No recent reviews on Yelp? How is this possible? Since this place has been "reinvigorated", we had heard the hype and had to see what was up. Our dinner there was one of the best we've had in a long time. We went on a Friday night so it was packed and had to wait an hour (at the bar) but it was worth it. The bartenders were extremely friendly and chatty despite being super busy. When we were seated, the manager(?) recommended a bottle of wine to us that was one of the smoothest we'd ever tried (Brown Estate Zin). When the food came (mussels, porterhouse, ice box cake) we were very pleased that this place does in fact live up to the hype. It was a tad loud, not really a romantic spot, but the decor was modern and the vibe was very upbeat. We enjoyed a great meal but wouldn't call this a steakhouse if that's what it is trying to be. Can't wait to go back! read more

Came here for a birthday and was disappointed. Food was excellent but the service needs work. We had finished our appetizers before she even took our entree order, which left us sitting for 30 minutes with no food and empty glasses. For such an expensive menu you expect good service, extremely disappointed. read more

Went to get a burger at Old Fields since they were on Newsdays 10 best burger list & I live so close by, also saw on their menu a "pickletini" and I just had to try it, sounded like a match made in burger heaven. I was getting the pickletini of course but the person I went with wanted wine, the young lady who waited on us offered to let her taste first because she was choosing between 2 reds I thought that was really amazing. The service throughout the whole meal was great. Now onto the food the burger was good, but I have to ask where are all the juicy gooey burgers, the ones when you bite into them the juice runs down your chin??? I cant seem to find one anywhere. The fries were good, also ordered the crispy onions they were ok I think the batter is too heavy for such a thin sliced onion, and yes the pickletini was good, kind of refreshing, more cucumbery than pickley. Prices are good, setting is cozy, all in all a good meal. BUT I am still looking for my dream burger. read more

Old Fields - The Pickletini - Steakhouses Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

See all

I'm so happy to have discovered this place!!!!! Impeccable, AMAZING food & drinks & customer service. I have not been to an amazing restaurant that is A+ on all levels in a very long time. This is DEFINITELY my new spot!!!!!!! I love it here!!!! The staff is INCREDIBLE!!!!!!!!! read more

Old Fields - Key lime martini too delicious - Steakhouses Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

This place has to have a review on Yelp. I ate there a handful of times from 2003-05. I remember liking it. Typical steakhouse with big portions and and high quality. The prices are a bit high - typical steakhouse. I really remember liking the atmosphere in there too. I don't want to say dank. How about charmingly dark? I wish I had some more specifics but it has been a while. I would like to get back sometime. read more

My husband and I visited Old Fields for the first time today and we had a really enjoyable brunch, for the most part. The restaurant itself is small, but really nicely decorated and very comfortable. I loved looking at the snow falling out the huge window and we had fun trying to answer the riddle posted on the chalkboard (all of my guesses were wrong, but my husband's was right!). The food was good - we both left feeling very full. We had the biscuits and gravy, which a little cold upon arrival but were good (I probably wouldn't order it again, but was glad to have tried it). I had the roasted tomato soup, which was delicious and filling, and my husband had the New England clam chowder (a new menu item, apparently), which he enjoyed and found to be very hot when it arrived at the table (this might be the first time a restaurant has delivered soup that he found to be the right piping hot temperature!). My husband ordered the chef's omelette of the day, which was a pulled pork omelette -- it was delicious -- with home fries and a biscuit. I ordered the popcorn chicken and waffles, which was also delicious. Then, because we're obviously animals when presented with a dessert menu, we shared a slice of brown sugar pie, an ooey gooey delicious and crazy sweet treat. Service was sort of spotty - but we don't feel that we can accurately judge the service today based on the fact that there was one server for the entire section, which we counted as having ten tables and two fairly large parties. She seemed a little frantic and service was pretty slow, but she was in a lot of places, so we're going to give Old Fields another try to see if this is typical. I will say that the most negative part of our experience was our fellow patrons. Look, I like children just as much as the next childless person, but I'll never find your kids as cute and amusing as you do, which might be why I don't find it enjoyable for you to sit at a table and enjoy your meal and your drinks while your young (2-3 year old) children literally run laps around the restaurant and start banging on the window and throwing pillows around on the other side of the restaurant. It's just not cute to me. Every time your kid runs past me, I kind of hope s/he trips. Also, as we were eating dessert, the table next to us, a large party, was getting up to leave... except that they hovered and sort of surrounded the back of our table (where I was sitting) to converse and play with their children. I don't know what goes on, folks, but a little consideration goes pretty far, no? Anyway, one of our good friends counts Old Fields among his top four restaurants, and we had a good experience, so we'll be checking it out again and recommend that you do too! read more

This is one of our absolute local favorites. Everything is fresh and delicious and the staff is so friendly. Whether sitting at the bar or in a cozy booth, it's a great experience. Highly recommended! read more

Great service! The Mac and cheese was delicious! A iron skillet of buttery cheesy goodness. The only bad thing is that I ate so much of the Mac and cheese I couldn't finish my perfectly cooked turkey burger. The sweet potato fries are perfect! This place is pretty happening even on a Thursday night. They have live music on Fridays. read more

My husband and I ate at Old Fields recently for the first time. It was a wonderful experience.The atmosphere was cozy,,,the fire was burning in the fireplace which added to the ambiance! The food was delicious. My hangar steak (the special that night) was perfect and the marinade was delish. My husband had the 56 burger which he enjoyed. The service was excellent, the staff was very attentive. The manager checked in on us and when he heard it was our first visit, he brought us a slice of their ice box cake, which was yummy. I'd definitely recommend Old Fields, we look forward to our next visit. read more

We have been coming here since we moved to Greenlawn, it is by far the best restaurant in the area...That being said it is a bit pricey, and you may need to wait for a table. The wings, shrimp and grits, burgers and special skillet steak are all great! Stay away from the fried chicken though too many herbs in their batter...would like to see more of a lunch menu as well and change in specials... read more

Love them! I've had nothing but great experiences with them. They have the best burgers in town! They also have a very cute room to the side that can be used for events. read more

I was spending the day in Long Island and was looking for a place to have dinner on the way home to Brooklyn. Old Fields came highly recommended by a friend. We started off with New England Clam Chowder and Shrimp and Grits. The Chowder was not the traditional New England style but was more like a bisque. It was nice and creamy and has a hint of sweetness. It was really good. The Shrimp and grits was a little different as well and is topped with a tangy red sauce. The shrimps were cooked perfectly however the grits, although good, had the consistency and tasted of a Supermarket instant grits. For the Mains we had the 22oz Bone in Rib Eye and 10oz Flat Iron steak. The steaks were seared nicely but a little under season and very tough. Tough to the point it was hard to chew. The meat itself lacked flavor for both steaks. This is very disappointing especially with the $44.95 price for the rib eye. That is a dry aged steak price and the steaks are not dry aged and was a cheap cut of meat. My jaw was tired from chewing. The side that came with the mains were smashed red potatoes and Brussels sprouts. The sprouts were under cooked and more on the raw side. The potatoes were ok and nothing to write home about. I'm sure the other menu items are better but do avoid the steaks. read more

See all

We've been here, maybe three times before, and enjoyed it. Funny how it just takes one terrible experience and we won't return. This was an awful experience. To begin, my husband ordered a burger and I ordered the salad on the special menu, a Country Salad, I think it was named. I asked for grilled chicken on top. It contained maybe four thin slices of cucumber, 3 halves of cherry tomatoes, some corn kernels, some potatoes, and perhaps it was arugula with massive uncut stems. Ok. So here we go. I asked my husband how his burger was. He replied, "Well if you mess up a burger, you're in big trouble!" Well how do you mess up a salad? I'll give you some ideas. The chicken on top was so rubbery that my teeth squeaked as I chewed it, like that squeak you hear when you chew Haloumi, only that's supposed to be like that. I tried 3 pieces and then asked my husband to try it. I couldn't believe the texture nor could he. Were they rubber bands disguised to look like chicken? So I called the waiter over and begged him to try the chicken. He refused, but asked if I wanted the same salad with shrimp. I agreed. I think there were 4 large shrimp over, those similar, Arugula stems with a few leaves, the corn, tomatoes, cucumber (can you spare the few slices?), and potatoes. Oh, let me tell you about the potatoes. When I was a teenager, I'd stand in front of the fridge, with a fork, and sample whatever was available. Well the potatoes could have come from that refrigerator. Ever have leftover cold potatoes? Nor have I, except as a teen. So, this "meal", along with a club soda and an iced tea, came out to $50. Yep. The waiter did bring over 2 small comp. glasses filled with ice cream and soda. I don't like sending food back. But this is the worst restaurant experience we've had in a very long time. Maybe they're stretched too thin, also owning the Huntington BBQ. How do you mess up a salad? read more

A friend of ours is a server here, so maybe we are a little biased. :) They have great comfort food and cocktails on the menu, and the fish and chips is authentic (the chef is from the UK). Other hits are the Mac and cheese and the pulled pork. read more

Great steak, great atmosphere, great service and a great drink list. I'm glad we stumbled on this great steak house across from the LIRR station in Greenlawn. I would highly recommend this small town, cozy steakhouse read more

Old Fields - Steakhouses Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

Have been here several times since moving to the area. Service is always excellent, as is the food - among the highlights for me have been the burgers and a couple of different seasonal duck entrees. Beer list is above average, with a lot of rotating selections. Have come here on my own, with my wife, with my young son, and most recently with a really large group - each time has been a great experience, which speaks to the versatility of Old Fields. I'm also pretty certain that the owner/manager has personally checked on our table every time we've come in, which is a nice touch. No matter who you're there with, you can expect an enjoyable meal. Go and enjoy some of Greenlawn's best! read more

Nice atmosphere. Dimly lit. Great friendly service. Not a long wait for food. The $$ is a lie...want steak? Gona run you min $30-$50. But..def worth it! Hubby had steak cooked med rare n it was perfect! Almost melted in your mouth! No steak stuck in your teeth. I had a burger and the ground beef was to die for! Like it was ground up steak. That with fries..$20 but worth it. Also got a mini soda float after our meal, free! Will def take the hour drive just to eat there! read more

High end food without the pretentious crowd. Warm atmosphere with that "grandma's home cooked meal" feel. Tory, our waitress, was very helpful and suggested great dishes! Unique menu and friendly, attentive staff. Will be coming back! read more

See all

I had the brunch yesterday, regret not going with a burger as other reviews suggested. Eggs were runny, bacon was cold, and home fries were french fires. We were told at the end of our meal, that they ran out of their regular home fries. It would have been nice to have been told that when we placed our order. Kids ordered popcorn chicken, it was oily and fatty. Only positive note, they have ipads so kids can play games while you wait for a table. read more

Saw some good things about Old Fields on Yelp and decided to give it a try. The smell as you're walking towards the restautant is intoxicating, smoky BBQ. The inside has a great contemporary rustic feel with interesting lighting. Loved the ambiance. We asked our waiter for some recommendations... he didn't promote the Burrata but it was the best thing we had! The desserts were sensational - smores sundae and bread pudding! The burger was pretty good but everything else was just ok. We would go back to try a few more things and perhaps sit outside. Give it a try! read more

Old Fields - Steakhouses Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

Updating to add my original email to the restaurant from 10/9/20. We also decided to give Old Fields another try and visited their second location in Port Jeff yesterday. Big Mistake. "Hi, I hate that I'm writing this but I wanted to get to the bottom of my experience this past Sunday night. I want to start off by saying that Old Fields was/is my favorite restaurant since I moved to Greenlawn 5 years ago. My fiancé and I love to eat there along with Old Fields BBQ in Huntington. We also supported the Ellas pop up in Greenlawn and Old Fields Port Jeff during the Greenlawn closure. My fiancé always orders the filet and I switch between the short rib beef risotto (which is my all time favorite dish) and the filet. Sunday night we finally got a chance to eat dinner at Old Fields Greenlawn since it opened back up. I was so excited for risotto. He ordered the filet. At first glance it didn't look up the par as usual. The demi-glace looked lumpy. He took a few small bites with an odd face and said this tastes strange. I then tried the steak thinking he was being picky but it was pretty bad. The filet did not taste like steak. It tasted tangy, almost sour and the texture was a bit off. I know what an Old Fields steak tastes like (delicious) and that was not it. I know the filets are not marinated (as they shouldn't be) and I don't think a marinade would taste like that. I made sure to taste the demi-glace alone which was disappointingly bland so that was ruled out. The filet was also cooked perfectly to a little less than medium (not medium but not medium rare) so it wasn't that either. When the waitress came to ask how the food was we told her what we thought and she took it back. He was so grossed out by the taste that he didn't want anything else. He tried to eat a chicken wing from our appetizer but that didn't help. He didn't even want to get a bread pudding that was always get. The manager came to the table and didn't really give us an explanation as to why it would have tasted like that, only that you get your meat delivered daily and it was probably a bad cut and she took the filet off the bill. I did have to stop her and nicely tell her that we have had the dish several times before and something was wrong. We did make sure tip the waitress on what the full meal would have been because we felt bad, it wasn't her fault. I looked up what it could have been on the walk home and the only explanation that I found is that he was served a rotten piece of meat which I want so bad not to believe. I just keep telling myself the maybe someone accidentally marinated a filet with a terrible tasting marinated. I know your other two steaks are marinated but I also can't imagine them tasting like that. Unfortunately when my fiancé has a bad meal at a restaurant he stops going there which is terrible news for me since my favorite dish is at Old Fields Greenlawn. I'm sure I can order to-go by myself as I have before but it's not the same as eating it there. I honestly don't know how to rectify the situation. guess I'm just looking to find out what was actually served and let someone in management know that we were possibly served a rotten steak. :(" read more

We visited to take advantage of Long Island Restaurant Week, but this restaurant is worth a visit at any time. We started with the popcorn chicken and the mussels for appetizers,and both were excellent. For dinner, we had the ribeye and the skirt steak, with both arriving perfectly cooked. Dessert was a sinfully great brownie sundae and a warm banana bread drizzled in chocolate. Our delightful server Christie did a wonderful job and we look forward to going back again. read more

We ordered the popcorn chicken, horrible. It wasn't all white meat and the pieces were not popcorn size. Burgers were ok, the fries were the best things we ate w our meal. read more

Sunday, eh, bad experience, been there a few times before and was good, but a Sat night, my meal good, my wife, for some reason big problem for a simple salad with grilled chicken, I guess message for the grilled chicken never made it to the kitchen, and oil and vinegar should actually have a bit of the vinegar part, prior to getting a dry salad. Was hoping for a nice Sunday eve meal with My wife, but a flop, I'll stick to the usual Saturday visits. read more

Amazing dinner experience. As always. Phil was amazing and very informative. Love the food and service.

Customer service is incredible, have been here before and food is great. This just happened to be a time where the take out order turned out wrong by mistake. But no questions asked, a whole new meal free of charge was delivered to my house instantly on one of the busiest nights of the year. I cannot express how great they were and did everything possible to make my food correct. Above and beyond, A+ from me! read more

This is a great place for a good steak, fish, burgers and cocktails. The atmosphere is soft lighting and the people are friendly. You may have to wait a little for a table but its worth the wait. This is a family friendly restaurant. If you have children they will seat you away from the bar area which is a plus. I have dined here for about 30 years and it is as good now if not better. (don't change a good thing). The prices are reasonable. The decor has changed a little, not as rustic but pleasant. I hope they never update it to much. There are not many places like this around anymore. They have a very nice fireplace which use to have a table in front of it but now its gone :( I have to admit I dont go as often now because they took away that table. No matter how long we had to wait that was our spot every week. They do have some games you can also play at your table (shut the box, etc). The attire is come as you are from jeans to a suit you will feel at home. They use to have some great and crazy things from oyster shots to peanut butter creme brulee. This oldie but goody is worth trying. read more

This is quickly becoming one of my favorite Long Island Restaurants. They really knocked it out of the park when they changed it over from the old Pace's in Port Jeff as well. At both locations the food is spectacular and the bar is just as pleasing. The braised short ribs (my all time favorite dish) are tender, flavorful and delicious. They come atop a bed of goat cheese risotto which is also very nice. I had the cauliflower soup which, despite being a vegan dish, was still very appealing. If I was going to the electric chair, the mac and cheese would be my last dish. This place was made for beer lovers as the bar is full of 8-10 craft beers and another 20 or so micro brews in bottles. The decor and ambiance is very good. I plan on having many more dinners at Old Fields. I have trusted them with a birthday and an anniversary. I will be back to have my friend's bachelor party in their private room as well. If you like a good steak and good beer without all the glitz of an Insignia or Blackstone's this is a great place for you. read more

This is the place for a burger and a beer! They don't allow kids in the main room, which is weird... that's where you want to be. Happy hour- wings and flatbread a no-brainer. Nice tap selection. Boring AF playlist. Decadent brownie dessert is a must. read more

Food is good but way to expensive for the portion size. I likely won't come back because of that. Two apps, two entrees two drinks and almost a 150 dollar bill. Pretty unavoidable for a night out there. For that much I'd at least like to have a reasonable sized meal. But again, the food was pretty good at least. read more

Nice crowd. Service was very good. Food was great. Professional service and staff. I'd definitely come back

Delicious. Ridiculously good. Excellent service. Can't wait to go back! Definitely will become a regular spot for us!

We had a delightful experience at Old Fields. The food (branzino and skirt steak) were well cooked and delicious. The chocolate martini was great. Most of all, Nick was a great server! read more

Stopped in for a burger and beer and was not disappointed. The burger was cooked perfectly and flavorful. They had Shiner on tap, although they ran out of Shiner Ruby which I'd wanted to try. The service was professional yet friendly and the decor is warm, and inviting and well executed. The only disappointment was the Mac & Cheese, which was very runny. read more

This restaurant and bar is actually very nice and gives out a very good vibe five. The wait staff there is amazing everybody's really nice and understanding. This was our first time here so we ordered the spinach dip and the turkey burger. The turkey burger was absolutely amazing. The burger was so nice and juicy. It was covered with Nice slice of melted cheese that really brought the burger are together With such a flavorful finish. Just finished that dip that we order however was really plain. I expected it to be more creamier however it was just microwaved spinach. The pita bread that they give with the spinach is actually very good. The onion rings and the french fries on the side were amazing. The onion rings mind you were really thin and crispy. They're not the normal thick slice onion. Rings that you would expect. I highly recommend this restaurant. If you're really into bar type food they have a great selection and very tasteful ingredients. Also they have a great menu for their beers and what they have on tap. I had the Scottsdale and my boyfriend had the loan the Ireland's pale ale. Both ears were amazing. They actually will give you a sample of the beer in these really cute tiny mugs. You know this is a very cute place to go very romantic for dates and also really friendly for family gatherings. read more

Old Fields was the second Newsday Top 100 restaurant that we put on our bucket list. Once again, it was a winner. The atmosphere was kind of like an Old West saloon with lots of wood and a bar that looked good for drinkin' whiskey. It was very comfortable and friendly. I ordered The "56" Burger which was kissed with their special "56" marinade and topped with swiss cheese and onions that were sauteed into almost an onion jam. I took the onion rings on the side, and they were more like onion straws so I immediately piled a bunch of those on the burger too. The burger was big and juicy ordered medium, and there were plenty of onion rings left over for munching. My son ordered the Marinated Skirt Steak with mushrooms on top, mashed potatoes, green beans and he ordered the creamed spinach on the side. The mashed and beans were fine. But the creamed spinach was spectacular, served in a cast iron side car and brimming with spinach, garlic and cream. But this was not creamed spinach like a puree; the individual elements were distinguishable from each other and it was just fantastic. And then there was the steak. After I tried it, I considered stealing it. It was medium rare with plenty of pink, yet super tender and incredibly flavorful. The marinade came through clearly and yet the mushrooms on top still worked with the marinade. Just a great dish. So we are two for two on our bucket list, and we have to revisit Old Fields again soon. Next time the Skirt Steak will be all mine. read more

This is my favorite restaurant on Long Island! I love the cozy gastropub vibe and the service is great! I highly recommend ordering a Pickletini at the bar and then Ice Box Cake for dessert. You can't go wrong with anything in between. read more

First time and definitely will go back. Love the atmosphere! We sat at bar and had 3 foods: French onion soup, slab bacon and Mac & Cheese. All excellent particularly the M & C. Good portion for appetizer, but could have ordered another. Yes. It was that delicious! Ron the bartender was very attentive. read more

First time at Old Fields and we were treated so well. We had simple burgers and beers but they were not simple, they were amazing !!! I can't wait to go back for steak !!! Ohh dessert was delicious too... read more

Absolutely amazing food. Haven't had anything yet that hasn't been delicious. And the service is great. Will definitely keep coming back read more

See all