Returned to this welcoming classic Italian space on an early weekend evening and were seated in a comfy corner away from winter drafts. The staff were attentive and had personality! Even sang "Happy Birthday" to my companion celebrant. From the garlic bread and house-made olive oil mixture, through dessert - all was good. I enjoyed the clear broth, vegetable minestrone with lots of carrot and celery. The Tuscan Salad was fresh and good. Do note it's got an onion kick to it. Loved the beautifully textured Rigatoni with mushrooms and thin-sliced beef in pink sauce. What a winner! Finished with Afagato (and birthday candle!) and Gelato. Yum! read more

See all

A pre-show dinner. Quaint little place for Italian ENTRANCE - we were greeted and reservations checked LAYOUT - the restaurant is narrow but long AMBIANCE - very cool looking with nice tables. Lots of pictures on the wall SERVICE - the waiters were nice and the bus folks kept glasses full APPETIZERS - I had the mussels which were very good. The broth was a touch salty. The shrimp cocktail was good perhaps a little over cooked VINO - we tried a bottle of Hamilton Cabernet which was ok ENTREES - tried the ravioli which was good but the marinara sauce tasted a bit burned DESERT - tried the strawberry cake which was not good. The cake part was definitely stale PRICE - I didn't pay but from the menu it was way more than $$$$ Tough rating that I rounded down because the food was so so read more

Nocello - View from the far back tables. The layout is long and narrow from the street to the back - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

The ambiance was comfortable, the food was outstanding, the service was first rate. What more could you ask?

Amazing food, great old NY service and the ambiance a subtle elegance. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with a smile and feel as though you're sitting down to eat Nona's home cooked Italian food! read more

Surprisingly large and beautiful space, with delicious food and old-world service. I hidden gem!

Spacious Italian spot in midtown and close to major tourist spots such as Central Park, MSG etc. Waiters were very attentive and all of them took turns; perhaps tips are shared? They frequently checked in on us which we greatly appreciated. Food was great (we had the special lobster tail fettuccine w no shrimp and requested it be made w the spicy sauce was delicious and homemade vegetable ravioli) except for the pistachio dessert. Not sure how it's one of the most popular dessert on Yelp but I guess everyone's tastebuds are different. Our fav was the baked clam. They were gracious enough to allow us to switch to the tiramisu instead. I def enjoyed the ricotta cheesecake - must have! I would return to try their halibut. Overall cute little finding after a bit of shopping. read more

See all

Cozy ambience, amazing service, specials of the day, great assortment of wines and food and I give them a 10 out of 10! The owners came around at separate times to ask us how things were going, and the weight staff was very attentive and refilled our wine, glasses and water glasses. The food was outstanding, and my out-of-town guests were very happy with the quality of the food, wine and ambiance. The owner came over and brought us grapa, which is infused with honey and chamomile and was amazing! This was a pre-theatre dinner. read more

Love this place. Great ambiance. Delicious food. Great value and good service. A quiet, cozy little spot!

We always return here when going to Carnegie Hall... The food is fantastic... The service to top notch... read more

This place is a gem and the staff are one of a kind. My boyfriend took me here to celebrate my birthday and I felt like I was in Italy the moment I stepped inside. While the restaurant is small it has an intimate and personal vibe. Throughout the evening multiple servers came to check on us and it felt wonderful to receive that level of attention. The food and drinks were by far some of the best I had. But the star of the show was the pistachio lemon cake I had. Nocello has created a life long fan in me. read more

See all

WOW!!! Sorry can't recall the actual names on the menu but... We started with the calamari appetizer. Delicious! I had the chicken with eggplant and hubby had the shrimp farfalle. Both,Delicious! Wasn't going to have dessert, but another couple recommended the pistachio cake. He had the custard with fruit. Both Delicious! The cappuccino Delicious! The customer service was awesome and not overbearing. Just enough niceness. I think this is our goto when we come into the city for a show. Thank you so much! read more

See all

A longtime favorite of ours. Great food, reasonable prices, warm and cozy atmosphere, and a location that can't be beat.

Super cute spot on W. 55th. The ambience gave a cozy Italian mom & pops vibe. I came from Florida to visit my uncles who live down the street and they had nothing but great things to say about the food & their service. When we arrived, we were immediately taken to our table and drink orders were taken(keep in mind we were a group of 9 people). Shortly after, while cocktails were being made our server returned to give a run down of their specials of that evening and chefs menu. Once o my ur drinks arrived - I ordered an expresso martini, our orders began to be taken. I ordered the chefs special which was a Alla Vodka Lobster & Shrimp linguini & my sister ordered the tortellini. So far the experience is amazing. Staff is very kind, waters & soft beverages remained always filled, we were able to chit chat amongst each other before our dinner arrived. Presentation,10. Taste, 10. Wow! I have to say the pasta was spectacular. Tasted fresh, authentic, & flavorful. I was very pleased with my dinner. My sister loved her tortellini. Didn't even let me try it... Then while we were oh so stuffed, they brought their dessert menu, but we were honestly so full. However, no wasn't an option. They comped tiramisu for everyone at the table. When I tell you, I've NEVER had tiramisu like the one they served... I was disappointed in myself for not ordering in the first place. It was so fluffy, light, & delicious! Not that cakey, tiramisu usually get at chain Italian restaurants... Moral of all of this is, the experience, the food, cocktails, dessert was 10/10. Would definitely return when I visit in the future & definitely deserves bragging rights. read more

See all

Everything we've ever eaten here is top notch. It's a cozy place with menus that light up. Love this place and come every time we're in NYC! read more

An old Italian restaurant from the past is here in New York City. Close to the theatre district, Nocello has been here for a long time. This was my first time here. It was recommended by one of the couple we went with. We were heading to a special event and needed to be out by 730. Good thing we were there at 530. The restaurant has a very nice, cultured ambiance, a large selection of primi and secondi entrees, appetizers and desert selections. They have specials of the day from appetizer to entrees. The variety is extensive from pasta, to fish, to true Italian, to fish and lobster. Prices are accordingly as this is a smaller and more intimate place. You will find more locals here and not people coming in from out of town. Last night we started with appetizers of salads and claims. The claims where small and cooked in a wine sauce. They were small and the price was high for 6 claims. Next we had two pasta dishes. One with a lamb rague and the other with broccoli rabe - a different type of broccoli that many Italians enjoy at home. This also include some fresh sausage. The taste was fine. It was fresh pasta and well seasoned. The wine sauce was goos and the broccoli was fine. But it was a bit over cooked and bland. There was no difference to the flavor it normally has. It was ok. The lamb pasta was better. We also had come chicken and salmon. Again, the taste was good and the flavor was fine. The salmon was fresh. It was served on some vegetables which were also fresh. As for the chicken it was breaded and cooked then topped with white wine. As for service, last night, service was erratic unlike other times. Our server floated in and out. You would make an order for something and he would disappear. You would always have water, but order a glass of wine and they vanished again. That would never come back for you. One of our diners had to ask for oil multiple times. The staff was either short-handed, harried or both. Plus the service between each course took more than 30 minutes. We never even ordered an espresso as we had to go the the theatre. Overall, the place is a reminder of the past. It is small and beautiful. The food is good. The prices are high. There are other and better places at a more reasonable price. The best part is that you can always remember that there is a place you can go before an event to attend. Just make sure you go early so you have enough time. 2 hours is not enough. You do need more. We shall give it another try. Ciao! read more

Great experience at this family owned restaurant. Enjoyed the service for our large group and loved the food esp the meat fennel ravioli. Our white wine was great too. Best of all the place had a nice ambiance, great value and helped us have a fun night! As a plus loved the backlit menus!! read more

Nocello - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

After finishing our activities at SPYSCAPE, my friends and I went across the street to Nocello since we were craving Italian food. I was so surprised at how easy it was to find authentic Italian food; upon entering, you can definitely tell that all the staff are Italian, they have pride in their food, and that they are very true to their roots. Interestingly, Nocello is a northern Italian restaurant, but I did not notice a distinction when I went. The atmosphere is pretty dark but they have LIGHT-UP MENUS! This is so cool and I absolutely love the concept. Before our food came out, we were served with bread and olive oil. Our first serving was great, I recommend adding salt and pepper to the oil before dipping it. On our second serving, we asked our server if we could get a bit of mozzerella to mix into our oil and he happily obliged and gave us TONS of mozz for our plates. As for actual food, I ordered the Pappardelle with Lamb Ragu. My boyfriend ordered the Rigatoni Imperatore and my friend ordered the Farfalle Alexander. Out of the three, my favorite was definitely the Rigatoni. The Italian sausage was so flavorful and I was a huge fan of the pasta. The Pappardelle was great too; didn't expect the tomato chunks (not listed on the menu) so I ended up switching with my boyfriend. I also ordered an Affogato which I had at the end, which was alright. I probably would have preferred the ice cream by itself rather than in affogato form, since the coffee was nothing special. In the end, though, we all walked out full and content. The prices here are very typical for NYC, so be ready to spend a bit here. read more

Nocello - Pappardele Nocello - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Rude. Terrible experience. There is better food better atmosphere and better all round within walking distance...don't waste your time or money. When we go back to NYC I will walk by to see if others have learned. Hopefully we see a new owner soon. read more

What a wonderful hidden find. Family owned Italian restaurant with excellent food. Since it is dark, like all Italian restaurant, their menus light up. It is truly unique and perfect for the situation. We loved every aspect of our food. The salad, soup, garlic bread, and entrees we all stellar. The lentil soup with sausage was a good surprise. The owners came to our table to check on things and welcome us. Pricing was what you would expect for NYC and the quality of food, but it didn't break the bank! They had a lengthy wine list (also lit up) and many interesting cocktails. read more

Nocello - Chicken with apple, prosciutto and.parm. Delicious! - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Family owned restaurant nice little space actually reasonably priced. Good wines by the glass we had the pasta. Alexander was excellent the Bronzino very tasty tiasu needed a touch of rum but after that it was delicious and they make a great espresso martini being an Italian restaurant they use real espresso. I will definitely be back. read more

See all

Absolutely beat Chicken Frances ever! Clams Oreganata are superb. Food quality is Michelin star deserving! Constantine treats everyone like family in his classy, sophisticated restaurant. perfect for date night, or any night! 5 Stars! read more

My wife and I went to Nocello on a trip to NYC in mid-December. We were only in NYC for two full days, and wanted to make sure we got some real Italian food. Nocello was a perfect spot for us, as it was in walking distance from the Times Square area and was on our route to see the Nutracker at the NYCB. The food was great! I had the Seafood Pescatore and it was very good. Service was also outstanding. They sat us on time with our reservation, took our coats and were immediately over to our table. My wife is dairy free and gluten free, so as you can imagine, it is sometimes hard to find a dish that meets both of those qualifications. Despite that, the servers were more than helpful, double checking the ingredients of the dishes and checking with the kitchen staff. Lastly, the seating can be a little bit tight, but in my opinion it helped with the overall ambiance and family feel of the restaurant. There are many places for Italian in NYC, but next time I visit the city I will likely go back here! Thank you Nocello! read more

I never get the positive reviews on here. We gave it another chance this weekend and were very disappointed. The last time we came the only thing we really loved was the artichoke appetizer, and again that was the only good thing. This place is obsessed with you ordering dessert. The last time we had the manager and four different waiters coming out of the woodwork asking us if we want dessert. This time it was three, and one of them wasn't even in our area. Very odd. Getting back to the food, everything is in the same red, basic marinara sauce. The Calamari pasta was in the same red marinara sauce as the artichoke which we ate without it, but this was unavoidable. Also there was a shell, or as the manager pointed out a bone in the Calamari. He thought that I thought it was plastic, and said sometimes it happens! So I should be ok with a "bone" or shell in my calamari? I could have choked on it! He wasn't even that apologetic as if it's normal! I've never had a shell or bone in calamari and I'm eating it for years! The prosciutto over melon was a total rip off and the melon had no flavor, and we've had better prosciutto from the package, and it was $19.00 for three pieces. The Lamb ragout wasn't very good either but we didn't say anything and nobody came by to ask us if everything was ok, they are only attentive when it comes to taking the drink orders and dessert. It seems like there are some locals and an older crowd, but otherwise it seems touristy. Because it's local, and is very mom and pop we figured we would give it another chance in spite of the food being mediocre last time bothering us to for dessert. In fact last time the manager ( or maybe he's the owner) actually was begging us to try his pistachio cake, and says it's the best even though we said we don't eat dessert. That turned us off from returning last time, but after this most recent dinner, we won't return again. read more

I usually stay in midtown when I come to visit - and Nocello is right around the corner from the hotel. I'm not sure how I've never noticed it - tonight we went thinking it looked pretty good. Expectations were high, and they were exceeded! Such a lovely space and NOT cramped and crowded - the servers were a bit disorganized, but were all so attentive and friendly making sure everything was just what we wanted. And the food...some of the best pasta I think I've ever had. I will be back without hesitation! Bravi tutti. Food: Linguini with lobster and shrimp special, halibut special, garlic bread (tbh, it was a bit too strongly spiced for us...but if you like a LOT of garlic, GET IT. It was toasted fresh and delicious). Sorbet and gelato for dessert were very generous portions and just perfect for ending the meal. read more

Amazing food and great service. Very reasonably priced for the quality of food you're getting.

An exquisite and romantic Italian meal in midtown. Love the spacing of the tables. The restaurant was crowded yet we didn't feel like we were rubbing elbows. The staff is attentive and friendly. The best part is the menus light up! Yes you open the menu and it has a backlight! My husband usually has to pull out his flashlight in a restaurant to read the menu and it's so bright. This was discrete and genius!! We ordered a bottle of wine and garlic bread to start. For our main course I had pollo panetone which is basically chicken & eggplant parm. Hubs ordered pollo Romano -chicken in white wine with artichoke and sun dried tomato. Both meals were spectacular! Fresh and full of flavor. Now I never eat dessert unless there's a ricotta cheesecake on the menu. My husband knows me well. He ordered it and asked for a drizzle of chocolate on top. They delivered and it was incredible! read more

See all

Consistently good food and service. Excellent value. One of the best near the theater and district.

Came here with a friend of mine who lives in the area. The ambiance is truly amazing. Some singer who perhaps is known was present and sang briefly while we were there so we got dinner and opera the same night. Service was fantastic and you should know their chicken parmigiana with eggplant also came with carrots and mashed potatoes, which you usually don't see but since I like both I ate those almost right away. For dessert, I had the cannoli and definitely can recommend that. Overall, a great experience and I'd return if invited again. read more

Great midtown West Italian. Had the farfalle with shrimp, very tasty! My friends enjoyed their dishes as well.

One of my favorite Italian restraints in NYC. It well known and not very big. The staff has been there for decades and knows everything about the menu and how things are prepared. They will create something for you if you don't see what you want. read more

Overall, this was a mediocre experience for me. I went on valentine's day with an overpriced fixed menu that did not have too many of the hits on the original menu. Some of the food needed salt and the menu was not particularly varied. The ambience was great, the restaurant was well decorated for valentine's day and was spacious. However, the servers and waiters did not introduce themselves, ask how we were, or even conversed with us. Overall not a great experience. read more

See all

This is a nice and quiet restaurant fairly near Columbus Circle. Too many restaurants are loud and too busy. The food is excellent and unassuming. I had one of the veal dishes.It was prepared excellently with some vegetables. I would tell you which ones if I knew. read more

Great last minute choice when we were going to the theater. Extensive wine list and drink menu. Food was flavorful and hot. Service was excellent. read more

Nocello - Chicken Pollo Frances - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Old world Italian restaurant, tight quarters but cozy and it gives you a chance to talk with tables nearby. Food was excellent. Service was spot on with beautiful Italian music playing read more

My neighborhood go-to Northern Italian restaurant never disappoints. Always great food and service

Everything was excellent- food, service and setting!!!!! Had friends in from out of town and they couldn't believe how great the experience was. read more

We are from Boston visiting NYC. The food was verry good,the service is amazing, the Owner and the staff are very nice and professional. The ambiance is perfect.We had a really good time.We are definitely comming back. read more

Delicious food, terrific service, wonderful ambience! I highly recommend Nocello! It's like dining in someone's home. You are treated like family here. read more

Had a nice dinner with a group here. I ordered a prosciutto and burrata special as a starter and it was very tasty. I had the Capelinni Salmone as the main and it was also quite good. Service was appropriate and efficient. Cozy ambiance. Would return. read more

Nocella is an old-school Italian restaurant that I think is a midtown tourist trap. Would recommend against coming here. Food 2/5: I got the special ravioli of the day (roasted beets and cheese), my friend got the salmon pasta, and we got garlic bread to share. The pastas were mediocre and definitely not worth this price (overcooked, etc.). The best part of the meal was the warm bread and olives that came at the beginning. Service / ambience 3/5: Service was fine but very matter of fact and felt like they were trying to rush you out of the restaurant. The place is cozy but felt a bit too old-school in my opinion. read more

Nocello - Ravioli of the Day - Italian Near Me - New York, New York