Good bagel spot located in the middle of town in Nutley. Pretty popular spot when school is in, it's always packed. They have all your usual bagels and sandwiches. They have gluten free bagels which my daughter loves. Place is pretty big inside with plenty of seating for dining in. The service was good and the prices are just about what you would expect. A solid bagel spot. read more

First time ordering delivery here. 15 mins away & the toasted sesame bagels were still warm on arrival. Fresh & delicious. Keep up the great work. Will definitely return. Place also looks clean in all the other reviews. read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - Toasted sesame seed Bagel with Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

For a flagel bacon egg and cheese it was decent. I don't feel like you can mess this order up. Bacon was crisp I didn't mind I enjoy it that way. Service was fast there was barely anyone. Cute spot to stop by for breakfast or lunch read more

See all

Love this place! Always fresh & delicious. Orders made on line are always prompt & correct. Really cute inside to sit & have lunch or breakfast. Ppl behind counter are super friendly too. This is my GO-2 bagel spot! Tuna is delicious too & I am V picky abt tuna! It's a win-win read more

They make the best Lox Bagel in Essex County! Fresh, flavorful and best served with fresh pressed juice (which is also served daily)! Love Bagel Boy! read more

Good sandwichs there bagels are very good. Fast service they are busy on school days. They are very close to nutley high school

Great space, amazing bagel and breakfast spot. Can call to pre-order. Staff are super nice and menu is extensive. Parking is street. Inside is big, clean and kinda "exciting" compared to local bagel shops. read more

Hello, my review is on their potatoes. I've always ordered baking egg, and cheese. But today I decided to order home fries. They're the best I've ever tasted from a restaurant. I didn't leave nothing on my plate. It was absolutely yummy. So just to let everybody know order their home fries they're the best. I gave them a five star. Get a heart.. Jaz. The staff called me to assure me of my order if I wanted something precise was very accommodating and polite on the phone. Kudos to you girl. Jaz G read more

Boy O' Boy Bagel Boy! Boy Oh Boy, Bagel Boy! Nutley bagel boy twisting up some delicious bagels. Soft and fluffy on the inside and toasty on the outside. With all the different schmears available, you will surely find a bagel that will make you, Oh boy happy! Service is good despite their busy weekends. Sometimes a short and sometimes a long wait but the wait has always been worthwhile. The kids love the rainbow bagels and I love the cream cheese and lox, cinnamon raisin with cinnamon raisin walnut cream cheese or a simple plain with cream cheese. They also have the NJ pork roll classic or the BEC bagel if you are craving a warmer breakfast. Will surely stop in again when craving a bagel! read more

See all

No matter where I sit there is an employee that slams the chairs down next to me. The whole place could be completely empty and they come right next to people and slam chairs down right by a person. Today they the table with four people closed off. The worker comes next to me and slams down the chair to right and left, hitting into my chair. They only clean where people are sitting. They leave the mess at out spot and clean always right next to people. There are four people in here. read more

Everything bagel with cream cheese: 7.5/10 Bagel was toasted lightly and tasted fresh. they went a little light on the cream cheese. Bacon egg and cheese on everything bagel: 7.75/10 Sandwich was seasoned well, fresh egg and gooey cheese, bacon was ok Baked hot cheetos: 8/10 Went well with the bagels. Overall good experience, place was nice and clean. not too busy, would maybe come back again. nick rates this place a 7.5/10 read more

See all

I've given this place multiple tries. They are way too big to provide the quality and customer service necessary for their customers. Some places can handle the volume of a bagel store AND countertop full lunch menu like Wonder Bagels (multiple locations in Hudson County)... NOT Nutley Bagel Boy II. Ordered a taylor ham, extra well done on scooped out toasted whole wheat everything.. pretty simple We got a Whole Wheat everything that had remnants of egg, cheese, and ketchup that were removed... no toast..no scoop... floppy taylor ham... This is not an exaggeration.. It's like they put someones egg and cheese on wrong bagel... removed it.. and slopped on Taylor Ham.. There were visibly 10+ folks working... The multitude of tickets hanging on the rack was clearly overwhelming... Advice.. Scale back to bagels and leave off the whole lunch menu until you get things right. a read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - remnants of ketchup and egg - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Pretty good bagels! I got two and enjoyed both of them. Something about the cream cheese really didn't work with my lactose intolerance though hahahaha. Still recommend, they had a perfect crust with a bready inside read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - Garlic bagel with ham, cheddar and spinach - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

Basic BLT on an everything bagel - can't complain! I forgot to ask for mayonnaise and I would definitely recommend it because the bagel can be a little dry without it. I went around 230pm and there was no line! read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - Blt on everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Why wasting over half an hour to get a bagel with cheese that doesn't take 1 minute to prepare it specially when there is no customers inside the store. Also why you have a restroom if its locked all the time. Missing management read more

I was so excited to discover that I could experience a true New Jersey bagel, Nutley bagel boy 2 after my hot yoga. They had exactly what I wanted, including a fresh fruit salad and a customized fruit juice drink. I noticed that they have free Wi-Fi so no longer will I ever go to Starbucks when in Nutley I am a Nutley bagel boy too. read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - Loved my custom bagel sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

Just ordered Nutley Bagel Boy for the first time on Uber Eats. We're new to the area and love bagels so we decided to try this place out. All I can say is that we will be ordering here most weekends. I got a 10/10 TEC and my daughter got a rainbow bagel with cream cheese, BOTH were absolutely delicious. This is our new bagel spot. read more

One of the only decent bagel spots in my opinion around Essex county. They have a lot of options for fresh bagels and everything tastes great. The establishment is also very clean. Just one star less because they are a little pricey. read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

I guess this is an Indian bagel store, I ordered by phone from outside the store as there is no parking available during the day. 35 min waiting time, until pick up, then the girl asked me "do you want a bag?". NO Comments read more

Reading these reviews I was hesitant to try this place. But a friend of mine was give them a try and if yours not satisfied I'll refund you the money myself. So decided to try them today, was so busy meetings and study's; didn't have time to cook. So I got a BEC (bacon egg and cheese) samich with a hash brown and some slices of tomatoes on a roll. And an iced coffee to wash it down. The bread was nice and soft. And the sandwich was overall great, only drawback was that there wasn't enough bacon to go with every bite. I think and additional two slices would have made the difference. The iced coffee was pretty good too. It wasn't watered down and had the right amount of sweetness to it!! read more

See all

So. Today I went looking for something new and good. Nutley Bagel boy is pretty new in Nutley but it is AMAZING! The food is fresh and really good! The people are friendly. The place is clean and spacious. Everything I love. It has a NYC corner deli flare with a lot more class. Right up my ally. Love it. This will be my new go to read more

See all

came here with my friend for brunch and was surprising impressed. the place is bigger than i thought which loads of seating. shockingly there were a bunch of school kids out so it was a bit crowded and loud at first, but once it hit after 12, the kids went back to school and my friend and I were able to enjoy the peace and quiet. there was an array of bagel choices and so i go the lox on multigrain while my sister got the bacon , egg & cheese with coffee. we both really enjoyed our meal. the price point wasn't that bad either. there was just a bit of a wait and no tap water (you get water from the sink next to the coffee station). read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - Lox - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Cool people and great service but food is pretty mid. Ordered bacon egg and cheese on a bagel but had no taste even with the salt pepper ketchup. What's also weird is they blacked out their prices with a sharpie on the to go menus lol read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - Menu - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Ordered bagels online for delivery. Everything bagels barely have anything on them (see picture) let alone everything. They're also extremely small, borderline mini bagels. $6 for an everything with some scraps of bacon on it...yea won't be returning. read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - "Everything" bagel with bacon - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Only giving one star because my order with Uber eats is always made wrong. Today we ordered turkey bacon and got taylor ham. I wish I could say it's the first time. It's not. They consistently make orders wrong. It's a shame. No breakfast for me today read more

I came to bagel boy like I do once a month or so. First time ordering the fresh juices I got the immune - beets carrots celery orange and ginger. My husband ordered the revive carrot orange lemon turmeric I have added picture so you can see the "FILLER" on the Juices I ordered a drink not the residual Can't even drink it from the straw . Disappointed... deceiving Never again!!!! More than half of my drink isn't a drink... read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - Bagel boy supposed to be Fresh juice but more than half of mine "red" is residual fruit-Filler - disappointing and deceiving. - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

I very much enjoy Bagel Boy II in Nutley. I get cravings for it! Their bagels are crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. They have so many varieties and all are delicious as well as their cream cheeses, chicken & tuna salads and other toppings. The bagels aren't the only star of the show. Their menu is vast with salads, cold & hot subs, Reubens, eggs, bacon, taylor ham... the list goes on. Some of my faves are a toasted everything, egg bagel with veggie cream cheese, the Farmer's omelette which comes with home fries and the Reuben sandwich. Their varieties of coffees and creamers are also fantastic as well as many other drink options. Very clean and spacious inside. Well run establishment. Online orders and take out available also. Plenty of parking in front on street or around the back in municipal lot. read more

You need to offer gluten free and dairy free like your competitors. Almond milk and egg substitute is not enough these days .

Delicious. Bagel Boy can easily be my second favorite bagel store. I stopped in the other day and got a sesame bagel with veggie cream cheese. It was really great, toasted crunchy bagel on the outside and super warm and soft on the inside. The veggie cream was good too, pretty flavorful. I noticed it had a lot of carrots in it, which I don't mind but if you don't like carrots stay away. It wasn't too crowded when I stopped by but I can see this place getting full. Street parking is pretty easy. The workers were friendly enough. They have a nice variety of muffins and sweets too. Their cream cheeses really stand out. I would definitely come back and try a few of their spreads. Great place to stop for a bagel! read more

Food is consistently good and the counter service people are very helpful. Bagels are very good too. Get here early for best selection

Food has gone down tremendously French toast isn't cooked all the way. Inside the toast was dry and stale. Bacon was cooked on top of each other some parts were over cooked while the inner pieces were on the raw side And the toast that comes with the eggs were stale and hard. I always thought you can't ruin eggs. I was wrong. On to the next place read more

I have been purchasing bagels from them on a weekly basis for years, and they are consistently great. I cannot speak to their other products. My one tip is to avoid lunchtime on beautiful school days. The nearby high school students can pack the place on these days. read more

I just moved to the area and am looking for a new bagel place. I gave this place a try. I was about to bite into my bagel only to find a squished bug. SO DISGUSTING. I lost my appetite forever. I have nothing else to say. I'll let the bug do the talking. read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Order from these guys in a pinch and I've yet to be disappointed! Today all items showed up and in amazing time and everything was delicious. (I highly recommend a Taylor ham and cream cheese bagel sandwich) One add on was missing from one of the order items and when I called to let them know, they didn't hesitate to try and fix what was wrong and were apologetic. Good food and great service :) read more

The bagels are not made in the store. For . me that's a downer. But that being said , the bagel were good(not great) a little expensive. The service was very professional and a short wait. read more

So there are two Nutley Bagel Boys - the smaller one which is the one I had to check into but not the one I actually went to - makes the bagels. Then they bring them down the road to sell (even though it's a bigger location). Anyway - great bagels. Plump, doughy and traditional. They have all the cream cheeses you could want plus any type of breakfast meat. Their coffee is good, not great. Plenty of seating inside and parking outside. Friendly staff. Went during a weekday and it was busy. Could be the better of all the bagel shops in the area. Enjoy! read more

Why oh why didn't i read the reviews before ordering today? shame on me. bagel sucked (everything.. with oats on it.. never saw that before) and like others said, small and not a good bagel. COFFEE is awful too. Like dirty water. Even extra cream couldn't revive it. Nope. Everything about this order is disgusting and garbage. Garbage. Inedible. read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - This is an EVERYTHING bagel !!! ???? Pen for size. smaller than a regular everyday bagel and not tasty at all - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

We're Floridians who visit family in NJ frequently but I just discovered Bagel Boy today and I'm obsessed! Nice, big open place with plenty of seating and a big menu! We got there around 10am and they were out of quite a few bagel types but none really impacted our orders. We got 2 bacon egg & cheese sandwiches on plain bagels, a cinnamon raisin bagel with lox spread, and a blueberry bagel as well as a mini rainbow bagel (mostly because it was so cute, I had to!) The sandwiches were huge and divine and definitely satisfied my NJ bagel craving. We waited about 5 minutes for our order and actually received an extra sandwich, which was great, because we ended up devouring that too! Plenty of metered street parking on Franklin Ave, though you might have to walk a few blocks if it's busy. We will absolutely be back to this place to try the rest of the menu, and maybe a little earlier next time to have more options! read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - Big bacon egg & cheese on a plain bagel, so hot and yummy - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Not bad of a sandwich. Bagel toppings are a little scarce. Ordered 2 sandwiches with Swiss cheese, both came with American. Would I return, absolutely. read more

Delicious bagels, as always, with fresh cream cheese. Fresh muffins too. Only draw back to delivery. Which is no fault of the store, is that food gets to your cooler than you may like and the delivery service doesn't always ring the doorbell and the app doesn't update immediately upon delivery. So in colder weather, what you hoped for hot is actually now cold. I don't drive or own a car so I'm at their mercy. Again, that's no fault of the Nutley Bagel Boy II, they hold up their end perfectly. read more