This is a great little diner! Being a local this is a pretty low key place to eat on a week night, well on a Thursday night as they are not open mon-wed. Weekends are unbelievably busy with out of Towners, but food is always on point and served in a timely manner. The staff are friendly and attentive! I would recommend this eatery even during the busy hours! read more

Got french toast and coffee for breakfast. Absolutely delicious and very friendly staff! read more

Oakhurst Diner - French toast - Diners Near Me - Millerton, New York

See all

Enjoyed the pancakes and veggie omelet for breakfast. Coffee really good. Excellent and friendly service. Happy we came to this classic diner in a cute old town feeling main street. read more

You know the homesteaders from Williamsburg have hit town when the classic American diner with the shiny metal deco exterior has craft beer, kombucha, and pho. We just had a quick nosh so can't comment expansively on the full menu but the joint seems to be a conjunction of nouveau-style cuisine on the diner theme with the classic ambiance. That the diner is elevated a little and you can cast your gaze out on the beauty of downtown Millerton. We'll be back to try a full meal. read more

This place does have waiter/waitress service indoors and out. The food is excellent and it is right by the Harlem Valley rail trail.

Nice looking place, food is nothing special. Patty melt using locally sourced beef was flavorless. Good thing they provide chili sauce at the table. Went back again on 7/28/19. Still can't make a burger worth eating. read more

Guys...You have a great idea. People are lining up at the door. But if you don't start to execute on the idea I don't think the lines will be there much longer. The three of us had: a Pho soup; a Bahn Mi sandwich; and a pancake eggs and sausage. The soup lacked flavor, The Bahn Mi was three bites and the pancakes were just average. The menu is really smart and unique. If the food was great I would even be willing to pay the NYC prices. Time to concentrate on the food! Two and a half stars - I rounded up. read more

I've been here for two meals now. The food is, well, exceptionally disappointing. I can't find a single positive thing about it. If it was half the price I could be persuaded to give it 3 stars, but for the price there's just no excuse. Unless you like to be served frozen hamburger patties. And fries that come from a bag. I just don't see why you'd serve food that isn't good. Like, it's not that hard. People make things good to eat all the time. Waitstaff is very friendly, hence the two stars. But I suppose if they were really that friendly they wouldn't serve the food the kitchen is putting out... read more

Took the family to dinner here before a movie. Got there at 5:45 and right behind us came families and older folks in a big crowd. The staff was cheerful and on top of things...this is an improvement from past service. My husband had said on the way over that he felt that in the past the staff "didn't care"...but this staff clearly did. We placed our orders and food came in a reasonable amount of time. Burgers for the husband and children and shakes, which everyone enjoyed. I had the curried chicken, which I love. Side salad was fresh and well dressed. $60 with tip for my family for really good food and service and a really happy family. Thank you!! read more

Hands down one of the best diners I've been to, staff was incredibly friendly, food was amazingly good & served very quickly. Only downside was their beverage selection was a little lacking for kids, definitely catered to a more adult audience. The Bahn Mi Roast Pork sandwich was amazing, the pickled carrots really added the right touch, the Cobb Salad was perfection and the kids cheeseburger was done perfectly. You should definitely check this spot out if you're in the area. read more

Yelp said diner was open. We rode an hour on Tuesday to get here. So upsetting... Love this place but must be accountable to sites like google and yelp! read more

Oakhurst Diner - Yelp said open! - Diners Near Me - Millerton, New York

If I lived near this diner, I'd be a frequent diner. We stopped here, along the drive to NYC. Parking available to customers. The diner is small, but tables aren't squished together. There are tables, booths and seats at the counter. Diner features 1 women's restroom and 1 men's restroom. I ordered the Oakhurst Hamburger with French fries. I can see the coarse salt sprinkled on top of those fries. The right amount of saltiness, crunchy exterior & moist interior in each french fry. The hamburger features Oakhurst Dressing or did they call it 'sauce'. No matter cuz it was delicious. The meat is provided by a local purveyor. Now THAT'S what I call 'good beef'. I had no complaints! read more

Stopped in the other day for a bite. Ended up getting the "Kev's Meatloaf Sandwich". Normally, I don't eat meatloaf when dining out, but previous experiences here made me feel safe. That feeling was well justified. The sandwich was served on garlic bread, with melted cheese and horseradish mayo. It was fantastically seasoned. On the side, I got Kimchi. Again. I can't get away from it. It doesn't hurt that it is a lower calorie food and that eating it makes me feel less guilty regarding my other meal choices. It turns out that Kimchi goes well with everything. One unusual thing I noticed on this visit was the coffee. Normally, I drown myself in the plain iced tea, which is Harney and Sons, and delicious. No sugar needed. But this time, I smelled them making coffee, and it was irresistible. I ordered one, and it was absolutely rich and flavorful. I confess that I am not a fancy coffee drinker. For years, my thirst was well-sated with Maxwell House. This wasn't for lack of trying other coffees. This was an amazing cup of coffee, super fresh and delicious. I ordered another cup to go. Why can't this place be located in my home town? read more

Food was not as ordered. Asked for over medium eggs and received over hard eggs. Was told could get over medium no problem. Waited over 20 minutes for the new eggs. Told them I did not want the eggs now as I was finished with breakfast had to split wife's meal with her. Ask them to take off bill said they would but did not. read more

This is the place to be. Breakfast served until 5pm? check. Beer - including a ginger ale shandy? check. Apple pie to close it all out? check. Bonus points from my kids who strongly endorsed the pancakes... read more

Oakhurst Diner - Diners Near Me - Millerton, New York

Good breakfast foods and some good burgers! If you are looking for traditional American cuisine this is a good place to go! Good service and also very close to the rail trail and all the shops in millerton a good place to stop for lunch of a good breakfast if you are local. read more

One of the best burgers ever. Incredibly fast service. Highly recommend the veggie omelet and soft serve ice cream too!

I stopped by here on my way back to NYC from a camping trip, Millerton is a little cute town, w mixed hipsters, locals and bypassers like us! The diner is very clean, chic and sunny! I have to say everyone on our table love our food, my grilled chicken sandwich was superb, chicken was grilled to perfection, tender, juicy and delicious! I don't know what kind of dressing/sauce, but it makes it one of my fav chicken sandwich place! The sweet potato fries are crispy and yum! I definitely prefer it over reg fries my friends ordered. they're very satisfied w their oakhurst burger! I love the fact they're doing their best to use local produces and it's indicated on the menu, service was quick and friendly, kitchen moves pretty quickly so does tables! There was brunch special and good varieties food selection on the menu. It feels more like a small local restaurant than a diner to me! And I will definitely stop by next time when I'm around. read more

I have a certain soft spot for diners. American nouveau in a converted diner, and you've struck a path to my foodie heart. Oakhurst offers breakfast from Benedict to buckwheat pancake. Dinners range from roast pork bahn mi to steak frits. Really, this is a wonderful of new american dining and at reasonable prices. The house made sweet potato fries are outstanding. Try the edemame dumplings to start, fried and served with a classic but indispensable Chile sauce, its a great light starter. My bahn mi was exceptional, if unusual; house mayo, pickled veggies and cilantro, fiery fresh jalapeños, and sweet thin sliced pork between sourdough baguette halves. It wasn't the bahn mi of Vietnam but distinctly the new american fusion of flavors I crave. Service was good, quick and attentive but not obtrusive. I'll be back for the homemade Whoopi pies and pie raining from behind the counter. read more

See all

Love it! It was the first place we ate at when we moved to a nearby town and now it's one of our go-to places when we're in Millerton. Good food, great service. VERY handy to the Rail Trail. Love it. read more

Let me be clear--this place is a gem. If you are in the area, this is not your typical diner. The meat is organic/from local farms. The food is good quality. There is outdoor seating and covid awareness. They also have a good selection of craft beers on tap. What more could you ask for.... read more

8 of us were on a motorcycle ride today and stopped here for a late breakfast. It was our first visit to Millerton and we'll definitely be back. Three of us had the Big Daddy breakfast and everyone else had an assortment of sandwiches and salads. The food was great and the staff were very friendly and accommodating. Millerton is nice little town and good place to spend a day walking around. read more

I've just been conned. Paid $9.60 for two "lattes" in an espresso to go cup which is max 3 inches tall. And we even gave $1 tip. Never been so insulted in all my life. I was so shocked I couldn't say anything. I just walked out the door with my doll house size coffee. Disgraceful. read more

The oakhurst diner has very good pancakes and ice cream qoute by my 10 year old grandson it was great

LOVE THIS PLACE!!!! Love vintage diners, still has original chrome inside! Food is great and they use real products- my french toast had real butter, real syrup, fresh eggs and bacon on the side. Not overly greasy like other diners but still super tasty. Will be back again soon!!!!! read more

Oakhurst Diner - Diners Near Me - Millerton, New York

See all

Adorable spot - a refurbished train car - right on the Harlem Valley Rail Trail! The staff is super friendly, and they'll happily hurry your order if you're rushing to hit the movie theater down the block! Macrobiotic plates, perfect eggs Benedict and even locally raised hamburgers, steak frite - they have it all! A local business that supports local businesses.. and it's delicious! read more

Ma Pho soup is the best, fills you up on a cold winter day.

We found this diner on our way to a car show. The atmosphere is retro & their outside patio is quaint. The menu has an eclectic selection of items. I ordered the Little Buddy w/Kale: Kale mixed with bacon, sausage, bell peppers, topped with melted American cheese and two sunny-side up eggs The presentation was wonderful, the quality of ingredients were fresh, and the flavors pop in your mouth. The service was also great, they were attentive and friendly. read more

Good food and prices Great location near bike path Service a bit slow Not too keen on their touchless check-where waiter asks you how much would you like to leave: 15-20-25%. read more

Stopped here instead of driving another ten miles to Dad's Diner in Copake thinking it was a typical diner fare and was quite surprised as the the Asian fare. The potato leek soup was warm and had a gritty texture hence the three stars, I didn't see a single leek, the pork spring rolls were flavorful as the vegetable spring rolls. read more

See all

This destination does not follow CDC guideline as the identified tables were closer than six feet apart. We waited over ten minutes at our table without anyone having the courtesy to greet us and let us know why they were delayed. I'm sure the food is great but the service leaves much to be desired. read more

Consistently great food and prices to match. I have visited the Oakhurst Diner on many occasions and always leave completely satisfied with the quality of the food and level of service by the waitstaff. Mario's chili is definitely worth a try for lunch/dinner! read more

I entered and paused at the register to see if the girl there would say anything about where to sit. She was too busy sending a text message to even notice that I was there. I had been warned not to try and sit at a booth unless you were the size of Twiggy so I proceeded to sit at the counter. Well the stools were like sitting on a rock! I have been going to diners of all types for 60 years and this one was one of the worst as to appearance. It just looks shabby. There were not very busy and there were two workers near the other end of the diner not really doing much of anything. No one came to wait on me and there were no menus available. After sitting for awhile and being ignored I left. The girl at the register was no longer texting but just had a sort of blank look on her face as I told her I was leaving since no one waited on me. I have no idea about the food since I never got see a menu. None of the people working there seem to have any idea about customer service and the whole place looks like a Depression era throw-back. The McDonald's in town is a much better choice. read more

Service was S L O W. Food fair but very small portions and waaaaaaay overpriced. Was unable to get a server to get that second cup of coffee so... Will not try this tourist trap again! read more

The staff was very good. But everything else was sub par-- from the coffee, to the food, to the comfort of the booth and table. Just whatever. Disappointing. We won't be returning. read more

I ended up in this restaurant because it was on the way to Stockbridge, MA. I didn't even know this place was still NY...lol The breakfast was really good and tasty. I had the eggs Benedict. The orange juice is really good and they sell a really nice sauce, don't remember the name, the bottle cost $13.00. The breakfast order comes with just One piece of bread, which I had a hard time with because I use 2 pieces of bread to eat my eggs. My mom gave me her piece of bread to complete my sandwich.The waitress was nice. If you need to use the bathroom, the door on the left is for females, I had a hard time figuring out the sign... read more

First time we tried it again in a while. Wasn't impressed last time, 2 years ago. Food was okay. Coffee ughhh. Super obnoxious bitter and burnt. Cream was broken. Wife n I put cream in and it was curdled. Explained to waitress and she says well it's from Ronnybrook farm and it comes that way. No thank you. We had her take it away and they charged us for it any way. You know you're in trouble when you put s pint of cream in and it doesn't lighten the color. I find that not so customer friendly. The sun was obnoxious coming in the full length Windows and no shades. SMH Waitresses were all business no smiles. Bye bye Won't be back. read more

Places like this usually get by on 1950's charm. Not this place. The food is amazing. We had the pork sandwich, eggs and pancakes. So good. I also had some kimchee with the pork sandwich. Mmmm mmmm. Also, the waiter was fast, helpful and friendly. This place is fun and good eating. read more

Update, Tried a few different meals. None were close to memorable. The food there seems to have a commonality of using inexpensive, simply prepared items that are not prepared by professional cooks and definitely not made with love. read more

This place has such a great menu, not the same old diner fare which is a nice alternative to chain restaurants. The menu prices for food is a tad high which is fine as long as quality food, a clean place and attentive service....but one out of three was the case for my experience here. My fiance's eggs Benedict were undercooked and the holindaise sauce runny. My grilled veggie sandwich was outstanding, but my fries were ice cold and were bits of fries with most being a half inch or less in size. (I know that sounds picky but seriously, fries found at the bottom of the bag are usually like this, toss them or mix them in with the full size fries in order to give some value to your customer) The waitress never came back to ask how our meal was. Our waitress was not on the floor and the other waitresses were not available as I could see one busy texting and the other was busy tending to her tables. She didn't ask how everything was when she cleared our plates either, even though none of my fries were touched (that should be a clue to any waitress). I give total credit to this place for their beverage selection as they had a great selection of beer and wine as well as some exotic sodas. Of course, he and I both ordered a diet coke as we always do. But, I was totally floored to see that we were charged $2.99 for each can of soda. I know things are expensive and it would cost that much or more in the City but seriously, that is gouging in every sense of the word. So, poor service, cold food and overcharging on the highest profit item they serve rates this place poorly for me and I would not recommend it. Kudos to the owners for putting together such a quaint place but honestly, if your going to do something.....do it right and get some management on the floor, add some quality control and be a good restaraunt instead of someplace that survives and relies only on location and kitch. read more