Went here for the first time today for dinner. The atmosphere was nice, lighting was dimmed with some cool old portraits in the wall. We started off with the spinach dip which came with pita bread and it was excellent ! Well seasoned and tasted fresh. They had some local beers which was cool. One of the best burgers I've had was there. Not too greasy and it came on a sesame bun. I ordered the Greenlawn burger which has cheese, bacon and onion rings on it. I had to add the fried egg on top because ever since I tried eggs on a burger I can't have it any other way!!!The potato wedges were tasty and crispy. The tables had tic taco toe to play while waiting. They also had some other game with numbers and dice but I had no clue what it was so if anyone knows what it is please let me know! Only complaint I had was that we had to wait a while each time we needed to order a drink or needed something from the waiter. Great place though! read more

Pro: Food was amazing! I had the breaded chicken and waffles & Mac n cheese. The chicken was crispy and salty on the outside and smooth and juicy on the inside. It was so yummy that it didn't even need to be dipped in sauce! The Mac n cheese came steaming in a skillet and was fabulous as well! The waiter was cute and attentive and the restaurant had a quaint vibe to it. Con: The drinks are pricy and the bar fills up quickly after opening. read more

Nice atmosphere set up more like a bar than a restaurant not as quaint as the restaurant in Port Jefferson biggest pet peeve hottest day of the year No Air Conditioning lost $100 sale minimum without drinks read more

Just picked up take out..Dining room was empty. This is the worst meal. My son had popcorn chicken nothing popcorn about the size. At the bottom of the container was saturated with grease gross!!! Did they hear of blotting? It came with just popcorn chicken. The portion is more than For one. Make the portion smaller and add coleslaw. I also ordered a Caesar salad, which was like a head of lettuce with pecans and a chunk of bread on top. My meal was a burger again more than a healthy amount of Grease roll was saturated with oil. my fries were greasy and limp.. we also ordered onion rings that were greasy with Grease just floating at the bottom of the container. It was pretty much not edible. I managed to eat most of my burger without Roll, my son had a few pieces of chicken. The meal was cold at pickup i arrived 5 minutes early... Staff in kitchen doesn't care It show i. Every way! I would not recommend!! read more

Stopped in before another event for a quick bite. So yummy. Everyone loved it. Would return in a heartbeat.

Went to eat at 8 pm and was immediately seated ordered the broadway burger medium and it did not disappoint read more

Old Fields - The Broadway burger added bacon - Steakhouses Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

We had dinner last night. The restaurant is very quaint and the roaring fireplace gave it a very cozy feel. The staff was very friendly. I had the skirt steak that was very good. It came with mashed red potatoes and roasted asparagus. Husband had the roasted chicken. He enjoyed it but would have ratcheted a fish meal. The only fish wax a fried fish and chips and crab cakes. Salmon would have been good to have on the menu. I was very disappointed in the lobster bisque soup. It was nothing more than a fish broth. It was not the typical bisque soup. I told the server there must be a mistake as it was only a broth with literally two very tiny pieces of what I assumed was lobster meat, smaller than the size of my pinky finger nail, I was told, no that is the bisque, it's "puréed" lobster bisque. It was not thick it was more a broth. He must have detected my disappointment as he returned with a thimble of lobster meat. I guess he tried to do the right thing. A little pricey. Portions not large but just enough. read more

Great local restaurant. Had the shrimp cocktail which was very fresh and tasty and the Veggi burger that is made on site and is delicious. Only thing i think they could do to step it up a little is make hand cut French fries just think it would give an extra something and also offer truffle fries. The other thing I don't understand is that there is no kids menu. Greenlawn is a very family orientated village and I find that strange not to offer one. Also we sat at the bar and Dave served us. He was very chatty and welcoming. He even offered us bread pudding on the house - delicious. Love this local. read more

Went here a little while ago - food was good as their quality is always consistent. On the other hand, I probably got like 3-4 sideways remarks from the people working there. Sorry your life sucks I guess ? read more

I was blown away by the quality of the flat iron steak. It was cooked perfectly, along with the mashed potatoes and asparagus. Very fair pricing considering the quality. The wait staff was friendly and helpful. Highly recommend. read more

Great local eatery. The service is always top notch, they make you feel like no matter how many other patrons are in the restaurant, that you are their top priority. I loved their Beef and Guinness stew, which has since disappeared from the menu (hoping for a comeback). Their steak is fantastic; my favorite is the skirt steak, which is also available as part of the Sunday brunch with eggs. A new favorite is their fish and chips; the fish is expertly beer battered and perfectly crunchy...my only gripe is that for $17 i'm only getting 2 pieces of fish. They don't take reservations for small parties so that can lead to serious wait times on friday/saturday evenings, so plan in advance to go before 7 or wait. read more

Was excited to go to old fields. But i have to say we all were very disappointed with our meals. My burger was dry and my bacon was burned. It was over cooked and only had a small piece of bacon that didn't cover the burger. My friend also ordered a burger medium and was dry and well done. Also my other friend ordered the fish and chips and it was over breaded and greasy. The cod was tasteless. Our bill wasn't cheap. It was overpriced and not worth it. However when we said the cod was disappointing she didn't offer anything to compensate. We will never return read more

We placed our order for our sit down dinner and added a take out dish to bring home to a family member who was working late. We asked for a check when we were finished with dinner and when the waitress brought it she didn't bring the take out we had ordered with everything else. We paid for everything then sat and waited 1/2 hour for the take out to come. Waitress kept saying the kitchen was backed up but I believe she never submitted the order. Very, very disappointing to be paid up and ready to go and have to wait 1/2 hour for the rest. read more

Oldfield's is so awesome! I've lived in this area forever but can't believe I only started coming here just in the last few years. Service is always great and I love the atmosphere. Their mac & cheese and shrimp & grits are some of the best I've ever had. I also can never resist getting dessert. Their ice box cake and bread pudding are heavenly! read more

See all

Come here every other week to take out a 10oz flat iron with potatoes and asparagus. This week meet was a bit on the rarer side for my family. Spoke with mike the manager and resolved the situation. Can't ask for a friendlier and customer caring steak joint. Most of them just want your money. Great job oldfields. Keep it real. read more

Chef Jovani is masterful at BBQ. His house-made BBQ sauce is a staple, a must have!!! Keep an eye out for his house specials. He is creative and accommodating. All sauces are made in-house, he orders prime steak cuts, all under Jovani's guidance. The cuisine is just delicious. The manager, Mike, is well versed in his knowledge of whiskey, his suggestions are always on point. Make sure you work with Angela (server), she will make sure your experience at Old Fields is classic and enjoyable. She is thorough, precise and consistent in checking to make sure you are happy and satisfied. Excellent food, great steak, great people. read more

I recently came here for a birthday dinner. There were 9 of us. Our bill came to roughly $500. As our dinner was finishing and we were sitting around talking before we were getting ready to leave, we pretty much got kicked out of the restaurant. They asked us to leave. I just spent $500 and you're asking me to leave? They needed the table. While I get that it is a restaurant and you're making money, I'm also a paying customer. We've been here before and it's been good. But after this, they don't deserve my business. I'll gladly spend $500 somewhere else where I won't be rushed. read more

The noise level is unbelievably loud. Even though it's rustic steakhouse it's not a bar. The service did not acknowledge or move us to a different location. We can't hear ourselves talk after waiting 40 mins to be seated !!! Disappointed !!!! read more

This is an amazing restaurant. I've been here several times and the food is always wonderful. Everything from the shrimp and grits to a veggie burger has been awesome. Cocktails are wonderful too. I really could not find a single issue with anything whether it be the food, service, or atmosphere everything was excellent. read more

I've wanted to come here for quite some time, what better moment than my birthday? We were seated in a very crowded area by the bar. It was comfortable enough, just people leaning over us due to the crowded bar was annoying. We had the spinach dip to start, which was very good. Unlike most, it was not overly greasy. The vegetable was married well with the cheese. Tasty pita slices too. I had the duck french dip, and it was quite good, except the duck was not really the standout part of it that I was hoping it would be. I had the brown sugar pie for dessert, thinking it would be similar to the Momofuku Milk bar crack pie that I like. It was good, but didn't match up. Still, I'd return and I'm recommending. read more

Food was average but a little overpriced for such small portions. The best part were the fries. I ordered the Caesar salad and it was giant leaves of lettuce which is just a pet peeve of mine. No one wants to sit there with a steak knife and cut their lettuce. Food took a very long time to come out and we also barely saw our server. Also, be warned that if you have kids there is no kids menu available. read more

Old Fields repackaged as Ella's. Nice trick, and I was fooled. Never understood the lure of Old Fields, and this place is the same garbage. Don't be fooled by the crowds that clearly have zero palette. Go to Wendy's or McDonalds....seriously. The burgers take you back to summer camp days...with a flat burger sitting in water. Chicken that is mostly breading. Succotash is what the side was called, not sure what it was other than corn niblets and Lima beans (but was admittedly better than the main meal). Limited bar....like when you ask for Stoli or Bombay and they don't carry that. It was a $100 bill wasted. read more

This is the place for a burger and a beer thats about it! Our waitress seemed a bit flustered She was slow on the ordering and on our refills but she was nice just wish she was more personable. read more

I love the atmosphere of this place. It's right near the train tracks which is oddly cozy. Inside is a beautiful fire place and cozy wood booths. The service was fast and friendly. They give complementary corn bread with a honey butter glaze which is amazing. I got the goat cheese and beet salad with steak. It was tasty, the steak was good. My husband got the brisket steak and eggs. The poached eggs were a little over cooked but still good. He enjoyed his meal overall. I would definitely come back. read more

A Bar/restaurant atmosphere. Juicy Burgers and deep fried steak fries. A good place to get your fill bear and food. Would go back again if I was in the neighborhood. read more

We came here for date night on Friday night and it was extremely crowded. We were told 30 minutes for our table, however, due to this wait, the hostess Logan treated us to complimentary drinks! We were seated after 20 minutes at a nice table. We ordered the fried calamari and honey truffle ricotta for appetizers. Both were delicious. Then for dinner we ordered Dave's chicken and the skirt steak. Both were exceptional as well. Highly recommend Old Fields due to their delicious food and wonderful service. read more

Tonight was a total disappointment compared to my last meal there. Sat out again - in the back this time. Some cushions on the benches would have been welcome. Service this time was just awful. "Confused" our table # and waited forever so simple order of burgers. And we ordered as soon as we sat down so we could eat and not get too cold. Waited an hour for 2 burgers - multiple BS excuses - other folks sat after us and got their meals before us!! Made no sense at all. Different waiter/waitress each time - fiasco - and this time burgers were not even cooked as requested! No soda refills - just was not what we expected since last time was truly excellent - wouldn't even tell manager to come out as we asked for. Just terrible!! read more

A fantastic world class steak house. Currently operating as a brick oven pop up called ellas. Incredible food. They have tables for the regulars who absolutely can't live without it. The pizzAs are amazing. The salad literally roughy tears to my eyes. Roasted tomatoes on fresh greens that are obviously so local the greens haven't realized they've been picked yet. Just amazing food. Looking forward to old fields proper re-opening because I miss their oysters and cocktails read more

Favorite Restaurant in the area. They have a huge menu with endless options. Everything I've tried I loved! And the atmosphere is fun. Parking can be a pain but it's worth it! read more

My husband and I have been coming to Old Fields for some years now and this place just keeps getting better and better! The food is always excellent and the staff are friendly and attentive. It's a pretty popular spot, so be prepared to hang out at the bar for 30-45 mins on a Friday or Saturday night whilst a table becomes free. The reason I'm not giving 5 stars in this review is down to the space limitations of this place while waiting to be seated - the bar is relatively small, there's not much room to stand around and it can get cramped quickly. My hubby particularly likes the filet mignon they do there and of course the rotating beer selection. As for me I just LOVE their risotto and the spinach artichoke dip is to die for. Overall a great place to go but try to get there early ahead of the dinner crowd. I recommend Old Fields - try it once and you'll love it! read more

ZERO STARS IF POSSIBLE! How could this place be voted top 10 in Newsday....who is buying off who? Last few times food has been slipping, burgers not being cooked too right temp.....little if any marinade. Bad ispwich clams, but this time will be the last for good. Order apps, decent, dirty plates sit in front of us for an hour.....while we waited for dinner. Took an hour in between. Dinner arrives, Red Snapper Special and Filet Mignon Medium....Snapper was Tuna cooked to death well done.....you advertise Red Snapper and we are served tuna. Really? Top ten and we don't know the difference between Tuna and Snapper? Filet Medium, was BLACK N BLUE! Stone cold and raw in the middle. Top ten and you're known for steaks and you cant cook it to a proper medium. No patience for the lack of care to tention to detail. The Tuna/Snapper was probably older tuna that the house needed to get rid of before it went bad, hey lets season it up, put some sliced vegetables on top and we will call it Red Snapper.....who will know? Doesn't the chef make the specials and set the menu? How does he/she not know that they are using tuna instead of snapper? The filet there is NO excuse for. But hey the're top ten......manager was apologetic but at that point too many mistakes made. Never Again! read more

My first review. I never planned on writing a review for this place, but my last visit left me empty and I need to get this off my chest. First let me say that I am NOT a picky eater. I want to support a local restaurant like this, but they need to really improve their game before I go back. One star is for the waiter who was very nice, and the other star is for the beer selection. My wife and I went here a few days ago for dinner. Our past experiences were mixed, and I know that this place has been trying to re-invent itself since its remodeling a few years ago. We were reluctant to go back, but we had a gift certificate to use so we went. Service was fine, and I give them more stars than this review for their beer selection and the $8 23oz. offer on some very fine beers. The problem was the food. My salad hardly resembled the description of "fresh garden vegetables". What I got was a plate with a handful of frisee and other lawn clippings with about a quarter inch of a carrot sliced thinly. The dressing was flat. YAWNSVILLE DADDY-O! Big disappointment. It's a freaking salad! The easiest thing to make nicely. Appetizer of macaroni and cheese...again another yawner. They really need to work on that. I think they should model this dish on the Beechers M&C recipe. For $9 I got maybe a cup and a half of thinly flavored M&C. They try to make it fancy by serving it in a small cast iron skillet. Dinner...I ordered the roasted chicken. It was served in yet a larger cast iron skillet that just didn't match the meal. I will give them kudos for boning the half chicken which makes it nicer to eat. The chicken flavor was just OK. They take the time to brown the skin nicely, then ruin it by simmering it in liquid which of course turns the skin into rubber. Why bother??? Barely any rice and the rest was forgettable. Very thin on flavor. My wife...not being too confident in the menu played it safe and went with a burger and onion rings. Her plate was filled with fried onions, and not onion rings, so I think they need to look at a photo of onion rings to see what they really look like. She said her burger was good, BUT...she went to pick up some onions and found a foot long hair fried in with them..YUCK and real downer that only solidified our skiddish opinion of this restaurant. Needless to say my wife is done with this place. Not wanting to make any scene, I quietly told the waiter what we found and he offered a replacement which we declined. He removed the charge from the bill..kudos. So...I will not be going back any time soon for food, but I still have part of a gift card to use so perhaps I will have a beer or two at the bar some day. I really hope that someone from the restaurant sees this and takes a critical look at their offerings. I want to like this place, but they make it tough to keep coming back. read more

Amazing dot dot dot. Just amazing. Great service. Mac and cheese on point. Grilled cheese geese burger my lord and the Guinness stew is obnoxiously good. Wow! 2 favorite restaurants are del friscos steakhouse in nyc and old fields just had the convo that we think old fields takes the cake because of the value and quality. WOW SO AMAZINGLY FUXXXIN GOOD! Mine and my girls favorite restaurant and we still drive out from queens in the weekend. Enough said read more

First time back after redo. was comfortable and not over the top felt easy to be there. We had the hamburgers and steak fries because we heard they were good. I am a burger guy and this burger was very good. It was cooked to order and the steak fries were very hot the way they should be. If you want a good burger check this place out. Next time I will go into the menu. read more

While we don't have any steak houses in Centerport, Greenlawn provides us with one of the best. I love the ambiance of this place! From the delicious food to the great beer, Old Fields has everything I need to satisfy my appetite. Although I always enjoy dining at Old Fields, eating here in the winter is my favorite. I feel like I'm in a cabin eating a steak with a draft beer. It doesn't get much better than that. read more

A local gem! Consistently wonderful food and service. The servers, hostesses, and staff are attentive and warm. The food comes reasonably quick, even when they're packed. The atmosphere is great: American, homey, and never too loud. Get there early for dinner, even on a weeknight. I prefer the Greenlawn location over Port Jeff for the coziness....Make sure you come with an appetite! read more

I recently had the flat iron steak which paired extremely well with their Simi Cabernet. Still packed at night, so don't feel bad if you have to wait - the staff are extremely talented with moving things along, yet we did not feel rushed during the meal whatsoever. I appreciate the door-curtain at the entrance, which keeps out gusts of cold air when someone opens it (since the bar and part of the dining area is right by it). It's the little details that count, and Old Fields gets them right! read more

I came here from out of town with a group of friends. We were a quite large party and when he came in they told us that we could not be seated together at a big table but the we would all be in the same section just divided into different tables. When they went to seat us they put us in a corner and then made the other people in our party sit on the other side of the restaurant. When we asked why the rest of the party couldn't sit at the empty tables near us they todl us that they were not available. Later when more people from our party came in they were sat at these same empty tables...obviously they were not saved for anyone. The service was horrible and the people who work there were extremely rude. The food was not very good and when it first came out it was cold. Everyone in our group thought that the service was horrible and the food was not good either. read more

Yes, The food and drinks are good. Those who are foodies and frequent the city, normal. This restaurant is in a family town in the middle of the burbs. The owners should realize what the updated version of family place means: Explore other competition restaurant do. Go to park slope and get a real picture. Updated families bring their well behaved kids everywhere. You need to accommodate them. My parents have been going to old fields before I was born, this place means something to me. Please try harder. read more

Old Fields is always great. The atmosphere is warm, and has lots of old pictures of Greenlawn and how things used to be. Always interesting to look at. We usually sit at the bar and have drinks and dinner. The beer is good and the cocktails are great, tons of options. They are known for their steaks, and live up to their reputation. The burgers are also a great option as well. If you're ever in Greenlawn, I would definitely check out Old Fields. read more