Just Got an everything bagel toasted with bacon, egg and cheese.... It's soooo delicious!! The place is spacious and very nice staffing. Don't get confused with the older bagel boy across the street from the high school, the first picture isn't the correct location. read more

Found this spot after living in the area for years and I wish I found it sooner. The inside of the bagel spot is huge and cozy, plenty of tables to sit and eat. The bagels are super fresh and very tasty. I usually get a bacon egg and cheese from here and they've never dissapointed. The eggs and bacon are always cooked to the perfection I like. read more

Definitely not happy with the service this shop provides. Poor order skills and poor follow through. Cannot count how often they mess up my order. They are just lucky I'm not a picky eater and have no allergy's. read more

IF you like microwaved food then this place is for you. Soggy sandwiches raw French fries. For additional cost , 3 bucks for a soda CAN. Shame the pride in food is ruined . I'm not sure how businesses can serve food the way they do and be proud of that , Only reason this place will stay open is because of school and students that don't know. You get better food from 7-Eleven . We can help and avoid crappy pleases that rip Community's off . If anyone cares about Quality. read more

the best clean delicious friendly polite comfortable environment roomy hardworking great read more

This place is easily in my top 3 in the area for bagels. I live in Lyndhurst, but I don't like any of the bagel places in my town. I discovered Nutley bagel boy on Doordash. I have since gone there to pick up, and it's a really nice place. Very large for a bagel store, complete with nice booths and tables for dining in. Super clean, which is impressive. And they have a pick up window outside, if you don't want to go inside, which is AMAZING. My only gripe is, I went there on a Saturday morning at 11 am wanting to buy a dozen bagels. My husband loves the Black Russians, which there were only 2 of in the window. I asked if they would be making more, (considering it's 11am and they are open until 5) and I was told "what you see is what you get". I was willing to wait or come back even, but I really didn't like that answer. I'll def be back, but that experience didn't sit well with me. read more

This place needs to get closed down. Me & my friend found a bug in our bagels on multiple occasions it's DISGUSTING STAY AWAY. They also didn't give a refund and said there's nothing they can do about it. So unprofessional. read more

The manager Charlie and workers are the rudest people I've ever met! I heard them talking about customers that would order and they have the biggest attitude. The manager is disrespectful to customers and I saw him grab the bagels with his bare hands. Disgusting. The environment is always so dirty any time I've been there. read more

Pictures on menu are misleading! Deluxe burger was nothing but cheese on regular burger bread. Prefer BGL on Washington Ave.

Yummy bagels, fabulous sandwiches, fantastic salads -- all very fresh and carefully handled. Clean and conscientious regarding safety during COVID. Highly recommend! read more

Love this place! Service was great ..people are very friendly and nice ..great place for school kids to get a quick lunch or snack

Onion bagel was soft, no crispness whatsoever, a little rubbery, eggs a little overcooked. Nothing like it's namesake in Brooklyn.

It sucks food was very bad and the workers were very rude. They kicked me out and lied saying I was yelling.

You order a natural juice and you get a cup full of pulp. Not coming here again. #PulpFiction read more

Nutley Bagel Boy II - You order a natural juice and you get a cup full of pulp. #PulpFiction - Bagels Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Against my better judgement I went to Bagel Boy again. WORST SERVICE EVER!! It wasn't even that busy for the wait I waited. Then I get home and the BLT was on white bread NOT TOASTED. I will never go again. This time I am serious. read more

So disappointed. Ran up to Bagel Boy 2 around 8:30am on Christmas Eve simply looking for 4 bagels - 2 cinnamon raisin, 1 plain and 1 whole wheat. They had virtually nothing left! I would have been willing to wait but when I asked the girl if they were going to have more, she just said she didn't know. When I asked how they could be out so early in the day she just said since it was Christmas Eve people were ordering by the dozens -- SHOULDN'T THEY HAVE BEEN PREPARED?!! Ended up with 4 plain - should not have bothered making the special trip. The bagels were good - but would have been better if I could have gotten what I wanted. When I asked it they had any more cinnamon raisin - I was told they had french toast. Of course they had those left --as well as blueberry and the others that no one orders. I am just glad I was able to get the plain - they didn't have too many of those left either. I am going to ASSUME they put out more after I left, but I asked if they were going to have more - I would have been willing to wait. Oh well, I gave it a try. So many other places close-by- next time I will try another. read more

Decent enough bagel although there are better options within 5-10 min. Plain bagel egg and cheese was good. The bagel isn't too soft. Service was fast and friendly. Parking can be difficult depending on the time of day. read more

Huge menu with fresh juices. Great food. Clean and quite place to enjoy tasty breakfast.

best bagel i have ever eaten in my life- LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE the rainbow bagel! had a french toast bagel for the first time recently and it was amazing read more

I ordered 6 bagels, requesting 3 each of veggie and Black Russian. I also ordered a gyro omelet. When the order arrived there were six plain bagels with a note saying "out of flavored bagels." No one bothered to call and ask if I still wanted them, which I would not have. And I ordered at 9 AM - how does a bagel store run out of bagels by 9 AM? Finally, the gyro omelet had zero gyro meat, and it was cold. Never again. read more

Great bagels. Horrible wait times. They usually have over 15 people working and it takes about 10 minutes to get a bagel toasted with butter. Even when you order over the phone, you always have to wait a while read more

Tried Bagel Boy for the first time on my way home this morning. This place is pretty expensive. I got a morning paper ($2), two bagels with Taylor ham, egg, and cheese, and an order of fries. Almost $19? I don't know, I'm not even factoring price into my review, but if that isn't too pricey for you... The bagels are tiny and not too great. The wait was very long. Most irritating? The customer service. I was treated just fine, not like he noticed I was there aside from taking my order, but two girls walked in. They were volunteers for an event being staged at the school across the street. They said their order was short seventeen bagels. The counter guy (who I believe owns the play and runs it with his wife) argues with her, "How do I know you didn't just take them out of the bag?" That was after the girl offered to go get them and bring them back for him to count them when it became clear he wasn't going to help her out. Next Bagel Castro is saying no one has ever said their order has been off. I'm guessing he won't be mentioning this the next time he pulls that one out of his back pocket. Finally, like pulling teeth, he gives the girl a ten dollar bill and says, "Next time you count the bagels before you leave," like they were planning on coming back. The girls leave and he proceeds to talk smack about them behind their backs. This guy seems like a real little Richard. Sunrise Hot Bagels is down Franklin in Belleville, right at the corner of Joralemon across from the Dunkin Donuts and Signature Fitness by the liquor store. Go there instead. read more

Love Bagel Boy! Have been here many times and don't have anything bad to say! Love that they have moved into a bigger sit down location!

Good sandwich and all, but $5.75 for a turkey, egg, and cheese on a roll? That's one hell of a profit margin. Parking around there can be pesky. read more

So enjoy the bagel Taylor ham and cheese on hot grill and pressed. Makes for a quick morning breakfast. All the best in your larger new location! read more

I love the bagels and the place. Best bagels place in nutley, but the staff could be nicer.

Haven't disappointed me yet. I get the egg salad in a roll with a pickle on the side EVERY TIME

Good bagels and fair price. Service is fast and friendly. Coffee is not that good. I always get the whole wheat and it's very good.

really nice guy bagels are good for sure just not the greatest chewiest bagels we all dream of everything bagel has good flavor not too salty read more

Great Bagels, not sure why there is such a low score perhaps from when Mike was there (THE OLD OWNER). He was a bit silly with newbies (I thought he was funny) there are new people in here now that are very nice & they also hold longer hours too. Most of all.. awesome bagels, try the french toast. read more

I don't understand why they have bad reviews, this place is fast, delicious, and inexpensive! My boyfriend got the plain rainbow bagel and I got the chocolate bagel, both were really good! read more

I would not recommend the purchase of anything from this establishment. They are the most expensive in the area. I feel bad for the kids that spend their money here and ask for a bagel with butter and get a bagel with a paper thin stream of butter or cc. Then you get charged if you ask for extra butter or cc when in fact there is almost ZERO on there to begin with!! The owner just died of a heart attack and now his wife is running the show and following in his footsteps. Take an extra 10 minutes and go to Sunrise Bagels in Belleville or Clifton Bagel in the strip mall at the end of Washington Ave. You will enjoy it more. Trust me!!! This place deserves ZERO stars!!! read more

This bagel boy is very good. The bagels and food are very good and the prices are cheap. Worth it

This place is horrendous. They are not cheap at all. They buy their Yelp reviews (from what the owner told me) and do not provide hand rolled bagels. Everything is frozen and warmed up. Anything to save money! They charge you an entire dollar for butter, where they only put a light scrape of butter one ONE SIDE of the bagel. A dollar for ONE SIDE? Outrageous. These people are scam artists! They scrape a tiny bit of butter and sell it to poor school children across the street who have no concept or value of that extra dollor. Used to go everyday, NEVER AGAIN! Shameful! These people should not be allowed to do business. read more

Every time I'm here its at least a 10 minute experience. Doesn't matter if I'm getting a sandwich or bagel with cream cheese....always a wait. The bagels are mediocre, though i do hold a very high standard to my bagel....this isn't even in the ball park. A more efficient system (like any well managed bagel spot) is absolutely essential read more

The "new" owners are considerably more thankful for your business compared to the last bastard. He was always condescending to his patrons. This shop deserves your business now. read more

I will never buy here again, discriminatory practices, I stopped to buy bagels here this morning and proprietor was rude and disrespectful . I refuse to spend my hard-earned money in a place that does not respect me as a person. Who needs this crap at 6:30 in the morning. I guess I'll head up to Sunshine Bakery Watchung Plaza Montclair, New Jersey. -1 star read more

Got bagels here during Hurricane Sandy. I expected better. I could've probably done just as well at Dunkin Donuts... And we all know their bagels aren't even decent. The parking here is tough and it just wouldn't be worth my while to go back read more

After patronizing Hot Bagels Abroad in Bloomfield and Clifton Bagels in... Clifton, I figured it was about time I found a bagel place in Nutley and support my hometown. I drive past Bagel Boy quite often. I stopped in to get a dozen bagels. $1.00 apiece with no break for a dozen, not even a bakers dozen. $12.00 for a dozen bagels? Hot Bagels Abroad charges $9.75 for a bakers dozen. The bagels are perfectly decent, though on the small side. Overpriced and undersized bagels will not make a regular customer of me. read more

This place is grungy and gives off a bad vibe. When we first moved to Nutley, I was looking for a local mom & pop shop coffee shop to support our daily habit, and was hoping Bagel Boy would be it. But their coffee wasn't good, and it took them 10 minutes to toast a muffin. None of it was worth the price. read more