I would give this place 6 stars if I could! What a hidden gem in Pine!! The atmosphere is great - best kept secret in northern AZ! Wonderful ambiance, delicious house-made cocktails, and amazing food all locally made. Our server, Matt, was fantastic! He suggested the homemade Bloody Mary (which was to die for) and the specialty Spanish chorizo pizza... my boyfriend and I are SO impressed! The charcuterie was amazing and can't wait to come back. The prices are great and the setting is adorable. read more

Have been wanting to try this place ever since we saw it on AZ Hwys. It started out good got a 2 seater on the porch area and had the yummy beer cheese and breadsticks appetizer. Had the lavender cocktail and a margarita. Both drinks were good. Ordered a white pizza with added pepperoni. This is where it went downhill. We sat and waited literally a hour to get our pizza. Our waiter was avoiding eye contact with us and all the tables that came after us had ate and left while we were sitting there waiting for our pizza. There was a table of 10 that came and went. Finally the waiter told us the kitchen had got backed up. But I call bull as we ordered before that large table had even come. Just admit you lost our order or forgot to put it in. Really wanted a dessert but after already being at the restaurant for 2 hours decided we were over it. Which really sucked. You would have thought we would have got a dessert offerrl for free or something or even the pizza off the bill. Can't say I want to come back here anytime soon again after this poor service experience. The pizza wasn't even cooked all the way like they rushed it cause they realized they made a mistake. It was doughy. Oh well read more

Wings , wood fired pizza and beer, this place is awesome and a must to stop and eat at, very friendly and service is great .. Update came back for the beer cheese appetizer and it's a must have , the lefty pizza is wonderful too read more

Best pizza in Pine/strawberry. If I could, I would rank the food 5 stars but the service is absolutely horrible and would be 1 star. There is always a long wait (1-2 hours) no matter what time of day. Hostess/servers are not very attentive to the customers. Fortunately, when the food does come, it makes up for the horrible service. read more

Holy Moly!! This may just be the best pizza I've had - including living for a stint in NY and visiting Italy several times - I thought I knew good pie... We got the clam pizza, and do yourself a favor, get it as well! Simone took great care of us even though it was a busy Saturday morning. We took a seat on the patio and thoroughly enjoyed our lunch. We're from Phoenix and let me tell you, this was worth every second of the car ride to eat this delicious pizza (and wings and pizza cookie). Next door is a tap room, so really, there's no reason to go anywhere else! Enjoy it, and we may see you up there again real soon - we will 100% be back!! read more

Great outside patio. Lindsey is a great server and welcomed us to Az. We had chopped Italian salad and Meat pie which were delicious. We will be back to eat it was awesome. read more

The food is delicious. Love the buffalo chips and prickly pear wheat beer on tap. Good food takes time, bring your patience and sit at the bar to watch the pizzas cooking. This place is worth it. read more

Old County Inn - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

Why can't I give this restaurant 10 stars? Came to Pine today to cut down our Christmas tree. What a find. We had the calamari appetizer in a tomato sauce with olives and fresh bread sticks. YUM! Then we had the Lefty pizza with chicken, bacon and onion with B- que sauce. The crust is amazing and so delicious. I am impressed that both the owner and chef are both graduates of Culinary institutes, with the owner a graduate of The noted culinary institute in Hyde Park, NY. The service was excellent and the atmosphere is warm and friendly. The sausage and bacon are homemade and delicious. I can see that i will be making trips up to Pine just to eat here. Thanks for a great experience!! read more

Amazing pizza with a great ambience. I had a simple with home made sausage, onions and hot peppers -- it was amazing! Maybe one of the best pies I've had in AZ. I came for the tonto natural bridge state park but would return for this pizza alone. read more

Old County Inn - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

Ended up here after taking the long way off the Rim Rd. and everything was closed. Would be happy to make a trip to Pine just to have this again! Staff was friendly and the atmosphere was a relaxed hipster feel. The food was fantastic. We grabbed the meat and cheese plate which came with perfectly cooked bacon and lightly pickled cucumbers. Those of which caused me to buy a jar of the delicious delights. We ordered a pepperoni pizza which was also up to par. The crust was crispy and not overly drenched in their delicious sauce. Our waiter was friendly, open with suggestions, and hugged us as we left which made us feel like we were at home. My only "complaints" were: a bit confused walking in with a libations menu up front for the tap room only, wish they combined the two. Also the pepperoni was tiny causing little pools of grease - this is a minor negative. Overall we intend on making another trip here to try out more pizza options, and spend more time in the relaxed atmosphere. read more

See all

If you're rolling through the Rim Country, give this spot a try. I was pedaling by on my bike and saw the separate little building advertising craft beers. It's cool. There's a courtyard in between the bar shed and the main restaurant that has lights and cornhole. Food was great, I had the Chix and Pix and the buttermilk dressing was AMAZING (and I don't usually dig creamy sauces.) Friendly bartender, good tap list and a live guitarist. read more

Great experience and food! It was snowing out and my family of 7 was offered seating at the bar since the rest of the place was full and too cold to sit outside. Staff was super friendly and made the experience very pleasant. The waiter took time to talk to my kids as he was making drinks because they were asking questions. Now the pizza....it was outstanding! Kids got a regular pepperoni which was very good but we had the balsamic artichoke chicken pizza and it was great probably one of my favs now! Don't hesitate to check this place out!! read more

Old County Inn - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

My wife and I have been here many times now for lunch dates and I must say that this is our favorite place. We love the spinach and artichoke pizza and the bottle neck clam pizza as well as the beer cheese dip and the Buffalo chips. All of these are amazing and the staff is too. There are competent servers at this place who do their job well. read more

The white pie was super delicious and so was the Italian salad. Definitely would go back for the white pie. The staff is equally as amazing. Our truck broke down right next to the restaurant and it was the best thing that could have happened to us. Everyone was super helpful and super willing to give us a hand. It gave us the opportunity to eat their amazing food and meet the extraordinary people. read more

First time to visit, food was amazing. Chili beer cheese dip and bbq pizza were great. New favorite in pine. Taproom is super cool. read more

Old County Inn - Beer cheese dip - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

This place was everything all the reviews say it is, fantastic!!! From the drink selection to the salad we had to the amazing pizza it was all delicious and just what we need. The icing on the cake was having Mo as our bartender/Server. Mo, who primarily works in their Tap Room makes it all happen and She made our first experience nothing less than fantastic. We are going back as often as possible. read more

Great food and wonderful staff. The wait is always worth it. We stop by here any chance we get, driving up from Surprise, AZ.

Yeah, a great choice when in Pine. Good service, tasty food, outdoor patio with great views of the Mogollon Rim. We used the Yelp app to look for restaurants in the area, and this one popped up as number one. Looked in the parking lot and the density of cars seemed to justify a stop. We had an Arizona Greens salad, Buffalo Chips, and an order of chicken wings. All was fresh and tasty. My only complaint - and there's always one. The wings were a tad too spicy. Not everyone likes burning lips while (and after) eating wings. Maybe make the heat level an option. read more

A big thank you to Mike for the great service. Finally collected my free pizza from 2 years ago. A man is only as good as his word ( I know, old school) but he honored his word from 2 years ago. Brandon is another good guy that has been there for a long time. read more

This is hands down some of the best pizza in the state and you won't be disappointed the pretzels and beer cheese are also to die for. It's usually pretty busy from open to close but you won't be disappointed if you make the wait read more

I have eaten here a couple of times and it is always a good experience. I first stopped here last year as my family usually camps in the area for Memorial Day weekend. We stopped last year on our way back to Phoenix to grab some food to go. We ended up hanging out for a bit because the pizza took a little time to make and they were busy (holiday weekend). We ate the pizza on the road and it was fantastic. We stopped in again this weekend and ate on site. Even though it was busy we were seated pretty quickly. The food does take a little time so be prepared for that. Their beer cheese was really good (appetizer) and we had pizza again. Overall, it was a good experience. If you are in the area, I can definitely recommend stopping in. Just be prepared to spend some time waiting for the food. They do have cocktails and beers on tap which helps with the wait time. read more

Passing through Pine, we were hungry for lunch and needed some shade from a long day driving in the sun. This place did not disappoint. If you love pizza, get down there and get you some wood-fired greatness. We split a big Italian salad to start. The had a great local beer menu, though we stuck with home-brewed iced tea which was delicious. For our pizza, we picked the Pancho. It was perfection. They have a nice patio but we sat in at the bar, where you can watch them at work making perfect pizza. Yum! read more

My husband and I stayed in Strawberry for an overnight trip up north. We decided to check out Old County Inn and left with it being our new favorite place. The staff were all so friendly and it was fun that the owner was making the pizzas + chatting with the guests. We ordered the Woodfired Wings, Green Chile Beer Cheese [best choice ever], and the Meat Pie Pizza. Even as leftovers - it all was delicious. We'll probably make the 2 hour drive again sooner than later just to eat here!! Delish! read more

Old County Inn - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

5000 stars! Absolutely THE best pizza EVER!!! Consistent every single time. You have to try the Lavender Drop cocktail. Best cocktail on the planet!!! You have to go. You have to try it! Make the drive. It's worth the wait. read more

What a delightful surprise when traveling from Williams to Globe Arizona. My husband, eight-year-old and I stopped here for lunch today. So glad we did. My husband and I had the most amazing Hawaiian BBQ Pizza. My son (who is a picky eater) choose the cheese pizza and commented on it being good. He actually ate 3 slices when he normally will only eat one. They offered a wide selection of beer on draft including a few IPA's. Although it was a bit chilly today..and we ate inside, they have a wonderful outside patio to sit and enjoy the beautiful scenery. Our server, Kerri was wonderful. She recommended a delicious green chili, beer cheese dip with homemade breadsticks, as an appetizer. So good! We later discovered it was made from their Grand Canyon Amber ale. I highly recommend to anyone visiting Pine to stop and eat here, you won't be disappointed! read more

There just aren't enough kind words to say about OCI. We've been going to my friend's cabin in Strawberry for years. We were so happy when OCI showed up. The food is AMAZING. The Arizona Greens salad is to die for and their ranch is homemade and addictive. I ALWAYS sit in Derek's section. He is so kind to my family and never annoyed by our children. He isba true gem. The reason I gave them 4 stars and not 5 is because they're just too small. This place needs to be 4 times as big to take care of all the people wanting to eat there and even then that might not be big enough! Open another location and make Derek the Manager. read more

A MA ZING!!! Try Taproom for an eclectic and well selected offering of wine, beer, and spirits. Gourmet food at a pizza joint?! YES! This place delivers Yum from the starters to the entrees. We were both surprised and delighted. Make this a must on your Pime agenda. read more

Seriously the BEST pizza ever. First time here and we were blown away even though we had to eat it from the trunk of our car. Ordered a pizza and the green Chile beer sauce. Highly recommend both!!! Can't wait to go back!!!! Side note, with covid-19 you have to call to order. It took 12 tries to get ahold of someone to order. I wish they had an online ordering system. read more

Day trip to Pine for Pizza! 100% recommend this joint. Delicious wood fired pizza. We had the meat pie. Pepperoni, sausage, & bacon. The sauce was extremely yummy. Whole basil leaves. We enjoyed ourselves out on the patio. After eating we played corn hole. I heard on the weekend nights they have a live band. Definitely going back!! read more

See all

I have been following their social media feeds for a while now and finally got to see first hand what all the fuss was about. We started with drinks and appetizers - Beer, green chili cheese dip is a must try. We had wings (huge full wing) and calamari as well. Pizza's - GREAT! There were six of us and we tried the meat pie - my husband said it was great, the Summer Squash pizza and the spinach, chicken artichoke pizza. Patio is dog friendly too! We will be back for sure - need to check out the taproom next time. THANKS! read more

Beer selection and ambiance are great. I would be so very grateful if vegan options were more plentiful and marked on the menu. I would love so see a vegan cheese available for the pizzas. read more

Hands down the best wood fired meat pie pizza we have ever had! The green chili beer cheese-well let's just say we have never tasted something so decadent and satisfying! And Lil Nash-potato is the cutest lil helper. Lindsay was our server and we became instant friends! This place was fantastic!! We can't wait to go back! Cheers! read more

Surprisingly tasty food in little Pine.Az. We just bought a home up here and the dining is pretty limited. This place stands shoulder to shoulder with the best specialty pizza places in the valley. Also tried the wings and salads, all top drawer. Don't forget a cocktail at the tiny taproom next door. Fun little bar with live music and creative drinks including oatmeal whiskey! Long lines some nights so plan 1.5 hours for dinner. read more

Absolutely Fantastic spot, go there. The pizza is excellent, the bar there is unique, great whisky selection and just a very cool spot.

Chris was great. Made us feel comfortable and welcomed. Best Old Fashion and conversation. Very welcoming of vacationers and diverse clientele. Will definitely come back. read more

Awesome place. The food is amazing and the people are really friendly. Definitely stop off at this place if you're passing through.

Amazing pizza. Generally very busy and can be a wait for a table. Very friendly owner and staff. Closed Mondays recently which was a bummer. Will return for sure! read more

We are Payson locals. We frequent this restaurant for the good customer service and awesome tap beers, the ambience and great food 2-3times per month and our tabs are over $100 a pop. We have decided that after tonight's disaster, we will not return. We anticipated a busy Saturday night crowd when we arrived at 5PM and were willing to wait. When we got to the front desk, the hostess, a young blonde with crazy red lipstick said there are no tables. I asked about the bar inside, she didn't even look, just said no. Then I asked how long was the wait? She said ummmm, I'd say 40 minutes. I said OK add us to the list. She then said well, I don't hold tables more than ten minutes - I said fine. I asked, how will you reach me if there is nowhere for us to sit? Then I said will you text me? She rolled her eyes at me, copped an attitude, and said well OK. Took down my cell number. There was a young couple with two small children behind us. As we were leaving the front area, I heard her ask them how many, they said four (same as our party) and she seated them immediately. It was cold outside and we decided to wait it out in our vehicle. After ten minutes, and watching several groups of people get seated ahead of us, we called the restaurant and placed a take out order. Brandon, a very nice person, took our order and said twenty five minutes. Yep, about the same time that the rude hostess said our table would be ready. 40 minutes later, we were pinged and immediately went to the hostess desk. She said Oh you are back. I said yes you pinged us, she said just take that table there. We waited for ten more minutes, no waitress, not even an acknowledgment that we were seated. Finally that same hostess came to our table and said what do you want to drink? NO hi how are you doing? No greeting whatsoever, just more bad attitude. We ordered cocktails then she said do you know what you want to eat? We said actually you might want to check with Brandon, we ordered our food ahead of time and it should be done right about now. She looked disgusted and said you did what? I said well we didn't want to wait 25 more minutes on top of the 40 so our food should be ready to just bring out. She stormed away from the table. She came back and said you are going to have to leave. I can bring you the take out food and you can eat on the picnic table outside of the restaurant but you can't eat your food here. I said it is YOUR restaurant food. She said ya but we can't have you eating from take out boxes. I said OK put it on plates or pans. She said nope we won't do that. It was windy and cold and she wanted us to eat our boxed food at an open picnic table! The correct customer service thing to do would be to unpack our food, put it on pans, serve it to us at the table with our cocktails but no, she decided to cop an attitude and said I'll get your food so you can GO (emphasis on the GO). Our bill was $95 - it could have potentially been much more with cocktails had she done the right thing. We routinely bring out of town guests to this restaurant but no more. That woman needs an attitude check and a lesson in customer service. No one deserves to be treated so poorly and with so much disrespect. I hope the restaurant sees this review and fires her. read more

on our day trip to pine we decided to come to this restaurant because it had good reviews. They were all wrong. The food was ok but the service was terrible. When we called to order food the lady who answered the phone was a total snot and she clearly had no care for our business. Do NOT come to this place if you want a good meal. If I could give them 0 stars I would. This place is garbage overall. Took 3 hours to get our 2 pizzas. read more

I understand that service is hard to come by these days, but this place is seriously THE WORST! The waitress & even the manager were super rude the entire time. Thankfully the host was a very kind man & the food was very good. Just be prepared to deal with an attitude! read more