Antipasta is so fresh, cheesy garlic bread, regular garlic bread... so good I almost didn't have room for any pizza. The pizza crust and tomato sauce is obviously house made. I can't with this place and the amazing owners. Sweetest couple, every time I turned around to get something myself, they were handing it to me. I love a fresh pizza that isn't covered in grease like most corporate joints. Somehow we made room for dessert. It's like ice cream cake. No more... but maybe tomorrow! I would come back here to watch some World Cup or other sports events on one of their many screens. Just a nice place to have a quality meal with family. read more

We normally order from the New York Pizzeria in Calimesa and have had good experiences, but tonight our DoorDash order was somehow placed with the Beaumont location instead. Unfortunately, the entire experience was extremely disappointing. We ordered two pizzas -- one Canadian bacon, pineapple and cashew, and one pepperoni and jalapeño. One of the main reasons my husband chose New York Pizzeria is because he knows how much I love cashews on my pizza, and they are one of the few places that still offer them. We waited about an hour for delivery, which honestly wasn't a problem at all. It was a Friday night, and we completely understood that both the restaurant and delivery services would be busy. The problem was how our pizzas arrived. BOTH pizza boxes had apparently been carried and left at our door upside down. When we opened them, the pizzas were completely smashed over to one side of the boxes, with the cheese and toppings stuck to the lids. They were ruined. My husband had actually caught a glimpse of the DoorDash driver carrying our order and thought it looked like the boxes were being carried like regular packages rather than pizzas, but he wasn't certain until he brought them inside and we opened them. I'm including the videos of us opening both pizza boxes with this review so you can see exactly how they arrived. I completely understand that the restaurant did not deliver the pizzas and isn't responsible for how a DoorDash driver handled them. However, we had never dealt with something like this before and weren't sure where to start, so I called the restaurant first. I was immediately placed on hold, which again was completely understandable on a busy Friday night. What bothered me was the interaction once someone came back to the phone. The woman I spoke with was difficult to understand and, more importantly, was very unfriendly and dismissive. I was basically told that it wasn't their problem and that I needed to take it up with DoorDash. I actually suspected that DoorDash would ultimately be responsible for the delivery issue, and I wasn't expecting the restaurant to take responsibility for something the driver had done. I was simply calling the business we had just ordered food from because I didn't know the proper process. A little kindness or even, "I'm so sorry that happened. Unfortunately, because DoorDash delivered it, you'll need to contact them for a refund or replacement," would have made the interaction completely different. After all of that, we still tried to make the best of the situation. We scraped the toppings and cheese off the lids, put a couple of slices back together, and tried to eat them because we were hungry and had already waited an hour for dinner. Unfortunately, the pizza itself tasted bad. That had nothing to do with how it was delivered. Even after trying to salvage it, neither pizza was enjoyable, and we ended up extremely disappointed with the food itself as well. I don't like leaving negative reviews, and I especially don't want to blame a restaurant for something that was clearly the DoorDash driver's fault. But the delivery damage was only one part of this experience. The unfriendly response when I called and the poor taste of the food were separate issues. We've always had a much better experience with the Calimesa location, so that's where we'll stick to ordering from in the future. read more

Went for lunch with our large family of eleven people to celebrate our grandson's winning baseball game. The pizza was delicious, service was fast, and the specials (4 extra large pizzas, each with one topping for $61) was perfect for all of us to take slices back to our hotel rooms for midnight snacks. Highly recommended! read more

Love love ordering here!! Best place in town for pizza! The service is top tier and I know the quality is going to be amazing every time! read more

New York Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Beaumont, California

See all

So pizza was not that good in my opinion. Dough was not the best I had. It was like a frozen pizza dough, we had better pizza. I don't know what to compare it to. Maybe was like a day old Little Caesars pizza. It was ok for pizza night. I say you try and be your own judge of the pizza. Service was 5 stars. Good Tuesday deal. 2 extra large for 35. Our opinion we had better. Our to go place for pizza is pizza pirate is really far from banning and if you want really really good pizza take a trip up the 395 to Chicago Mikes pizza 6 hours away. read more

New York Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beaumont, California

See all

Pizza was under cooked, I called to let them know the issue I had with my pizza and she said "you ordered pizza, and you got pizza right?" read more

New York Pizzeria - pizza medium 12" Two Medium 12" (8 Slices) NY Special Pizzas Special - Pizza Near Me - Beaumont, California

Literally waited 45 minutes in an empty restaurant after arriving 20 minutes after the supposed 25 minute order was to be ready. The owner kept saying 5 more minutes. We asked for a side of ranch and she said no it's $1.25. That was the straw that broke the camel's back. Never coming back to this poorly run establishment ever again, lost a long time customer over $1.25. read more

This pizzeria is a great place to get pizza. I tried their pasta with meatballs and it is amazing! The owner Max and his wife are very friendly. This is a family owned pizza place that everyone should check out. The place is clean, and very comfortable greate for family to have dinner. Highly recommended! My family and I love this place. Will definitely come back again even we live 45 minutes away. read more

Best pizza in the Banning Pass. And they always get our order right. They've been in the area for many, many years.

Pepperoni pizza was good and hot from door dash not too expensive but yeah pizza is great!! I'd recommend this place to anyone read more

New York Pizzeria - Lg. Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beaumont, California

Our first time by a friend's referral. Great find for a place that's easily overlooked. We ordered two pizzas. One thin crust and one normal. The dough on both was cooked perfectly, the sauce was not sweet canned pizza sauce. The toppings were tasty and fresh. The sausage wasn't greasy, and had some crispy ends, very tasty. Definitely going back. read more

New York Pizzeria - Two pizzas to-go. - Pizza Near Me - Beaumont, California

Good food and like to support local small businesses. The pizza was pretty good. The thin crust wasn't as thin as expected but still tasted good. read more

Great pizza, great establishment, feels homing inside and good staff. I'll definitely be coming back

Picked up a couple of pizzas to take home the other day. It was our second time in and we loved it again. Especially for the price, this place has a great pizza. It's a small simple place prob more meant for take out, maybe family owned and they are cranking the pies out. The sauce was nice and pizzas were cooked well. We did a plain cheese and a pepperoni. Simple. The woman at the front was juggling it all with one helper but they both said hello and were so friendly! For the money especially it's a great spot. read more

This isn't a huge place but when we asked about a party of 15-20 adults, The owner and his wife didn't hesitate. We had my brother's funeral up the street and it was convenient. They had the food ready for the time we discussed. They were both professional and welcoming. The pizza was AMAZING!! We will continue to support small businesses like this. Thank you! read more

Calimesa/yucaipa location. Their pizza is the Best!!! We had our Military friends visit so we went & got pizza from New York Pizzaria. Our friends raved about how good it was. They have had pizza from literally ALL over the world & they said this was definitely the best they'd ever had. read more

I like this place for pizza, it's one of my favorites however we tried the deep dish and it's a big nah. It's not what we wanted and different than what we expected. We were hoping for deep crust pizza packed with toppings and cheese instead we got thick crust with the normal amount of pizza toppings. Too much crust. Now if you order their regular crust pizza, you're in for a treat. Yum yum! But don't do the deep crust unless you're into lots of crust. read more

New York Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Beaumont, California

We're new to the area and thought we would give this place a try. We were not disappointed! We ordered the special for two small pizzas online and couldn't be happier with the taste as well as the generous helping of toppings! The staff there were also so sweet. We will definitely be returning. read more

Great, fresh tasting food. Yummy, worth the price, worth the wait. Family owned and operated.

Good place to get a slice of pizza and beer great atmosphere good people I go here every month

Love the owners and the pizza. The lasagna is also always on point . The owners make you feel like you're family.

Very good pizza. The dough is light, fluffy and still has the perfect crisp on the bottom and edges. The toppings are fresh and plentiful. I would definitely recommend dining in and eating it piping hot. Owners are so nice too. We'll be back. read more

New York Pizzeria - New York, no pork sub with ground beef. - Pizza Near Me - Beaumont, California

I tried a combination pizza and an antipasto today. The pizza was excellent, and I have been looking for a great pizza place and I believe I have found it! The crust tastes homemade and is not greasy like so many of the pizza places these days. Very generous toppings and great quality ingredients. The anti pasta was delicious, very fresh and also very generous with the salami, pepperoni, and ham. I would highly recommend New York pizzeria !! read more

UPDATE 06/30/2024 - Ordered pizza online (slice.com) for a birthday party yesterday. Pizzas came exactly on time, hot and tasted great. Excellent pizza for second time. read more

Decent pizza... decent prices Great personality on the owners. I'd come back no lie just for the cheap $2 pizza slices. read more

Great food for a decent prices. I liked the vibe and the hospitality of the owners. Come thru

Very disappointed I waited 15 minutes to place and order and while I was there the staff has no gloves on while handling food and very disappointed that I saw the owner drop a pizza crust on the filthy floor in the kitchen area and picked. It back up and used it to make someone's pizza I'm astounded that this took place and will never return and didn't place an order for food Health department needs to be called many many red flags Place should be shut down read more

I haven't been to this place in over a year.., but last time I was here their Pizza was really good! And the ranch was bomb! The pizza now is absolutely horrible! The dough is super dry ... yuck! And the pizza is very cheaply made! and the ranch... ugh everyone knows you need some good ranch to dip that pizza in ...nope.... That is now horrible as well... I will not return to this place again.. this place is very rundown looks dirty and old ... An update would be a great idea & a new cook read more

My parents love the Calimesa location, and since this one is closer, we decided to try it one night for dinner. We did a pick-up order. 2 large pizzas and a side salad. I love that when you walk in, it isn't fancy and gave me the feels of a pizzeria from when I was little. I absolutely love the woman who runs the counter. She is sweet and efficient and always has a smile. I love that she is no nonsense too! Our order was ready right on time and piping hot. We got a supreme pizza with everything, and the toppings were not lacking. There was plenty of cheese, and the crust was cooked just right. Good flavor. We were very happy. The other pizza was just a cheese pizza. Surprisingly, you would be amazed at how many places can screw up a cheese pizza! Not here! We were very happy the crust/dough was perfect, and so were the sauce/cheese ratio. We were very happy with our pizza selection and the prices are very reasonable. The only complaint I have is the side salad. It was a small to go clamshell with literally iceberg lettuce and 2 pickle slices. No dressing, no other toppings, nothing. I love salad with my pizza (I know, I'm weird!), and this was not what I was looking for. I saved the lettuce and used it on my kids' sandwiches the next day (that's how big the pieces were). The salad wasn't anything to deter us from coming back, I just know not to order it next time. The pizza and the staff are worth coming back for though, and I can see this as being a regular pizza pick for us! read more

This was a favorite of ours. Not anymore. Our sandwiches in the past were missing meats. It has been a few months since we ordered from there. Today 1/11/25 I ordered 1/2 plate beef raviolis and it was mostly sauce and the ravioli's were tough. Also they did not include the bambino pizza on the lunch special. Also the salad included was lettuce and 3slices of dill pickle. I called them and they said when you come in we will credit you. read more

Torpedo Sandwiches are my favorite. I don't even think I've tried the pizza. The bread for there sandwich's are so tasty, I believe it's the best part of the sandwich. 3 types of meat and also cheese. The chef makes sure to throw it in the Pizza oven to get it a lil crispy. I get the Italian dressing on the side and drizzle that all over while eating it. The special is from 11-3 daily and includes chips or a salad and a small drink. Solid Meal, My favorite when I'm rolling thru town. read more

This location was recommended by a friend, so we decided to give it a try. We ordered (1) of the specials that included: pizza, salad, bread, sandwich and lasagna. Bread - Very good, what you would expect garlic bread to be like. Should have ordered more. Salad - Good, but interesting ingredients. Salad had: lettuce / tomatoes /pepperoncini / pickles / and dressing of your choice. I have never had a salad with pickles, and I was not going to start that day. Just removed them, easy peasy. Sandwich - Picked the turkey sub, very good. Bread was soft - meat / cheese / produce - tasted fresh and yummy. I would go back just to order the sandwich. Pizza - Ordered pepperoni and it was sufficient. Not the best pizza I've ever had, but not the worst. Right in the middle. The crust seemed a little thin (for my liking) but I don't know if I made that choice when ordering and just didn't realize it. Overall, I'd try it again. Lasagna - Terrible. There was for sure something the matter with it. It had a super weird taste and after 1 bite (which I spit out), the entire container went in the trash. Something was bad in there or someone should no longer be making lasagna. Overall, we will give them another try and so should YOU! read more

Went looking for pizza kinda late and found this place and stumbled in. Wanted hot greasy pizza and pasta. Pasta was spaghetti with meat sauce. Please avoid ordering this. The noodles were oven burnt or dried. Hardly any sauce and no flavor. Medium pizza looks good but also no flavor. It was okay but should have went somewhere else. The good thing is the staff was very nice and friendly. read more

New York Pizzeria - Medium pepperoni pizza and spaghetti with meat sauce - Pizza Near Me - Beaumont, California

My favorite pizza place, even though they're not perfect , they are 5 stars! Best pizza and consistently great. Just thinking about their pizza writing this review makes my mouth water. They have been in town forever and I hope they stay forever! read more

Love this place! Great pizza and staff is what makes this place even better. Always get the pizzas from here at least every other week. read more

See all

Pizza is delicious Quality you can taste Many pizza places are inexpensive After one bite you taste the difference in quality Service Very friendly and fast read more

Ordered and paid online. Pizza was not fresh and had the wrong ingredients. I had to throw it away because they put onions and peppers which I am allergic to and specifically did not order. read more

Update: 7/7/2023 I really wanted alllll the toppings, which we don't usually get because the kids like plain pepperoni. So I thought the special deal was a good choice. I would get 2 for $35 as I chose an XL 2 tool, both toppings were pepperoni. Then I got a L NY Special. I ordered over the phone and was told it would be 30min. Got there on time, and the cashier, brought my total up as $48 and change. I reminded her that I got the special. She explained that in order to receive the Specual price, the pizzas have to be the same size. She showed me the menu and I pointed out that it just states you pay the greater of the two pizzas. She asked the gentleman in the back, I assume he's the owner, I could barely hear them. She came back and wanted to charge me $39, the price for an XL NY special. But I only got the large. On the menu, the price for the pizzas I selected was $35 so that's the price I was willing to pay as it does not state they had to be the same size. After a few minutes of talking to the man again she said she will go ahead and give me the discount this time. I reassured her that I know now to order the same size. I was king of bummed since I really do like this place, but the info should be more clearly written. read more

See all

Pizza is always hot and perfectly baked. Service is extremely friendly but this establishment is really set up for take out. Inside dining is available for those who choose. read more

Really guys? I come in to order a pizza and you have News Max on. I lost my appetite and moved on. Went to Tuscanos instead. Customers don't want that crao on in the dining room. read more