A little over a year ago I was wowed by their pizza. I posted about it on Facebook, on Instagram, and here. But, almost overnight, the pizza went to UNACCEPTABLE. I kept going back hoping that the bad slices I had were an exception. Maybe they needed a new oven. I spoke to Dante, the owner, and showed him my VERY underdone slice with scant sauce. He knew immediately what the problem was and said he would deal with it. For months I dropped in once in a while, took a look at the pizza in the "we'll serve this next" case, saw that it would not be good, and left. I deleted my Facebook post about NYPie, as well as my Instagram post. I will try this place again, as I have not been there for six months. If need be I'll edit this review. Clearly, if they can't make a consistently good pie (and my first couple were close to perfect), then they will have lost a customer. read more

NY Pie needs to crawl in a corner and die. How could you serve people this unbearable quality of food? It was my first time ordering from your restaurant and I am disgusted. I just moved to the area and have been exploring the restaurants around here and I have no idea how you have managed to stay in business with the level of quality I have seen in your dishes. Is this how you serve all your customers or just the ones who order out. I payed good money to have my meal and having ordered delivery should not make a difference in your execution of your food. I would advise anyone to stay away from this establishment. read more

See all

I wanted the NY Combo Pizza which was pictures but not on their on line menu. The guy told me to order The Works and put the word "taco"on the order description and he'll know it's for the NY Combo Pizza. What I got was a taco pizza NOT the NY. It was missing pepperoni, had too much cheese, bell peppers were not fully cooked, and pizza was very salty. It was not what we expected! read more

This review is made with a heavy heart. i have had pizza from NY Pie before (delicious!) and have had garden salads with grilled chicken (also delicious!) but the steak sandwiches were simply out of this world delicious. Today, after raving about these sandwiches, I convinced my sister to go clear across town because it would be worth it. My best guess is that this place is under new ownership. Previous trips found the owner at the grill. This visit had 5 people working and nobody was familiar. I ordered a steak and cheese sandwich and a steak pepper and onion sandwich. after taking the order the polite young man at the register said it would be about 10 minutes so we stepped aside to wait. After a few minutes we saw a woman removing empty sandwich buns from the oven. Since my sandwiches were never toasted before and I was not asked if I wanted them that way I did not automatically assume they were for me. They were, and if that were the only departure from the wonderful sandwiches of the past I would have been okay with it. However, upon taking the first bite both my sister and I were instantly met with the taste of heavily spiced steak loaded with Adobo seasoning. I loathe Adobo seasoning. Nobody asked if we wanted that, and I never had a sandwich from NY Pie that consisted of anything but steak, cheese and bread. This has to be new ownership because the man who always made my food was strictly Italian in his food prep. Many folks like heavily spiced food, and more power to them. But a business should ask a customer who orders steak and cheese if they want any other things on their sandwich other than what they asked for. I have learned a sad lesson. If the staff all look new, the food probably won't be the same. Bye bye, NY Pie. read more

Stopped by randomly as I was craving an Italian sub. Wow, was I surprised! Great service and EXCELLENT sub. The ingredients were super fresh and high quality....romaine lettuce, red onion, nice toasted roll. Glad I stopped in :). read more

Pros: - relatively quick, I was able to get my sub in ~10 min - decent size subs Cons: - the staff doesn't wear masks - bread was a little too chewy read more

I happened to grab a leftover surprise box from this place to share with my friends. The lady at the counter was kind enough to let me pick the flavor for the box. The pizzas were also big and really good even as leftovers. Will definitely order a whole one in the future read more

NY pie pizza is by far the best pizza I have had. This is the first time where the sauce and crust were perfect! Highly recommend this place, service is great, received a warm and fun welcome upon arrival. Great pizza, great people overall read more

During the covid pandemic I decided to support local businesses. O boy such a mistake it was! I have never ever have eaten such a bad pizza. I think it is really hard to make a bad pepperoni pizza but apparently it is possible! It was extremely oily, salty and saggy. The fries were stale and sticking to each other. Next time I will stick to what I know and I've tried before. read more

My friends and I always order from here whenever we want pizza. We've ordered the Hawaiian multiple times and it's pretty good but they skimp out on toppings sometimes. The Honey BBQ Buffalo (Honey BBQ Buffalo sauce, grilled chicken and ranch dressing) is probably one of my favorites! read more

good pizza, good mozz sticks. service real good, quick! the pizzeria looks like some from back home (new york lol) and it lived up to the way it looked! read more

Located in the quieter segment of an otherwise fairly busy Moody Street is NY Pie. The small restaurant offers up some pizzas, subs and various other items in a casual setting and is located directly across the local skate park. It has a private lot with a few spots and they strive to make fresh food with good ingredients. Fast forward nearly a half a dozen visits and it's been a good experience overall. I've only done pickup since I live within a stone's throw away, and while the pizza isn't the best in Waltham, it's decent and their subs are top notch. The bread they use is incredible. It's crunchy and soft and works very well with just about any type of sub I've had there, from buffalo chicken subs to eggplant parm. It's large enough to be filling and the ingredients they use are great. It also feels a bit less greasy than Carl's which is less than a mile away but is more expensive with subs averaging $8-9 which is a bit steep and at least a dollar more than most places. Not a huge deal but definitely something to keep in mind. That aside, the place does have some seating although it's fairly limited. No tables either, just a counter with a few stools. Service is very friendly and there's in the midst of considering having gluten-free dough for pizzas in the near future, something that I hope they do. read more

See all

Great food and great customer service. Make sure you order the steak and chicken with the spicy fries. It's a life changer.

NY Pie has the BEST pizza. They use organic flour, which really makes a difference when it comes to quality, flavor, and health. They also offer amazing vegan options that taste super cheesy and delicious. NY Pie is my favorite spot for pizza in the Boston area. read more

Never dined in, but ordered delivery a few (5-ish) times. Delivery time: The estimated delivery time (over the phone or online) has always been 45-60 minutes, but I've always gotten it around 25-45 minutes to housing near or on Brandeis. The delivery personnel are always friendly and patient, and also very good with directions. They also take credit/debit card both online (obvi) and over the phone which is convenient. Food: I've only gotten the pizzas here. X-Large (18") pizzas are huge! They are around $20 and well worth the price: always delicious and filling. There is a large selection of "gourmet pizzas" and the toppings are always plentiful. For the X-Large pizza, it is possible to go half-and-half, so often I will choose something for the meat-lovers as well as vegetarians or veggie-lovers; for example, you can choose half honey-barbecue chicken pizza and half gourmet veggie pizza for no extra cost. read more

NY Pie - X-large pizza. Pen for scale. This time the delivery was about 50 minutes for a half veggie and bbq chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

The first and only time I walked into this place to order food and it will be the last, and I haven't even tasted my food yet. The young girl behind the counter is very short and agitated, but one man in the restaurant putting together the orders for delivery is very pleasant. I have been in this area for 20 plus years and won't ever patronize this place again, the owner should take a look at who is at the front of the house. You only have one time to make a first impression. read more

It's 7:22 on a Saturday night an I just left NY Pie after the most UNCOMFORTABLE customer experience I have EVER had. All because of the owners daughter. But the way the owner and his team handled it, added on to the delicious food completely warrants a 5 star review. I would give more if I could. I was waiting for my food and something set the daughter off- from what I saw it didn't seem like it was anything important. She started swearing and yelling at her father (the owner), she was acting completely unprofessional and disrespectful with a store full of customers. She was encouraging the other counter girl to leave (and by encouraging I mean forcing). The other girl looked frazzled, was just trying to do her job and help the delivery driver get situated. It was awful, I was shocked at how this girl was speaking to not just her father but her boss. All of the customers were just keeping their heads down and trying to not react. The owner and his other employees never stopped working, they didn't engage with the angry girl- everyone just continued doing their job. The owner basically ignored her but did quietly try to diffuse her a few times in both English and Italian. He didn't stop cooking, he tried to not contribute to the shit show and disengage as best he could. It was impressive given the nasty things she was saying and that there were customers present. My family orders from NY Pie frequently, the food is always fresh and delicious. We had never had an issue with an order and recommend a lot of our neighbors. The owner and his wife have always been incredibly friendly. We really enjoy supporting our local, family run pizza place. It made me sad to see how disrespectful someone can be towards someone who is clearly working their ass off for their family. How can you take no pride in the business you work at and a business that represents your family?! It blows my mind. I'm looking forward to my next order and not seeing her face at the front. read more

I'm really sad to write this review. We have been ordering from NY Pie for 3 years but the last 2 times have been awful. Something changed with their crust and it is not what we had been enjoying. Instead of having a puffy crust (pizza bones!), it is now thin. In addition, we had to use forks for the last 2 orders since the center crust was not cooked and crisp and no way to pick it up without toppings sliding off the "crust". And ordering desserts have always been hit or miss. We usually ordered chocolate cake but would get phone calls they were out for the day and ended up getting Oreo pie instead. Eventually, they stopped calling and just sent what they had on hand. If you're going to put it on your menu, you should plan accordingly. We sent emails through the website but never heard back from management. We're now on a quest to find a new pizza place. read more

If you like your pizza big this is place to be. I'm not a Yankees fan I love they're pizza's. Full you up for half an hour you can't go wrong read more

Best calzone I've had in a while! The pepperoni calzone is my go to! I order from here at least once a week.

Stopped into this establishment on lunch break on my quest for the best pizza. This is probably one of the best pizza's I had in 20 years. The person that put mine together today is a true crafts man or woman. Everything was top knotch. That touch of flavor in the crust, the soft crunch, the style and the sauce and toppings was laid out, the texture and taste of the marinade on that toppings.... magnificent. The only part of this meal that I was unsatisfied with is eating the last bite. I wanted more. They looked a little sketched out when I walked through the door. Could be a bit friendlier but honestly that small stuff does not bother me I'm there for the pie. I give this a 4 so far. Deserves 5 stars .... I always have to reserve the 5 for the best in the world. Great job in this establishment. read more

I've been there a few times now, so time for a review. Tiger Beef. Enough said. Get it. Definitely a fan of the za as well. Their staff is very friendly and welcoming and the service is pretty quick. No complaints. I'll certainly be back many times. read more

THE BEST!!! NYPie is so nice and we are so happy they support our organization!! Awesome people.

Ate here for the past 6 years. Never went anywhere else for a quick bite. The pizza I get is chicken bacon ranch which is my go to. And I sometimes get the Donnie burger too. But also they have bomb chicken Alfredo pasta. If you like other things they probably have it too. I like to order a lot of different foods. But I still haven't tried everything yet. But I was always left satisfied!! read more

I called last night for delivery I ordered chicken cordon blue sub it was great I opened up the pizza (Ny Basil pie large) the bottom of the pizza was completely burnt Black like char cole I had to spit the burnt pizza out of my mouth I was completely disgusted because it showed me that NY Pie just doesn't care $20:99 plus tax plus tip a complete waste of my money and time. read more

So, nowhere in the description of the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza does it say anything about tomatoes. Yet, here we are, with tomatoes on the pie... maybe update your description. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

See all

NY pie is my favrorite pizza places in Massachusetts! Not just because of their quality pizzas, specifically their mexican taco pizza, but their unbelievable love and kindness to the community. I work as the Case Manager at The Community day center of Waltham which is a drop-in day center for the homeless and am also currently managing the emergency warming shelter for the homeless set up by Mayor Jeannette McCarthy allowing the homeless to sleep there day and night and not freeze during the cold weather. Owner; Dante, is the most giving charitable person we have ever had. He not only donates pizzas weekly to the homeless but saved us during this recent blizzard by making pizzas for all of our homeless residents at the Bright school emergency station. He is a wonderful kind man who consistantly assists those in need. I am so grateful to this business. read more

best place ever. the people are friendly and helpful. The food is great, especially the eggplant parmesian. read more

I had never eaten there before so I tried it based on some good reviews. The service wads excellent, that's just as important as the food, to me. The pizza was BIG, I ordered a large. It was very tasty and good. I do recommend them and I will go back. read more

Tasty pizza, especially on a cold January night. The staff inside was really friendly and got me what I needed real quick. I will be back for more! The pizza had the perfect amount of sauce and the crust was just how I like it, crunchy and crisp on the bottom, but left with a little chew. read more

This place is absolutely fantastic. Consistently good food, fantastic service, everyone is super nice there. I've been there 5-6 times and I am yet to be disappointed. Burgers, pizza, hero's are all awesome. read more

They catered a film I worked on titled "Wish I Was There" https://www.imdb.com/title/tt11474166/ Their sandwiches were fantastic, specifically the chicken salad sandwich. Pizza was great too. If we shoot in Waltham again, you best believe we will be catered by NY Pie! read more

Has the BEST steak tip salad. I bought one today for lunch and it was made perfectly! The steak was WELL seasoned, it cooked just the way I like it and the lettuce was fresh. I would definitely recommend this and I WILL be returning. read more

Delivery to my hotel for pepperoni pizza and antipasto salad. Pizza was not very good especially the crust which was like card board although big. Salad was ok but definitely not NY standard. Wouldn't come here for pizza nor salad. Maybe they have other items people like. read more

This is an amazing local restaurant. I've personally been going there for 10 years and find their food good but more importantly as the Founder of a hospitality company their service is impeccable. To see a take out pizza place delivering service at this level is not often seen. J# @fhsboston read more

Buffalo chicken pizza is amazing. Have had many great pies from NY Pie. However, the other night they had chicken, bacon and ranch slices behind the counter that we decided to try. The slices were dry and flavorless. Barely edible. read more

I have ordered here many, many times over the 15 years I've lived near this place. My favorite has always been the meatball sub. Last night, I ordered that and when I opened it up to eat it, it smelled horrible, like the meat was bad. I had to throw it out. The next day, I let them know. I figured maybe they'd be slightly concerned. Grubub spoke to the manager who just said, no refund (it was under $10) and we made if fresh last night. Well, that doesn't change the fact the meat smelled horrible and something was definitely wrong. I purposely tried to let them know before just going to write a review. I'm now disappointed in both the meal I was not able to eat last night and the response from them. This place has finally lost me and my family as customers. read more

Been ordering from NY Pie regularly for the last year and a half. Never had any problems, pizza, subs, sides, everything is always made to perfection and on time. This is my go to pizza place since moving to the area. Staff is always attentive and friendly when I pick up in store and the delivery drivers always call when they're a few minutes out. Excellent service. read more

I order my first pizza from NY Pie a few days ago. The pizza was the best I had in Waltham so far (been to about 4 different places). It arrived hot and the cheese was terrific. The crust was traditional NYC, but not quite as good. I also ordered a slice of carrot cake. The piece was pretty small for the $5 it cost. I was disappointed by this. IMO the delivery driver was pretty sketchy. He was acting strangely, but no altercations. If they can correct these things, I'd give them a higher rating. The pizza was really good. read more

NY Pie - Tiny slice of carrot cake - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

I keep coming back to NY Pie for the amazing cheese pizza and Apple Cranberry Walnut Salad. Dante and his people make 20 different styles of the best NY pizza, tons of salads and great NY inspired subs in Greater Boston and at the best prices. You simply must get there or get your food delivered. I recommend NY Pie to everyone! read more