This was absolutely super New York style pizza but I overdid it ordering a whole pizza for my hubby and me. We could have had a few slices a piece at the most and it would have been more than enough food. We even got the smallest (14") pizza! Next time....we will get it by the slice!!! The service was efficient and I love how they bring you your order and not make you walk up and get it at the counter. Very accomodating and we would definitely return if we are in Taylor again. read more

See all

We ordered the food takeaway, and the service was quick and the food was hot. Now, onto the taste. My wife ordered the Margherita pizza, which is one of the best she has had. I ordered the spaghetti with everything, which really hit the spot. As for the ambiance, it has a small dine-in area that was clean and well-maintained, though a bit dated. I would dine there without hesitation, and it will definitely be our go-to place for pizza or pasta. read more

Let me tell you, this place is the best and most authentic Italian restaurant that I have found in central Texas. My wife had ordered the chicken ziti Alfredo with spinach while I was at work. 3 hours after the food had arrived and I went to open the container, I half expected the top to be covered in grease and the food cold. That has been the experience with other Italian restaurants as well. I would say it's due to not using an abundance of oil and the authentic ingredients that made it so delicious! 10 out of 10 and will do again! read more

Really good. One of the closest New York style pizzas I've had outside of New York. I had a slice of pepperoni pizza. Good. Go try it.

The menu says 8.99$ 2 pizzas one drink my total was 12.37$. Pizza was horrible, service was okay and ambiance was mid evil. 1 out 10.

I was in the area for work and was told that this place is good well, that's a lie. I had the worst cheesesteak ever. Definitely don't recommend read more

*We ordered takeaway, and only briefly was inside the restaurant*, but it was clean and the counter attendants were attentive when we entered to order and we had no issues. The price is extremely reasonable and the food is ready pretty quick. Taylor location is in a convenient location, very easy to spot off of the main road and has plenty of parking. They have fast service and the food Looks great, but seriously lacking in flavor. Average pizza/American Italian options. If you're in a pinch and want to avoid large chain pizza restaurants this is not a bad pick, but I don't think we'll be stopping by again just based on how bland the Supreme pizza and the cannoli we tried was. read more

See all

Best pizza in Taylor. They seriously make some of the best pizza around. Great prices too. Friendly service every time. The restaurant always smells and looks outer clean. Absolutely love this place. I've been coming here for years. read more

My husband is a pizza snob. I thought it was ok. Not 100% NY style crust, but still good. He thought it was better than good. The pros: they are very generous with toppings. Menu prices changed, so I added pictures of the current menu. It was tasty and filling. That's what matters. Very friendly folks too. Gives hole in the wall vibes, which is a good thing. read more

See all

For Taylor TX this place is pretty darn good. Inside it has an old school North East pizza shop vibe. Pizza and hoagies were great. Highly recommended. read more

The "Sign" caught my eyes . New York Pizza. I ordered on slice of regular cheese. Super bland & greasy. The crust was the best part. Definitely needs more ingredients in the sauce. Might wanna remove the rat trap in the back. read more

See all

Passing through Taylor and this place had good reviews...better than other places in town....but they miss the mark. House dressing ruined the salad. I could have asked for another salad with different dressing, but I came for the pizza. We had to use multiple napkins to soak I the grease from our pepperoni slices. When I took a bite, it was a LOT of cheese and virtually no sauce at all. Needless to say, I paid $10+ for a bite of pizza and a few swallows of coke. Would not recommend and will not return. read more

Was disappointed because I came in expecting NY style pizza. Their pizza is ok but too much cheese & toppings make for a heavy floppy slice. Looks like most of their pies are 2 layers of cheese & 2 layers of toppings so the crust is moist & not crispy, Actually dined in too during the lunch hour so it was fresh but it's more like a Marco's pizza to me, nothing special. read more

When we want a good and consistent pizza we always stop here or call it in and pick it up. Excellent pizza all the time, every time. Highly recommend giving it a try. read more

See all

You have to try the pizza rolls! The sauce is freshly made, it's amazing with the rolls

Left me speechless!! Such a gem, great service and delicious food. The complete combo gets you lots of food for cheap. Great little drive through. Will be back! read more

Tried some of their pizza today. I thought it was all right. The ratio of sauce to cheese was good. The crust was not too thick. It had quite a bit of saltiness to it. The pizza had good oil which helped its flavor. The crust was quite bland and tasteless. It was a good value, as the price was reasonable. They also gave a free two liter soda with a whole pizza. This would be the pizza to eat in Taylor. It compared favorably with the pizza chains. It appears to be family owned. The biggest improvement needed is to put some taste in the crust. They close at 3 PM on Sunday. Kind of early. The rest of the week, they have decent hours. read more

The restaurant was small but had a great atmosphere. The service was good. You go and order and they bring it out to you. The pizza was delicious. We'll definitely be back if we're in the area again read more

New York Pizza - 18" half pepperoni half hamburger and jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Taylor, Texas

See all

Relocated here about a year ago. I drive about 10 miles specifically to get their pizza. Best in the area by far!

great pizza at a good price. Best pizza in the area. Highly recommend - tried their combo pizza.

My son introduced us to them. By far the best pie, crust close to authentic. Never get tired when we get hungry for pie. Simply take out, easy with Slice mobile App best part just 5 mins away. read more

I order the chicken parm here sometimes, sometimes just crave it specifically from here and it hits the spot every time. Service is A+++, I was coming by pretty close to closing time and he was so nice about letting me order. read more

I'd like to leave an honest review in hopes that the owner reads this and fixes the issues. Note the pizza is really good here most of the time. But tonight we ordered the meatball subs and it was actually sad. Our meat balls were cut in half and I got a total of 5 halves in my sub. They over loaded it with cheese and barely any marinara. The meatballs were very plain and had no flavor and they even burnt the bread. After two bites I threw mine away and my wife couldn't get through half. It was a very sad excuse for a meatball sub and whoever made it should be ashamed of themselves. We have ordered other sandwiches from here and they have been very poorly made. I'm Italian and a former chef with 15 years experience. I hope the owner can read this and make the changes to improve the food here. Our little town needs and deserves better! read more

Ordered through Uber Eats while visiting since we'd gotten great pizza from here the year prior, but this was just bad. Somehow got the order delivered within 15-20 mins, but the pizza dough was soggy and parcooked from the center out. Over 1/2 was wasted because of this. Ordered the spinach rolls to split as well since the website showed 4 in the photo, then only got 1 that was cold. Called the restaurant about the order and were more or less told "I had no idea!!". Uber Eats refunded the order total and gave us a credit to replace the tip amount left to the driver. read more

I'm very happy I found this pizza spot up here after moving into the Hutto area in 2019. As a member of the Ragtime Pals (founded in 2012), we have explored Austin pizza in our annual pizza crawls. The top spot by far is Little Deli in Austin. But I will definitely add this place to our next pizza crawl for evaluation. Ingredients seem fresh, the sauce is tangy but not overwhelming, the cheese is stretchy and tasty, the pizza is foldable and stays out straight when bringing to your mouth, but the crust remained soft with a crispy surface and not too chewy. I had pepperoni, olives, and mushrooms. The olives were a tad too salty but the mushrooms were cut thick and were plentiful. I will continue to try other dishes but their slice is really amazing. read more

The pizza is good, but the slice is a bit greasy. Service is good and they draw a good crowd. I would go back.

This pizza is some of the best I've had in my life!! When our waitress took our order, she said the pizza would be ready in 20-30 mins, so I ordered a couple of the pizza rolls. One was the spinach, the other was the pepperoni. Our waitress knew we had a party of 4, so she brought out 2 more rolls than we ordered, just to let us all try. None of us needed to share and thankfully so!! Each bite was better than the prior one and just so delicious! The sauces added a lot to these and made the s all hog our bites, as if we had territory to protect. My family of 4 (all adults) agreed it was better than any Chicago pizza or any pizza we'd ever had. We had the margarita and the Philly Cheese steak pizzas that were unbelievably yummy. Great work! We WILL be back! read more

The first time I ordered a BUNCH of food from them for delivery. It showed up hot and on time. We were quite pleased. However, the 2nd time we ordered a pizza where one side was one thing and the other something else -- it's how we ordered in ON THEIR WEBSITE. We received a phone call from them saying they couldn't do "half and half" and we'd have to do a full pizza of each or put all toppings on both sides. When I asked why they couldn't do it, they just said "we can't". So I told them to just cancel the order. Then they explained they couldn't and that we would have to cancel it online. While I had them on the phone I went to their website and could not find a way to cancel it and they just hung up. So I am disputing the charges and will not likely order from them again. Too bad, they really had good food. read more

My favorite pizzaria in Taylor by far , i haven't been to those big chain pizza restaurants since i moved here in 2020 and never will

We ordered a white pizza and Hawaiian style along with an order of manicotti. The Hawaiian was great, very tasty and cooked perfect. The white pizza was unbelievable, I can say it's the best I've ever had. I'm a garlic fan and this pizza was exactly what we were wanting. The manicotti was delicious. I recommend this place. Even if you stop in for a slice and head down the road, it's worth it. read more

Pizza one of best in the area and almost as good as NY Pizza. Their service is implacable and speedy. Nice to have them in TAYLOR TX!

5 star alert! Food: pizza is really good! Very authentic! I really like the cheese blend they use. Very tasty. Extremely fresh. You can tell they make the dough fresh daily. I appreciate the small touches like that. Also this is a big plus, the soda machine works and tastes so good. Most restaurants don't know how to operate their soda machines and they care to make sure they taste good. So thank you for that. Big plus. Back to the pizza. It's simply amazing. Hot wings: I would love to rate them but since they don't advertise them I didn't get to try any. Management: you need to put a big sign on the counter that says "now serving hot wings" another prime example of a restaurant that makes great food but lacks in marketing skills. Guys this is important, get a sign that says now Serving fresh ass hot wings. That's huge. Okay. People need to know this. You are there to sell your pizza and wings. Advertise that shit bro lol read more

See all

One of the best pizzas I've ever had in tiny Taylor, Texas!! They are always spot on and the pizza is always perfect! Order one tonight! I ordered a white pizza with mushrooms, red onion and bacon! Sooooo crazy good!!! read more

New York Pizza - White pizza with bacon, mushrooms and red onion! - Pizza Near Me - Taylor, Texas

the flavor of the pizza is good , but the two stars are because of the soggy crust the whole pizza flops , how can a crust be dark but still not cooked. i'm from new york and gave this place another shop but its way to soggy for my liking. again the cheese is really good and sauce as well but the whole thing was hard to eat. i would advertise this as normal pizza but not ny style, if your looking for a crunch in your crust i'd take it home and pop it in the oven yourself. read more

New York Pizza - back off pizza crust no crunch pretty soggy - Pizza Near Me - Taylor, Texas

My husband almost wouldn't go in because it looked really run down, but with 4.6 stars we decided to brave it. Building is dated, but seemed relatively clean inside. Staff was friendly. Being from New York born n raised...this is NOTHING like New York Pizza or cuisine. Pizza crust was good flavor for being reheated, but my Stromboli was raw dough and both were way over loaded with grease and uncooked fillings and toppings. The tomato sauce had good flavor, but was too watery. I did try the pepperoni and spinach knot, both were greasy and way over cooked. I'd try the cook to order once and bet it would improve my rating a little from a 2 to a 3.5. Could have so much potential. read more

New York Pizza - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Taylor, Texas

Amazing pizzas, pastas, and salads! Great service, very friendly. I really recommend this place for lunch or dinner. read more

New York Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Taylor, Texas

Small business, doesn't look like much. But the food is amazing. Give it a try. I had a pepperoni pizza, and was truly impressed. read more

Ok friends neighbors countrymen meatheads and rednecks here it is " some of the best DAM pizza I've eaten if it gets any better than this God himself will have made it, this in my opinion is awesome"!!! read more

Great pizza! Always consistent , fresh and tasty!! We drive 10+ miles to pick up this pizza as it is the best NY style we've had in Central Texas after Carmines left Hutto in 2008! read more

We always get the chicken Cesar salad, 18" supreme and calzones. I haven't found better pizza! MUST stop! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Taylor, Texas

See all