Service was excellent. Friendly staff. Our food was terrific. I had gluten- free pasta primavera - generous portion and so delicious! My husband couldn't stop bragging about his bone-in pork chop dinner. It was a very nice birthday experience on the patio read more

Checked Nyla's out after meeting their manager Brent on a whim. Took a colleague there to check it out and was more than impressed. It's tucked away in an area that looks to be being revitalized. It's a beautifully charming red farmhouse with an amazing, yet not intimidating ambiance. We sat outside which was perfect for the weather and the view of the, unbeknownst to us, thriving little district. Sam was our server and she was amazing!! Between myself and my colleague, we tried 5 of the listed cocktails, although you can order off the menu as they have a full bar. Don't let the descriptions fool you because as complex as they were, the flavors married so well together. We tried three appetizers, fried green tomatoes, deviled eggs, and filet tips fondue. All were AMAZING!! It's been two days and I'm still thinking about how good they were. We shared the lamb chops and cauliflower risotto. All so tasty and prepared perfectly. I will definitely be back to try more of their offerings. Highly recommend!! read more

See all

Great restaurant in the heart of Westfield. They have valet parking which I recommend because it can be tough to find a spot in busy nights. They serve steaks, seafood and items that remind you of home. Deviled eggs, meatloaf and fried green tomatoes. We had the fried green tomato app and they were great. Better than grandmas. I had the duck and it was fantastic. Nice wine and drink list. I would love to come back again. read more

Everything was absolutely perfect and the Mushroom Soup was fabulous. The Sea Bass was fabulous. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Mushroom Soup! - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

My wife and I just moved to Westfield several weeks ago. It was our 27th anniversary so we wanted to explore Westfield so we picked Nyla's for our dinner. So glad we did! We used Open Table to secure reservations, recommended. The food and flavors were just outstanding. The ambience was cute, cozy, friendly and just what we wanted. Everyone was friendly and there were smiles all around. 100% great experience and we will be back many times. I don't eat meat so I got the vegetable pasta- out of this world! My wife got the fillet and was so happy. Great job Nyla's! read more

My brother n I took our wives to Nylas next door to the gem Italian House. It was hard to pass up The Italian House but we found another gem!! Cool atmosphere, excellent service and very good food. We tried the cornbread and delish w the honey butter. Mushroom soup was superb with a rich creamy sauce n nice pieces of mushroom. The wedge was very good w blue cheese crumbles on the vinaigrette. Two of us had Chicken Milanese n a go to item that was yummy. The sea bass w the miso sauce was superb. Finally the last dish was the pork chop with a jam sauce that was cooked perfectly! Zach did a stellar job attending to us and gave us all the time we needed. Love the $10 valet since parking is so limited. Absolutely will return! read more

See all

I thought the place look familiar after seeing the red barn. We've been in it a few times when it was still Rails. They did a good job re-doing the inside giving it the upscale look and feel, though not sure if having 2 full bars,1 downstairs and 1 upstairs is necessary. Food wise, my ribeye steak was great and wife enjoyed her veggie wellington. There are quite a few restaurants together with residentials units in the area so street parking can be tricky. We went on a busy night and ended up parking close to hwy 32. I can see us coming back, especially for special occassions. read more

See all

What a special place! Nyla's offers a uniquely intimate experience, incredible service, and an outstanding combination of flavors. It sits in a cute little culinary pocket in Westfield, with free parking a short walks distance from the restaurant, valet is also available. I definitely recommend a reservation because it seems to be a favorite of anyone who's ever been, and there are a few bars within the restaurant to visit at while waiting to be seated. We had the pleasure of being attended to by the charismatic bartender and server, and each team member we worked with, as well as returning guests around us, had nothing but positive feedback and suggestions about the menu. Dinner did not disappoint- big bold flavors, great quality ingredients, and overall an amazing experience. This will certainly be somewhere that comes in mind for dinner. read more

We had a great meal at Nylas's in Westfield. Our server Luke was friendly and on point all night. We started with the crab stuffed mushrooms that were very tasty. I had the lamb chops and my wife had the Miso Soy Ginger sea bass, all great dishes and nice portion size. We ended with the apple crisp, very filling and well done. Great place and nice to have valet parking for the busy area. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Lamb chops - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

Last night we had the pleasure of dinning at Nyla's Restaurant in Westfield. This eatery has it all from terrific food to great service. We were seated by the bar in a very comfortable location in this cute revamped Restaurant . Our waiter James was not only was very helpful with our Menu selections, but tutored us on the evolution of this new establishment. Started off with the unique Margarita Lavender, delicious. All entries come with your choice of a wedge salad or mushroom soup. I chose the fried chicken which put The Colonel's to shame. Also ordered the Sweet Potato Casserole which was a true taste sensation. Pam really enjoyed the Chicken Milanese. Both of us a looking forward to a return trip to this new gem in Westfield. Bob read more

Such a cute place! My second visit. Food is absolutely delicious! I had the chicken cordon blue this time and stuffed shrimp before- both the best ever! And the goat cheese appetizer also outstanding. And they were busy on a Tuesday evening which is a good sign. read more

I'm looking forward to seeing this gem improve. They haven't been open long so I will be back. However, things you should know... Pros: Our server George was the perfect waiter, checked on us often but never rushed us. The candied bacon deviled eggs were outstanding. So was Nyla's blue cheese dressing on the wedge. Same recipe as all her other restaurants. The old building had a lot of charm. Cons: The chicken Milanese tasted off to me. It was fairly oily and had a flavor reminiscent of overused fryer oil. Absolutely horrible parking situation. Yes, they offer valet but that was also very busy and you have to pay and tip on top of an expensive meal. The garlic horseradish mashed potatoes were flavorless and I couldn't taste any horseradish. The building, while old and neat, is very tiny and crowded. Tables upstairs were just packed in there, in addition to a bar with 5-6 people seated for dinner. read more

Checked out Nyla's Restaurant, and it did not disappoint!!! From the service to the food and drinks, everything was remarkable! As our appetizer we got the Crab Stuffed Mushrooms. Entrees came with a soup or salad. I got the Mushroom Cream Soup. For my entree I did the Shrimp & Zucchini Pasta. My hubs did The Coop's Fried Chicken. For my drinks, I enjoyed a Lavender Margarita and an Espresso Martini. Definitely check it out if you're in the area. Bon appétit! It's pretty cozy in there when it comes to seating so I highly recommend making a reservation! read more

See all

We went to Nyla's this evening to celebrate a birthday. I'd made an early reservation for 4:30 to ensure seating. We'd been once before for cocktails and loved the ambiance so were excited to return for dinner. Once we checked in, the host said we'd be eating in the other building. We followed her back outside and into the small building (I remembered it previously as an ice cream shop). Inside was quite small with minimal design, 4-5 tables and there was a large counter which seemed to be for pick-up orders. Our wobbly table was across from the kitchen door, so we could hear all the clattering & noise. It might have felt especially awkward because we were the only customers in there at the time but I just couldn't shake that the vibes were off-- it wasn't the birthday dinner or experience I'd expected. I asked the server if we'd be able to sit in the main building. She was very understanding and instructed us to go back to the host stand with our request. Once we were reseated upstairs in the barn, we enjoyed the delicious food & complimentary birthday dessert while surrounded by the rustic, cozy ambiance I'd imagined. read more

Went to have a joint birthday celebration for friends. We had the crab stuffed shrimp. You get a choice of soup or salad. Both were ordered & delicious! The salad dressing was very unique. Our server was polite & gracious. Love the look, parking is kind of a pain. read more

We had a fantastic anniversary dinner here. We got the Crab Stuffed Mushrooms as an appetizer and then I got a ribeye and wife a filet with mashed potatoes and mushrooms as our sides. Also we both got the cream of mushroom soup for a side and good lord it was fantastic. I got the oatmeal raisin manhattan to drink and my wife got a mocktail that our server just whipped up because they didn't have any on the menu! Also make sure and ask about what bourbons they have because the menu is out of date but they have a very solid bourbon selection. We could not have asked for a better anniversary dinner location. It was relatively secluded and the lighting made it feel intimate. And both servers were had we very very good. We will be back here for sure read more

See all

Went to Nylas for a late valentines celebration with my hubby. Great atmosphere, service, and food. We started with the crab stuffed mushrooms and i enjoyed a lychee martini. All incredible. We then enjoyed the lamb chops which were cooked to perfection and chicken milanese. 10/10 would have again. But, to be honest, we both were talking about what we would try next time! At our servers suggestion we also ordered the cornbread as a side for dinner. It is to die for! Do not skip! We were also wonderfully surprised that our server remembered us from when we sat at his table next door! (Once) it made us feel so welcome. We will certainly be returning! read more

See all

First visit, won't be the last! We enjoyed the fried chicken, beef stroganoff and chicken cordon bleu as mains and the Candied Bacon Deviled Eggsas a starter. All of the food was very good with nice portions. Service was friendly and attentive. Closed on Sundays and Mondays. read more

Only a mile from our house & we're wondering WHY we have not been here sooner! I'm a BIG Girl & I was afraid of the tight seating... BUT it was very comfortable seating! Bret was our server he was GREAT! All the staff were attentive, polite & impressive. The staff always looking & watching, not afraid of eye contact. Now the dining experience: The rum old fashion drink = A+ The mushroom soup = A+ The fondu appetizer = A+ The Sea bass entree = A+ The apple crisp = A+ Do you see a pattern? Thank you so very much for a Fantastic Dining Experience! read more

See all

Service was great, food not so much. Most of these yelp photos of food is not what is available today. read more

Great, local spot tucked away in Westfield! The goat cheese balls are one of the best appetizers I have ever had! The ambience was sweet and the wait staff was fantastic. The food options were great comfort food items. Would come back! read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Goat cheese balls - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

My wife and I both loved the experience and the food. Smores Creme brulee was spectacular, as it's chocolate with toasted marshmallows on top and graham cracker powder. It tasted like Smores. Entrees were also great with chicken being tender and tasty. read more

My husband and I celebrated our anniversary on Thursday at Nyla's. We went based on all the good reviews and were so glad we did. The food was delicious and the service was great. We shared the deviled eggs, I had the crab stuffed shrimp and my husband the ribeye. We ended our dinner by splitting the crème brûlée. We loved everything about the restaurant. Our drinks were tasty as well. We will be back! read more

The short answer on this review is if you want a cozy environment to enjoy a great meal with exceptional service try Nyla's, a new restaurant along a block of quaint places in a neighborhood in Westfield. We made a reservation for three via their website for a weeknight dinner. We started with a few drinks, which leaned on the sweet side but were fun and creative. For apps we tried the fried oysters and some cornbread. Our entrees were all the highlight of the meal and would be the reason to want to return in the near future. On a 1-10 scale here is our review of our experience. Environment/atmosphere - 10 Parking - 3 (street parking congested) Drinks - 8 (creative but sweet) Cornbread - 5 (bland, want to revisit) Mushroom Soup - 9 (love it) Fried Oysters - 7 (fresh but heavy breading) Ribeye - 10 (wow, special) Pork Chop - 10 (big, juicy,fresh) Chicken M - 10 (melt in your mouth) Sweet Potato casserole - 8 (yum) Chocolate Cake - 3 (cold, seems like store bought, pass) Service - 10+ (personal, attentive, knowledgeable) This place is unique in the mix of nearby offerings and as they evolve the menu it could stand out as one of the best spots on the entire north side. read more

See all

Another great concept in Westfield! Our server Sam was wonderful. The atmosphere was intimate and beautiful! It felt like we were dining with family. I had the sea bass and my husband had the chicken Milanese. 10/10 all around. The fish looked so good I forgot to take photos! Looking forward to getting back! read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Deviled eggs - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

We decided to check out Nyla's for a birthday celebration. I would highly recommend making a reservation! I was shocked at how small the inside was but it is very beautiful and not loud at all. Now the food, AMAZING! Everything we ate was perfect! Everything was made to perfection and brought to the table in a decent time. We will definitely be coming back The only con is the parking. We had to park streets away and it was a cold night with snow. They had valet but was a bit on the pricey side. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Miso Soy Ginger Seabass - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

All the food was delicious and we loved the atmosphere. Parking in this area is usually a pain, but the weather was nice so the walk wasn't too bad. We will definitely be back to try other items on the menu! read more

See all

Everything was incredible and Claudia was amazin!!! Thank you for a great experience since I'm not from this area as you made me feel like I was at home. read more

See all

Amazing restaurant for a date night or just a home cooked meal vibe! I love how quaint the restaurant is in the service was phenomenal. Such a great spot. Also, the food was absolutely delicious. Make sure to get the cornbread. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Lamb - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

This is my favorite restaurant, not just in Westfield or the Indy area, but anywhere. My wife and I have been 3 times, two for special occasions, and they absolutely crush it. Shoutout to Taylor. She is the perfect waitress for any occasion. The deviled eggs and goat cheese app are so incredibly good that we are yet to order anything different for starters. I am not a huge mushroom soup guy and I get theirs every time. The entrees have all been great but the pork belly is out of this world. The drinks are always well made. The bacon fat old fashioned is the smoothest old fashioned I have ever tasted. With seating inside and outside there is something for everyone. It's cozy without feeling cramped. I have recommended Nyla's to several friends who often eat at the nicest restaurants around Indy and they agree that they'd rather go to Nyla's than any of the steakhouses around. The owner is often there and comes around to make sure everything is great. Go to Nyla's. You won't be disappointed. read more

Superb sea bass with a very light miso ginger glaze, perfectly cooked. The Fried chicken is cooked in a pressure cooker so the meat is cooked and the skin is crisp. Only one soup available but a superb mushroom soup. Service is excellent and the ambience is very cozy. Highly recommend this eatery. We will definitely be back to try other things on the menu. Reservation through open table and parking available through valet or you can try your luck finding street parking. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Sea Bass - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

Nyla's provides a fine experience from beginning to end. The atmosphere is quiet. Even with a full house, you can still hear the playlist. The service was extremely attentive without being annoying. The food portions were plentiful and it was all delicious. The cocktails were fantastic as well. I would return again for a special occasion read more

Great service and food. Ambiance was great outdoors - it's a nice little restaurant! We had the beef , chicken and soup for appetizers and main course. The beef tips were OK, chicken was great and the soup was awesome read more

What a fun place! It was my second time here. Food is great and good portion size. Service always a delight. And since it has wood floors and ceilings, it isn't as loud as some of my other favorite places. Parking is a nightmare and the first floor seating is noisier than upstairs. read more

The service was great and the food was amazing. The mushroom soup is divine. What a gem in Westfield.

We had a really nice meal at Nyla's recently. The service was on point and the food was cooked perfectly. I would have licked my bowl if I wasn't out in public. 10/10 would recommend. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Miso Soy Ginger Sea Bass - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

A few months ago I made reservations to eat here and got here with my family to realize it was 21 and over! For some reason, I never realized it when making my reservation. So, I was excited to come back! My husband and I ordered What A Racket and my husband a Rum Old Fashioned. Both were amazing! For appetizer we got the candied bacon deviled eggs......10/10. Highly recommend. We both got the mushroom soup and it was delicious. For our main dish, I got the sea bass and my husband got the chicken milanese. They were good. The service was great. The only negative is that parking is terrible around there and the tables are close by. But still worth the meal and drinks there read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Rum Old Fashioned and What a Racket - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

Absolutely amazing!! Our service was great and the food was delicious. Our favorites were the Mushroom Soup and Chicken Milanese.

I am so excited to have this restaurant in Westfield! We've been waiting for something like this. So many delicious and healthy options. Every single thing we ordered, we loved. Service was great. It is very expensive -- BUT they delivered with the quality of the food. We ordered lamb chops and filet with broccolini and the scalloped potatoes. So so delicious. We can't wait to go back! Brent was our server and he was fantastic! read more

Absolutely amazing dinner. The service was polite, efficient and offered great suggestions. We started with the crab stuffed mushrooms. They were delicious. I had the mushroom soup with my meal. It was warm, creamy, and loaded with mushrooms. The ribeye for an entree was cooked perfectly and had the most delicious butter compound on top. For sides, we had the au gratin potatoes and the miso mushrooms. We struggled to decide which we liked better as they were both delicious. It was the perfect place to celebrate my birthday. read more

See all