Three Sisters Cake Shop

4.6 (15 reviews)

Custom Cakes, Bakeries, Cupcakes

Closed • 9:00 am - 2:00 pm

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Three Sisters Cake Shop Photos

Three Sisters Cake Shop - Wedding cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, New Hampshire

Three Sisters Cake Shop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, New Hampshire

+17

Three Sisters Cake Shop - Signature cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, New Hampshire

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Three Sisters Cake Shop

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Cindy M.

Outstanding!!! I am a longtime customer of Three Sisters Bakery. They always outdo themselves. This time they squeezed me in. I asked if they could add something a little "beachy" to the decoration. They certainly amazed me! The cake came out absolutely stunning! The taste was equally wonderful! You wi) not be sorry with your purchase from Three Sisters Cake Shop.

Annie O.

The worst customer service I have ever experienced. They did not respond to emails or phone calls and when I made a complaint was attacked verbally by one of the owners. Never again. This was our second experience. The first experience was ok. Beautiful cakes....tasted ok.....they know how to decorate but could use some serious customer service knowledge. And don't ask for gluten free or inquire during non business hours as you won't get an answer back.

Lauren B.

Katie and Holly were absolutely amazing to work with; they were super accommodating working mostly over email with me. With less than two weeks notice, they pulled off the perfect cake!! Not only did it look like something off Food Network, it tasted incredible!! Our birthday girl cried when she saw the cake so I'd say it was a massive success.

Our cake was delicious! We got a vanilla cake with vanilla frosting and a raspberry filling for our wedding cake. It was delivered on time and all of our guests commented on how beautiful it was decorated.

Once again Three Sisters cake shop nailed it! My son was beyond happy. Thank you ladies!!!

Tannah P.

Another amazing cake! Looked awesome and tasted amazing. Very happy crowd and most importantly the birthday boy was ecstatic!

See all

Jennifer R.

Elite 26

30

359

462

2 years ago

I am a sucker for cookies and will buy a single one wherever I see them. I picked up a cookie at Fiddleheads Farms today and it was splendid. Perfect. I got a heath bar cookie. It was fat and soft and chewy and moist and delicious. If they pay that much attention to the cookies, the cakes and everything else must be great! read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Dave W.

Elite 26

4

134

12

3 years ago

Ok wait....WAIT! I had a piece of cake from Three Sisters Cake Shop today at the Dover 400th block party. I took it home so I could have it for dessert. I had the signature cake. When I tell you it was the best cake I ever had in my life and maybe the best dessert I've ever had in my 52 years of life, I am not exaggerating. So moist and so damn yummy! I know they also make outstanding wedding cakes because I remember a few years ago, they replicated my in-laws' wedding cake for their 50th anniversary - everyone loved that cake, too. BUT, this signature cake...great job Three Sisters. I am now a HUGE fan! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joe K.

0

1

0

1 year ago

Three sisters cake shop is outstanding. I've had several cakes made here for friends and family and I've been blown away each and every time. The cakes both taste and look incredible and the frosting is not too sweet (like it often is with cakes). Communication with the shop has always been prompt and friendly. I'd recommend them to anyone. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cindy M.

0

2

3

4 years ago

Outstanding!!! I am a longtime customer of Three Sisters Bakery. They always outdo themselves. This time they squeezed me in. I asked if they could add something a little "beachy" to the decoration. They certainly amazed me! The cake came out absolutely stunning! The taste was equally wonderful! You wi) not be sorry with your purchase from Three Sisters Cake Shop. read more

Three Sisters Cake Shop - A "Beachy" cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, New Hampshire

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Annie O.

20

76

66

7 years ago

The worst customer service I have ever experienced. They did not respond to emails or phone calls and when I made a complaint was attacked verbally by one of the owners. Never again. This was our second experience. The first experience was ok. Beautiful cakes....tasted ok.....they know how to decorate but could use some serious customer service knowledge. And don't ask for gluten free or inquire during non business hours as you won't get an answer back. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lauren B.

108

113

28

6 years ago

Katie and Holly were absolutely amazing to work with; they were super accommodating working mostly over email with me. With less than two weeks notice, they pulled off the perfect cake!! Not only did it look like something off Food Network, it tasted incredible!! Our birthday girl cried when she saw the cake so I'd say it was a massive success. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Anna M.

0

12

5

4 years ago

Our cake was delicious! We got a vanilla cake with vanilla frosting and a raspberry filling for our wedding cake. It was delivered on time and all of our guests commented on how beautiful it was decorated. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Taylor H.

210

2

0

4 years ago

We hired Three Sisters for our wedding on 7/9/22 and our wedding cake along with cupcakes were a huge hit! They were affordable and did amazing work!! Very easy to work with and responsive, we are so happy with our decision! :) read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tannah P.

0

6

42

7 years ago

Another amazing cake! Looked awesome and tasted amazing. Very happy crowd and most importantly the birthday boy was ecstatic! read more

Three Sisters Cake Shop - Once again Three Sisters cake shop nailed it! My son was beyond happy. Thank you ladies!!! - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, New Hampshire

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Aidan M.

0

1

0

3 years ago

Cake was decorated very nicely and a good size! However, the cake itself was very dry and dense. It did not taste very good.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Laura P.

1

57

66

7 years ago

What an amazing job!! Cake was beautiful and delicious! Strawberry buttercream! They created a geode cake for my sisters birthday that was absolutely beautiful. I sent photos of ideas I had seen online and they went the extra mile to create the perfect cake and did a better job than the versions in the photos. Cup cakes to compliment the cake we're also delicious! read more

Three Sisters Cake Shop - a tray of cupcakes - Custom Cakes Near Me - Dover, New Hampshire

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kristen C.

1

60

0

7 years ago

Used Three Sisters Cake Shop for our wedding cake and cupcakes. Despite the fact that neither I nor my spouse are usually big cake/cupcake fans, we LOVED Three Sisters Cake Shop. Went to the tasting and ate up every bit of sample! At our wedding, we heard soooo many people exclaim that the cupcakes were amazing. All of our gluten-free attendees were besides themselves with joy over the gluten free cupcakes - those were the first cupcakes to run out! We discovered that most people who had 1 cupcake ended up having a 2nd one later in the evening because they were so good! Cupcakes were delivered on time and setup was beautiful. Most delightful moment came at end of the night, after reception, when we went back to our suite and discovered that 4 of the cupcakes had been set aside for them by event team! They made a delicious 2nd dessert and next-day breakfast :) Overall - Three Sisters Cake Shop was very professional, communicative, and easy to work with. Highly recommend! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Abigail D.

0

1

0

7 years ago

Out of all the custom cakes I've ever ordered, the best tasting came from the Three Sisters. The cake was super fun and just what my 2 year old expected. I will be ordering all our future cakes from here! To put the icing on the cake, the ladies were super friendly and personable. Thank you Three Sisters! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa G.

0

3

2

7 years ago

The most amazing tasting cakes with any design you can imagine! We have gotten cookies cupcakes and cakes and can't wait for our next event to order again! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ashley A.

0

13

0

8 years ago

We used Three Sisters for our wedding cake in September. From the get go, they were easy to deal with, fast in setting up appointments, and our tasting was so much fun. They gave great recommendations for a variety of cakes for our big day, and also helped us plan out the look and feel we were going for with our cake. One of my top 5 pictures from our big day was a picture of our cake table. Everything came together so nicely, and the cake was the most delicious dessert I have ever had! We received many compliments on the cake from our guests too! I would highly recommend Three Sisters for anyone looking for a beautiful creation for your big day! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Three Sisters Cake Shop

1 Washington St
Ste 3142
Dover, NH 03820
Directions
(603) 834-9978
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.threesisterscakeshop.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Three Sisters Cake Shop open?

Three Sisters Cake Shop opens at 9:00 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Three Sisters Cake Shop close?

Three Sisters Cake Shop is closed on Monday and Sunday.Three Sisters Cake Shop closes at 2:00 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

Mon, Sun ClosedTue-Sat 9:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Outdoor Amenities

Does Three Sisters Cake Shop have parking?

Yes, Three Sisters Cake Shop has parking options.

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Custom Cakes 110 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Aubrey's Coffee House and Bakery

4.5

(22 reviews)

4.0 mi

My first visit to Aubrey's was so lovely. My friend's always mentioning how cute it is there, and…read moreI've seen others post about their protein coffees. I was finally able to try out a protein latte myself, and it was delicious. It's MASSIVE, so be prepared for that. I had come for a baby shower, so if you're looking for an intimate space to host an event, look no further!

This is my favorite local bakery!! Everything about it is just so on point…read more The location is a little off the beaten path, so if you didn't know they were here, you might easily miss them... Trust me, you don't want to miss them! The food is incredible (softest and most flavorful bagels in the area hands down), coffees are delicious and they have so many different flavors/ varieties... Baked goods are over the top yummy- and they offer lots of gluten free choices. They also have a salad bar, which I think is awesome! I've yet to try it but everything looks very fresh and they have a wide variety of ingredients available. The atmosphere inside the shop itself is so cute, and the dining room is clean and inviting. Staff has always been helpful and patient with my questions about their available options. And bonus, they have a drink punch card, so as a repeat customer you can earn free drinks, which is always nice! Check them out, you won't regret it.

Photos

See all

Sweetened Memories Bakery

4.7

(31 reviews)

5.0 mi

The cookies and cupcakes are outstanding! I would like to order a cake someday. Just delicious food!read more

Visually the cupcakes look tasty. I got a lemon cupcake described as "filled with pastry cream"…read morewhich it was not. There was about 1 tsp of cream and it was also unfortunately lacking flavor. There was lemon flavor in the frosting but I found the cake texture to be a bit dense, not light and fluffy. Considering the price, $4 a cupcake and it is a size of a cupcake one would make at home I wouldn't return.

Photos

See all

The Flour Girl

5.0

(1 review)

1.3 mi

The baker, Tamia has been making custom cakes for more than 25 years. Her secret, moist cakes are…read morethe best. She decorates to order. We ordered a communion cake that was out of this world. Next it's my birthday cake. Tamia excels at wedding cakes. Please call ahead to order your custom cake. You won't be disappointed. https://www.facebook.com/The-Flour-Girl-323917064824242/

Photos

See all

Baking By Blanchette

5.0

(2 reviews)

6.5 mi

Delicious chocolate cake, woopie pies & strawberry shortcake cupcakes for a 90th birthday party!!…read moreAccommodating & so pretty... a big hit!

O. M. G. These cupcakes were DELICIOUS!! I ordered last minute for Easter and was so happy a dozen…read morecupcakes could be accommodated. The presentation was very professional and they looked so yummy! (I'm sorry I don't have pictures, but they were gobbled up so quickly). I had strawberry shortcake, chocolate peanut butter, funfetti, and maple with brown sugar buttercream. I had the latter. Normally I am not a maple fan but WOW. It was SO GOOD!!!!!! I can't wait to order again!!!

Photos

See all

Pipe Dream Cupcakes

4.6

(22 reviews)

36.4 mi

I needed cupcakes for a company event. I emailed Nadine for a quote and she replied quickly. I…read morewas able to get the whole order done with just a few email messages. When I arrived at the shop to pick up the order, it was beautifully packed and waiting for me in 2 shopping bags. The entire process could not have been easier. We had a large enough order that I had six of each variety she baked that day. The cupcakes are as lovely as they are delicious. My team were having a hard time deciding which one they wanted but the comments on every flavor were very complimentary. I will be ordering lovely treats from Pipedream again. Nadine is great to work with and the cupcakes are fantastic.

I've now had the opportunity to check out the new store a couple of times - a great addition to…read moreNorth Andover! Very cute, also serving coffee and they have tables so you can eat in or take your cupcakes. The selection rotates but they are all good so you can't go wrong by just showing up to see what they have.

Photos

See all

Cupcakes 101

Absolutely amazing!! Ordered again for a baptism and they were a HIT! Friends and family LOVED…read morethem! The staff was so amazing and helpful with recommendations of what and how much to order. Picking up was a breeze! We got funfetti, Boston Creme pie, mud pie, and Gluten Free Apple Pie

Had the most amazing cake pops for a baby shower. The owner was lovely to work with and no one was…read moredisappointed. She created 4 dozen beautiful baseball pops in strawberry, oreo, funfetti, and red velvet. All were just incredible and the intricate baseball design was a home run! (Pun intended). Everyone has been raving about them. I know we will be back for more tasty treats!!

See all

Cupcake Therapy

4.5

(40 reviews)

60.4 mi

I stopped in the other day to get some vegan cupcakes to bring to a dinner party. They had a large…read moreselection of flavors and the cupcakes all looked beautiful. The cupcakes tasted amazing, too! The cake part wasn't super-moist, so it held its shape and tasted great, but the frosting was the real star. The frosting on the lemon cupcake was intensely lemony, and the chocolate frosting was rich and smooth. I and the other non-vegans at the party couldn't tell that they were vegan, and our host was delighted to know that there is a bakery nearby that caters to her needs. I'll definitely be coming back to try the regular cupcakes soon!

I was really excited to try this place! I ordered the dozen…read moreassorted cupcakes and chose a wide variety. The cupcakes are cute, but the taste wasn't the best. We tried the buttercream frosting and the cream cheese frosting. Buttercream frosting was a bit sweet, I preferred the cream cheese. We ordered for the day before the party and put the cupcakes in the fridge. Would recommend taking them out for about an hour so the frosting softens up. TBH the cupcakes were good for allergen friendly cupcakes but if you don't have any allergies then the cupcakes just don't compare to regular ones. I would consider ordering from them again if I needed allergen friendly cupcakes. Otherwise likely would not choose this bakery if I need regular old cupcakes. PS It is delivery only, no pick up option.

Photos

See all

Oreo, salted caramel (vanilla base), strawberry, birthday cake, red velvet and salted caramel (chocolate base)

A Southern Girl Bakery

5.0

(24 reviews)

12.2 mi

On our way to Maine we stopped at this wonderful bakery for a sweet treat. I loved that this is a…read moreblack owned business, and the lovely lady behind the counter was definitely giving Southern charm. She was kind enough to allow me to sample a tea before purchasing. I didn't end up getting it because I'm not a tea drinker. We got a cupcake to share that we thought was coconut shavings on top but it was granola. This is a nut free bakery. The cupcake was decadent and good. I recommend stopping by and enjoying but get there early because I did not know they sold boozy desserts and they were sold out!

They were so helpful with our special order and did SUCH a wonderful job. Communication was great,…read moretiming was great, and everything went really smoothly. The cupcakes were delicious! So happy we chose A Southern Girl Bakery.

Photos

Bourgeoisie cake

Register

See all

Mini S'mores cupcakes

The Cake Fairy

Great customer service. Explained all the yummy choices. I travel an hour to visit this bakery!…read more Best whoopie pies (peanut Butter) and the Banana Boats are simply heavenly. Lady from Gilford, NH

My wife and I LOVE this place. We have had their cookies, coffee cake, brownies, strawberry…read morepastries, Carmel apple bar, Oreo bar (both pictured)....for my birthday tonight we got my favorite...pineapple upside down cake. I included pictures of everything but as of writing the review have only (been there many times before) but have only eaten the PUC and that chocolate mousse "parfait". It's ALL SO GOOD. I wanna make this particular review about this pineapple upside down cake though. It's one of my favorite desserts and I've loved it for years. TCF's P.U.C is PHENOMENAL. It's got this delicious, dense cake that sort of crumbles under your fork, it has almost a biscuity character to it. I'm only trying to make it sound better with that description. It's moist, dense, perfect. I've had PUC where it is more of a sponge cake cake, but there's is on another level. The toppings of pineapple and cherries were equally good and the cake had an amazing caramely character to it. Also not sure if sweet/condensed milk is in the recipe, but I thought I tasted a little in the cake. It was subtle as if they poured a little on the bottom of the box before placing my cake into it. The bottom was perfectly cooked and I got a lot of caramel notes throughout the cake. It had been sitting in the box just long enough to soak up all that delicious moistness, but not so long it lost its crumble or edges. Totally bomb. Totally recommend it! I also want to mention the women that work there are our absolute favorites. We have met 3 or 4 and they are all just entirely pleasant, sweet ladies who always have an engaging story. Very nice people working hard here. I really love this place.

Photos

Espresso cheesecake that almost made me cry it was so good- those pretty stars are edible sugar & don't interfere with texture or taste

Picture says it all. Zoom in to see the little silver stars! Yum yum

See all

Two layers of a cake, chocolate mousse, topped with chocolate sauce, walnuts, and whip.

Cartelli’s North End

4.2

(73 reviews)

3.8 mi

omg the food was so good! Everyone is super nice and the service is wonderfu! my husband and I were…read moresitting outside and the owner came out and had a full conversation with us and she was so sweet! We will be coming back for sure!

Wow!!! Hubby and I…read morestopped here since we received a gift card and had been meaning to go. He made a reservation in advance We were seated promptly and greeted by a lovely server who took our orders. I had pizza and hubby got a pasta dish with meatballs. The pizza sauce was perfect! Not too sweet and the crust was perfection! The meatballs were obviously made with love and care Highly recommend and we will be back

Photos

Meatball appetizer

Shrimp scampi

See all

Calamari appetizer-a large serving. well worth it!

Terra Cotta Pasta

4.1

(11 reviews)

0.0 mi

Terra Cotta pasta, lasagna, desserts etc are perfection. Need to impress guests buy something from…read moreTerra Cotta. Taste homemade.

Love their pastas. Need to try their sandwhich's as well as their soup. Worth stopping by!read more

Photos

See all

I wish they were open more.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Holly M.

1

4

9 years ago

Custom cakes for every occasion!

Three Sisters Cake Shop - customcakes - Updated June 2026

People who viewed Three Sisters Cake Shop also viewed

cake. vegan bakery

12 reviews

The Flour Girl

1 review

Baking By Blanchette

2 reviews

Medovnik Honey Cake

1 review

Confection Art

3 reviews

The Potter's House Bakery and Café

79 reviews

Beth’s Hometown Bakery

1 review

Susie Q’s Cakery

2 reviews

Golden Swan Sweets

1 review

Talula’s

1 review

Three Sisters Cake Shop

Three Sisters Cake Shop Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Three Sisters Cake Shop

Reviews With Photos

More info about Three Sisters Cake Shop

Outdoor Amenities

Ask the Community - Three Sisters Cake Shop

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Aubrey's Coffee House and Bakery

Sweetened Memories Bakery

The Flour Girl

Baking By Blanchette

Pipe Dream Cupcakes

Cupcakes 101

Cupcake Therapy

A Southern Girl Bakery

The Cake Fairy

Cartelli’s North End

Terra Cotta Pasta

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

1 review that is not currently recommended

Three Sisters Cake Shop - customcakes - Updated June 2026

Best of Dover

People found Three Sisters Cake Shop by searching for…

Trending Searches in Dover, NH

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Dover, NH

Browse Articles

People who viewed Three Sisters Cake Shop also viewed

Three Sisters Cake Shop

Three Sisters Cake Shop Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Three Sisters Cake Shop

Reviews With Photos

More info about Three Sisters Cake Shop

Outdoor Amenities

Ask the Community - Three Sisters Cake Shop

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

More businesses like Three Sisters Cake Shop

Aubrey's Coffee House and Bakery

Sweetened Memories Bakery

The Flour Girl

Baking By Blanchette

Pipe Dream Cupcakes

Cupcakes 101

Cupcake Therapy

A Southern Girl Bakery

The Cake Fairy

Trending businesses in Three Sisters Cake Shop's area

Cartelli’s North End

Terra Cotta Pasta

1 Three Sisters Cake Shop review that is not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

1 review that is not currently recommended

Three Sisters Cake Shop - customcakes - Updated June 2026

Best of Dover

People found Three Sisters Cake Shop by searching for…

Trending Searches in Dover, NH

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Dover, NH

Browse Articles

People who viewed Three Sisters Cake Shop also viewed