We are on the road for hours, We are hungry, We see this big sign that it is a restaurant, We go in, We leave STUFFED. That above is the high level summary. Overall: Price is right with big portions and very good food. We bought a pie to go to give it as a gift and it was fairly priced. The pie was very good - cherry pie to be exact. The toasts and potatoes were tasty. read more

This is ok for a highway stop. Nothing was great. Just ok. *very important * cash only but they do have an atm

Ketchup. I've never seen such an old and stained set of ketchup bottles. But that's just the surface. I can only imagine that a place that's been topping off their ketchup bottles for how many years(?) is likely to take the same shortcuts in the back of the house. If you're not keeping the dining room clean, are they really keeping the kitchen clean? It's not that the place is outdated, it's that it's dirty and outdated. I'm not saying don't eat here--but I am saying that if there's 20 other restaurants within an exit or 2 then visit those first... read more

New Smithville Diner - Stained and dirty ketchup bottle - Diners Near Me - Kutztown, Pennsylvania

Always like stopping here when in the area. The staff has been great, servers check on you often and the cook does a fantastic job. So far I haven't ordered anything I didn't like. The desserts are delicious, though after filling up on the main I have to take the dessert to go. Yes the building is old and a bit ran down but it still serves its main purpose well. Will say the tables could use a good cleaning especially around the edges. read more

See all

Okay, the place is a highway off ramps greasy spoon dinner, so come here expecting that. However I had a excellent breakfast here for very cheap and they made the best piece of scrapple I've had in a long time. Cooked exactly like it should be. read more

I found this place today after parking my semi truck next door. Figured I'd give it a try for lunch. As soon as I opened the door that smell of good hamburgers hit me in the face. I instantly knew what I was gonna get. I got the bacon cheddar burger and it was HUGE! Got the beer battered fries with it. The burger was just like I expected. It was great. The fries were hot and crispy and golden and just awesome! The service here was nothing short of awesome. Very nice conversation with the servers and they actually spent a little time talking to me. I WILL be back every time I come by here. If you come, come hungry! They don't skimp on the portions! read more

New Smithville Diner - Bacon Cheddar Burger - Diners Near Me - Kutztown, Pennsylvania

Terrible food and the service was worse. The corned beef was hard and gross. The "waitress" did not bother to come and check on me. Another employee picked up my plate full of food and did not ask why all my food was still there. When paying for my bill I was asked how everything was. Told her it "was terrible" and got no response. Do yourself a favor and go to the next exit for food. Do NOT recommend wasting your money at this establishment. read more

Had dinner here tonight and it was great! Had the Chopped Steak with gravy, and fries. Delicious! My husband had Liver and Onions, his favorite. It was great! They have a great selection of cakes, pies and ice cream for dessert! Will definitely be back! read more

New Smithville Diner - Their salad is very flavorful, using romaine lettuce, spinach, no iceberg! - Diners Near Me - Kutztown, Pennsylvania

See all

I can't believe I've been driving since '96 and never stopped in this place until couple days ago. The main reason was because I would usually head to Frystown where there was an independent truck stop with a nice restaurant until those Flying J Jerks took over and destroyed the place. This is one of those "don't judge a book by its cover" type of places. The lot is an unpaved disorganized mess. The building looks like a s---hole. And while the inside wasn't too much different the waitress was much friendlier than was expected for an area this close to Jersey. And the food was pretty good too. Next door was the fuel and convenience store building. Which much to my surprise had a Drivers lounge/TV room upstairs. Sure wasn't expecting that. So for now on when stuck in the area I'll probably just shutdown here instead of that FJ or the even crappier TA in Jersey. read more

Okay this place looks an is kinda run down but the food was pretty good burger had good flavor, fries golden hot crispy on the outside soft inside, all around it's not a bad place prices are decent an won't drain your wallet read more

exterior looks sus. dont be wordied though, the food was good. real chocolate milk. chicken fingers and egg omlet was good. home fries were unbelievably delicious. bathroom was very clean and smelled good. service was fine. price was great. read more

New Smithville Diner - the outside of the restaurant - Diners Near Me - Kutztown, Pennsylvania

Trying to find a new spot to eat with the family. We stumbled upon New Smithville Diner. Please don't judge this place by appearance. You will be surprised by what you find inside. BTW we love places like this. The restaurant was Covid compliant. Social distancing was enforced. Wait staff was wearing masks. Tables were sanitized after use. We started our meal with jalapeño poppers. They were not too spicy and had a nice crisp to them. If my daughter ate them then they are not spicy. Drink of choice was coffee. Coffee was filled on a regular basis. Which is a good thing. The coffee had a good fresh taste. I had that Louisiana Panini. I'm sorry to say that it lacked flavor and needed salt and pepper for enhancement. The beer battered fries we're actually cooked just right. Finished up the meal with a piece of carrot cake. Very filling and had to take it home with me to finish. Like I said please don't judge a book by its cover and stop in and give this place a chance. We will be definitely going back. read more

New Smithville Diner - Menu - Diners Near Me - Kutztown, Pennsylvania

As local seasonal campers, this has become our favorite go-to for breakfast and lunch. It's not much to look at on the outside, but don't let that fool you. The food is consistently good, and plentiful. The service is fast and the servers are pleasant and friendly. We are treated like regulars! We have never once been disappointed here. read more

This has to be the worst chicken Alfredo I ever had in my life .Tasted-like flour , salt and butter. staff looks high and kitchen looks rundown and dirty. When my dog doesn't want it either it has to be bad read more

It looks like a five but don't let that stop you- had one of the best patty melts I've ever had with sweet potato fries for only $8.99 and a delicious blueberry pie. The servers were also nice and friendly- want to remember this place! read more

This place is absolutely filthy. The staff was pleasant and the food was respectable. Seriously this place is gross.

Not so great. Maybe a 4 star for the area. I got meatloaf and mashed, average. My wife's eggs were good enough. My sons hot dog looked like it was a week old. They brought him a fresh hotdog. Still a stall bun. So it's up to you. Maybe some where else read more

I drive throughout the country, I love seafood so when I was parked for nite I was excited to see seafood on the menu, to my DISMAY: 1: the food was not cooked thoroughly, fries were soft and flexible, scallops were not cooked properly and left an extremely bad fishy aftertaste, all three did but they were too expensive to waste, fish was undercooked Crab cake had one side soft batter... 2: cocktail sauce still frozen could not use 3: dirty restrooms 4: dirty tables Overall if I was a health inspector, I would have shut this place down.... No refund given Worst $22 of my life and not deserving ANY rating So it is less than one star DO NOT EAT HERE you have been warned read more

I had a chicken pot pie. It was great. There was more in the bowl than I could eat . The dumplings in it tasted homemade. Never a bad meal here read more

I went in this morning and will never go back. The cashier asked some of the other "girls" to take my order and walked away but none of them responded. She came back and decided to take my order but when I told her I wanted number 3 and 9, she claimed she didn't know what that is, rolled her eyes and grabbed a menu. She then asked if I wanted toast and I said yes, wheat bread. She then complained that I said bread instead of toast (common sense should tell her it's toasted wheat bread but I digress). I then asked if I could have corned beef hash instead of home fries, she said they don't have any beef hash (never mind that the number 9 on the menu includes comes with beef hash). The woman was just nasty and angry so I took my business elsewhere. Also, the place is filthy. read more

Drove by this place 1000 times and never thought to stop. Family wanted breakfast for dinner and looked up on Yelp. Doesn't look like much in and out, but people were super nice and food was great! Burgers were HUGE, French Toast was great. And best part, chocolate cake was super rich and cheesecake was tremendous. Would highly recommended! read more

Locally owned off the hiway. The place is great. Friendly staff made me feel as if this was not my first time in to eat. Soup, crabcake, veggies and tapioca pudding for dessert. Oh so good and full. As you drive down the highway and are close this is the place to stop. read more

One of the best little home style diners I've been to in quite awhile. Service was outstanding my cup of coffee never even made to the 1/3 mark without being asked if I want more. The waitress was extremely nice and seemed to be just absolutely loving life. I had a bacon cheddar burger which was the lunch special it was very good, can't go wrong with some homemade chilli. Definitely we'll be coming back if I'm around the area again. read more

Great small diner! My friends and I just stopped in passing by. We ordered a triple decker roast beef club, chicken Parmesan, and two burgers. Food was fresh and delicious! It's hard to find a nice place to eat when traveling but we came in and came out with smiles! Also Pam our waitress was very friendly. Great people and service! I'll be back when I'm passing through Pennsylvania. read more

Was pleasantly surprised! Omelets we're yummy, bacon was as well. Food was very reasonably priced, nice staff and I think the owner was there as well (was also very nice and attentive). Will definitely make this a stop again! read more

Stopped here on the way back to NY from Tennessee as a late-night dinner stop. We showed up a bit after 9pm, after they had already shut down the broiler, but they were nice enough to still seat us. Vibe was friendly, there were quite a few truckers from the truck stop behind the diner still hanging around. The beer battered fries were pleasantly crispy. The Reuben wrap was okay, but the buffalo chicken wrap was very good. read more

Great Food, very Reasonable and very friendly Staff. Don't see many Places where you can have Breakfast for 2 and pay $15. Highly recommend.

What can I say about this place????? The food is so good and the staff so friendly. Must check out the breakfast buffet lIts to choose from

The staff was friendly and courteous however the place was dirty. The utensils were spotty. The eggs had mayonnaise on them and they soaked the bread with butter. read more

I stopped there twice while attending antique radio show last month. Excellent home cooking and friendly staff. WIFI, too!

The New Smithville Diner, has an amazing menu to choose from. The food is outstanding. Today I ordered the Greek Salad, and I have to say that it was the best Greek Salad that I've had in forever. It was huge which required of course a doggie bag. I will be having the rest of it for dinner tonight. I highly recommend the New Smithville Diner if your looking for good food at a reasonable price, this place can't be beat. The staff was amazing as well, so friendly and courteous. Again I've been here three times while my dogs were getting groomed and the food was always delicious, the staff friendly, I would recommend to all of my friends. read more

This place is great. Definitely stop by on you way down the highway. Husband and I both got two completely different things. Definitely get the vegetable soup or chicken orzo and boiled cabbage. Italian trio special is also really good. read more

Food was gross, extremely salty, and the place is dirty. Ordered mozzarella sticks, were burnt. The steak was dry and over cooked. Forgot a kids meal. Better diners in the area. read more

Best chef in tri-cOunty area after 1pm Monday through Friday! Hands Down. Anything labeled as "chef special" is awesome!

This place has the most awesome desserts, and some truly original menu items. Staff is warm and friendly. Your gonna be glad you came here. read more