Lovely place, great for cupcakes. If you want to do custom orders I hear you have to plan in advance that she books up! But when the store is open, there's so awesome selections every time. The place is decorated very witchy? Is that a theme? Well it's definitely themed, there's also pretzels and hot dogs. I'll definitely go back. So much to try. read more

Mystic Sugar Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

This is a really cute bakery that has a lot of fantasy themed cupcakes. When I visited, they had Harry Potter cupcakes and they were delicious! The cake was not dry at all and the frosting was really good as well. It is definitely worth the visit if you are in the area and have a sweet tooth. read more

See all

Not only Delicious, but Beautiful Cupcakes We Absolutely Loved them. They are a nice size and so yummy that even though a little pricey, they are well worth it. They are so gorgeous to look at that they almost look fake. Definitely worth the trip. We tried 4 different flavors and everyone of them were Delicious. read more

Delicious, first time visiting today and resolved our families after dinner sweet tooth. Loved the theme this week - Harry Potter. The atmosphere was lovely, the staff were helpful, friendly and patient as I tried to decide on which flavors to take home. Everything looked and smelled so delicious! We opted for the following cupcakes: Wingardium Leviosa Golden Snitch Ravenclaw Sirius Black Gryffindor Goblet of Fire Slytherin The cake was moist, light, fluffy, and not too sweet or overpowering, the frosting was light, fluffy and perfectly flavored. The ratio of frosting/ cupcake and toppings was perfectly balanced. They were easy to split and share so we each got to sample two flavors each. Will definitely be back again! read more

This place is awesome! Best cupcakes I have ever had. The filling, frosting, and cake itself are all done perfectly! The staff is great and the decor inside is very nice. They do themed cupcakes based off of popular movies every now and then and this weeks was Alice and wonderland. Every cupcake is named after a component within the movies and they even play it on their tv! Such a fun idea. Their Portuguese breakfast sandwich is also very good as well for something more savory. read more

Mystic Sugar Bakery - Portuguese breakfast sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

See all

One of my favorite bakery. Everything is so good here and the staff are just delightful. Can't wait to come back! read more

See all

Bake goods made in house. Lots of options for cupcakes. Most other pastries were already gone when I arrived. The cupcake was moist and not too sweet. The staff was friendly read more

Amazing cupcakes. They look and taste incredible. Grabbed a dozen for a birthday party and everyone loved them. They were very friendly and clearly love what they do. I would highly recommended stopping by when you have the chance! read more

Delicious cupcakes with a melt in your mouth buttercream frosting. Tried several flavors and loved them all! My favorite so far is the vanilla cupcake with a lemon filling and lemon buttercream. Going back for more again and again. Friendly staff too! read more

Fantastic cupcakes and cookies. Great service and ambiance. The cupcakes have been the star at two family birthdays. Super unique flavors and combinations. Thank you! read more

Mystic Sugar Bakery - Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

Amazing cupcakes, we always make it a point to stop at Mystic Sugar when we are in Conway. The cupcakes are wonderful, they are currently doing a Willy Wonka themed cupcakes. read more

See all

Amazingggg cupcakes all homemade everything! The baker is gracious and super friendly! A beautiful business inside too! read more

Got 2 cupcakes, the Salzar and the other one I can't recall the name but bottom line both were excellent. They did tumble around in their cupcake container-but not to worry, we just devoured them anyway...but if appearance is key, maybe don't drive them around the Kanc at a good clip :D read more

AMAZING!! Love, love, LOVE the Pirates of the Caribbean theme. Super cute that they play the movie for you to watch while you're eating too. Every single cupcake was amazing. My faves would be Tia Dalma and the Flying Dutchman for sure. We also got a nice warm cream cheese everything bagel scone and their soup of the day which was chicken pot pie gnocchi (um, YUM). BEST BAKERY IVE BEEN TO BY FAR!! My coworker recommended this place to me and I'm so glad she did. Staff was amazing as well!! Will definitely be back. read more

See all

Best cupcakes I've ever had! Very pricy but it's worth it! I only get them once a year and if I lived closer I would go everyday! read more

See all

The selection was wide and the service was great! A treat worth indulging in while on vacation. The cupcakes were worth going out in a snowstorm. I had to make sure to stop by a second time during my visit to bring a few cupcakes back home! read more

See all

Amazing cupcakes, friendly staff, convenient location. My family grabs a dozen to go every time we head home from North Conway. read more

Oh my!!! Went for high tea on Sunday ( one Sunday per month I think, call for details and reservation). It was exquisite. Lovely both visually and gastronomically. In other words, so pretty and YUMMY. As a a review for the bakery goes, this tea had a sampling of much of their offerings. Their macarons were airy but substantial in creaminess and flavor, and gorgeous. Their scones were so light and tasty I had three! If the canapés and finger sandwiches were a window into what they can do for savory, I will have to assume their breakfast and lunch sandwiches are tasty indeed. The brownies were a perfect mix of gooey and cake-ness, the truffles were pure chocolate decadence, and my personal favorite, the lemon cookies, dreamy!! Even after the whole tea, I rushed to the counter and got the last bag of them! The whole experience was perfect. The ambience was warm and witty and so are the names of their incredible array of cupcakes which my local friends say are delicious! So next time you're in North Conw.... Forget next time, just GO!! read more

See all

Excellent, friendly service! The young woman who baes her own goods is passionate about her products. Baked goods were terrific! Ambiance was cozy, small but comfy and quaint. read more

I'm not usually one for sticker shock since I'm used to NYC prices. I just came from the city a few days ago. Never paid $5 for an albeit jumbo sized cupcake until now. The allure for me was the different flavored cupcakes. However todays offerings and what I saw on their website I was hoping for the Earl grey. No such luck. I got the Witches brew-Coffee-Soake vanilla Cake with Coffee Buttercream and a Chocolate-Covered Espresso Bean. It was fine. But the cake was crumbly is my only issue with this cake. Lots of flavor so they delivered on this. Got the crystal ball- coconut cake with coconut frosting. I didn't taste much coconut in the cake part. The frosting did have a strong coconut flavor. Again, crumbly cake which is annoying. However the most disappointing was the cereal milk tres leche cake. Was told the cereal milk is captain crunch, which sealed the deal for me to purchase. I did not taste an approximation of Captain crunch at all which was a let down. So it was just a saturated milk cake (I didn't taste any condensed milk either). We didn't exactly go out of our way to stop here, so it wasnt wasted time. However 2 cupcakes, and a slice of cake for $18 is pricey IMO. read more

The chocolate cupcakes looked great; unfortunately, they tasted like they came from a box of Duncan Hines mix. The peanut butter buttercream frosting, however, was very good. The service was pleasant. read more

Found this sweet gem while exploring downtown N Conway. Visually the treats are pieces of culinary artwork. I've honestly never bought a large amount of pastries/cupcakes without first tasting but I took a leap of faith! I honestly have to say everything I was told was 100% true! Unfortunately I forgot to ask his name but the husband of the talented Mystic behind the baking is the best supportive glowing salesperson who knows his wife is super talented! This little piggy-great for someone with a lesser sweet tooth. Subtle blueberry and maple flavors and super moist perfection. Frosting was not overly sweet or heavy. The wicked stepmother is wickedly sinful chocolate and raspberry. It looks gorgeous too. Can't wait to tempt my coworkers, family and friends with these yummy cupcakes! Seek out Mystic Sugar you won't be disappointed!! read more

See all

This bakery is a must do! The inside is very well decorated and the treats are outstanding. They offer vegan and gluten free treats also! Win/win for me! The owners are very sweet as well. read more

Mystic Sugar Bakery - Cupcakes and treats - Bakeries Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

Expensive treats but quality! All the cupcakes are beautiful and aesthetic - looks like they were carefully crafted. I thoroughly enjoyed both the peanut butter and vanilla raspberry cupcakes. The chocolate chip cookie was wonderful too! read more

Mystic Sugar Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

The ambiance is quite alluring! Upon entering you will be greeted with a sweet aroma and shelves full of the most beautifully crafted cupcakes. We purchased over a dozen of them. Each are equally rich and flavorful! We also appreciate the shoppe's atmosphere. We had the opportunity to meet the owner who certainly takes pride and ensures quality items with exemplary customer service! We are certain to return. read more

Visit once and you'll be back! It was hard to decide between the gorgeous baked goods. We returned for the delicious, huge, and steaming hot breakfast sandwiches. The staff is friendly and the place is dreamy. Mystic Sugar is a must experience and worth a drive! read more

By far the most satisfied I have ever been with a bakery. Our whole family looks forward to our visit to Mystic Sugar Bakery. Their new location looks phenomenal. They went out of their way to make me an out-of-stock cupcake right before closing. They are truly the kindest people and deserve all the kind reviews they have received. If you are in North Conway, you HAVE to visit this bakery edit: I have of course have returned where I tried one of their breakfast sandwiches. I am convinced there is no better breakfast sandwich out there, especially for the price. They can do it all!! Simply, Shane read more

I have always wanted to come here, and I'm so happy that I finally walked in. The shelves were stacked with all kinds of delicious baked goods. The cupcakes truly looked to die for. I settled on a piece of gluten free coffee cake and gluten free banana bread. My fiancé tried a piece of each and said it honestly tasted as good as the regular versions. if you are gluten free run don't walk here! They had a whole little sections with different cupcakes, breads, muffins etc. I will definitely be back! read more

We were there briefly in October. I'm ready to book another trip just for the brown butter chocolate chip cookies! Absolutely the best I've ever tasted! read more

This is a cute little shop in downtown Conway. These cupcakes are so delicious!! I love the frosting it is so light and fluffy. I got the almond joy and fairy godmother and both were so tasty!! The owners are so nice I went in specifically looking for a cupcake flavor which they didn't have and she offered to make me some for the next day! I thought that was so nice! We will definitely be repeat customers!! read more

Mystic Sugar Bakery - three cupcakes in a plastic container - Bakeries Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

Lovely service and everything we got was delicious! We had the lemon blueberry scone - yum! And the chocolate hazelnut croissant which was filled with Nutella! What a happy surprise. And then the brown butter chocolate chip cookie. And Great Service! read more

Really cute little ...literally...spot. We split a chocolate chip cookie that was so good. Don't miss the unique chandelier. Sorry I didn't take pics. read more

A magical little bakery with the most delicious treats! Something for everyone. GF options as well. So pretty, and the names of the cupcakes and their taste are just off the charts! read more

Mystic Sugar Bakery - OMG YUM!!! A mix of magic and deliciousness all rolled into one!!! A MUST when visiting North Conway! - Bakeries Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

Best cupcakes and awesome maple doodles. A must for pastry - fresh and fabulous! I received a less than fabulous croissant from a different place so I went in search of yummy (having discarded the offending croissant) and I found it here - did I mention they have incredible croissants? Totally saved my breakfast, awesome! read more

This place is amazing and the owners are too. So many things to suggest trying but the cookies are by far the best anywhere. read more

See all

Great little place the cupcakes are absolutely tremendous! My bride had a croissant and scone and loved it! Give them a try you will be happy! read more

This is a perfect bakery in my mind. They had a wide assortment of delicious treats. Jason was very friendly and personable. They have coffee and cold drinks. They offer excellent hot dog combinations for lunch that were so good. We will be back on the weekend to try their breakfast sandwiches. The bakery was warm and cozy inside and we ate at a small table outside. This is really a gem and will be on my radar anytime I am passing through! read more

Delicious! Their chocolate chip cookies are so very good and their dark chocolate cupcakes are So good, thick frosting with glitter but yet light cake. I highly recommend them! We went the day after Thanksgiving and again on Saturday. So glad we are locals so we can go back. read more

This weekend was our first time visiting Mystic Sugar Bakery but it won't be our last! The shop is adorable, has thoughtful touches (like a self use microwave to heat up your desserts), and the baked goods were delicious! We absolutely loved everything we bought especially the chocolate chip cookie and the pecan sticky bun! read more

The brown butter chocolate chip cookie is truly the best cookie I have ever had. Soft and chewy yet crispy, buttery with a great well rounded depth of flavor. read more