Cancel

Open app

Search

New Mill Restaurant

4.0 (174 reviews)
Closed • 5:00 pm - 9:00 PM

New Mill Restaurant Photos

NEW MILL RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Classy
Moderate noise
Outdoor seating
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like New Mill Restaurant

Recommended Reviews - New Mill Restaurant

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Susana C.

Loved this place. MAKE A Reservation at holiday season. We came at Christmas time and we had to book ahead weeks in advance. The parking lot is huge and it was difficult to find a spot, ladies have your gentlemen leave you at the front door . Inside is decorated beautifully, not over decorated, but cozy and home like feeling. The staff was wonderful and super friendly. They worked around every single allergy of mine and were wonderful about all of it. The food was delicious and the portions are gracious. The outside I noted had a little pond but honestly we didn't get to check out every detail of the place because let's face it, it's New England in December ... it's freezing cold outside and I was in a skirt. The place is casual wear. I was def overdressed. Def worth a try.

Cavatelli with homemade Italian sausage
Ruth N.

Joined friends here for a Post Christmas dinner couples date; it was the perfect spot, quaint, beautifully decorated and despite being very popular, not at all noisy - we we able to speak and he heard in a normal tone. Our server Monica was the perfect mix of friendly, fun and perfectly accurate and informative- we couldn't have wished for better! The four of us shared the (fried mozz) spiedini appetizer which has now spoiled me for any other "fried mozz" soooooooo delicious and plenty for a party of four! Their cocktails and mocktails were perfect and generous. Our party ordered the cavatelli ( homemade pasta, with homemade mildy spicy Italian sausage) and delicious sauce; the stuffed chicken which quite honestly was one of the most amazing chicken dishes I've ever eaten - two thin golden cutlets with a mouthwatering ricotta, Gouda, spinach and sundried tomato filling - over freshly made mashed potatoes and fresh green beans. I shouldn't forget the warm, freshly baked rolls, butter and dipping oil! So good! This place is perfect for a date night, a group party or even a special occasion!

Crab stuffed cod
Lauren B.

The food and drinks are always amazing at the New Mill, and the portions are good for the price! You can never go wrong with the crab stuffed cod. It's a great spot for date night or to celebrate a special occasion. The parking lot is always packed, so I would recommend making a reservation.

Ivana F.

Wow! The New Mill is my new spot! Everything was perfect including the grounds! Walking in was even enchanting with a garden, bridge and a mill right outside the entrance. The red bar like building has so much charm and character, it made you feel cozy and reminded me a a house similar to Snow White's. The service was superb. Each staff member from hosting/greeting, our server, the manager and even the bussers were so polite and welcoming. My first time at this restaurant and it was a 10/10. They started us off with fresh bread a s olive oil. They also had a special of the short rib with green beans and mash potatoes that my daughter ordered. I ordered the stuffed cod with asparagus and mashed potatoes. Of course I had to try some of hers and both were phenomenal, I couldn't even pick which one was better! I ordered a Josh Cabernet to enjoy with my meal. The portions were generous that I packed half my meal to go and saved room for dessert. Once they told me they made a homemade cheesecake I was sold. They also had a seasonal bread pudding I could not pass up either so we had both. I was celebrating a birthday of someone who is no longer with us and let the server know and they placed a candle on the cake which went the extra mile and made this experience perfect. It was a way they went above and beyond and it was appreciated. I will definitely be back and I can't wait to try some of their other amazing dishes.

12oz  Filet Mignon
Jay S.

I was captivated by the warm and rustic ambiance of this restaurant. The food was simply amazing. I believe they served one of the best steak dinners we've ever had. The flavors of the string beans and roasted potatoes were delicious.The steaks were juicy, well-seasoned, and cooked to perfection.

Allison C.

It's rare to find such a well-oiled machine like New Mill. For a packed Saturday night, New Mill had it together! We went to celebrate my grandfather's birthday and couldn't have asked for a better experience. Our server, Caitlin, was super attentive and even gave my mom a great suggestion of cooking her filet mignon medium rare plus, which we had never heard of before, but it came out exactly the way my mom wanted! Every dish was delicious, and we really enjoyed the vibe of the restaurant too. It's clear to see why you have to make reservations well in advance for weekend dinners here! We will absolutely be back!

very yummy steak
Jay M.

The New Mill restaurant has a New England country home like charm! The decore and seating area is rustic looking and feels cozy and comfortable! The restaurant is definitely a local favorite as it was fairly busy for a Tuesday evening! The server suggested their marquis appetizer: Spiedini Alla Romano (made with mozzarella, battered/fried, and served with a light tomato sauce). I tried it, and it was pretty good, but nothing out of this world! Although Broccoli Rabe was good! For the main entrée, I ordered a very nice NY strip and it was very yummy! All in all, a very nice family friendly italian restaurant with fun decor for the evening! Enjoyed the food and the wine!

Gorgeous decorations!

See all

Photo of Jim F.
0
13
2

19 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

29 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 1

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Rob R.
2
80
1

3 months ago

Excellent been there many times never a bad meal,food is always fresh,workstaff is Excellent

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Great food, not so great service and rude host. Spent a lot of money here over the years so super disappointed

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 136
Thanks 43
Love this 126
Oh no 0
Photo of Laz M.
51
1
0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Erin. S.
163
14
1

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Poor service/management and the food has no flavor. Yes the portions are big but not worth the money. Will I go back hell no!!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 4

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of J S.
0
12
0

6 months ago

Service was good food was terrible!! Not fresh pre made. Terrible! Nice interior and charming but terrible food.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 1
Photo of alyssa m.
161
31
11

1 year ago

Got the crab stuffed cod - it was generously filled and delicious!! Also yummy espresso martinis!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of John G.
15
30
0

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of John M.
72
51
76

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Cassie G.
29
54
156

5 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 1
Photo of Jim O.
0
31
5

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Morgan B.
138
24
9

2 years ago

Cozy and a nice spot for a fancier date night. The service was great and the food was delicious.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 3

2 years ago

My husband had the most amazing steak here years ago and we've vowed to go back. We went when the patio was closed. The view is beautiful.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 1 of 5

Ask the Community - New Mill Restaurant

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Italian 5,262 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Noto Americano - Cajun shrimp Alfredo special

Noto Americano

4.0(78 reviews)
1.6 mi

Decided to try Noto Americano for the 1st time for Father's Day takeout. We ordered the Chicken…read moreParmigana, Lemon Bay Chicken and a Meatball Grinder. The price for takeout for these (3) things were on the high side to not include a side salad. With that said, we were aware that those weren't included as it wasnt listed on their online ordering. We just figured the portion for both Entrees were likely larger and thats why you paid a la carte for the salad. We come back home with the takeout and to our surprise for quite a high price, the portions were small. How small, each meal fit with pasta inside a plastic container, similar to those used for Asian takeout. For any other restaurant that serves Chicken Parmigana, its always been a larger round metal dish with pasta on the side. Typically with 2 pieces of chicken. Putting portion aside as one can argue that we may have been able to find that out before ordering, the (2) entrees were not great. The Chicken Parmigana had one piece of chicken and the chicken was charred, dry, minimal amount of cheese and the both the chicken and pasta itself had a scarce amount of pasta sauce. I found myself having to scrub the side of the dish for any sauce left. The lemon bay chicken was also quite dry and unfortunately the mixture of recip (chicken, pasta and sauce) was quite tasteless. I'm not typically one to leave a 1 or 2 star reviews often, as I'd rather just not go again to the place where I had said experience but between the quality of food, price and portion, this place falls into a bit of an exception for me. Look, I've eaten at many places, if your portions are going to small for the price (and without sides), then the quality needs to EXCEED the excepted regional standard for that dish to justify that reasoning. This experience did not do that, instead we are left with half of take home container of each meal that we will have to toss in trash for Fathers Day.

Such a cozy, moody dining room but still feels family-friendly. The bar and patio look so…read moreimpressive, I'd love to sit out there on a nice summer day! Apps came out before drinks and the food was super quick overall, service felt a bit slower but everyone was still very helpful, and friendly. The cacio e pepe was a little too peppery for me but maybe that's the point, the chicken cutlet was perfect...crispy and juicy and the meatballs had a great little kick. Ended with the cheesecake that was rich and creamy, wish there was a bit more crust. Overall, great vibes and I'd definitely be back to try something different

Photos
Noto Americano - To go area

To go area

Noto Americano - Verdura pizza

Verdura pizza

Noto Americano

See all

The Lab at Factory Square - Stuffed Nachos

The Lab at Factory Square

4.2(48 reviews)
2.3 mi
•$$

The first time we ate here, the food was really great. I really appreciate an inspired menu and you…read morecan tell that the staff have a passion for what they are doing. We couldn't wait to come back. Several months later on our second visit, we arrived well before their posted closing time - 9pm. It was around 7:45pm, the lights were on, but the door was locked and the staff seemed to be cleaning up. One of them looked up, saw us standing at the door and then went back to doing whatever they were doing without bothering to engage with us. It was incredibly frustrating having driven almost an hour with the expectation of getting some delicious food, only to be ignored by staff at a time when they were supposed to be open. Many months later (giving them the benefit of the doubt that the early closure on our last visit was a fluke) we made the trip up again. We arrived to find the place was locked up and dark - again during a time when they were supposed to be open. Today I was with some friends and we stopped to have lunch at Smokin' With Chris next door. During our meal, I mentioned my past experiences with The Lab, but also said how good the food was. So, we walked over to look at the menu and possibly pick up dinner for later that evening. It was around 1:30pm, the lights were off and the door was locked. I double-checked their website, and they were supposed to be open at 11:30am. While I was on my phone, an employee came up, unlocked the door, turned on the lights and began his shift - two full hours after they were supposed to be open! WTF?! Apparently, the owners of The Lab seem to believe that their food is so epic that they can just operate their business whenever they like regardless of their posted hours. This total lack of consideration for their customers is beyond insulting. It's really too bad because the food is good, but not good enough to offset the unprofessional manner the owners are running (or in this case, not running) this place. There are way too many other great dining options available nearby that actually adhere to their posted hours to put up with this nonsense.

We got the Grinder Shaved steak tossed in A-1 steak sauce. It also comes with caramelized onions…read moreand cheese with a Smokey garlic Gorgonzola drizzle all of it baked on a ciabatta bread. Also got a plain cheese quesadilla, Mac and cheese and a burger. The grinder was amazing. So flavorful, fresh and bold. The white cheddar Mac and cheese was pretty good. I do wish my fries were a bit crunchier and not as soft but overall everything we ordered was great. The chipotle aioli on my burger was a nice added bonus of flavor. Messy, dripping with flavor just like I like the food haha. The atmosphere is fun and cute, cool inside with art for sale. And outside you can sit and check out other stores around.

Photos
The Lab at Factory Square
The Lab at Factory Square - Street Corn Chowder in a Bread Bowl

Street Corn Chowder in a Bread Bowl

The Lab at Factory Square - "Golden Snitch Hush Puppies" (golden fried hush puppies served with candied walnut and rum honey butter")

See all

"Golden Snitch Hush Puppies" (golden fried hush puppies served with candied walnut and rum honey butter")

Nataz Restaurant

Nataz Restaurant

4.5(127 reviews)
2.3 mi
•$$$

Nataz in Southington has impressed me once again!…read more We hosted a company dinner here on a weekday evening, and the service was impeccable from start to finish. Management was wonderful to work with, especially when it came to rearranging the space to accommodate our group's specific needs. A special thank you to Chuck for making everything run so smoothly. We had two dedicated servers, Heather and Alex, along with a food runner, and they provided outstanding service throughout the evening. They ensured everyone had what they needed and that meals were delivered promptly. Heather has served our group before, and she continues to be exceptional. She is friendly, attentive, and always goes above and beyond to make guests feel welcome. Every dish I tried was phenomenal. The appetizers were plentiful, and the salads, entrées, and desserts were beautifully presented and full of flavor. If you're looking for a great local restaurant with excellent service, a welcoming atmosphere, and delicious food, I highly recommend Nataz. Whether you're planning a large event or simply dining out with family and friends, you're sure to have a wonderful experience.

Last night was our third time dining with Nataz and first time in the new location. They did a…read morenice job with the new space. It is way more spacious than their previous location and nicely decorated. We sat in a nice Modular Half Moon Restaurant Sofa in the back. Felt like I was looking down upon the rest of the guests having dinner. Nice table just felt a bit like we were on display however I still enjoyed as I love the style of these tables. Our waiter I think was new and definitely did not know wine. We asked for a bottle of the Merlot, which he pronounced back to us "Mer-LOT." I couldn't help but chuckle a bit when he left the table. Someone else came and opened the wine for us and when our main server came to check on us, he grazed the side of my glass and freaked, telling us the glasses are $500 each and if he breaks one, it comes out of his paycheck. Ummm what? This stuff we probably should not know! Again, I think he was new, probably not having much experience as a waiter. He definitely needs training on how to pronounce wine! Moving on to the cheese, they used to give you a cheese board with a few different cheeses. It's a bit different now. They give you whipped butter, a few pieces of cheese (last night was Cheddar), roasted red peppers, and whipped goat cheese with a touch of honey on top and some bread. Not sure if this changes/rotates at their new location. We chose not to do the raw bar or appetizer courses (fyi those are extra). For my salad, I chose the Signature Salad (forgot to take a picture of this course). This is where things went downhill for me. I asked for no apples. He said no problem. He did not tell us they ran out of the dried cranberries and caramelized nuts which to me make the whole salad. I used to love this salad at the old location. So, when telling us the specials he did say he "thinks" they had one salmon entree left, but had to check. Restaurants run out of things, and I get it, but take that salad off the menu if you're out of 2 ingredients and the customer asks for no apples. All that we got on our salads was lettuce, gorgonzola and fried potato skins. I feel like I had French fries on top of lettuce. It was awful. Also, I'm the only one that asked for no apples and my boyfriend got the same salad I got with only potato skins and lettuce and gorgonzola so clearly they were running out of things. We then saw other customers getting the same salad lacking main ingredients. For my entree, I got the Heavenly, which was supposed to have a lobster sauce. I couldn't put my finger on what the flavor of the sauce was. It was strange. It wasn't bad, it just didn't really go with the lobster. It had a brown tint to it. The manager came over after we ate and asked us how things were, and I told him about the salad and asked what the flavor in the sauce was. He told us a crab style sauce which made sense. Boyfriend had the filet. He said it wasn't Ruth's Chris good, but it was good. Mashed potatoes were very bland. Presentation was pretty bad. Dessert they get from a third party. I had the flourless chocolate cake which was the best part of the meal. Desserts are where they have improved with the new location. They used to give you petit fours style desserts, and now they give you full size desserts. It was delicious. I really want to like this place more because I like the concept of what they do. I guess on Wednesdays, Fridays and Sundays the chef creates whatever he'd like for guests for $25 a head. Mystery meals. The manager said that's where the name "Adventures in Eating" comes from. Again, we had come here previously, and I had a problem the last time with the Branzino where the waitress didn't tell me it came as the whole fish. Servers are friendly here, they just aren't top notch. Food is ok.

Photos
Nataz Restaurant - First night in the new space

First night in the new space

Nataz Restaurant - Potatoe croquettes

Potatoe croquettes

Nataz Restaurant

See all

Ideal Tavern - $3 Taco Tuesday

Ideal Tavern

4.0(400 reviews)
2.2 mi
•$$

WING LOVERS... you might want to put this one on your list!…read more This time Good Eats In CT made a stop at Ideal Tavern in Southington, CT Before getting into the food, I had to give y'all a look around because I really liked the vibe in here. From the dining area to the bar, it definitely has that laid-back tavern feel where you can grab some drinks, catch a game and of course EAT! But let's get to why we're really here... THE WINGS! We went with two different flavors, and just LOOK at that sauce on those wings! Nice size, sauced up and served with the carrots and dipping sauce on the side. Sometimes you don't need anything fancy... just some good wings, a drink and a good atmosphere. Ideal Tavern | Southington, CT Have you been to Ideal Tavern before? And more importantly... what's your go-to wing flavor? Follow @GoodEatsInCT for more Connecticut food finds! #GoodEatsInCT #IdealTavern #SouthingtonCT #CTEats #CTFoodie

Popped in for a happy hour as it has been several years since I have been here. Bartender was…read moreawesome, drinks were on point. It was taco Tuesday with $3 tacos, we got four of them to try, carne asada, pork, chicken, shrimp . All really good. Guac and chips- for ne the guac could have used salt or acid but it was and easy fix by adding myself. Truffle fries, good fries, would rather an aioli as opposed to ketchup but to each their own. Arturo for dessert and a lava cake. Bothe really good. Well def be back for another happy hour

Photos
Ideal Tavern - Bar area

Bar area

Ideal Tavern - Mac and cheese

Mac and cheese

Ideal Tavern - Chicken Parmesan

See all

Chicken Parmesan

Back Nine Tavern

Back Nine Tavern

3.7(80 reviews)
0.4 mi
•$$

This place got really busy quick so I completely understood that our waitress was juggling a lot…read moreand wasn't upset that someone else brought out my food. The only minor issue was that my salad never arrived with the rest of the meal, and I had to flag her down to let her know. It was a little strange receiving the salad after I'd already finished my hot entrée. That said, she was working incredibly hard under difficult circumstances. There was a large party that decided to split their checks at the last minute, and she appeared to be handling much of the workload on her own for a while. We were seated outside, and the wind was so strong that it blew my glass of water right into my lap. She noticed immediately and rushed over with napkins, which I really appreciated. She also went out of her way to find a wine chiller for our bottle, which was a thoughtful touch. Most importantly, the food was delicious. Despite a small hiccup with the salad, the service was friendly and attentive, especially considering how busy the restaurant was. Overall, we had a very enjoyable experience and would gladly return.

I recently attended a luncheon here after a funeral. Beautiful grounds, spacious dining area, and…read moreplenty of parking. The catered foods were great. I enjoyed the roast beef and penne alla vodka. It was an open bar, and they served quality drinks. It's a nice restaurant for big parties/celebrations. And I believe the pricing is not bad.

Photos
Back Nine Tavern
Back Nine Tavern
Back Nine Tavern - $20 cheese steak?

See all

$20 cheese steak?

Viron Rondo Osteria - My Mother's Chips

Viron Rondo Osteria

3.7(1.5k reviews)
1.6 mi
•$$$

This restaurant is conveniently located not far off the highway. Although you'll feel like you're…read morein a garden in Italy. The greenery outside of the restaurant is so beautiful and on a beautiful day sitting outside would be a must ! I went to Viron Rondo for lunch with my family and we are glad we did. Although I want to be honest for families with little babies and toddlers. This isn't a family friendly spot. There is no changing tables in the bathroom or tables to place bags on in the bathroom. As a mother- this matters to me so want to help someone else out. The inside is huge and spacious though. The food is freshly made to order in nice huge portions!! Everything was delicious. But we did struggle to get our waitress. Service could use some help as dishes weren't removed from the table until asked. The bread that is provided is soft/flavorful and delicious !!! We got muscles for and appetizer and OmG !! So tender and sauce was so good I couldn't stop dipping the house made bread in it. My mom got the pulpo (octopus) for her lunch with a side of jumbo shrimp. Let me tell you that pulpo was tenderrrrr and one of the best we've ever had !! I had the apple salad with jumbo shrimp! First it's the best salad!! And it can last you for 3 days it's so much!! If they work on service I would so give this place 5 stars. (Oh and my aunt was charged for a club soda with lemon- that's another little downfall) but the martinis were perfectly made and worth the money for sure !!

This place is beautiful and the food okay, but the service is obnoxious and rude…read more Went for our anniversary and was pleased when the host said "Let me start by wishing you guys a happy anniversary!" My wife, must have mentioned it when she made the reservation. If the rest of the staff were so kind, it would've been a great night. The waitress was harsh and cold, and seemed to have a problem whenever we ask for a spoon, a drink, or some bread. She couldn't seem to hide the annoyance on her face. Except when a group of men took the table next to and she fawned over the them for the rest of the night. She must've known it was our anniversary, since the Host made a point of mentioning it, but didn't mention it, so maybe she had a problem with married people. This place has amazing reviews, but I guess it caters to local crowd that doesn't leave Cheshire very often and has been trained to eat mediocre Italian/Mediterranean food that you could easily get at Olive Garden. Left her a 10% tip and I was sorry that I left that much. I should've left zero.

Photos
Viron Rondo Osteria - Large bar area with gorgeous chandelier and stunning flowers.

Large bar area with gorgeous chandelier and stunning flowers.

Viron Rondo Osteria - Grilled Lamb Chops

Grilled Lamb Chops

Viron Rondo Osteria - Fluffy Rolls & Olives

See all

Fluffy Rolls & Olives

New Mill Restaurant - italian - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...