Cancel

Open app

Search

NY Hometown Deli

4.6 (16 reviews)
Loading...

Order NY Hometown Deli Takeout or Delivery

NY Hometown Deli Photos

Business Info

NY HOMETOWN DELI ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

More like NY Hometown Deli

Recommended Reviews - NY Hometown Deli

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

31. Fire Fire Deli Sandwiches
Darren G.

Went here for lunch, was immediately welcomed and asked what would I like. I got the fire fire sandwich without tomatoes, no issue with asking for no tomatoes. Man was good, usually places use dried out chicken breast for sandwiches, this place , chicken was juicy and tender, grilled lightly, seasoned and tossed in sauce. Kaiser roll was fresh and not stale. A spicy sandwich but not overwhelming, just the right amount. Service here is always so friendly, came here before for a grub hub and they were very friendly then too. I will come back for fire fire again, but a wrap next time. :)

Storefront

I was looking for a new deli to try. After searching online and finding this place I found a hidden gem. They have a lot of different sandwiches, paninis, wraps and salads you can pick from or make your own. They also have smoothies, protein shakes and juices to choose from. Along with that they have an assortment of chips, candy and drinks. I got turkey, lettuce and tomato on a toasted roll for under $10. The service was fast and staff was nice. I definitely recommend.

the outside of the deli

See all

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jo L.
0
44
2

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of LZ B.
82
24
12

3 years ago

Kind people, Great breakfast sandwiches and even better fresh juice!! They had so many options! Worth a stop!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Debra E.
95
67
13

3 years ago

Very friendly people working there. It's clean and the breakfast Sandwiches as well as any cold cut sandwiches are fresh and very good .

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Super friendly staff great prices and amazing food. They have so much to choose from and I have never been disappointed.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Kat U.
0
35
0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jay S.
0
59
8

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

They have the best food, and great customer service. It's the healthiest food in town

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - NY Hometown Deli

You might also consider

The Wherehouse - Seitan Nachos

The Wherehouse

4.1(213 reviews)
3.2 mi
•$$

Food was honestly amazing, great quality and a good amount, service was amazing and the staff were…read morevery nice and helpful.

Newburgh, NY - we were directed to eat here by a friend after we visited nearby Motorcyclepedia…read more It's a popular local hangout, and the vibes immediately strike me as: if this were my neighborhood watering hole, I'd be a regular here. The decor alone earns a star: rock n roll ephemera covers every surface - walls, ceiling, shelves and display case - and takes me back to the days when I went to "shows" and not "concerts." There's even a small stage in the corner for live music, so that definitely checks out. Our friendly server Dianne hands us menus printed on newspaper, and I needed a moment to decide between the large selection of comfort food classics with creative variations on a theme - burgers, sandwiches, salads, mac & cheese, chilis & soups, burritos, wraps, fajitas, rice bowls, and specialty entrées - finally settling on some apps and a burger to share with my kiddo (which I'm told are good here), while our friend went for a steak bowl. There's a surprisingly large vegan and vegetarian section. Surprising because I haven't come across many veggie-forward pubs that offer anything more than a perfunctory Beyond Burger/black bean burger and an anemic salad. Here, they actually respect the non-carnivore's right to have some decent choices. The "hot" wings are alright and not really hot (though admittedly my spice sensors are likely eroded from my intense affinity for heat), but the poutine was a standout, which we ordered with bbq pork add-on. And while it won't quite pass muster in Montreal (tbh I've rarely had authentic poutine in the US despite seeing it on menus a lot - the cheese curds are never right), it was piping hot and delicious. The revelation was the twisty cut potatoes underneath, seriously additive! I love places with heart, which isn't always easy to define but the effort can be discerned in the atmosphere and the details. The Wherehouse has got that spirit & essence. With 16 rotating draft lines featuring regional brews, and substantial food offerings that far outpaces the typical bar menu, it's a down-to-earth dining establishment with the soul of a dive bar, that makes you feel welcomed like a local from the get-go.

Photos
The Wherehouse - Bar

Bar

The Wherehouse - Bacon cheeseburger and fries

Bacon cheeseburger and fries

The Wherehouse - Cycling Frog

See all

Cycling Frog

Newburgh Brewing Company - More Poutine

Newburgh Brewing Company

3.9(320 reviews)
3.4 mi
•$$

Have been going to Newburgh Brewery for years off and on, but feel they've really stepped it up…read morethese days. Always a wide variety of beers, the brown ale is my husband's fave while I tend to go for one of their ciders. Yesterday, there to watch the Premier League opener, I opted for a Gin & Tonic. Whoa, legit was probably the best G&T I've had a a bar in ages! They use a local gin from Warwick too. So if you're just going for drinks and a game/match you're in very good hands. But don't overlook their food offerings. The menu has been dependable (smash burger never fails) but they've added some new items and they are really super. The Birria tacos are a new item and are served in blue corn tortillas. Delicious. Poutine is absolutely yummy with savory gravy topped w fresh green onion. Even the chips & guacamole are stepped up w terrific double crunchy chips. The space is gorgeous, wide open and bright with high ceilings, wide tables and benches. So you never get that feeling that you've entered a black hole time warp on a lovely day. The real cherry on top of the place is the staff and vibe. Greeted kindly by every staff member with easy conversation about the game or what's on offer. It's a welcoming place for sure with an ace in the hole of how it strives to craft community first. So all this, along with quality food & drink? It's class. Well done Newburgh Brewery! Looking forward to our next visit!

This place has turned into an all-out sports bar. That's family friendly. The wings were really…read morereally good which I wasn't expecting and they turned out within about 15 minutes of I'm ordering, which I thought was fantastic considering there had to be at least 150 people in there ordering food during the World cup game. So service is definitely great and the food also is an attraction here along with the drinks.

Photos
Newburgh Brewing Company - A nice touch! Book exchange.

A nice touch! Book exchange.

Newburgh Brewing Company
Newburgh Brewing Company

See all

Toasted

Toasted

4.9(15 reviews)
3.3 mi

A new addition to the southern part of Liberty Street, Toasted offers supreme deliciousness between…read morethe bread along with other goodies that will keep patrons coming back. The bistro has a cute exterior offering a few outdoor seats and a minimal but stylish interior and is perfect if you want to stay and chill or get your food to go. This isn't Subway so the sandwiches are priced above $10, but considering the quality and quantity (and maybe because I'm just acclimated to paying ridiculous prices in the City) you definitely get your money's worth. I heartily enjoyed the sliced hanger steak sandwich and found the mix of horseradish mayo, sautéed mushrooms, and arugula on a toasted ciabatta to be perfection. I also tried the fried chicken sandwich which was well seasoned and made all that much better with the sriracha mayo and pickles! I will be back for certain to explore the rest of the sandwich and salad options, especially the capers and oyster mushroom sandwiches and roasted beet and goat cheese salads. They also offer baked goods from Newburgh Flower Shop down the block as well as a variety of coffee and tea drinks. If you get pickup, call the restaurant directly because the prices through Doordash are higher to compensate for the fees the restaurant has to pay. Good to have Toasted on the Liberty Street scene!

Wow, I can almost be a vegetarian with food prepared like this. I had their fried oyster mushroom…read moresandwich and it was so delicious. The bread was sturdy and crusty and crunchy on the outside. The oyster mushrooms were accompanied with a lovely spicy aioli and pickles. Even though it may a cost a little more than a sandwich from a national chain, the food is made with lots of care with fresh ingredients and the portion is enough for two lunches (at least for me). It was a little messy so I was glad I was outside to enjoy it. It's a small space inside (perhaps 5 square table for 2 each) and it's almost kitty corner to my favorite shop, Oliver & Chatfield. Since it's a little further down on Liberty street, you'll find plenty of street parking.

Photos
Toasted
Toasted
Toasted

See all

Coyote's Tavern - Strawberry Tavern Margaritas

Coyote's Tavern

3.6(18 reviews)
2.9 mi

I was intrigued by the cocktail pictures and the menu's descriptions. After I saw the Taco Tuesday…read moredeals, I was sold. I'm not sure if it was the night before a big snow storm or because this place is still new but there were 2 people (one cook and one bartender) on staff for about 50 customers. I came with a party of 7, we ordered our food and drinks at around 7:15ish. It took a while for us to all get our drinks but they were amazing!! I had the tamarind margarita, it was the perfect balance of sweet and sour. I couldn't taste the alcohol but then again, I also didn't feel it. My friend had the amaretto sour and thought it was the best she's ever had. Two of us got our food at 8:30 while the rest of the party got their food past 9. The tacos were some of the best I ever had, the corn tortilla was fried ever so slightly that they were able to hold the hefty portion of steak, cheese and salsa. 4 tacos for $6!! Overall, I think this place looks fun, has delicious food and drinks but the service needs work. 2 hours for food, not worth the time...

I went with my boyfriend to see Lola Brooke. I thought it was going to be packed and it was. When…read morewe first got there, there were no lines so it was quick to get inside. They definitely check IDs (for the youngins). I saw some girls waiting outside because they didn't have proper IDs and couldn't get in. It was $20 to enter. Not too bad considering there was an artist performing. They patted us down very thoroughly both males and females. Then we went straight to the bar. This also didn't take long to get a drink. It took about 5-6 minutes. I ordered a Don Julio with cranberry. I just wanted something quick. It cost $20 for a double. I think that's pretty crazy but I feel like all bars charge crazy prices for drinks. I would advise pregaming. The bar was definitely packed. There was no table of chair that wasn't filled and the dance floor was full of people. The music selection was great. Mainly rap and R&B, new and throwbacks. There are LED screens everywhere that really give the appearance of an upscale club. The bathrooms are pretty clean and accessible. The people are friendly and good vibes. I didn't try any food because I got there around 12 am, but I will be going back to try. The security guards do their job well and yes they told my boyfriend and I to move away from the hookah door by asking us "Are you buying hookah? If not move away from the door." Like excuse me sir, you could've said it a little nicely. But it didn't ruin the vibe. When Lola finally came everyone crowded up by the stage and she did her thing. We had a great time and we will be back.

Photos
Coyote's Tavern - Tavern Margaritas

Tavern Margaritas

Coyote's Tavern - A "fish bowl" drink or something

A "fish bowl" drink or something

Coyote's Tavern - Waaang Wednesday

See all

Waaang Wednesday

Ms Fairfax - Friday special...snapper,potato wedges & a salad

Ms Fairfax

4.3(200 reviews)
3.2 mi
•$$

I was pleasantly WOWED by Ms Fairfax and I'm so happy Yelp helped me discover this place and I got…read moreto enjoy the best takeout at the airport! I was craving something hearty and healthy so naturally, I went for the pearly bowl which originally comes with couscous, roasted cauliflower, golden raisins (trust me these add THEEEE touch), pickled red onions (YUM), tahini sauce, avocado, and a lemon-mint vinaigrette - THISSSSSS. I ended up substituting the couscous for quinoa which was perfect for the type of meal I wanted before traveling. Can we talk about that lemon-mint vinaigrette? It's perfectly green and brings the whole bowl together, SO GOOD. Wish I would've gotten a whole side of that. Ordering delivery through Yelp is so easy thanks to DoorDash and I was so thankful I didn't have to be stuck eating chips and m&ms - love these but I needed a little something more. Next time you're taking a flight from Newburgh airport be sure to get delivery from Ms Fairfax. Can't wait to try their crepes and green goddess wrap from their breakfast and lunch menu!

I have been hearing & hearing & hearing about this place! I finally got to dine in on a friday…read moreevening. I will most definitely be checking this restaurant out more often! Street parking available, as well as a municipal lot around the corner. Near a historic site to check out as well, Washington Headquarters. Greeted as I walked in, asked if I had reservations (which I didn't), I was shown the tables available inside & was told I could sit in the back area as well. They also have a cute table in the front outside as well. I sat in the backyard while I waited for my friend to arrive. The establishment has a chill summer vibe. All the staff were friendly & attentive. The special was the red snapper & OMG, they need to just put it on the menu! It was delicious, fried to perfection & had alot of meat. I am not a hummus fan but the appetizer my friend orderd-the hummus was tasty.

Photos
Ms Fairfax - Interior of Ms. Fairfax in Newburgh.

Interior of Ms. Fairfax in Newburgh.

Ms Fairfax - Mediterranean

Mediterranean

Ms Fairfax - Window side view

See all

Window side view

NY Hometown Deli - delis - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...