Some tasty items, but not as good as it thinks it is, and the kitchen is difficult. Possibly successful in Austin in a way that it couldn't be in a bigger city with more serious competition.
I went to Olamie with two friends in mid-July. Some items were very good - the tomato salad for example. Others were not as described - a fish dish was described by the waitress as a large piece of fish, but that fish did not dominate the dish, while the dish itself was essentially a many tiny pieces of fish that my friend did not finish. The menu itself was a bit pretentious - for example, Olamie uses the most obscure word possible. Even sesame doesn't escape the "upscaling" treatment. In the menu, it is listed as benne, which is an 18th century Americanism for the exact same thing as the word sesame that all English-speakers know today.
The most frustrating part was the kitchen, however. I'm aggravatingly allergic to several foods. I therefore asked if one dish, the hopping john, could be served without egg. This did not require any special work - the egg is poached and put on top of the dish, so all the kitchen had to do was not add the egg. In fact, my request was less work for them and less costs than the original version.
The waitress at first refused, saying that kitchen would not make any changes. Since that meant that there were no dishes that I could order and we would have to leave without eating, she agreed to check with great reluctance. The hopping john came without an egg, but with rice cakes not described in the menu, and which were a substantial part of the dish.
We again had trouble when dessert time came. The desserts all had dairy or something else I couldn't eat, which is not the fault of the restaurant. What is the fault of the restaurant is that there was one thing that i could eat, peach pie, just not with the cream scoop that came with it. I asked for the pie without the ice cream put on top. The waitress again refused. My friend and I wanted to split a piece, but she did want ice cream, so we asked if we could get pie an dice cream, just with the ice cream in a bowl so that my friend could add the ice cream after I cut my half. The waitress said that she would check.
We found out that the answer to "can I at least have the ice cream in a separate bowl?" was no when another waitress came to the table with pie, and ice cream already melting on top of it, to my friend and put it down in front of her. That waitress must have been new, because when I asked her if I could have pie too, just not with ice cream, she said yes. She never came back though.
Instead, the manager did, to see "how things are going." I told him about my wish to order pie, without ice cream, and he said that the chefs won't make changes to their menu, but that Olamie does care about allergies and "takes allergies very seriously." I do admit I got a little sarcastic at this point and said "all I'm asking is that someone not make a motion like this (miming putting ice cream on a pie) so that I can have dessert without also having an asthma attack." He must have seen my point, because he walked off and came back minutes later with my ice cream-free pie.
Which wasn't good. After such a fight I expected something delicious, but it was a few peach shreds and mostly sugar gel and food coloring. Frozen pies from the grocery store have more fruit and more flavor. My friend who had pie with ice cream also said that it wasn't that great, as did a friend who ordered an ice cream assortment.
Out of the three of us, the only dish that we could all agree was unequivocally tasty was the tomato salad. Everything else was good enough or disappointing. The attitude of the kitchen left a bad taste in my mouth. They act like their dishes are special creations that could be tarnished by the slightest alteration of their perfection, when really the alternations don't change much and the dishes aren't that special. Even Noma is more pleasant to deal with, and their food is something special. read more