Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Nutley Elks Lodge

    5.0 (2 reviews)

    Services - Nutley Elks Lodge

    Venue rental

    Nutley Elks Lodge Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Nutley Elks Lodge

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Johnny I.
    64
    14
    15

    12 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Venues & Event Spaces 6,640 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Bacarosa

    Bacarosa

    (32 reviews)

    Unfortunately, they're closing on Dec. 20th. The location is the only thing I can think of. The…read moreservice was great and the ambiance was well thought out. Ordered only apps, though unique presentation and flavors. I enjoyed them and so did the customers I yapped with.

    Points for taking a crack at "just like in the city," but the "economic difficulties" definitely…read morecome from this area of Essex County not being able to turn tables as if it's the city--and not at the premium Bacarosa needs to charge to make that magnificent menu and this space pencil out. I give the team a lot of credit for pivoting when it was clear The Hudson Rose wasn't going to take, but Nutley still exists a few steps below Montclair and Maplewood in this regard. A post-pandemic restaurant needs certainty and needs to minimize the weird lulls that now exist in the dining calendar. Bacarosa had the product and service, but there just weren't the logistics to drive this kind of scale. Nutley's always been kinder to the smaller places on Franklin Avenue, and I think that's still where it sits as a dining destination. That's no fault of the staff or product, but that makes it very difficult to manage overhead on this space, quality, and staffing. I don't look forward to this space inevitably taking a step back to its Gondola/Peter the Great banquet hall days of yesteryear, but The Franklin Steakhouse set a poor precedent by moving from its cozy spot just north of here to a space that could hold two of its former locations. I wish this team the best and hope we see them in this corner of the county again sometime. Thank you for giving the place the quality it deserved, even if the traffic just wasn't there.

    Mamma Vittoria Catering

    Mamma Vittoria Catering

    (127 reviews)

    I have been to Mamma Vittoria twice. Schools in Nutley have a lot of their student events there…read more This last time I visited was for a repass. I was pleasantly surprised that they had roast pork as one of the entrées in the buffet. I don't typically think of that being an Italian dish, but regardless it was really delicious and that made me happy! They also had chicken francaise amongst other dishes. I must say that I consider myself a chicken francaise connoisseur. Lol! That is my favorite Italian dish and what I always pick when I go to an Italian restaurant. I found this particular chicken franchise to be just OK because the chicken was on the thick side and I like it thin. I also thought there should be a bit more sauce in the container it was in. I do remember that the other time I was there the chicken francaise was thick as well. Otherwise, the restaurant is fine as they have ample parking, though the spots are tight. Service was attentive and I do recommend the restaurant for any party or event.

    In October or November 2025 my daughter-in-law booked Mamma Vittoria for May 17, 2026 to celebrate…read moremy son's 60th birthday and was given a price. In February 2026 she received an email stating that due to the time of year and demand, the price would have to be increased which came to an additional $700 for the party. Obviously my daughter-in-law cancelled. That then made it impossible to find another venue. This is no way to do business.

    The Brookside Banquets - Our First Dance

    The Brookside Banquets

    (17 reviews)

    Was here for a family event. My husband and I thought the decor was very nice. The party was well…read moreplanned and the service was excellent.

    Two weeks ago 4/6 I had a surprise birthday party for my sister. I had looked at various venues and…read morethe Brookside stood out to me the most. Because I live in Atlanta majority of the planning took place over the phone. Lorraine was simply AMAZING! Christina worked with me due to the fact that I was planning a party all the way from Atlanta. Everything was explained to me in detail. They even assisted in an area where I couldn't make a decision. The night is the event Chris was the Mgr assigned to my party and everyone on that team were beyond helpful and amazing. From the set, drinks, food, and lighting were done to perfection. We had guest arrive super late, and Chris went out his way to see if it was possible for food to be served. Food: Italian Meatballs- Great, Shrimp and Rice: Great, Pasta: Great. I was very pleased with the food. You choose 6 entree's. Dessert: Whoever Baker their cakes Great work! I got nothing but who made this cake? I would highly recommend the Brookside for any parties. They carter to you. Now, they're not cheap, but I am firm believer you pay for what you get. The service provided took care of any additional cost for the services I needed. Again, THANK YOU, Lorraine, Christina, and Chris for making my sister super surprise 40th birthday a night to remember. She is officially 40 & Flawless!

    Nutley Elks Lodge - venues - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...