I've been back a few times since this experience, and they've redeemed that star! 1) their happy hour is great, but it's literally an hour so get there 5-6pm and enjoy! $5 drinks and $10 pizza 2) $10 pizza on Tuesdays!! Even the speciality ones. Great price but expect a wait because this is popular 3) we hosted an event in the Maxwell Room for my alumni association and it worked so nice! Now, it's weird because the room isn't exactly attached or where you think it is but we figured that one out. The staff, including Riley and Jillian, were so kind and helpful, and they let us stay longer to hang out and mingle. Nice smaller space and would definitely recommend for other events. read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Maxwell room - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

I went here on a whim. It was a Friday evening so I expected a wait. (no reservations) The host was very nice and accommodating. Part of our group left and she sat us sooner. We were seated the bar and it was cool to watch the kitchen in action. They were moving and focused! Our server was nice but I think she had too many tables to cover. We were in no rush so it was ok. She was always rushing by and I felt so bad for her. I had a cocktail. It was ok. I ordered something else and it wasn't good at all so the server so kindly replaced it. The ravioli was delicious and the pizza was cool. Kind of pricey. I could see this being a spot where locals frequent. I will say, I felt very overstimulated. It was very loud. read more

See all

Nicky's is one of our favorite spots in Nashville! Reily is the best and always makes us feel welcome. We love coming here for happy hour--the deals are great, the pizza is delicious, and the atmosphere is always fun. The patio is super cute, especially on a nice day, and the easy parking is a huge bonus. Great food, great service, and a relaxed neighborhood vibe that keeps us coming back. read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Burratta salad - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

One of the best happy hours around and such a fun spot for Christmas when it is fully decorated! Service and food has been great every single time I've gone. A picture of the happy hour is attached but the phone definitely did not eat first this round. Highly recommend the warm olives! read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Food was really really good! However we had 2 pizzas... spaghetti and meatballs. Focaccia app, Caesar salad, bolognese and shrimp vodka. Food was amazing however the lack of flexibility of the restaurant makes me pause on whether I will go back. My daughter wanted the vodka dish without shrimp and they said no... sub chicken... no... spaghetti w/ vodka sauce no.... Side of meatballs to pay for instead of the shrimp ... no... shrimp on side.... No. It was also extremely loud. read more

Quite a way away from our hotel in the Gulch area, but on my go to list. Welcomed quickly and nicely, told there was about a 10-minute wait. We were seated in the main area and our server stopped by quickly, she was great, went over the menu and made suggestions when we had questions. I tried the Nashville Amber beer; it was very smooth and light and I enjoyed it. We started with the Big Italian salad, it was enough to split, I got it without cheese. It was great. I am newly into olives so I ordered Olives and Oven Bread. I wasn't a fan of the olives, they were so hot temperature wise, I couldn't eat them till after the pizza, and they were just to much seasoning for me. I loved the Oven bread. Crusty on the outside and soft on the inside. A great char from the oven. For pizza we ordered the classic Margherita and added pepperoni. I was delicious! Lots of pepperoni, great chew on the crust. yum! On our way out we chatted with the manager, he was super nice and I enjoyed talking food with him. My reason for visiting Nashville on the heels of watching Somebody Feed Phil and Nashville eateries featured on Diners, Diners, and Drives. Great visit! read more

See all

My husband and I had our wedding at Nicky's Coal Fired, and we could not recommend it enough. Caroline, the co-owner was quick to answer our inquiry, provided us a PDF of what they offer for private events and quoted us a very reasonable price for a food and drink minimum for 120 guests for a seated dinner. Their food and drink minimum included set up, clean up, servers, bartenders, A/V system, plenty of free parking, and a day of coordinator who was amazing. We met with our day of coordinator, Katie, a couple of times before the wedding, and she was also very easy to communicate with via e-mail. She made the day of our wedding run very smoothly so we didn't have to worry and were able to enjoy ourselves. Nicky's also has a lovely atmosphere with a modern and industrial feel, with brick walls, high ceilings, large windows, wood floors, mid-century modern art and lighting. Our guests had a great time and still talk about the food, especially the focaccia bread. The staff start prepping the food well before Nicky's opens and make everything from scratch including their bread, pasta, and pizza dough, which is very evident in its fresh taste. Before and after our wedding, we have dined-in several times and have always had excellent, friendly service. Our favorite night to go to Nicky's is Tuesdays for the $10 pizza. I recommend Nicky's to anyone looking to plan an stress-free private event with yummy, fresh food or just looking for a quick and delicious meal at a cozy, locally-owned Italian restaurant. It's great for large parties or small, and they now offer reservations online. read more

See all

Beautifully decorated for the holidays! I'm so glad I came here for the Christmas pop up. It definitely put me in the holiday spirit. Food and drinks were really good. The pizza was phenomenal, the wood fired crust was light and tastes better with the coal fired method than a regular oven. For the table, we got the garlic bread and I can drink the homemade marinara. So fresh and the bread was baked perfectly. For the pizza, we for the pleased to meat you and think of a meats lover pizza but not too heavy. It had Spanish chorizo salami, Pepperoni, and Italian sausage. The espresso martini was delicious, they added some holiday touches to it. They have a great happy hour but sadly we missed it due to the wait, but I'll be back! read more

See all

Had an absolute amazing experience here dining in solo. I met the manager and he was so incredibly sweet and hospitable. My pizza and fresh baked focaccia bread was incredible. Plenty of seating inside and they also had a bar. I will be back! So happy to have this place close by. read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Dare I say one of the best happy hours in Nash? And $10 pizzas on tuesdays?? Oh I will be returning. Fantastic service and food as always at Nicky's. Love supporting them. read more

See all

Came here for a networking event. They were very accommodating to our large group. Food was so yummy. I tried meatballs and garlic focaccia. Will def return for the pizza and happy hour. Gorgeous restaurant. read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

I love this place! Probably my favorite pizza in Nashville it's hard to find Coal fired. The prices are reasonable portions are good if they rotate their menu it's fun to come here on Christmas time because they decorate the entire restaurant Floor ceiling. Surf is always super friendly and quick. I would definitely recommend the pepperoncini martini right now and I just love the classic margarita pizza! read more

Me and a friend went to "Saint Nicky's" because we wanted to do something festive but low key and heard good things. We started with the focaccia which was like a crunch cloud - perfect! She got the ravioli and I got the ragu with fun tree pasta. Her ravioli butter sauce was quite rich according to her. The ragu was perfect and the fun pasta shape was a perfect temperature. I loved the music (they played a lot from the 80s made for tv classic "once upon a Christmas" with Kenny & Dolly which I loved). Lots of fun decorations inside and out. It was like a Christmas nostalgia capsule dialed up to 11. Can't wait to go back next year, but until then I'll still go visit for a less festive but equally delicious meal! read more

See all

Nicky's has been on my list of restaurants to try since I moved to Nashville over 3 years ago! So to say I had built up anticipation would be an understatement. Lauren was our server and she was so sweet and attentive the entire time. She answered all of my menu questions and made sure we had an incredible experience. She is fantastic! We got the Classic Margherita (heart-shaped for upcoming Valentine's Day), warm olives (only $5 on HH), Tiramisu (MUST ORDER ITEM!!) and my friend's little girl ate for free from the kid's menu because kids eat free on Mondays! Everything was phenomenal and was made quickly by the kitchen. Nicky's absolutely exceeded every expectation I had and it was SO worth the 3 year wait! But it definitely won't be that long again before I return :) read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

They're the Soup Nazi's of Nashville. Great product, and they know it. But it comes with attitude. If you're ordering online for pickup, good luck. They cut off online orders very early in the evening, some nights, not others, with no explanation. They don't answer the phone and don't respond to email. They also add the sneaky gratuities charge into the bill and don't tell you. If you're not careful, you end up tipping twice. I give them 5 stars for pizza and 1-2 stars for service. Depends what you're shopping for. read more

First time using Nicky's for catering and certainly won't be the last. I worked with Caroline who is a gem, and a fellow Chicagoan! Menu first... phenomenal. They cater to you. Need gluten free? Done. Need vegan? Done. So helpful for work events. I ordered so much: kale Caesar, cauliflower app, chicken piccata, famous meatballs, a few pastas, tiramisu and some cannolis. Everyone raved about the food! My personal favorites were the salad and meatballs. Caesar dressing was so fresh and the red sauce with the meatballs you should jar. When the meeting was over I legitimately scraped the extra sauce into a ball jar and took home. Best red sauce ever, and I'm critical. Delivery was a breeze and they were perfectly on time. I have no complaints. 10/10 recommend. read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Riley wins the day giving our group the best recommendations. White pizza with the honey drizzle amazing. Meatballs were so tender and the sauce authentic. Caesar salad and the lamb cavatelli. Thank you Riley! read more

Tuesday's the pizza is only $10 which is rocking deal!!! The outdoor patio is so nice, clean and they have options for sun or shade! Service was great!!! Happy hour deals are a Knock out as well! read more

My first experience here was not good. It was not because of the restaurant, but they were having an event and way too many people showed up which meant we kept getting hit by people passing us and I was annoyed the entire time. I believe the pizza was suffering due to the sheer size of the crowd, but it's been a hot minute since that and I recall that I liked it. Skip some pretty good but not remarkable visits. My last experience with this place involved me and the fam absolutely demolishing the tastiest pizza I've had at a (currently existing) sit down in the state. It was one of those pizzas I will have to learn significantly more words for describing how the flavors complemented each other and nearly everything screamed "this is done right, yup." My kids who are not pizza oriented like me both destroyed their offerings (except the crust because my kids are weird,) and we had crust to dip in flavorful marinara sauce. I've had a few experiences here but that last one was something I still think about and you know, I'm just going to have to go there when it's not busy again and try some more. While it may be a faulty memory talking I'm pretty sure the place gets tastier when it's not packed... or time has just made them better. read more

The best focaccia ever! Love having this in our neighborhood for local Italian. Also, our friends had their wedding there this past May and it was beautiful! Great food and great service! Going tonight to try their $10 pizzas! read more

The food was delicious, the Caesar salad was different but still good. Our server, Courtney, was very sweet and gave us wonderful service. The food came out quickly, and the Resturant itself was an urban industrial setting and they were clean. read more

Stopped here because it's a DDD. Pizza was delicious, had a Nice to Meat you pizza, and service was fast. read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Hands down Nicky's makes delicious and fresh Italian cuisine. They are known for their meatballs and yesterday I finally tried them--huge and full of flavor! Typically, I'm not a spaghetti and meatball kinda gal, but I thoroughly enjoyed this entree. Might I add that this dish is big enough to share or pair with something else and have leftovers (as I did with my salad). I enjoy their pizzas, but I was very pleased with the meatballs and salad and I would order again. read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Meatballs & Spaghetti - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

We had an amazing experience at this St. Nicks! The food was absolutely delicious, the service was friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere made the whole evening feel special. Decorated for the Holiday Season. Highly recommend to anyone looking for authentic, flavorful Italian cuisine! read more

Closing the kitchen / not taking orders at 7:40 on a Monday when you're open til 8:30? Got to be shitting me. Oh that and a 14% surcharge on takeout orders? No no no. read more

Stopped by and it was amazing!! Tony is a great guy, super friendly, invited and makes a great pie!!!! read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Tony!! So great meeting a fellow midwesterner !! - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

I want to start by saying I want to give a 4.5 star review. This place is definitely better than good, but I pretty much require perfection to give a 5. Anyway, I went for dinner with my daughter, her husband, her friend, and my infant grandson after going to see the lights at Cheekwood. I really thought there would be a wait at 7 p.m. but we were seated quickly. Maybe it's because it was the Sunday after Thanksgiving and people were tired of eating. I originally chose Nicky's for their Christmas pop-up decorations and themed drinks and was not disappointed. The lights and decorations were abundant and my cocktail was delicious. We shared two pizzas - the Santa's Super Shroom and St. Pasqual the Second. Both were delicious and I really liked how thin the crust was. The focaccia was definitely a favorite. Service was prompt, friendly, and consistent throughout our meal. They were especially accommodating to the infant car seat and we had plenty of room. read more

First time visiting. We ordered the classic margherita pizza, Caesar kale salad, 1 beer and the vegan supreme pizza. The salad was tasty but a lil dry just needed a tad bit more dressing and more garlic in the Caesar. Very good size, enough for 2. The margherita pizza was ok, a little greasy but still tasty. The vegan supreme was ok not $25 worth though. Overall cute place everyone was very nice. Our waiter was super cool. I'd return to try other items. read more

See all

The food was good the service was just ok. The look of the place it looks like the put a restaurant in an old warehouse so its sort of got that industrial look to it. The pizza was very good sort of that thin crust style. The food is a bit on the pricey side, but I feel like that's a lot of places in Nashville. They also have outdoor seating as well. read more

Went there with my boyfriend for his 21st birthday (we're both men). Got seated at a table directly in the sun despite the restaurant being empty. Waited half an hour for a server to show up, and none did. Yet other people who were seated after us were not only placed in the shade, but served fast. When we went to walk out, the host was incredibly dismissive and apathetic. Not sure whether it was homophobia (which is incredibly two faced given that they decorated with pride flags. Capitalism at its finest I suppose) or the fact that we are both college students, so they didn't think we'd be big spenders. Though mind you we were dressed up in button downs and slacks (and would've spend a sizable amount plus a generous tip had the service been even somewhat friendly). Absolutely terrible way to celebrate a 21st birthday and will certainly not go back. read more

What an incredible time I had last night. I went for the first time with my parents who have been before - they were taken a back that there's now a wait staff. The service was incredible. They even did a cocktail my mom enjoyed that was no longer on the menu. The food was delicious. The restaurant was beautiful even with a private party going on in another area. I cannot wait to go back! Btw try the mushroom pizza - it's insane! read more

Nicky's is the name, pizza is the fame and long line waiting was the game! This coal fired pizzeria had all the fun & glorious holiday decor for Christmas time! The pizza was delicious. The service was overall pleasant. I'm just really glad I didn't know how long of a wait we were in for upon arrival, or I probably would've bounced. Not sure if this is the norm or it's mostly because of the whole Christmas vibe. I mean this place is totally decked out so you'll notice on social media. The certainly put a lot of effort into the interior decor. It's impressive. Standing in line outside in the cold isn't ideal. Definitely would not do it alone; And just when you think you're close and your time in line is ending, you get inside the building to see that you are only half way!! Because like an amusement park ride, the line must curl and wrap around lol. This may not be everyone's experience, especially outside of the holiday period, but it was mine. They offered a holiday drink menu while outside in line. We didn't partake. There is a patio also. While the food is tasty, it seems to me a bit overpriced. Even while splitting a pizza and a salad, my friend and I still both spent at least $50-60 individually. (we each had an alcoholic beverage too) You order and pay before you're even seated which was a bit different to me for a sit-down dine-in. For our salad, which came out first, we did the kale caesar which was a good size and enjoyable. We had some kind of White Pizza that included ricotta, other cheese and mushroom I believe, which was good. For my bubbles I had the Snowflake Spritz which was prosecco, raspberry, pomegranate & snowflake swirl for $14. By the amount of drink in the glass, I felt a little short changed (even when comparing to my friend's and others), but hopefully the glass was larger than it seemed. She had the Frozen Egg Nog and enjoyed it but agreed on my small serving size. I'm happy we got to experience Nicky's in all it's west Nash instagrammable glory. I enjoyed the food & company, but not sure I'd rush back because I am not a fan of standing in lines. If I pulled up and saw it, I may reverse and find another place. There were some people who did just that once they got to line. If you want tasty coal fired pizza or Italian cuisine in a cool bar, try this place out. Just beware of long lines when there's a Holiday pop up buzz a-buzzin. Perhaps it's not so bad when you go close to Christmas, be prepared to dedicate 1.5 hrs of standing waiting and $50+ to dining. Star Ratings: 2 - wait time / line 2.5 - pricing 3.5 - drinks 4.5 - food taste & quality 4.5 - service If I could score a 3.5 I would! read more

See all

The food is very good. Been quite awhile since we have been here since the pandemic. Used to be a sit down place where your table had wait staff waited on yoU. Now you order as you come in and the bring it to you. Just a different vibe. That being said the spaghetti and meatballs is great. We both had pasta and it was definitely Al dente and had good chew but needed to have more salt in the water when it was prepared. Both the sauces we had were good though. The meatballs are mind blowing. read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Spaghetti and meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Went here around Christmas time and wow! The ambience, the drinks, the service, all so good! Food was delicious and drinks were perfectly strong. Only downfall is it's pretty pricey, but you get what you pay for. Side note: I appreciate the vegetarian options! read more

See all

Loved the Scallop & Corn Spaghetti which might be a seasonal summer item. Hopefully it becomes a standard menu item year round because it was fresh and delicious. Also enjoyed their half off wine Wednesday's with their house red. We got a carafe and the price was very good. We enjoyed our time out on the patio with the weather. Plenty of parking in front or in back. Service is outstanding! read more

See all

We toured the restaurant because they have a wedding venue on site. The pricing was competitive and the staff was very professional, communicative and prompt. Although we went a different route, they were extremely helpful and would recommend to anyone looking for a wedding venue. We also had dinner there and the food was really good. read more

I came here with some friends around 5:20 pm on a Thursday. Unbeknownst to us, they were having happy hour until 5:30 pm. I was a little annoyed because I had checked their Instagram, website, and Nashville guru to see if there was a happy hour but it only mentioned happy hour from Monday- Wednesday. So I am not sure if it was a one off happy hour or what. Anyways, we ordered the happy hour pizza for $10 and got a glass of wine for $5. You order at the host stand and take a number and they'll find you. I got the margherita pizza and it was quite delicious!!! I would definitely eat this again. My friend got their Christmas pasta, which I did not get a good photo of at all, and it was also delicious! Once we sat down, we were able to order more drinks and food using a QR code. This was a nice feature, and it may have been because they were so busy. I'll say I understand the usefulness of the QR code, but generally if I'm going to a restaurant I do like the personal feeling and talking with the waiter. This is a personal preference for sure. And again once we ordered stuff with the QR code it was very easy, quick, and efficient getting our orders to the table!! The other thing I did not like was the presentation of the drink I ordered. I ordered a holiday drink from the menu! I was pretty excited because I had seen some drinks come out with candy cane rims or gingerbread men. However, my drink didn't have any of that holiday pizzaz so I was a little bummed. The drink itself was delicious. There is parking in the lot which is very nice. The Christmas sweaters hanging up were a nice touch. It felt festive. I would visit again because the food was really good, but with the understanding that I order from the host stand and won't have a server in person experience. I'll also just take my chances going at the start of happy hour, which is 4 pm. read more

For starters, you order at the register up front then go sit at a table of your choice. On Tuesdays they have $10 pizzas with a ton of options to choose from. When sitting at your table, you can scan a QR code and order drinks right to you which is great when they are busy and a server can't come to you. I ordered the corn and scallop spaghetti, but there was some confusion between the guy taking the order and I so the food runner brought out spaghetti & meatballs. After saying I wanted the other spaghetti, they brought out the correct one within 5 minutes no problem. And it was DELICIOUS! So much flavor and it was good as leftovers the next day. I will be coming back because everything on their menu sounded so good. read more

Nicky's Coal Fired - Corn & scallop spaghetti - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Great pizza. Super popular (so be prepared to wait) but worth every second. We got seated at the bar and they missed us at first so comped our drinks. Thank you! Cool Christmas decorations. Best pizza in Nashville. read more

The food and staff here are a joke , terrible place. Overpriced waste of time and food!