Cancel

Open app

Search

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

3.6 (84 reviews)
Open • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

Order Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Takeout or Delivery

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Photos

Business Info

OLD CHICAGO PIZZA + TAPROOM ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Moderate noise
Outdoor seating
Good for kids

You might also consider

More like Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Recommended Reviews - Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

it looks and tastes just like digiorno pizza except $15 more expensive. but it was okay

Pep/Sausage/Mushroom
Todd K.

Decidedly average thin crust pizza. Buffalo chicken rolls were good. Not bad, but nothing spectacular. I'll try the deep dish next time.

Buffalo roll ups appetizer
Antanete F.

Buffalo Chicken Roll ups: OMG DELISH The cauliflower Tuscan Pizza also caught me by surprise. Our server Emily was phenomenal, she was very attentive, if we needed anything before we could ask she was already there ready to serve us. The pizza speaks for itself. We will be back soon for more as we can't get enough!

Gyro pizza special
Lisa R.

I really like A-OK for this place as a descriptor. For some reason when I lived in Nebraska I really did not like eating at this chain. I never went to the downtown location in Manhattan either. When it moved to "walkable from our house" and also open quite late serving food and drink, I became more open minded. The rotating beer selection is impressive and there are some great late night specials. The service is usually really good too. What bums me out about this place is that it discontinues the best things on the menu. In fact, I pretty much only ordered one thing every time: the Mediterranean farmer pizza. It was amazing a la goat cheese, sundried tomatoes, artichokes...and then after I got it for over a year, the company decided to discontinue the pizza AND the goat cheese, just stab me in the heart. The best monthly special pizza was a gyro pizza with banana peppers, tomatoes, tzatziki...it was gone in a poof. The replacement for my beloved farmer was a deep dish artichoke pizza. We tried it and got a lot of dough and sauce with hardly any toppings. Last time we went and I was desperate for anything non-poultry after Thanksgiving which meant burgers or the one salmon dish. It seemed obnoxious not to get pizza or wings here, but I did. Not having my favorite pizza makes me sad. However, the late night menu is really amazing. $3 draft beer, $3 apps. I over-ordered as a cheap date (with myself) when I came to watch Game 7 of the World Series starting in the bottom of the 8th inning after I went to a volleyball game. I got a beer, a mini ricotta jalapeno pizza (custom individual $3 pizza!?!?!? awesome), boneless buffalo wings, and parmesan fries. It was decadent but hot and tasty and I took some home for the next day's lunch. Overall, it is a neighborhood joint for us and the best place to watch a sporting event given the beer selection, specials, TV location, and late night hours. I will keep returning but hoping for great monthly pizza specials or I can just build my own and pay a lot for the toppings individually.

Pepperoni Deep Detroit Pizza

I've been here several times and this is a good pizza place, and I would recommend it to my friends and family visiting from out of town. The Classic with hand tossed ale crust was delicious. The crust itself has a good flavor which was a bit different than other crusts that I've had. The roasted garlic paired well with the meats on the pizza. The Double Deckeroni with tavern thin crust was also very good. I usually prefer thin crusts so I can taste more of the toppings. You get a flavor explosion of pepperoni and hot sauce with this one. I normally avoid deep dish pizzas because you are just eating extra bread basically, but decided one evening to give it a try since Chicago is well known for deep dish pizzas. I was a bit surprised that I liked this one! The edge of the crust had a little baked on crispy cheesiness - this is awesome! It's like having a cheesy, parmesan bread stick as a crust. The pizza sauce on top makes it taste like you are eating it with marinara sauce. The pepperoni and seasoning added some meatiness and balanced out the pizza. We also had pretzels and pizza rolls here too and they are good. I am usually the one to drive so can't say much about the beer but it seems like they have a good beer selection. The service is good and the restaurant is clean.

Sami R.

Old chicago has some gooooooood pizza. This thai pie is so good. It had mushrooms, chicken, broccoli, and tomatoes. IT WAS PERFECT! I went during their lunch time so it was 9.99 for this personal pizza and unlimited side salad!!! I never go to old Chicago since I'm a college student and the Old Chicago here in Manhattan is pretty far from campus but I occasionally make my way over there!

Hangover burger

See all

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Do they have Happy hour?

Yes. Drink and appetizer specials until 7pm on weekdays

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Powercat Sports Grill - Wagyu Strip steak

Powercat Sports Grill

3.5(82 reviews)
1.5 mi
•$$

Powercat has been a staple location in the area for years…read more We got into the restaurant right before close and they served us promptly and were very nice. The beer came in great big glasses and were chilled. Food was delicious! I highly recommend the wings.

Boy were we shocked this past weekend! Friends asked us out and wanted to go back to PC cuz they…read morewanted to see The Pride Band's Pub Crawl! Did we all get a shock! The chicken fried steak was 30% smaller, had to ask for mashed potatoes n gravy! There was almost more breading than meat and it was a slab of un-tenderized, tough as shoe leather, round steak! The Aspen wrap always used to be my favorite because the turkey portion was so generous but this one was ALL lettuce and I had to hunt for any turkey and cheese! Awful! And the sweet potato fries were limp as rag dolls, not a sign of crispy goodness!!! And no honey mustard for dipping! Only ranch dressing!!! Definitely a big disappointment! Probably equal to the hockey puck biscuits I reviewed a few years back! You fixed the biscuits! Now fix the chicken fried steak and Aspen wrap or I won't be back and I'll warn everyone to avoid PC Grill! Wait staff was very nice and doing their best but totally understaffed for a football Friday night! And what's with keeping the crowd waiting outside when we counted 5 Big empty tables? Management needs to get this fixed!!! This trip was definitely my worst experience ever at PC Grill!

Photos
Powercat Sports Grill
Powercat Sports Grill - Coach's Favorite Reuben

Coach's Favorite Reuben

Powercat Sports Grill

See all

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...