The name of the owner,Jason Mladenovic, has a last name that is probably eastern European, but his roots are Greek operating an Italian restaurant. With this broad diversity, Jason has built his experience working in the restaurant industry since he was 15. He worked for his father first, then his father in law and now for himself. This kind of experience couple with passion to cook, blends in perfectly to create amazing food. Everything in the restaurant including meat and sea food are fresh and not frozen. The seafood is freshly bought three times a week from a local distributor. We got a pizza, garlic bread and soda. The pizza crust was not too thick, not too thin, crunch but with a chew. We had veggies on our pizza and we enjoyed our pizza. We will definitely go back there again. Yelp has an offer when you check in. Good food, combined with a discount and helping a local business owner who is active in the community by either being part of a kids sports team or sponsoring the team calls out for local support from residents or consumers like us. read more

Nonna's Pizza Restaurant - the dining area - Italian Near Me - East Windsor, Connecticut

See all

Great food, friendly staff, nice clean and bright atmosphere. Can be busy due to auto auction traffic but reasonable prices.

Great service! Quick and friendly. The gent at the counter was kind and personable. Pizza was light and fluffy not heavy nor greasy. Good amount of cheese and the pizza was not thin. Yummm read more

Nonna's Pizza Restaurant - Valentines pizza! - Italian Near Me - East Windsor, Connecticut

ordered pizza for delivery and waited nearly 3 hours and it never arrived. I wouldn't recommend ordering pizza from here and will never order again from them . read more

First time here. Came with a large Meetup group, there were 15 of us. We took up the entire middle. There are 4 or 5 booths and maybe 5 tables total. Nonna's is not a large place. There is one server. She was amazing, I have to say. We had a reservation and the table was set for us with silverware and menus. Our server brought waters and asked if we had any questions. They had quite a few specials for the night. Since this is an Italian place, many of us had pizzas. I had the eggplant, ricotta, tomato and olive 10in pizza. I changed it up as I'm not found of tomatoes by omitting them and having it with garlic sauce. I also ordered a basket of sweet potato fries and garlic bread to share with the table. I wasn't expecting the basket of fries to be HUGE! Nor the bread to be an entire 12in loaf. Both were delicious. My pizza was perfection. The crust just the right amount of buttery chewiness, the sauce fragrant, the ricotta was melt in your mouth, the thin bread eggplant...divine! I truly was in heaven eating it. I laughed as I mentioned to my dinner companions how once the food came, it became eerily quiet. A true sign of everyone totally engrossed in their food. I'll definitely be back. Oh, we had seperate checks! Bravo... it was Deliciouso!!! read more

Pizza was ok however when viewing the pictures online they do not look the same. Pizza was this but the sauce was a delish.

I don't usually come down this section of Route 5 very much, but I had a Groupon for food & drinks for 4, so we asked some friends to join us last Saturday for an early lunch. I'm not usually ready for Saturday lunch until 2, but our friends had a tight schedule and so we got there between 11:30-12. Had no trouble parking or getting a table, as we were the only ones there. Not surprised, cuz who gets pizza at 11:30am? Still, it was nice to have the place to ourselves. There appeared to be one gentleman working, the place having barely opened for the day. He was very attentive and friendly. Accepted my Groupon voucher with a smile and welcomed us to our first meal at Nonna's. While there were several things we wanted to try from the menu, we decided to stick with pizza for the first visit. I mean, "pizza" is in the name of the place--and you can never have enough good pizza places on your Go-To list, amiright?? The husbands shared a large pizza with bacon, sausage, and pepperoni. My friend had a specialty pizza (Greek/Grecian?) and I ordered a small pizza with jalapeños, bacon, and feta. I know. What's with me and the bacon recently???? We all shared an appetizer of cheesed-up garlic bread, which was scrumptious! Then our pies came...and they were all fantastic! Very tasty sauce (tomato but with a depth of flavor), perfect amount of cheese (not skimpy, not gobbed on), and a delicious crust! The guys absolutely killed their pizza, while my friend and I ate half our small pies and boxed the rest for home. I gotta tell you, when I ate my pizza the next day, it was even better! How can that be possible? It was already fantastic. But the next day was divine. My friend texted me the same thing about her leftovers. I'm soooooo glad to have found another seriously good pizza place, as there just aren't that many really good ones around here. And one of our favorites recently closed. So Nonna's is a real treat to find. Great pizza & service. Score!! read more

Food was always great while I was on a business trip. Absolutely recommend this place! Service was quick and very polite!

It was alright, nothing to fancy to write home about. Not much Italian going on there, more like American deep fried cooking... but if ya like that kinda stuff, alright. I am not gonna make a trip back read more

Nonna's Pizza Restaurant - Italian Near Me - East Windsor, Connecticut

Had a very nice lunch here today. Nona's is your prototypical small family-owned pizzeria restaurant - think half a dozen booths and half a dozen tables. Think a very broad menu with soups, salads, appetizers, pasta dishes, Italian entrees, fried and baked seafood, two dozen different grinders, wraps, sandwiches, club sandwiches, burgers and dogs, calzones, and 18 different pizzas. That should take care of 99% of the public. I paid $12 for a cup of lentil soup ($2.25), an Italian Wrap with fries ($7.50) and a Coke. Everything was fine. The soup was served piping hot and was delicious. The Wrap had a lot of meat on it, alongside some chopped lettuce and mayo. It was served with a small cup of good cole slaw and some excellent hot and crispy fries. Service was attentive from a friendly server. The cook chatted with me when I paid the bill, everyone was nice. You'll also get $5 off of $15 with your Yelp Check In. The only odd thing about my experience here had nothing at all to do with Nonni's. There was a mother and two real creepy looking kids having lunch in the back. One of the kids got up, looked straight at me, and walked right at me as though he was gonna pick a fight or brain me with a napkin holder. LOL, that was pretty disconcerting!! read more

See all

It's been many years since I last dined here, shame on me as Nonna's has a very good quality Greek style pie. I ordered a small 10" pizza with sausage and mushrooms; I was pleasantly surprised it came with fresh mushrooms, not always the case in many pizzerias. Good quality cheese, sausage, a perfectly cooked crunchy bottom crust with a good pizza sauce, you just can't ask for much more. I felt the quality to price ratio at $9.45 was a very good value; I would return not only for pizza but to sample items on the dinner menu as well. Service was fast, efficient with my order arriving quickly from the kitchen. read more

See all

Decided to check out this pizza place after looking in yelp and Groupon. It was before a volleyball game and we needed something quick but not fast food. Definitely recommend if you're looking for a quick bite to eat! read more

Nonna's Pizza Restaurant - Steak and cheese grinder, buffalo chicken salad, and sweet potato fries - Italian Near Me - East Windsor, Connecticut

No frill, always delicious, really good prices and it's owner operated so the service is amazing.

Stopped in on our way back from the ice castles for a latter dinner and it was Great!! Service was great, food was fresh and hot and cooked perfect!!! Would definitely recommend and be back!!! read more

Over the last few months, I have gotten take out from Nonna's around 15-20 times. I generally get the chicken tender wrap every time, as it's one thing I know is safe for my IBS. The food always tastes fresh and the chicken seems like good quality meat. The owner has remembered that I asked for extra fries instead of a pickle (even though I only asked this once or twice) and gives me the fries and no pickle every time. He also recognizes when it's me on the phone and is super friendly. The staff in the restaurant is also very friendly, saying hi or smiling. I have gotten some of the subs/grinders and they are good but cannot speak of the pizza; I can't eat it. I highly recommend checking Nonna's out and supporting local business. read more

Pretty decent pizza. Got a sausage and cheese. My preference is New York style, which is quite a bit thinner than the crust here. No real complaints. Order was ready quickly and correct and the staff was great. read more

Nonna's Pizza Restaurant - Italian Near Me - East Windsor, Connecticut

This place has amazing italian food. For such a small place its menu is huge (bigger than chilis for example). It has everything from pizzas to grinders to classic italian dinners. The service is quick and if you become a regular you are always greeted by a friendly smile. The food is of incredible quality with hearty portions. Their main courses are delicious but I think their specialty are their mozz sticks and fries. Crispy, fresh and probably made with love by nonna herself. This place is a bargain for the price you pay and the quality of the food. Would recommend it to anyone! read more

Nonna's Pizza Restaurant - Jays special pizza. no you don't have to be special to eat it - Italian Near Me - East Windsor, Connecticut

See all

Heard about the place and it's very local so have it a shot. Italian Combe grinder is really good. Ordered it loaded and it was. The next night we liked it so much we ordered a pie. Ok this will never be confused with a New Haven pie but it's very good. Fresh ingredients, nice crust, not greasy or oily in the least. Almost dare I say a healthy choice so far as pizza goes. It may have been healthy if I didn't each six slices! We will be back! read more

Great Daily Specials. The Chicken and Bacon Rose Pasta was very good and voluminous. Upgraded to a nice small house salad with the house oil and vinegar with herbs dressing. The hot garlic bread was very light and tasty. The creamy tomato sauce was perfect and the penne pasta was cooked just right. There was so much, I will get another meal out of it. The server was quick, attentive and very friendly. She checked back several times and anticipated my ice tea refill timely. The price was spot on and the whole experience was excellent. read more

See all

Nice family run place. Excellent customer service. Food always hot and fresh. Whether you have a grinder, pizza or salad the staff always whips it up fast and brings it right to the table. My wife is a frequent customer (although not too frequent) and the staff always greets her by name. read more

My grandchildren and I had Nonna's calzones for dinner tonight! OMG! THE BEST CALZONES EVER! We had pepperoni, meatball and sausage! Each one was perfection! Thank you! read more

First time at Nonna's. Food quality was very good. Highly reccomend. Spaghetti noodles cooked to perfection, meatballs were honestly AMAZING, they are a MUST in your spaghetti. cheesy garlic bread was also very good! Order was slightly made wrong but that being said, I called them back and they were very apologetic and willing to either refund me or allow me to pick up same order another night. I appreciated the multiple choices that were offered to me. Despite the order errors, I'd come back in a heart beat! read more

Great food Always by Jason and staff!! Pasta dish hot and tasty as always, and excellent service, love this place!! read more

Had to get some work done on my car today, and I'm not from the area so my boyfriend and I walked over to Nonna's. The server was very nice - easily the best part of the experience. The food was simply ok. Didn't blow me away, nor was it bad. We got some chicken wings as an appetizer, and we both had grinders as our meal. His was steak, mine a chicken parm. Neither of us could put a finger on it but it just tasted like the chicken parm was missing something? Still edible, but not as good as other chicken parms I've had. Might stop again in the future to try other items on the menu if we have more car work done. read more

This place has really good pizza, I had the taco pizza and the special chicken and stars soup. Both were really good, but the wait times could be better. Still a worthwhile meal, and I would definitely recommend stopping here for lunch or dinner. read more

I stopped by this place randomly to grab lunch. The woman behind the counter was there alone (besides the cook) and had a group of 5 walk in before me. She was answering phone calls, tending to the group that was there, taking orders and cashing people out. She did all this like a pro, I was in and out quickly and the food was great! I will be back for sure. read more

living in New England all our lives to moving to Texas to find great pizza is not happening , so flying back up this time thru Hartford we wanted to find some awesome pizza with all the pizza places out there we choose Nonna's with all the reviews , with no regreats from the meatball grinder to the lrg pizza it's spot on we even order another lrg meatball pizza to take back to Texas , the owner Jason took care of our pizza wrap it in foil so it will make it home safe read more

I ordered two pizzas- one small hamburg and one large pepperoni. They were both tasty. The staff was very friendly on the phone and in person when I went to pick up the pizza. The prices are also reasonable. Finally, the $5 off of a $15 purchase or more for checking in was great! :) I would highly recommend this pizza place! read more

Overall the restaurant is pretty decent. Jason, the owner, is very friendly and accommodating. The food was good especially for the price. I will go here again. read more

Very good pizza and all around decent food

Nice quiet family restaurant. Food was good and service very warm and welcoming. Highly recommend.

The owner is extremely nice, usually we order out. They'll pretty much make a pizza however you want it. We get buffalo chicken pizza with a blue cheese base instead of tomato and its phenomenal. Give this place a shot, you wont regret it. read more

They have the best Pizza in Connecticut!I love their veggie Pizza! if you are ever in east Windsor don't forgot to try their pizza!

Really enjoyed their Chicken Scampi pizza. Not NY style but good nonetheless. Great service. Fun family spot. Would be happy to come back.

I'd give this zero stars if possible. I ordered delivery and went to eat a grilled chicken Cesar salad and after eating about 1/4 of it, found a dead FLY in it!!!! I am appalled and 100% disgusted!!!! I will NEVER eat anything from this place again! read more

Nonna's Pizza Restaurant - Bonus dead FLY in my salad!! - Italian Near Me - East Windsor, Connecticut

I always like to eat at Nonna's. The service is good and the food is better. They are generous with portions and are well worth the price.

Great food fast service free refills large portions friendly staff cooked to order very good

Not bad at all. Had lunch there last week while waiting for paperwork on a car purchase to come in. Had a sandwich and my frien had a pizza. good prices and quick service !!! read more

Undercooked pizza crust-premade from somewhere. Meat topping was rancid, if you can find the sauce-you win a prize- I have had better pizza from generic Price Chopper DO NOT BOTHER with this joint read more

Hit the jackpot with Yelp in finding a good restaurant while traveling with the family. Lots to choose from for the whole family and healthy options too with salad. We really enjoyed the meal and great service. You know the place is good with the many local little league baseball pictures on the wall. read more