This place is amazing. The owner Dante is always so accommodating and makes the Best Food ever!! We have never had anything we didn't LOVE. Everything is fresh . You must try this place. Ask also about his special Greek desserts they are out of this world as well Big Fan Karen read more

Great pizza, Period. Not much else to say. I'm from Brooklyn, NY and this pizza reminds me of home. It's a dive, but most of the best places are. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

I call this "I just moved and we lost track of time from unpacking everything but we're starving at 10pm and what pizza place can come in clutch right now". That is NY Pie for ya. Delicious, huge slices of pizza, huge pieces of pepperoni slapped on top of cheese, and OPEN LATE! This is exactly what we needed after a long day (and weekend) of moving, and it was a struggle finding some place open so late. Alas, NY Pie was open AND was delicious. There's also a small parking lot next to it which makes it super easy to pull in and park since it's on a busy street. The inside is small but super cute and has everything so no complaints here (chips, sodas/waters/gatorade, and a bar height table to eat along a window). Classic pizza joint. Will remember this place as the hero of our moving weekend!! read more

NY Pie - Half cheese half pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

This is a local favorite spot for us to order takeout. They are always delicious and consistent. They take customer service very seriously. Tonight we placed an order and the driver showed up with the wrong order and he was quick to say I apologize. Let me go get your order and he did and he came back and there was a couple things missing just some sauces and when I called, I believe it was the owner who came with the sauces personally to deliver it to my house and I feel like that is just a gold standard for customer service! I would give this a five star review even without tonight's experience and everyone should give it a try! We love NY Pie! read more

Decided to come here for a quick bite before hitting the highway back home. They had a couple different topping ready to eat slices available and I tried the ranch chicken bacon slice. I asked for sides of garlic powder and pepper flakes. They added great extra flavor to the slice and I am glad I tried the chicken bacon ranch. Super delicious! I am not a huge pizza person, but NY Pie seems to make great pizza... probably one of the better pizzas I have tried in a long time. read more

See all

Just add more sauce to your pizzas - just double the amount of sauce and the pizza goes from average to very good.

- subpar pizza (mediocre taste) - wait time for a midday, midweek, order is insane - customer service is lackluster BETTER options in the area and places to spend my hard earned dollars. read more

This place does pizza right always. It is very close to pizza from back home (Brooklyn NY). We love this spot and always travel for a slice or a pie to go. Great service. Nice and friendly staff. The smell of the sauce alone is intoxicating. Thanks you! read more

See all

Even though NY Pie is across town, and there are plenty of other sub/pizza shops in Waltham that are ok, NY Pie is a winner. I'm not sure if their pizzas are like the pizzas in NYC, but everything we've ever ordered has been beyond delicious. My partner always has the Greek wrap with chicken...I know the way to her heart is through that Greek wrap. I keep trying different wraps and subs, because whatever I order is great. The turkey in the thanksgiving wrap is tender, plenty of stuffing, they don't skimp on how much they put in your items. Pizza is great, love the corn meal from the oven, stuck to the bottom of the crust. Not only is the food great, but they have polite and kind drivers deliver the food to you. Every time I tell the drive how thankful I am that he brought the meal to us. Tonight will be no different. Going with the Cuban tonight - again - because it is everything a Cuban should be - tangy, salty and crunchy ! read more

Their speciality pizzas are fantastic. Most consistent pizza spot in Waltham that I've found.

The best NY pizza around. Large, great flavor, perfect crust. Great customer service. Highly recommend.

I just wanted to give a quick shout out-I've been coming here for a while and it's always been an outstanding experience. The owner himself is commonly here and is a great guy! Tonight I as greeted and served by Nicolette-she was so amazing!! This place is top notch when it comes to service and quality and I so highly recommend! Enjoy!! read more

In the interest of full disclosure, my reason for stopping in here wasn't so much that I had heard anything good, bad, or indifferent, but it was 11:15 pm, I was craving pizza, and every other kitchen in Waltham was closed. It was clear the owner was finishing up for the night, but he graciously offered to make me something anyway. (*Side note: I intentionally used the word "graciously", because it exactly sums up his demeanor. I even said, "I know the sign says 11, so if you're trying to get out of here, I totally understand". Nevertheless, he offered to cook for me, and was so genuine about it, that I accepted) Now, let's be honest. When you're shopping for pizza at 11pm, there isn't a high probability you're going to do much better than average if you're lucky. In fact, at that hour in Waltham you'll be hard-pressed to find anything that fulfills the concept of "pizza" in even the most basic definition of the word. NY Pie is definitely the exception. I got a large Hawaiian, and it was absolutely as good as I wanted it to be. The toppings were generous, and everything was cooked perfectly. For a guy who, 10 minutes earlier, was about to close up shop, and could have been forgiven if he just threw something together to get me out the door, the owner really made a point of preparing something delicious. Good service is as important to me as good food, and in this case I really appreciated both. The owner when out of his way, and I couldn't have been happier with the food. I drive by here regularly, and after only stopping in for the first time recently, I'm now looking forward to returning to check out the rest of their gigantic menu. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

See all

Although the pizza delivery arrived quickly, the buffalo pizza and artisan pepperoni pizza were both very dry. All my guests were trying to understand how any pizza is made so dry and spent quite a bit of time wondering why there wasn't even a hint of sauce on either pizza. We will not be ordering from NY Pizza again. read more

The pizza is terrible and the tuna they put american cheese on by default. subpar pizza for sure

We go here every day for lunch break, I have yet to get something that I haven't thoroughly enjoyed. Pizza is unreal with so many different types of toppings, but the regular cheese pizza is still the best I've ever had. The service is great. The owner is there every day making pizzas with the employees. You can tell he is a good man. The spot is nice, with its own parking lot as well. read more

The food here is terrible . I've gone here three or four times in the past two years and every time there's an issue with the quality of food. I ordered a specialty pizza off their menu recently and when I received it, it didn't have the toppings that they claimed to have. Their "staten island" pizza is supposed to have Fried chicken, grated parmesan, marinara, provolone cheese, mozzarella, parsley, and drizzle of ranch dressing. It was a plain cheese pizza with a couple chunks of chicken, no parm, no provolone, no basil, no ranch. I contacted them and got no response. The sauce wasn't spread throughout the pizza as well more like a ring of sauce with barely any cheese and almost 2" crust. There are better options all over Waltham. This place is a HARD PASS! read more

NY Pie - "Gourmet pizza". Abysmal. - A pizza with cheese, tomato sauce, sausage, and other toppings in a cardboard pizza box. - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

Great food and GREAT service. Perfect neighborhood spot and excellent for both family and individual dinner. They're the best pizza place in town. read more

NY Pie - Classic Pepperoni Pie; Classic Meatball Parmesan Sub - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

Ordered takeout from here for the first time. Ordered the XLarge cheese pizza with pepperonis, jalapeños, and pineapple on half the pizza. Had a coupon, so total came out to $3.75. What's Hot - Service. Pizza was ready for pickup at the time I ordered, which was good. The staff, behind the counter, identified me quickly and knew which pizza I ordered. Quick and smooth service for pickup, which was great. Pizza was hot upon pickup and smelled delicious. - Quality. Good pizza and tasty with a good amount of toppings, but it wasn't knock-your-socks-off. I've had better. - Price. That I was able to get an XLarge pizza with 2.5 toppings for $3.75 is not bad. Additionally, they have a points system based on your orders. They also offer student and military discounts. What's Not - Quality. It is NY style pizza, so the crust is not thick and chewy. I prefer thicker crusts that have more chew. By the time we got this pizza home, the crust was crispy and not chewy. The pictures on the menu make the crust look bigger/fluffier/thicker, which it isn't. Not a very cheesy pizza, either. - Price and menu. I'm not completely clear as to how my total added up to $3.75. Why did the coupon say a free large pizza when they don't have large pizzas on their menu? They are inconsistent in their advertising. A large pizza on the menu we received in the mail is listed as $13.99. However, an XLarge pizza on their website menu is listed as $13.99, also. When I added pepperoni on the website, it added $1 to the order. However, pepperoni is listed as an extra $3.50 on the paper menu we received in the mail. Why is there this contradiction?? Jalapeño is not listed on the paper menu we received. When I added it to the order on the website, it looks like it's an additional $3.50. That a veggie costs less than a meat addition is uncommon. Why is there a contradiction in the in their information and advertising? Not a good sign. - Service. According to the coupon mailer we received, the coupon clearly stated a free large pizza. The instructions stated you need to set up a profile on their website, which I did. However, the online menu did not have the option of a large pizza. The only 2 sizes available are medium and xlarge. As a result, I called the restaurant. The staff who answered said they only make medium and large pizzas. When I asked him about the coupon mailer, he said he didn't know anything about that and that he would need to ask his manager, who wasn't available. The staff asked me to call back in 5 minutes, which I did. When I called back, the staff who picked up immediately asked me to hold, which I did. I waited almost 5 minutes and when he did not come back, so I hung up. I don't understand what's so complicated with this menu and why their staff aren't aware of the simple details. Final Answer Willing to come back, but not a first choice. Not bad, but I've had better and the inconveniences may not be worth it. read more

See all

Well..well the old NY Pie is back!! Great sandwiches and pizza!! My only criticism would be there was too much chicken in my Ceasar wrap, if that's a bad thing. So much I needed a fork . read more

NY Pie - A sandwich with sliced ham, cheese, and chopped onions and greens, wrapped in aluminum foil. - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

See all

Save your money and go elsewhere, $13 Italian sub was basically a sub roll and some lettuce read more

NY Pie - Italian Sub - A sandwich with lettuce, sliced onions, and deli meat is held in a person's hand inside a car, with a black interior visible. - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

I had to be in Rehab in the Waltham Ma area. Well the food in Rehab is pretty bad so I was able to order a Pizza through GrubHub. I chose NY Pie just to try a new place. I order their NY Combo Pizza. I was very please, generous toppings. I mostly enjoyed the crust was very good above average in my opinion. I would order pizza from NY Pie again. My review simple and straight to the point. Have a nice day. read more

NY Pie - NY Combo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

Good "go to" when in the area. Always reliable and consistently good! Prepared as ordered.

The Food was great and the service was very good and the Ambiance is what i expected,(A CLASSIC SUB SHOP)!! I ordered a steak and cheese w/peppers, onions,mushrooms and Extra cheese..Thanks,I will definitely be returning!MY NAME IS Charles.... read more

Pizza is top notch and service is even better. I'm taking the time to write this review because earlier today I had the completely opposite experience. It's been a weird day. When I ordered through the online system, something must have gotten mixed up because the driver accidentally left my food at the wrong address. The driver informed me that the manager would personally bring the food to me and she did - quickly! On top of that, she was incredibly nice and threw in a few cookies. Bottom line, the restaurant went above and beyond to "make it right" and it was entirely appreciated. My half cheese, half pepperoni pizza was fantastic NY style pizza. I lived in NYC for a while, so I feel like I know pizza. My caesar salad was basic, but tasted great and was as expected. The chocolate chip cookies that were sent were a treat! Gigantic chocolate chips - yum. I will definitely be ordering from this restaurant again. Happy customer. :) read more

Solid pizza. Great wings! Dependable quality. Will try some other items next time. read more

The food is so good! The pineapples are huge chunks. The pepperonis are ginormous. They are so generous with the toppings too. Definitely worth it. The pies are also pretty big. They barely fit in the passenger seat with me. The calzones are very cheesy too. There's some seating inside, but the vibes are a little weird, so I try to stick to pick up. read more

See all

This is real ny pizza in waltham. Truly the best in the area. You can taste the flavor in the dough- good sauce and good quality cheese. They do pies and slices and have some seating indoors (not great for large groups). They also have outdoor seating for when the weather is warm. read more

Thev are back to their early greatness. Good size subs and large fresh pizza. Still a little pricey but your paying that extra for quantity and freshness. I'm going to be a regular again. read more

Hit or miss honestly. Inconsistent quality. This pizza is two hours old as they forgot to deliver this in a timely fashion. I was patient and understanding but I think anything over one hour is a bit excessive. On a different note, the employees here are very negligent which is expected but this is a business and they should learn to show a bit of respect for patrons and their satisfaction. The food is good but the service can be very off-putting to a lot of people. It makes you not want to go back. read more

NY Pie - Reheated pizza I received - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

Excellent pizza. Have eaten there about a dozen times and the pizzas are consistently good. Thin crust and quality ingredients. I often don't eat the crust edges on other pizzas, but this crust / dough is delicious and I eat it all every time. read more

NY Pie - Artisan pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

See all

This pizza is actually what it says it is! As a native New Yorker who has lived in Manhattan, Staten Island, and Brooklyn, I am always skeptical about places outside of New York that claim to be New York pizza. However, my persistence paid off. I was pleasantly surprised to have found this place. As soon as I walked in the door I knew it was authentic. The smell alone tells a story of old New York pizza... So far I have tried the plane and white slices and both of them were on point. I doubt the residents of Waltham truly appreciate this place for what it is, a rare gem completely authentic and true to taste. Now I go out of my way to Waltham just for a pizza. Gotta love this place! read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Waltham, Massachusetts

I don't typically write reviews but I go to this place so often for lunch and think that keeping this salad a secret any longer is mean to everyone else. If you're looking for hands down, the best salad in the boston area - you need to try the Apple Walnut Salad, BUT make sure you get the low-fat italian dressing! All of their dressing are homemade and so good. Beware, the portions are huge - so you can have two days of salad out of one! The staff is amazingly kind and friendly - great place overall!! read more

We got a pizza and a sub and it was $50.. that's fine we added a few extra topping and thought it would be worth it for a good pizza... we ordered pickup and it was ready in 30 min. the pizza was meh.. it was soggy and bland. The sub was decent but I recommend spending your money somewhere else. read more

Our neighborhood pizza joint of choice, and we have a lot of other pizza places to choose from. We have tried them all, and NY Pie reigns supreme. read more

Someone from NY Pie kindly reached out to me to try their pizza again and all I have to say is I am SO happy that we did. Our second experience getting takeout from here was night and day. It was like it was an entirely different restaurant!! the pizza that we got was so delicious we were fighting over the leftovers the following day! The sausage were so juicy, the crust was perfectly cooked, and it wasn't overly doughy like some other local pizza places we have tried. We will absolutely be ordering from here when we are in the mood for good NY style pizza! read more

Superb pizza. Best in Waltham area hands down. (I like NY thinner crust style). The owner, Diante, takes extreme pride in all aspects of his place, especially the freshness of all ingredients. Can't believe I zoomed by this place for a couple years before pulling in. read more

good pizza, good mozz sticks. service real good, quick! the pizzeria looks like some from back home (new york lol) and it lived up to the way it looked! read more

This review is made with a heavy heart. i have had pizza from NY Pie before (delicious!) and have had garden salads with grilled chicken (also delicious!) but the steak sandwiches were simply out of this world delicious. Today, after raving about these sandwiches, I convinced my sister to go clear across town because it would be worth it. My best guess is that this place is under new ownership. Previous trips found the owner at the grill. This visit had 5 people working and nobody was familiar. I ordered a steak and cheese sandwich and a steak pepper and onion sandwich. after taking the order the polite young man at the register said it would be about 10 minutes so we stepped aside to wait. After a few minutes we saw a woman removing empty sandwich buns from the oven. Since my sandwiches were never toasted before and I was not asked if I wanted them that way I did not automatically assume they were for me. They were, and if that were the only departure from the wonderful sandwiches of the past I would have been okay with it. However, upon taking the first bite both my sister and I were instantly met with the taste of heavily spiced steak loaded with Adobo seasoning. I loathe Adobo seasoning. Nobody asked if we wanted that, and I never had a sandwich from NY Pie that consisted of anything but steak, cheese and bread. This has to be new ownership because the man who always made my food was strictly Italian in his food prep. Many folks like heavily spiced food, and more power to them. But a business should ask a customer who orders steak and cheese if they want any other things on their sandwich other than what they asked for. I have learned a sad lesson. If the staff all look new, the food probably won't be the same. Bye bye, NY Pie. read more

I wanted the NY Combo Pizza which was pictures but not on their on line menu. The guy told me to order The Works and put the word "taco"on the order description and he'll know it's for the NY Combo Pizza. What I got was a taco pizza NOT the NY. It was missing pepperoni, had too much cheese, bell peppers were not fully cooked, and pizza was very salty. It was not what we expected! read more