What a great place. I've had the grandma slice, regular slice and garlic knots and I was not disappointed with any of the food. Definitely worthy of a try for comparison for those in the area. It's easy to miss as its in a obscure location but once you find it you will happy you didn't go pass it :) something with the tomatoes and cheese that make the slices pop and really stick out from the rest. I hope they are around for a long time. Also the staff are very friendly and always have a smile on their face. Great customer service! read more

Stopped in and picked up a pie to go. It was well done like I asked for and was tasty. Sauce had a sweeter taste than I'm used to but it was very good. read more

We have always enjoyed the food hete. Very unique, well prepared dishes. The veal peppericini is outstanding I also have had sausage,peppers and potato dish. Zeppole is a great touch. We highly recommend this place. read more

So fucking good. To the upside down, grandma slice, chicken parm slice. Everything is so good. The bread is so soft and it just melts right in your mouth. They'll even make a chicken vodka pie!! They know what they are doing! Best pizzeria in town, hands down. read more

I've ordered from this place in the past But never had an issue with the.food like I did this time...The stuffed shells tasted sour like the ricotta had turned..which means it wasn't even close to fresh... The chicken cutlet pram tray had some kind of milky white ooze coming from under the breading which resembled nothing I've ever seen before in a chicken cutlet, except in an undercooked egg white. 40$ for this DISGUSTING display of Italian cusine. Never Again..! read more

If you order from them you should do pick up...advertised as a 30-45 min delivery window but ended up waiting 90 mins for the delivery. Also, we live 6 minutes from the place so it makes no sense for it to take this long. Pizza and pasta was cold and tasted horrible. Called twice to confirm delivery and ask for status. We were told the delivery was on its way and it shouldn't be long till we got our food. Wrong. It was another 30 minute wait ... We've ordered from here before and we've always waited a bit but never this long... disappointed that our food was cold. read more

We have been eating here for seven years and now our office is moving to central Islip - how will we survive without Mulberry --by far our number one lunch venue-- Great pizza and Caesar salad slice and a pasta fagoli is to die for--you're treated like family by the owners who are great and Have always been very kind to us--dinner is great too and for lunch they have luncheon sized portions from their dinner menu--i'll still come back for dinner and the pasta fagoli! read more

They have the best garlic knots I have ever had, seriously. Pizza is pretty good too. read more

This is definitely my favorite Italian restaurant/ old school pizzeria in the area. Order by the slice. Or sit down in the back with waiter service. Penna ala vodka is awesome. And the chicken mulberry is fantastic read more

Best pizza in town! Owners are always very polite and they welcome all who enter. Many repeat customers here, they know everyone's name!

Stopped in for a few slices, very fresh, delicious, was not in the slightest disappointed. So good we came back twice in one day ahaha

The pizza was good, except for the chicken francese sauce (we asked for extra sauce on the side) that spilled all over, the lid wasn't put on tight. Still we give them five star, fast delivery. read more

Baked ziti did not taste good $12.98 way too expensive for below average baked ziti Packaging terrible, container split open and paper bag was soaked Will never eat here again read more

Great Food , Great Service , Great Prices you get really good restaurant quality food at Pizza prices the pizza is excellent ,reminds me of growing up in Queens absolutely the best Pizza on LI , Nat And Vito will take really good care of you ,very friendly pace ,they will make you feel at home read more

Friendly service. Ordered plain cheese pie. Half meatball, and sausage. The plain pie was good, quality crust. It all blended nicely. The meatball slice was on the money, very well balanced. The veggie slice with peppers, onions also did it's job. Overall very satisfied. read more

We used to live right behind here and would order pizza and pasta and garlic knots all the time. Hands down their grandma pizza is the best. Miss this place and their friendly staff. read more

Omg, the best grandpa pie I have had and I have lived all over NYC! It's all about the sauce, it has to have the right tang/sweetness and this one does not disappoint, their regular pies are a step above as well (though I have had better... such as Brothers in Queens) Definitely order in the Grandma pie here. The owner is such a nice guy as well, once I forgot my wallet and I drive two towns over for my pies here. He let me go with my order and said I can pay next time. Of course I called as soon as I got home and paid over the phone with my credit card, but still, this is what good customer service and building customer loyalty is all about. My sister-in-law also orders pies from here for all of her parties and she lives a good 30 mins away in Queens! Great owners and great establishment. read more

The delivery guy for this place attacked me while I was walking with my kids. He used racist profanity in front of my three young kids because he thought I looked at him the wrong way. He got out of his car and continued to make threats and yell. I brought this up to the owner and basically it was his son who was the driver, his excuse was that he is all crazy in the head because of covid-19. Dangerous place to go. read more

Even when you eat pizza that you don't like it's usually still worth eating .. well I have finally had a slice that Wasn't worth the stomach space to finish. First time I i ever tossed a half eaten slice in the trash. Not sure if I it was an off day but definitely not worth a trip back .... read more

This is the only place I've found so far that makes a Cesar salad slice and it's amazing!! The counter people always have a smile on their face. I would defiantly check this place out! read more

This has become a weekly destination for my husband and me. The entire staff is so friendly and treats you as their own. Definitely try their Grandma's Pizza, wonderful tomato flavor and killer garlic...two slices is never enough!! Haven't ordered anything we haven't loved. But, if you are dining in the back...give yourself time. It's very relaxed and not a rushed meal. read more

We had to come all the way to Long Island to find a real deal Ny Pizza place, friendly staff and prices right for a family to be able to afford it. I'll leave it with my belly been satisfied and over ate be cause it was that good.. read more

I love my pizza. The grandma slice was awesome. The sauce wasn't overly sweet like most places make them. The crust was njce and crispy. We also tried the spinach slice which tasted great. The pinwheel was pretty good and so was the chicken roll. To top.it off the staff was so pleasant. read more

Should you find yourself in Hicksville out on Long Island, run, don't walk, to this little nondescript gem. It's tucked away in the corner of a strip mall, across the road from a diner that no doubt attracts more traffic, but is dishing out some of the best Italian food I have ever tasted. Ever! That sounds very dramatic, so to tone it down some, how about I say at worst, it was in my top 3 of all time. Of my entire life! And I've been around a while and been to Italy 4 times, so let the gravity of that sink in. I had garlic and olive oil pasta, my friends had shrimp fra diavolo, and fettuccine alfredo. I tasted theirs too and they were all exceptional. My co-workers happened upon it a while back, which is how I eventually ended up there, and they revealed to me that they actually schedule meetings in this area several times a year just so they can go eat at Mulberry St. Pizza. That's a big deal given that they work in Manhattan. read more

Great grandma. High quality simple cheese slice as well. The people and customer service is great as well. Best pizza in the Hicksville area. read more

Hands down this is the best pizza in hicksville, the staff is so pleasant and they have exceptional service. I went in for a late night pizza craving and had a great experience tonight. Love it! read more

Solid pizza, something on the level that you get in the outer boroughs of NYC, tend to find Long Island pizza a bit underwhelming but this place is on the same level. Excellent regular pizza. Also unlike in NYC, lots of parking and easy to get a comfortable place to sit and enjoy the food. read more

Delicious hot cheesy pizza! My cousin and I stopped in for a slice durning my lunch break, and we were super impressed. We walked in and a Sicilian pie was just being taken out of the oven. We both ordered a slice of it, and split a pepperoni pinwheel. It was all delicious and totally hit the spot. We will be going back! read more

The absolute best filet of sole ever!!!! This place is a gem and you could tell the food was made with love!! You cant go wrong with their seafood options!! read more

This is my family's go to place. Tho they have had problems with an order more than once the owner always makes sure it is done correctly. Recently when we went for my moms birthday and the order was messed up he insisted on redoing the WHOLE order because he knew he messed up. Then gave my mom a free cannoli. They really take care of their customers and the pizza is out of this world. I can honestly say it's the best pizza I have had in my life. read more

No awning for this place, but it's right off of N. Broadway. Went in for a quick dinner with the kids and it wasn't busy at all. Ordered a couple of regular slices for the kids, a grandma slice and a sicilian and the only thing that stood out was the grandma slice. Skip the sicilian. read more

The first time I stopped in, I ordered chicken parm on a hero. A smudge pricey but pretty darn good with good quality cheese. 2nd time was last week. Ordered a couple of reg slices and a Sicilian slice. Fanatico has gone down hill so this is my new go to spot for Pizza! read more

First time going, went on the suggestion of my girlfriend's brother and his wife. Walked and in and was greeted right away. Good selection of pies to choose from. Had a slice of pepperoni and a pepperoni pin wheel. Great pizza and knots. The sauce is fantastic. Service is top notch read more

The worst delivery system. Ordered 3 times from them they bring the wrong food or never show because they have the wrong number.

The crispness of the bread, slight astringency of the tomatoes, and mellowness of the cheese have always harmonized into a consistently amazing bite. The only downside is that the inside of the restaurant is rather dark and not all that unwelcoming. There is always parking. read more

Mulberry street used to be me and my families to go spot when we where ordering pizza. Slowly it just became my to go spot because they could never get the pie right that my family ordered. The owners where always there when we ordered so i cant help but think that they just didn't care enough to get our pie correct. I used to go in there to grab a slice but every time i was disappointed so i slowly stopped and changed to Fanatico down the block. If your gonna get pizza from here get a pie. Nothing else, slices taste like they have been sitting there for hours. read more

Great pizza... I'm from out of town and was looking for delivery. I couldn't have pick a better place. Thin pie at a great price... Make sure you are hungry if you ordered the large. read more

The pizza is ok at best for the area. the chicken and eggplant parm are much better though. garlic knots are fair priced

Decent pizza, great meals. Chicken Francese is delish

One of the best kept (italian ) secrets on the island. Food = excellent. Nat and Vito =old school. Cannot go wrong with this place. I give it 4 meatballs. read more