If you are a fan of real, classic, tart frozen yogurt... this is the place for you. This spot is severely underrated. This is a place for froyo purists... tart and one other flavor are the only selections and the toppings are high quality. Pro-tip: go right after it rains to avoid standing in a line. read more

Mythos is not my favorite froyo spot in the city. It was still good but the frozen yogurt itself was not my cup of tea. It was a little too thick and rich (not entirely sure how to describe it). Really great topping choices tho. I loved my combo of pistachio, ferrero rocher, and strawberry. Cute interior. Line was pretty short and went pretty fast too. I'd probably go to another place over Mythos. read more

Mythos - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

If you like a creamier thicker frozen yogurt then this place is for you. Also, $1 per topping and they don't give you a lot. I got a large and 3 toppings: 1. pistachio sauce - 4/5 2. Strawberries: basically one strawberry cut into think slices 3. About 15 blueberries Total Cost $17. I'm more of a pinkberry person. I prefer the tanginess read more

Mythos - Large with pistachio sauce, strawberry, and blueberry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

TL;DR: Froyo is sweeter and barely sour compared to the typical style. Texture is soft, but very creamy and thick. Very high-quality toppings. A bit pricey. Anyway, this is a very recently opened frozen yogurt (or as I will say from now on, froyo) place, so much so that they're in their soft opening. As such, only one flavor (plain) was available, though apparently, the next flavor or two would be here in 2-3 weeks. Due to the froyo craze, there was a large line with 8 or 10 people ahead of me, but it moved quite quickly. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable for how short it's been open, and they have a nice space in the back to sit and eat. The prices are quite high, being $8 for 5 oz, $10 for 7 oz, or the comparatively reasonable $12 for 12 oz. The toppings were the highlight there and were $2 each, regardless of whether they were simply chopped up fruits/nuts, or their more interesting syrups and compotes. These included chopped baklava, a mixed berry sauce, pistachio sauce in both plain and Dubai form, chocolate sauce, two types of Ferrero, including the standard milk and white, another hazelnut sauce, and apple compote, among others. I think some of these are seasonal, but I am not positive. I got a medium size with Dubai and mixed berries, so it was around $14 overall, which sounds like the most 2026 sentence I've ever posted. In terms of the actual froyo, it was much less sour than I expected for the name being Greek, and was much thicker, almost reminding me more of a froyo flavored gelato or something similar, but not milky. The mixed berries added a bit of sourness with some large pieces of compote, while the Dubai had some good pistachio flavor and wasn't too sweet. Overall, it was pricey and decent. I prefer a sourer yogurt, so I personally wouldn't stop in again, but if you like sweet froyo, I'd recommend this place. read more

See all

I've been avoiding this place since several coworkers have mentioned that the small portions that they give don't justify the high prices. It seems like the amount of yogurt you get is highly dependent on the server working that day so when my coworker came back and said she got a huge portion I knew it was my time to try it out! I got a small cup that was piled up high with their froyo along with their Dubai pistachio topping and I really enjoyed it. The pistachio added just the right amount of sweetness and crunch to the yogurt. The yogurt itself was perfectly thick and creamy. Warning: it's pretty tangy so if you're not a big fan of cheesy/dairy tasting desserts this might not be for you. ~$10 for a small with one topping so not the cheapest but it definitely filled me up. read more

Mythos - Small froyo with Dubai pistachio topping - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Ok at best. It's just cold yogurt. Can you even call It Greek yogurt if it's mostly sweet and not tart? I'm ok with this because I prefer sweet to tart but to charge $2 per topping and then give u a teaspoon of topping is wild. I understand that you're paying rent but at least give us a little more! I got a small with 2 toppings and $13 later I'm not truly satisfied. This is a place you try once and only once. There is no appeal to come back. I don't see this place being open very long. read more

Mythos - Ok but for $13? - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I was excited to try this place out. Figured if I go later on in the evening it would not be as crowded. Well I went when there was a pause in a rain storm. Still there was a line. They only allow 6 customers in at a time. I ordered a small regular with chocolate chips. Due to my food allergies I can't have many of the toppings. I told them I was allergic to nuts and the person asked if I was allergic to hazelnuts( isn't that also a nut)? I said Yes. I asked if they could put the toppings on from the back since they are all in containers back there like all the other places I go to do. They said ok. For the price that this was they should be able to put a little more toppings since also that is the only thing I got. But honestly it was too tart for me and the texture just was not doing it for me either. There are better frozen Greek yogurt places in NYC that I would spend my money at. read more

See all

Stopped by on Wednesday afternoon around 4pm and thankfully there was no line. I've heard great things about this yogurt place so I've been wanting to try it especially since their other location is very popular. This place did not disappoint and I loved it! Although it was a bit on the pricier side ($10 for a medium), it wasn't like anything I'd ever tried before. I dislike frozen yogurt but this type of yogurt was very creamy so I enjoyed it. It was definitely more on the tart side but I got the Dubai pistachio sauce and strawberry so it sweetened it up a bit. Would definitely recommend to try this place at least once! The only downside was that there were a lot of flies towards the back of the store where there was seating. read more

Mythos - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Meh, waited in line for this when I probably shouldn't have. The yogurt is overpriced and besides the toppings tastes no different than if you froze the standard Greek yogurt from your fridge. Don't buy into the hype. read more

Mythos - Yogurt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I think this was hands-down the best froyo in the city. We went around 9 PM on a Monday night and there was still a line that took about 15 minutes. They only let six people in at a time to order. It was a bit on the price of your side but they're very generous with the yogurt amount. One topping is $2, two toppings is three dollars etc. but the froyo itself was really good. It definitely tasted less like an ice cream and more like a sweet Greek yogurt. It was more on the creamier side which is how they do it in Greece. The toppings are really yummy. I recommend the Dubai pistachio. read more

Mythos - Dubai chocolate - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

The frozen yogurt itself was good but the pricing is a bit unreasonable for the size. It was about 17$ for a medium with 2 toppings, and the medium wasn't really that big. There was a line out the door when I went as well but service was quick read more

Mythos - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Ok, I came back a second time and it was still just as amazing. I have been on a fro-yo tour lately, Myka, Mimi's, Mythos, Bakery Room, Anita's and a few others. Mythos is still top of the list. Then maybe Bakery Room/Myka and Mimi's tied for second. Mimi's is fun because it is a classic DIY with the yogurt and toppings but Mythos has somehow perfected the perfect balance of creamy and rich, but tart and light and has clean ingredients. It also has elevated toppings and sauces. read more

Decided to give it a try since there was no line when my husband and I walked by! We got a medium frozen yogurt with two toppings and the total came out to $14.15 with tax. A little expensive but I think the price is pretty similar to what we are seeing in the new froyo places in the city. We got the baklava and pistachio sauce as our toppings. The frozen yogurt texture was very thick and creamy. I think they whipped a lot of air in it since the frozen yogurt was very light weight. The texture was definitely very different than any froyo place I've tried but we liked it! The flavor was tangy and not too sweet to me and I also really like both of the toppings. Will probably go back if I'm in the area again! read more

Mythos - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

New dessert spot opened up on the Upper East Side! Perfect day for their grand opening because it was really hot today. Staff were super nice and welcoming. I had first tried Mythos when I was in Aruba and loved it. The yogurt is light, airy with a slight tart taste. Will come back to try their other flavors! read more

Worst place ever. The customer service was terrible. The employee gave me a frozen yogurt that had already been scooped for the customer before me, who only wanted a sample spoon. Instead of throwing it away, they handed that same cup to me without saying a word. I didn't notice until I had already walked out, and I honestly didn't have the energy to go back and argue. This was incredibly unhygienic and showed a complete lack of respect for customers. I definitely won't be coming back. read more

Whoa!! Yes. I don't understand these other reviews. It's crazy good!! Creamy thick texture of like McDonald's soft serve, but a tangy Greek yogurt taste. Toppings are unique & so good. Damnit this is going to be an expensive habit. read more

Very tasty but way overpriced. A small with 1 topping is 10. A small with 2 toppings is 11. Over $20 for two for dessert at a place where you order from a counter and hope to get a seat in the back is really insane. Don't get me wrong - it tastes really good and is creamy with just the right amount of tart. But for that money, I'd rather order really nice pastries or cake and eat at a real restaurant... If upper east siders keep paying this type of money, more places are going to rip off like this one. read more

10/10. Froyo is SO CREAMY and the perfect sweet-to-tart ratio. The toppings are so fresh and fancy. I think about this place every day LOL. read more

Mythos - Atmosphere 10/10 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I am a low cal frozen dessert fan and have been for decades. Tried the Mythos yogurt. Got a plain ( only 1 flavor available) it cost $10 for a medium cup with a huge empty spot in the middle of the cup. A friend of mine had this exact experience. Is this intentional ? Talk about shrinkflation ! While it was tasty it was a bit too tart for my liking. But the big air pocket in the middle made me feel ripped off Being back Tasti DLite !!!! read more

The frozen yogurt is delicious! And the toppings are quite unique, like pistachio cream sauce and baklava crumbles. The problem is the price... We got a small and a large, two toppings each, and the total was $28. I know it's fancy, but this is beyond reasonable. read more

Absolutely delicious, tart and refreshing. The topping variety is excellent! The mango yogurt is sweeter than the plain for anyone who prefers that read more

Overpriced for what it is and the skimpy amount of topping they give you for $2 extra. I was excited and that quickly died down after trying it. Likely will not go back. Also, maybe give all these hospital employees a discount like most of the places in the area. read more

A medium with toppings was 14$, the core was empty and the girl behind me ordered a small which was way bigger than mine. For 14$, you should'nt be able to compress it down to be 6 total bites. You're better off going to butterfield where you get way more for $8. I'm not sure if the girl who made mine was just tired and wanted to go home but as someone who used to work at a soft serve shop you're supposed fill the base to avoid having a hollow center. read more

No clue what all the hype. First of all, it does not compare to Bloomingdale's and Butterfield yogurt. Second, the toppings area is filthy and all the topping are mixing. They use the same tweezer to place fruit each time so it is touching other dripping toppings. If you have any allergies it is definitely not the place for you. read more

Toppings not worth the add on Price 2.00 per topping? For 7-8 blueberries or a tablespoon of smashed baklava Better to get only frozen yogurt and buy own fruit and add it read more

The frozen Yorgurt was too sweet and not tangy enough for my liking. Plus the price was really inflated in my opinion so this is no repeat for me but it seems to be a very popular place if you have a sweet tooth, the line is always long though moves fast. read more

So yummy and creamy, staff was friendly, and comfortable seating area unlike most ice cream shops

we wanted to try this place because of the buzz. waited in a short line. the yogurt is very thick but very bitter and sour! unless you cover it with chocolate sauce, eh. It costs $21 for 2 smalls with one topping. one and done. read more

Best froyo in the city! Love the topping options and the froyo is so creamy and tasty