed to be "medium" and it was definitely on the "medium-rare" side. The meat itself was pretty tough to chew/cut/eat and hardly seasoned to enjoy on it's own unlike other steaks we've had. The charring tastes did not come through. We were plenty full after just ordering 1 app and 2 dishes for our party of 4. Overall, the service was exceptional. read more

See all

It was just ok to me not my favorite. Foe the price you would think it would be this great steakhouse but it's not . No flavor at all , that I was eating the sides instead of the steak to be full. I will go to other steakhouses for this price. Parking is valet which is fine. Inside seating is super tight and extremely loud, so if you want quiet this isn't the place. I will not be back it's a big No for me as there are so many other steakhouses that are better that are not too far. read more

Having a short stay cation and someone suggested Pace's Steakhouse.From the friendly valet service to the greeting at the front desk I knew I was in for a treat. The waitstaff were on point! I had oysters on the half shell,fresh and sweet. I ordered the special app to go Slab bacon and if was perfect late night snack . I had the filet mignon Oscar's medium rare perfectly cooked. My vodka martini hit the spot! No complaints. We dine again and highly recommend read more

See all

Now this is a steakhouse! Upscale vibe with valet and attentive waitstaff. Started off with the bread at the table, the star being a pull-apart roll with butter and seasonings baked in. The other breads were a bit lackluster but definitely don't fill up here. Had one of the best scallops I've had in my life as an appetizer along with generously stuffed mushrooms. Every salad at our table was phenomenal. I myself had the Caesar where they don't skip out on the Parmesan! My partner and I split the Porterhouse Steak for Two, which was deliciously tender and made for great leftovers. Mushrooms and spinach on the side were perfect, especially the spinach. Had amazing red wine at the table to top everything off. I would say my only feedback would be for waitstaff to come around and sweep crumbs in between dishes and for a bathroom remodel, as that aspect of the restaurant wasn't quite as "high end" as the rest of the facilities/building (old doors, plastic soap dispenser, etc.). Would absolutely return for a special occasion! Loved it! read more

Pace's Steakhouse - Porterhouse Steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

See all

I enjoyed this Place. The ambiance feels like a moody living very cozy. The staff were accommodating. The food was delicious. Cozy fine dining experience. read more

Valet moved my car outside mirrors. They should not touch the car, only for moving it. Girls up front when you walk in, very unprofessional. Fooling around, one girl - dressed sloppy. We did not have reservations because the night was early. The girls immediately had an attitude - "You really need reservations! We have 300 people coming! You have to be done by 6 oclock! We can't put you in the dining room. We can put you by the bar." But - the petite filet mignon was good. Warm bread. I told the waiter that it was my mom's birthday. About 6 waiters came by to sing! Very nice! They sang very well I must say! lol! Candle with ice cream and a piece of cake. The service was good. The boys were on top of things - cleaning the table, the right silverware, filling the water. read more

Had a great birthday dinner with friends. Started off with the slab of bacon which was on special (AMAZING), shrimp cognac and baked clams which were all great. We all had ribeyes which were also great. The ribeyes are much bigger than we anticipated, so a lot of delicious leftovers. The creamed spinach was good but probably a skip for me next time. We had the mushrooms and steak fries also. I really enjoyed the mushrooms, steak fries were good as well. For dessert we had a brownie with peanut butter on top which was amazing. Pricing was reasonable considering the table was drinking and we had a three course meal. Definitely will return! read more

See all

All of our food was awesome. Portobello oh my god so good. And that the porterhouse was amazing. Our bartender Ryan was the best. Special shout out to him.!! Thank You for a wonderful meal as always! read more

Pace's Steakhouse - Stuffed portobello - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

Great Steakhouse, non-chain restaurant feel, excellent service, excellent food. Good place for business meetings or intimate dates read more

Honestly this place is just mediocre .... I know it's been a staple around town for ever, but the steaks are just ok. I've been back 3 times in the last 4 months and not pleased with the service to be honest. Had a very junior guy serving us with zero experience and he was working with one of the others who have been there for a while and is seriously embittered, tbh. Putting that aside, the food is just ....ok. Filet mignon was good, but just good. Had the pork chop once, that was quite good and warn you to stay away from their pasta dishes --. Terrible. Zero flavor and overcooked. For the prices they are charging, it's just not worth it. Won't go back. Also VERY seriously dated decor. read more

Wow! Above and beyond! If you're looking for good service - this is it! From the valet to the host to the bartenders to busers and the servers! This is a raving review of what good service should be! Every element of service was provided when it came to drink specials food specials and the menu in general! The atmosphere is old fashion steakhouse style with the bookshelves and in my opinion speakeasy setting to boot! Absolutely love the aesthetics! Food was delicious! Ribeye for two, lobster tails, creamed spinach, creamed corn, berries & cream, And tartufo as well as coffees! read more

Pace's Steakhouse - Clams On The Half Shell - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

See all

This place sucks, has gone way down hill like all of the other places, food was inferior quality, nothing organic and too salty. The valet is a reject and needs to be fired. Typical young snot nose kid who grew up on the internet, no clue on how to provide customer service. hire qualified and courteous people. You do not need valet here the place is so tiny. read more

We had a lovely dinner here last night. Our 'team' of servers....Patrick and Heidi were the absolute best. Bus people were on top of everything too. Would return in a heartbeat~! read more

The $75 steak (before tax) I ordered arrived severely burnt, as shown in the photo. When I asked the server about it, I was told, 'the steaks here have a crust like that.' In my opinion, this level of charring goes beyond what would typically be considered an acceptable crust, especially at this price. read more

Pace's Steakhouse - Porterhouse Steak for 1 - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

I love this place been here a couple of times. It has great ambience and the food is very good. Server this time rushed me and my family. I knew what I wanted, but my parents never been there so it wasn't a great experience for them. But overall they really enjoyed the food and would come back off the simple fact of the food being really good. in the photos we got steak fries, garlic mashed potatoes, lobster mac & cheese, the New York shell steak, seafood platter, and the half chicken. read more

See all

They have great espresso martini and the steak is amazing. The apple strudel was perfect it wasn't too sweet which I like! Our server was great! And the ambiance was nice perfect for a date night. It is a bit dark so keep that in mind but I enjoy it. read more

See all

Steaks are delicious here and so is the lamb. The sides also very good. Service has always been solid. The only negative is it can get very loud for some reason. Overall love this place been many times. Great steakhouse! read more

Went for the first time for husband's bday after learning it is highly recommended via Long Island Restaurant Group! Everything from bread basket to dessert was delicious. Big shout our best waiter to date Trevor - thanks for making our first experience a 4 star rating - read more

Pace's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

First time at Pace's and it didn't disappoint. Started out at the bar for some cocktails, Joe mixed us up some very tasty cocktails and was very personable and accommodating. Started with Tuna Poke which was fresh and delicious. We had a rib eye for 2 that was cooked perfectly. The outside was crusty and it was cooked medium rare. The sides were spot on, garlic mashed, creamed corn, creamed spinach and mushrooms. All delicious. Our servers Alexandra and Josh were terrific. Great steakhouse atmosphere. Highly recommend especially for special occasions. read more

Pace's Steakhouse - Tuna poke - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

See all

Family of five (4adults,one child) ate there last night and what a major disappointment. Starting with waiting on the road to pull into valet parking our experience was subpar. Although we had reservations made a month ago, we waited twenty minutes for our table. Our drinks were excellent. Two star rating instead of one because the appetizers were excellent. We shared shrimp, slab bacon and Caesar salad. All were delicious. Then came the steaks. What a major letdown from a steakhouse. A rib eye steak(med), a porterhouse for two (med rare) and a porterhouse for one (med well) were ordered . None of the steaks had any seasoning or flavor...just grilled hunks of beef. The steak ordered med came rare, the steak ordered med rare came med and the steak ordered med well came well done. They cooked the rare steak more so that was ok, they offered to make a new steak for the overcooked steak but since it would take time they opted to keep it and manager said he would take care of it. When the check came, They did take off that off the check which was the right thing to do. If a steakhouse can't make a flavorful steak cooked to order, it is a steakhouse we will never go back to. read more

I have been to many fancy steakhouses on the island and no matter where I go it just never beats Pace's. The mac and cheese is life changing and the service is always outstanding. They always cook their filet to perfection! I have never had anything less than an amazing experience here. read more

Even after a year of not ordering take out and a few years not dining in. This place never disappoints. We were in route to another steak house but somehow ended up right here. Nothing really changed from my last review except the menu. We ordered off of the lunch menu this time because I really didn't want anything from the dinner menu except. Rack of lamb. Lobster Mac and Cheese and creamed Spinach. However, from the lunch menu we both ordered The Filet Mignon Steak Sandwich, this is what the waiter Trevor recommended and I'm so glad he did. First of all Trevor was the most amazing waiter we have ever had. Everything about him was perfect and he did not disappoint. Anyway, back to the sandwich it was made with love. Definitely recommend it and it went great with the sides we ordered and it also came with a house salad. I substitute the house salad for a Caesar salad. But yet another great night at Pace read more

See all

NOT A SAFE PLACE TO DINE!!! We are 6 seniors, two men and four women, who were verbally accosted by two other much younger male diners. TWICE THEY STOOD OVER US AND YELLED: WHATS YOUR PROBLEM. YOU DON'T HAVE KIDS. They were so out of control that FINALLY the manager and another man had to push them away from our table. The mother loudly screamed at our table the expletive F... at her more than once during the evening. One of us, a 76-year-old woman, left in tears before our dinner started. All this started bc we asked the manager to politely ask them to control their kids who were screaming. Did the manager ask these out-of-control bullies to leave the restaurant? NOPE. The only person who had our backs was the waitress who said: I'm so sorry. Don't worry I'll protect you. Seems Pace's is now a thug handout where the thugs rule. read more

AMAZING SERVICE!!!! thank you for everyone. Ryan best bartender Patrick best manager thank you

Dated decor, overpriced and mediocre food. Visiting from Texas, so I know what a good steak house is.

Very nice atmosphere. We dined here for our anniversary. It's welcoming and warm inside, which was well received. I expected more from the food. I had a steak, not marinated. It was a pricey cut of beef, and had no flavor. None. I applied som3 salt and pepper and it helped a little. Not much. Disappointed and will not return. read more

It wasn't worth the money they didn't cook the steak the way we wanted it .came out raw not rare

The food was great, the service was great, and the atmosphere is very nice. The only thing I'll say is that the steak could use a bit more flavor and a little less of the fire. Overall great !! read more

See all

I have not been here in years but let me tell you, I was still very impressed. When you arrive you feel like you are transported back in time to an "old school" but classy steakhouse. We walked into the bar for a pre dinner drink and Joe was behind the bar. Not only can this guy make you laugh but he can make a solid drink. The bar was crowded so we sat at small rail to hang out. My wife is pregnant and Joe went above and beyond. He saw her ginger ale and cranberry was almost empty so he came around from behind the bar and dropped off another one for her. We were very impressed by that. When we sat down we were greeted by Taylor and Josh. They were very knowledgeable about the menu, were very professional and funny. We started with a Caesar salad which was massive and 2 soups, a French onion and lobster bisque which were also a huge portion (forgot pics bc so impressed and hungry lol). All the apps were so good! Then for dinner we split the 40 oz bone in porterhouse special. This thing just like everything else ... HUGE! It was cooked perfectly and full of flavor. The steak was so tender and juicy. For sides we ordered Mac and cheese, creamed spinach and garlic mashed potatoes. All around the sides were amazing in size, taste and quality. We had to try the dessert since everything else was incredible. I ordered a piece of chocolate cake and my wife ordered the tartufo. Both of them were very satisfying. Throughout the whole meal Taylor and Josh were on top of it and made sure we had everything we needed and that everything was to our liking. Our water glasses were never even empty and empty plates were never on the table long. We will definitely be returning and I highly recommend that you give this place a shot if you have never been! read more

Pace's Steakhouse - Chocolate cake - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

See all

Service was really good . Staff was super nice . Manager was going around asking how dinner was . Restaurant a little dark for my liking but they do have lamps at each table . Prices are reasonable . They aren't overly expensive . Ranges from 50-100$ for a steak depending on size and type . Food was good . Steak was cooked perfect to my liking . Sides are just as amazing . The commentary bread was so good as well . read more

See all

By far the worst steakhouse I've ever been to. The filet was poorly cooked and extremely greasy. We waited almost an hour for subpar food that was way over priced. The bartender made a good margarita, hence the one star. read more

Was there for a party. They were very accommodating with gluten free. I ordered the filet and it was cooked perfectly. Nice ambiance and bar area. read more

Pace's Steakhouse - Filet - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

Not much in the area aside from visiting father in law and mom but we decided to take them out for their birthdays to pace! First time here and literally one of the first before it got really busy and quick. We didn't have reservations and it was a Sunday so we waited a bit but accommodating were made for our family with 3 kids we sat by the bar and a fire place, even though we weren't in the actual dining rooms we still enjoyed the view and the service very much. The food was very delicious and very flavorful, and the drinks were delightful. There is complementary valet service for your vehicle once you arrive. read more

See all

I think it's over hyped it's good but it's expensive there are better steakhouses peppercorn sauce was best thing there read more

Pace's Steakhouse - Wine - Steakhouses Near Me - Hauppauge, New York

See all

Just went there and had the rack of Lamb. Can you say yum? It was so good. And like usual, the service was amazing. Thank you very much, see you again soon. read more