Good and open late. A family size is only $22! Got a 10 buffalo wings, a cheese calzone, a pepperoni pizza, and a supreme pizza(not just for me). There is a Noel's within walking distance. So I set out there only to find out by mistake we ordered from the Noel's further from my apartment. Luckily they stayed late to make sure I got my order. Very kind! Despite our lateness, the order was still hot and ready. read more

Best pizza we had so far in NYC! It's a small location so easy to miss! They do have three tables to sit and eat. Yumm! read more

Noel's Pizza - Best Pizza we had so far in NYC! Yumm! - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered 2, paid for 4? Leftovers I guess! Large pizzas for a pretty decent price. I got 4 for $14. I wanted two slices, the meat ones in the photos, and somehow the woman understood that I wanted two more slices of cheese on top? I finally got the pizza box, which I thought was overly large for just two slices, and then come to find there are four inside! Welp. The pizzas ok. Good toppings. Served warm. All you need is two if you are really hungry. Big portions. read more

See all

This has become my go-to in upper upper upper Manhattan. Are there other pizza places around? Yes. Are there longer established places here in Inwood and Washington heights? Yes. But this is the everyday, I need a slice to treat myself and comfort food location. The staff is devoted and hospitable. There's not a lot of room to sit and eat but so many people have seen take it to go that you know it's a staple up here. They do delivery and they will even deliver that slice you crave at the end of a bad day. read more

White slice and a soda came to $4 which was perfectly reasonable. White slice was appropriately flavorful...sometimes it can taste like cardboard. The basil on it was a nice touch too. Crust is nothing special, although it was nice and crispy, which is a plus. read more

Noel's Pizza - White slice. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

We ordered on Grubhub and got great service. Pizza was delivered hot, earlier than expected, and the delivery person was nice. What was disappointing was the pizza. We ordered thin crust, so I worry for the people who order regular or thick crust, but this pizza had a super thick, bready crust. The bbq chicken pizza was really sad with a sauce that didn't resemble bbq sauce, and the chicken was super processed, tiny, tough cubes. We also ordered a marguerita pizza, and it was equally disappointing. It was like having dominoes but worse. Maybe it was a bad night? Or maybe it was a mistake and we got thick crust instead of thin crust? Whatever happened, it might be worth a try, but maybe stay way from bbq chicken and marguerita pizzas. read more

their lasagna costs 10 dollars and going to charge 14.. 4 dollars in taxes. pizza shop is bugging. tryna rob poor people. i'm flabbergasted.. how theyre charging almost half the price in taxes!?! read more

It was late and I was craving pizza. So I asked my boyfriend if he wanted to eat pizza. I check their menu on Seamless and called the restaurant to see if they deliver, which they do. I ordered a small supreme but it was big, like 14-16 inches wide. I ordered a roll but is more like a sandwich, or it could be what they call it in NYC. Both were surprisingly tasty and was quickly delivered even when it's almost closing. The delivery guy must not know English because I asked him how much and he only showed me the receipt. read more

Great pizza love coming here. I had wings and fries here and they were good. I will definitely continue ordering from here

It's one of the only places around that has coco bread so that is what I usually get which you can't go wrong with. I love their beef pattys with cheese pepperoni and coco bread. Their tiramisu is also pretty decent. Service when I've gone in to order has been good and efficient as well. read more

Didn't expect it but, Noel's Pizza was definitely brilliant. I was left speechless. Their Supreme was excellent! Supreme was done just perfectly. Everyone who works there is always very helpful. Def coming back soon. read more

I called for delivery at 8pm. Everything was good. Minimum $ on seamless says $10. An hour passed with nothing. I called at 9pm and a man on the phone told me how hey never made my order because it was below the minimum. And now it's too late to send anything my way. Places are close by and I am hungry. So this man at Noel's just screwed up my night. He blamed me for making an order on seamless below the minimum. But... Seamless would not let me order the food if I was below the minimum. It's impossible. So this place with all their food super meh decides to tel a customer to screw off because this place filled out their Seamless info incorrectly? Stay awake. Forget this awful place exists. Go somewhere else. Plenty of better places. read more

Fast delivery for the saddest excuse for food. Very cheap and cheap quality. Pizza and wings both severely undercooked. Not cold upon arrival. UNDERCOOKED. You get what you pay for... read more

My fiancé and I ordered from here on the Slice app and since we've moved uptown it's been tough for us to find our go-to pizza spot and we just found it! Delivery was 30min earlier than the app estimated, we got plain slices and garlic knots which were all super delicious, and the prices are super reasonable. Loved it, can't wait to try more of the big menu! read more

The food at Noel's is gross. I can't tell you how disappointed we are. Delivery time was great but the food wasn't. Stale French fries, the chicken Parmesan pasta was disgusting, the chicken wasn't seasoned nor battered, the sauce was just so cheap and I can tell that the chicken wasn't fresh at all. Please please get a better cook or put some effort into your cooking because it was straight up disrespectful. Never again!!!!!!!!!!!! I'm still grossed out by this food, oh and we are sick to our stomachs thanks to it! Seriously, avoid this place like the plague! read more

Not a good experience for my first order. I ordered take out, to be picked up. I was told 15 minutes. I waited 15 minutes and went to pick up my order and it was not ready. They had not begun to prepare it and then I had to wait another 15 minutes for my order. The restaurant was not busy. A total of three patrons were in the restaurant. My order was clearly thrown together. A huge amount of white sauce covered an open faced gyro. The sauce was soured, and the meat was overcooked and cold. My order of hot wings were smothered in hot sauce, but the meat was also cold. The only hot item was the baked ziti and that is probably because they had to melt the cheese in the oven. I will not be patronizing them in the future. I will also discourage my team from patronizing them. It is just too much to choose from in the area to get such crappy service. read more

Noel's Pizza - Cold Chicken Wings masked in hot sauce - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I think the food here is very good. I had a chicken parmigiana slice of pizza which tempted me to order delivery. I got the meat lasagna and it really impressed me that they gave me delicious garlic bread free of charge. The lasagna was good. Prices are cheap. Overall a good experience read more

Ordered Pasta with Chicken Parmesan and it was not good. It looked like a baked pie. It was just a mess all thrown in together. In addition the garlic bread was hard and burnt. The price was reasonable. read more

Why does a place that pays rent and can become great, just does not care and does the absolute minimum to survive. This is that place. Pizza is OK, Garlic bread is OK and everything else in not good at all. Do not order anything other than pizza and request it well done. Guess what....they do not know what well done means so you will have to cook it more when you get it. The wings were terrible and the pasta was gross. read more