The food was great but the service gave me a bad experience. Due to our server "closing out soon" she had me pay my bill before I even got my food. Never have I ever experienced this type of service before. She brought my bill to my table and I didn't feel like paying until I had my food and she insisted continuously that I need to pay my bill for her to close me out and so she can go. It's not my problem to help a person leave yet alone if I'm paying for a service I have not yet received. In what world does it make sense to pay for food/service not yet received? read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - BEEF NACHOS GRANDE - Pizza Near Me - Manhattan, Kansas

A very disappointing carryout lunch yesterday. The chicken caprese sandwich was 2 small sandwiches on a hot dog bun. Much smaller than the full sandwich I order frequently at the Salina location (and the menu picture). No cutlery or napkins were provided. My 15% tip was a total waste. I guess they think carry out customers aren't important. Won't be coming back on my next visit. read more

My husband enjoys the Shrimp with Andouille sausage meal, very much. But I struggle to find something that I enjoy, it's been a problem since they removed Lasagna from the menu. Tried the Spaghetti with Meatballs it is very spicy and hot! Not my idea of Italian. I'm very disappointed in this restaurant these days. read more

Tried to reserve tables for 20. Young people at front we are old so they seemed young, college town, tried to reserve tables for 20 (wedding party) couldn't accommodate us as only could do 18. Can't do anything for 20, sorry! Many open and empty tables. Went to Powercat in Manhattan & they accommodated us with open arms!!!! Bill at Powercat was over $500 but not enough to accommodate Old Chicago! read more

Stop by today for pizza and wings with a group of guys and experienced a very nice dining experience. Great service and the food was very good as well all at the fair price. Would definitely come by again read more

Food and service is always solid! Love the late hours and the variety of drink options. We've probably been to this location 100+ times and never had a poor experience. Great job Mike Rice and team! read more

My daughter loves this place, she really likes the atomosphere. We have tried their wings, burgers. Everything tastes good. We will be back!

One of our 'go to' places over the years. The best bone-in buffalo wings in town. Good burgers, salads & more. Never had poor service which is unusual in today's world. You won't be disappointed! read more

it looks and tastes just like digiorno pizza except $15 more expensive. but it was okay read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Manhattan, Kansas

Decidedly average thin crust pizza. Buffalo chicken rolls were good. Not bad, but nothing spectacular. I'll try the deep dish next time. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pep/Sausage/Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Manhattan, Kansas

See all

This place is usually great, one of our families favorite places to eat. We had lunch there today and were a little disappointed. The service was great as usual but the pizza was not great. The hand tossed ale crust was thinner than usual and the pizza didn't have the brick oven cooked flavor we enjoy. It was good, but not Old Chicago good. We will not jump to any conclusions, and will certainly go back. We just hope our experience today was a one off. read more

Buffalo Chicken Roll ups: OMG DELISH The cauliflower Tuscan Pizza also caught me by surprise. Our server Emily was phenomenal, she was very attentive, if we needed anything before we could ask she was already there ready to serve us. The pizza speaks for itself. We will be back soon for more as we can't get enough! read more

See all

Love the food here. Have to drive clear across town to enjoy it, but the food and ambiance are worth it.

Loooooove the food here! Never have had to wait long for a table and service is always wonderful! Great drinks too:)

This is a go to spot in the local area. There isn't a lot of local businesses that have pizza restaurants, so this is definitely the best! The wings are amazing and the deep dish is a favorite. Con: This definitely has Chicago prices. read more

I've been coming here for decades, but this location for only a few years. The food is always great. This time we ordered 2 pizzas to go for the first time and we got tiny personal pizzas instead of the normal sized pizzas we are used to which sucks because we had 6 people at home. I specifically asked if these were the normal sized pizzas or if there was a sizing guide but they told me they're the standard pizzas and come in one size. Well, they were two bite slices and there was 4 slices per pizza. All for over $30 with a tip. This is just a bit ridiculous and I feel as though I was duped for sure. While I've always loved Old C's, I'm never coming back for to go orders ever. Stopping at little Caesar's now to make sure that my guests have food (for a quarter of the price btw). read more

I've been here several times and this is a good pizza place, and I would recommend it to my friends and family visiting from out of town. The Classic with hand tossed ale crust was delicious. The crust itself has a good flavor which was a bit different than other crusts that I've had. The roasted garlic paired well with the meats on the pizza. The Double Deckeroni with tavern thin crust was also very good. I usually prefer thin crusts so I can taste more of the toppings. You get a flavor explosion of pepperoni and hot sauce with this one. I normally avoid deep dish pizzas because you are just eating extra bread basically, but decided one evening to give it a try since Chicago is well known for deep dish pizzas. I was a bit surprised that I liked this one! The edge of the crust had a little baked on crispy cheesiness - this is awesome! It's like having a cheesy, parmesan bread stick as a crust. The pizza sauce on top makes it taste like you are eating it with marinara sauce. The pepperoni and seasoning added some meatiness and balanced out the pizza. We also had pretzels and pizza rolls here too and they are good. I am usually the one to drive so can't say much about the beer but it seems like they have a good beer selection. The service is good and the restaurant is clean. read more

See all

I really like A-OK for this place as a descriptor. For some reason when I lived in Nebraska I really did not like eating at this chain. I never went to the downtown location in Manhattan either. When it moved to "walkable from our house" and also open quite late serving food and drink, I became more open minded. The rotating beer selection is impressive and there are some great late night specials. The service is usually really good too. What bums me out about this place is that it discontinues the best things on the menu. In fact, I pretty much only ordered one thing every time: the Mediterranean farmer pizza. It was amazing a la goat cheese, sundried tomatoes, artichokes...and then after I got it for over a year, the company decided to discontinue the pizza AND the goat cheese, just stab me in the heart. The best monthly special pizza was a gyro pizza with banana peppers, tomatoes, tzatziki...it was gone in a poof. The replacement for my beloved farmer was a deep dish artichoke pizza. We tried it and got a lot of dough and sauce with hardly any toppings. Last time we went and I was desperate for anything non-poultry after Thanksgiving which meant burgers or the one salmon dish. It seemed obnoxious not to get pizza or wings here, but I did. Not having my favorite pizza makes me sad. However, the late night menu is really amazing. $3 draft beer, $3 apps. I over-ordered as a cheap date (with myself) when I came to watch Game 7 of the World Series starting in the bottom of the 8th inning after I went to a volleyball game. I got a beer, a mini ricotta jalapeno pizza (custom individual $3 pizza!?!?!? awesome), boneless buffalo wings, and parmesan fries. It was decadent but hot and tasty and I took some home for the next day's lunch. Overall, it is a neighborhood joint for us and the best place to watch a sporting event given the beer selection, specials, TV location, and late night hours. I will keep returning but hoping for great monthly pizza specials or I can just build my own and pay a lot for the toppings individually. read more

See all

We've been going there about once a month since it opened in Manhattan near 20 years ago, but, sadly, it's been a disappointment the last couple of times (cold food) and tonight was the worst. To put this in perspective, I rarely if ever complain about food and I've never ever sent anything back at a restaurant, but I did tonight, not once but twice. The Italian Nachos came out with the cheese unmelted and the toppings cold, and a cheeseburger ordered "well done" came out medium rare at best. To add to the fun, they've begun putting down waxed paper on the bottom of the Nachos pan and it was like they shook them up before heating....all the cheese and toppings sunk to the bottom and stuck to the wax paper. Disgusting. You'd think that, knowing a customer sent something back twice, a manager would come over and ask how to improve, but despite two older men in Old Chicago shirts hanging around, not one ever approached the table. We won't be back. read more

Old chicago has some gooooooood pizza. This thai pie is so good. It had mushrooms, chicken, broccoli, and tomatoes. IT WAS PERFECT! I went during their lunch time so it was 9.99 for this personal pizza and unlimited side salad!!! I never go to old Chicago since I'm a college student and the Old Chicago here in Manhattan is pretty far from campus but I occasionally make my way over there! read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Manhattan, Kansas

I've been visiting Old Chicago pizza and tap rooms all over this country. Started back in 2009, and this one rates right up there with one of the best I've been to. The service has always been great, the food has come out almost 100% how I've ordered it and the beer selection is always really good. If I've ever encountered a problem at this location, the staff and management have been very quick to fix things and even offer complementary items. Even through Covid times, the service and food have not suffered. If you're out on the west side of town and looking for a good pizza and good beer this is your place to go! read more

See all

I just love this place. It's close to home for me which is nice, but the folks that work there make it fun. I always sit at the bar and all of the bartenders know exactly what I'll be drinking and know I'll choose one of two food items.....with the customizations memorized! Only downside is that the menu could be expanded to offer more items food-wise. Still a great place! read more

Everything was good. Pizza was good. Calzone was mainly bread and lots of cheese. The only thing that was unsettling was that the correct change was not given as the server kept the coins. If they aren't going to give exact change then err in favor of the customer. For example the bill was $18.65 and received only a one dollar bill for change. Where is the 35 cents? Even the receipt states that the change should be $1.35. unacceptable practice. I was going to tip generously but I want to receive exact change. Difficult to believe Old Chicago would do this. Hopefully this isn't standard practice with all your servers. read more

Definitely enjoyed the environment. Service was good and the pizza was delicious! I recommend this to anyone looking for a great place to eat! Also had Bratwurst Mac: Sliced bratwurst, mushrooms, peppers and onions blended in a rich golden beer cheese sauce tossed in cavatappi. Topped with cheddar cheese, parsley and buttery toasted bread crumbs. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Sliced mushrooms, Italian sausage and roasted garlic. - Pizza Near Me - Manhattan, Kansas

See all

From the very start when we got there, I had a great time! Everyone there was so nice and our server was awesome!! Emily took care of us, recommended things, and I loved everything! Food was delicious! And my fave, the mushrooms! Food came out fast and Emily also made sure my kiddos got their food right away!! Food came out hot! Which is great! Because who wants cold food??? Will definitely be coming back! I also mainly wanted to review because I had a first great experience and even though it has a 3.5 stars I decided to give it a try myself and decided it deserves better reviews! read more

Our chicken parm was burnt to no end! BUT our drinks and everything else was very good and our waitress was amazing! Don't go here for chicken parm. Maybe a drink and appetizers. read more

Have waiting 15 minutes to be seated and restaurant was half full. The reasoning was because the kitchen staff was backed up. If you can't feed 25 people you might want to think about another business. I won't be back. read more

We love the Traditional Deep Crust pizza! Everything tasted fresh and was delivered to our table hot. Excellent service too. We will definitely be back again. read more

I don't usually do franchises, but I will certainly do Old Chicago! Packed on game day and still received good service and delicious food. Our party of seven shared two large pizzas and a large wing. Everyone was full by the end and had no complaints about the food. The original pizza crust was very tasty and perfectly cooked. The bone-in wings were standard but very good as well. The menu at Old Chicago is pretty extensive but I would like to give a lot of the items a shot. When I come back I will probably go for the Spaghetti Pie! read more

Loved this place for the beer for a few years. Recently, since the COVID, the menu and service has gone to shit. The food tastes frozen and the experience is all together unsatisfactory. If you want good beer and good food, might as well drive the extra 3 minutes to Pizza Hut or Kites (Kites will make your drinks WAY stronger for WAY less). My service this last time wasn't awful but the food left so much to be desired. read more

Great selection of menu items!! Great service and awesome waitresses!! Cold beer and warm Smiles!! My favorite food and sports bar in Manhattan!! read more

For the love of a God. This place is amazing. I can't even put in words how much I love this place. I'd work here for free in exchange for free food. Our server, Isaac was INCREDIBLE. he was quick, polite, PERFECT!!! Fuck I love this place so much I can't wait to come back. read more

The management at this establishment is more concerned with the back of hose operation than with the experience of the customer. We sat down to order a drink at the outside bar and were informed there were too many bugs and the door was shut. The manager on duty could not explain why and she had too much to "deal with in the kitchen" to hear about our issue. Overall the the staff was generally not concerned with the customer. Pretty disappointing. read more

I ordered a hamburger thinking it would be just ok. It was a great burger. I was not so excited about the coleslaw but the onion rings we ordered were great. Nice place and I want to go back and try the pizzas. They looked delicious. read more

Awesome place to hang out at. Awesome friendly staff. Great rotating beer selection. Food menu has a nice variety. I recommend any of the burgers or pub pizzas during late night. They have really reasonable happy hour specials and late night specials during the week. Not a lot of food selection on this side of town and this is one of my favorites for sure. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Thai Pie - Pizza Near Me - Manhattan, Kansas

The staff is AMAZING. Ronnie, Austin, and Annalise were very helpful and informative when greeting us. There was a wait but we didn't mind. Our server Annie treated us with the most respect and got us our food very fast for a busy (after game) night. The rest of the staff was very friendly and patient with the stressful evening. Even though there was one very upset customer who didn't like that Old Chicago Management didn't want bugs inside (they shut the outside bar). Management did their very best even though he was still very upset. He said many rude things and verbally abused a manager in front of front of house. She kept herself together and handled it perfectly. read more

The most expensive medium pizza in town. The flavor is not that great and super greasy. I'm better off going to AJ's for a medium cheese. It's cheaper there and it tastes better. One time we went to Old Chicago when they opened their newer location off Kimball and the tables smelled like they were wiped with rotten egg water. Rinse the rags with soapy water! I won't be coming back. read more

The food is great but the service was not so much. I made a special request for my Stromboli which was not followed the first time around. Then they promised they would remake it and put it at the front of the line but I waited far longer then the original incorrect order took to make. I will be back because hopefully this was a fluke and the food tastes awesome. I've had the wood fired jalapeño pretzels, the fried pickles, and the Stromboli and all were great. The difference maker is they didn't even give me a discount on my bill for having to watch my friends eat their entire meals in front of me. I understand that things happen but good customer service should trump those mistakes. read more

Old Chicago is one of my absolutely favorite places. I am currently on my 8th World Beer Tour and keep going back. I have been to several locations including the original in CO. The Old Chicago in Manhattan was spectacular. It was around 5:30p on a Wed night and it wasn't too busy. The bar area was full, and I sat at a table by myself. The service was great, I was there doing the Winter mini tour and the waitress answered all my questions about the beer selection. I placed my food order and it was out quickly. The manager stopped by to check on the quality, which I greatly appreciate. They truly have a good team there as I noticed other servers were bringing me my beer orders to help out. By the time I left the place was full with a line out the door. I will be back to this location. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Manhattan, Kansas

See all

I have been waiting for far too long on a call ahead. When I call ahead to a restaurant I expect to be sat in a reasonable amount of time. I have been waiting almost an hour on a call ahead order. Waiting an hour is simply unacceptable! read more