Just ordered carry out. My family ordered a pepperoni pie and a sausage/green pepper/mushroom pie. It was delicious! I placed an order over the phone. They called me to let me know it was ready. I went in the store and the gentleman said he needs one minute because they usually give customers a call as heads up. I told him I was parked illegally (sorry it's Devon 20-30 min before iftar!) so he told me to go wait in my car and brought the pizzas to me. Great service! My family , especially my very picky eater nephew enjoyed it thoroughly! This will be our new family pizza spot! I highly recommend! read more

8/5/2026 This place should be closed for good, this restaurant is totally disgusting, nasty and unhealthy, we order chicken wins,pizza and fries, I can't beginning to tell you how upset I got looking on this food, I took a very small bite the chicken was ROTTEN smelling like poop!!! the fries you can tasted the bad oil they were like rubber. I contacted the CITY OF CHICAGO INSPECTORS, THIS PLACE NEEDS TO BE SHUT DOWN IMMEDIATELY!!!! read more

DISGUSTING & BURNT FOOD, TERRIBLE SERVICE, LONG WAIT, LOW QUANTITY!!!! We ordered a chicken burger, fish burger, fries. The meat itself tasted and looks like it was fried in old oil, the lettuce, onions, and tomatoes used were going bad, and barely any fries given, and bun and meat obviously burnt. I asked the cashier man to make sure it's not burnt but still gave burnt food and when I opened the bag and complained he claimed it's the cheese that's burnt.... and for the fries said, "I actually gave you more fries!" He was very rude. My stomach hurt after read more

See all

Took a chance and wanted to try a new place as I been tryna find good NYC pizza in Chicago and I dont think this is it chile. The pizza itself was okay but as I ate towards the crust the pizza had a very weird perfumey/cologney type taste to it??? It was very confusing and offputting. At first I thought it was maybe the oregano but I dont think it was that so just based on the pizza tasting weird and off I wouldnt reorder. Still on the hunt for now read more

Thin crust pizza is great here. Ajaz makes the best pizza and everything else. Try the wings they are awesome. I love to come here at least 2 times a week. They are very nice and welcoming. read more

Note to self; just don't bother. Based on reviews I take it ordering a full pie is the way to go. Going the route of a slice, the prep in that is passionless. If in need of something to stop hunger pains, I guess a slice could suffice since they are affordable at $2-$3 dollars ea. Slices were salty and of the thin & fold-able variety. It's a Halal pizza joint. It's safe to guess most toppings are made of beef, including the pepperoni. It is then over-salted to mimic pepperoni. So faux-pperoni? It befuddles me why they make a pepperoni-like topping at all. Why not just beef sausage and ground beef or chicken slices? Ps ground beef on a pizza can be a game-changer. Judging from the view-able environs, I doubt another go. I found this place by searching online and placing an order for pickup. A decent (& clean) carry-out shawarma shop inhabited this space years ago (Kabul House express), since that time, it looks as if recent & past owners have allowed cleanliness to leave & never expose itself again. A kid was at the counter when I picked up, maybe 15. We're talking late-night, 2:30ish a.m. To me, high school age kids should be in bed not having to work late-ass shifts. I gave him a couple bucks tip. I wager it's a family owned establishment. I teeter on a 2.5. read more

See all

I have nothing really to say about this place because I ordered online and paid online. When I got to the restaurant, the restaurant was closed. There was a gentleman inside who told me that I could come by tomorrow if you would give me my pizza very confused and went to work with the ordering platform. read more

Disgusting . I ordered fried mushroom and a Philly cheese steak. Idk what they just threw in but I'll let the pictures speak for itself . My Philly cheese steak had ZERO meat. $26 for garbage I won't even let my dog eat. read more

New York Halal Pizza - Not steak - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Took 2 hours to arrive and was not NY style pizza. Ordered through Grubhub and it said 60-70 mins to arrive and I def took much longer. Not worth it The next day the owner called and said he requested 2 hour delivery from Grubhub and I was not notified. Food did arrive hot and may have been an issue with Grubhub. Either way 2 hours is crazy read more

As a halal foodie, this is my favorite pizza spot in Chicago. Be patient in knowing that this isn't Dominoes or that nasty Lou Malnatis or whatevah-- this locally-owned, halal, and has super fresh ingredients! I noticed people expressing their frustration with their order time - pro-tip: they open at 6pm but need at least an hour to make the pizza... because everything here is super fresh! The ingredients are amazing (and honestly exceeded my expectations!) The chicken nuggets are a must-try, some of the best I've ever had! Super crunchy and handmade-- even after arriving from Grubhub. Highly recommend the sausage they put on their pizza--- it's delicious. Crisp crust that's ideal for any NY pizza lover. Perfect amount of cheese and a lot of generosity with the meat. The inside of this establishment is humble and definitely family-run. A good place to do takeout. I experienced excellent service. read more

Used to be a loyal customer for pizza delivery Great pie but the service is making me stop. They sell pizza by the slice which is great, but the owner for no reason decided to make some sexist assumptions when I didnt ask for his opinion. Restuarant is filthy. He didnt heat the slices properly. A few months ago I ordered from him on a Sunday evening and the pizza was so late I cancelled read more

I went there was my first time and the employee nice and friendly owner was sitting right next to it. I asked for BBQ pizza and I don't eat olive and onion so I asked them if they can substitute for something and owner got upset wanted to me pay for and start saying I have to pay out own and my pocket and etc. Apparently I can't used the "word substitute" but he knew what I meant. read more

Ordered 34$ food and I had to trash more than half of it because it was burnt the whole thing such a shame

Having limited options available for Zabiha Halal pizza, I am always on a look out for one. I ordered BBQ chicken pizza that took an hour to get delivered. I can happily say that it was one of the best pizzas that I had in Chicago. It had just the right amount of cheese and a good amount of meat on it. Highly recommend for meat loving pizza fans! read more

New York Halal Pizza - a half eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Food was good, prices on outside menu were very inaccurate compared to actual menu prices inside store.

The pizza is really good here but it's almost impossible to order from them. I understand hours of businesses change...but I swear theirs change from day to day. I have been trying to order for a week and eventually just ordered from somewhere else. It isn't worth the hassle. read more

Ordered the burger with fires an let me tell you them fries!!!! Oohhwwee them thangs were the perfect amount of crunch

Food was tasty and hot. But delivery took almost 2 hrs. I would really appreciate if they work to make deliveries faster.

By far the worst pizza I have ever had in my life. Frozen pizza a better. The two pies I got were burnt and yet so floppy. I threw both in the garbage. I couldn't even feed it to my dog. read more

The pizza arrive over an hour after I purchased it. The delivery person was a very old dude, who told me fell and injured himself yesterday. He was too feeble to climb the stairs. Why wouldn't the New York Halal Pizza give this guy a sick day to recover rather than letting him suffer!?!? Secondly, whole order arrived cold. Cold pizza, cold cheese fries and cools cheese sticks. the pizza had an extra topping that I did not order and the restaurant refused to provide any reparations for and untimely and unprofessional service. :( read more

Best Philly ever. Had a gyro and fries the 1st time I came, if I would have left a review then it would have been 2 stars. But when I taste the philly it definitely made me add 2 more stars read more

The cheesesteak from here is fire. Actually, everything I've tried here is very good. The portions are pretty generous and the owner is the sweetest person. One of my favorite places to eat. read more

What's the point having specials if you won't honor them? Advertising fail, went through the trouble of making an order just to be told they aren't doing specials anymore. Ok, then stop advertising them on your menu. Such a simple basic thing, the management should be disappointed in themselves. If you're taking short cuts in your menu in the front of house, where are you taking short cuts in the back of house. Restaurant red flag 101. Poor kid at the counter was so confused. Customer service was so bad that it's not even worth it, halal or not. So many options for pizza in Chicago, why waste your time here. read more

Great food. The Philly cheesesteak is very good. The staff is also very nice and we're welcoming.

My order was scheduled for 7:20pm, showed up at 7pm. AWESOME! SIKE! Wrong order, plus the restaurant told the driver they just started my order. So around 8:35pm, the same driver shows up, nice dude, made sure he had my order. GRUBTIME! NOPE! Order of wings about the size of a thumb. Wife got a veggie sandwich, no cheese. Sandwich dripping with cheese, plus they forgot her fries. Pizza alright, but this Chicago, alright pizza won't cut it when I'm sober. At least they got the Pepsi right. I hope. read more

New York Halal Pizza - New Style Pizza, more like Suburb Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Excellent New York style pizza! I had a if you misfires calling them up not answering the phone and then ordering on yelp and then getting a notice that they weren't open. The next day I did call in an order and they were open when I went to pick up the pizza they asked me if I was the same man that called the other day and made an order that was not prepared, I said yes and he gave me a free 2 L drink!The pizza was great the closest thing to New York style that I found in the city of Chicago I'll be ordering from them again! :-) read more

I ordered on Yelp (through Grubhub) two hours ago and haven't gotten my order yet, and I've been calling for the past 45 minutes, they aren't answering. Terrible experience!! I could've made my own pizza in this time. Thank you, A very disappointed customer read more

Ew never again!!! Arrived very late but for some reason it smelled so disgusting! made my whole place smell like sweat. Nasty! Had to garbage that right away and sprayed febreze everywhere read more

It's sounds good ny pizza but it's greesy they have to cut down on oil its like flood all veggies floating

I'm from New York so you don't see that style in Chicago very often, this is probably the only pizza in Chicago that I will eat. I can honestly probably eat a whole pie to myself. read more

Had the chitown supreme/classic pizza it was pretty good. Big thin slices and it tasted really good, I'll be coming back for more as a pizza junkie. read more

Amazing Pizza...A hidden Gem That I never knew about until Tonight....The veggies on Pizza were so fresh..Great service Pizza delivered Hot,,,I write very few reviews especially after I eat..Highly recommend read more

As someone from NY, I'm constantly searching for ANYTHING in this barren wasteland of a pizza city that does even a reasonable approximation of New York style pizza. There are a couple of places that are quite good. Jimmy's Pizza Cafe and Dimos Pizza come to mind. Not one of those places delivers to me in rogers park, though. So I was stuck. Stranded. Forced to eat those brittle crackers with sauce and cheese that you people call thin crust pizza or force down your heathonistic tomato sauce and cheese casseroles whenever I ordered pizza. I tried this place several months ago, as I try all pizza places that sound like they have promise. (this one even had New York in the name!) and it was terrible. Tasted more like High School cafeteria style than real new york pizza. (though, to be fair, high school cafeteria pizza in NY is better than the nonsense they serve in Chicago). But I must have just caught them on a bad night. Tonight, I gave them another shot and let me tell you, Chicago, it's everything I ever hoped for. The cheese was gooey and greasy, the crust was equal parts crisp and floppy, folding in half perfectly and still releasing that heavenly crunch on the outside with a doughy chewy center. Is it the solution to all of Chicago's pizza problems? No. But it was pretty damn close to the real thing and they delivered it to me in 30 minutes. It's safe to say I have a new go to pizza delivery joint. Thank you, New York Halal Pizza, for being an oasis in a dystopian pizza wasteland. read more

Love there grilled wings. Taste best with bbq sauce. Also try there BBQ pizza, it's delicious.

Great food , great service , fast delivery. Open late hours. Can't go wrong with chi-town classic

I'd like to review their food, but the Uber Eats delivery guy ate most of it. He showed up at my door 2 hours late and the food was cold and most of my fries were eaten. Maybe next time. Until then, I'll give them a 3/5. read more

First of all, the man is robbing you in plain sight. $22 for a pizza that won't even feed a teen going through puberty. Second, the amount of grease put into it is enough to kill a healthy human being. The service? Don't get me started on that. The man was acting nice but we know deep down inside he was laughing hysterically while we gave him the cash. I also ordered onion rings. $4 for 5 pieces? Are we rationing for a war or something? Chief ima tell you, this place ain't it. Don't go here people. Save yourselves. read more

Great late night snack option, Fresh tasting ingredients with amazing thin crust to match

I decided to try the place out because there are only a few places that offer Zabiha/Halal Gyros Pizza. I ordered a Medium using Slice.com to order online. The parking situation is horrible on Devon, everyone knows that. I think this is something people should know though if they haven't been to that area. You will have a hard time finding parking, unless you are very lucky, or come on certain days and times. The pizza was average at best. It was just pizza, nothing more. There was nothing special about the pizza. I felt like I was eating a frozen pizza that was warmed up for me. As someone that enjoys pizza, and is willing to pay for quality pizza, I was pretty disappointed with it. It did not leave me feeling satisfied at all. I will probably not order from here again. I feel like I would've had a better pizza experience if I just ordered a cheese pizza from Domino's, and spent the money I saved on Gyros slices I could have just put on the pizza myself. Not worth the money at all. read more

Everything here has been delicious! We have had the pepperoni, gyros and sausage pizzas and they were all excellent. Big floppy NY style slices and open mage, cant go wrong with that. Philly cheesesteak was also great - nice mix of meat and veggies with lots of cheese (important for me as other places skimp). read more