The world's greatest- my first stop when I am in town- best food and service, pizza salads everything!

First time here and I had a lovely meal! Would come back if I am in the area again. Solid pizza and prices.

Well .. I never ate here but I still want to give them five stars because somehow in California I ended up with a frisbee from them and it's my dogs favorite. He's a good judge of character so I'm guessing the pizza is legit .. next time I'm that way I'm gonna try for myself ! read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Swag at its finest - Pizza Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

Once again ordered, some pizzas for my Super Bowl party, place the order on Thursday, for 7 o'clock delivery on Sunday, and you can set your clock to it, arrived right on time, hot, exactly the way I ordered it, that's why say, MARIO'S IS THE BEST PIZZA. The lady that answered the phone, is friendly, courteous, very knowledgeable, and very patient when trying to figure out what to order. read more

I only come here when we're in town visiting family and this is my most favorite place for Grandma pizza. It's always served hot, fresh, and crispy. The staff here are always super friendly. Other things I've enjoyed here are their ziti and chicken roll. Can't wait til I'm back again... read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syosset, New York

The BEST Mario's... no offense. They have the best balsamic vinaigrette dressing! The food is consistent and the staff is friendly. My hands down choice for pizza and Italian food. read more

should listen to customer on how they want they food. not satisfied!!!!!! Ordered garlic knots with extra garlic and oil and it wasn't done how I asked!!!!? read more

An absolute classic restaurant that satisfy all cravings when you want Italian food. The cheese pizzas were delicious with the crust being crunchy and on top of that with ample sauce and cheese. The rigatoni alla vodka was very tasty and I loved how they gave lots of sauce, so that we could dip our garlic knots in it. The service was great where they delivered us our food to our table and the wait was not very long. One of the workers also helped me pack my leftovers to go and cleaned our spot right after we left. Ambiance was great for a Sunday night with lots of customers ready to indulge in some pizzas and pastas. Loved to see it and will definitely be back for more. Food: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Ambiance: 5/5 read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

I've had their chicken and pasta dishes many times and they were very good. I recently tried their pizza and the cheese pizza needed to be cooked a little more but the buffalo chicken pie was cooked perfectly. read more

I come here with the kids all the time. Whether it's for a slice or two, or a family meal for 30 and I need catering. Regardless it's always a good time and the food is always hot and fresh. Go Knicks! read more

Really, really good pizza. First timer here who had heard so much about Mario's and the Greek family that owns it. Well I was the recipient of tremendous Greek and International love, hospitality and lovely food in a warm and family atmosphere at Mario's Pizzeria on Jericho Tpke in Syosset. This is a warm, inviting and immaculate restaurant in a small busy shopping center smack in between the Syosset Hospital and S Oyster Bay Rd. They say a picture is worth a thousand words, a video ten thousand. Please check out the four videos of the gorgeous food plus a couple of photos of the extensive menu. The staff is absolutely stellar - the young ladies at the counter, the kitchen staff in the back and the lovely folks who are constantly clearing and cleaning the tables up front. Smiles galore and just warmth and how I can be of service oozing from all. Mario's features some great appetizers, healthy wraps, salads, hero sandwiches, pizzas, pasta dishes, calzones and some pretty awesome desserts. ( chocolate mousse cheesecake and the cannoli were stellar). They do a lot of catering and the takeout is non stop. I enjoyed sitting inside and dining and can't wait to come back. You have got to stop in and taste this amazing fare. Mario's is about a half a mile west of the 135 Hwy on the south side of Jericho. read more

I'm 65 years old. I've eaten tons of pizza in my lifetime. Mario's is the best pizza I've ever had.

A family classic--always got the house special (meats and veggies and a lot of cheese)

Since I left NY for SF, good pizza and Italian American food is probably what I crave most. And within that genre, eggplant parm hero is the item I enjoy the most. A good eggplant parm hero is hard to find, even amongst the thousands of pizzerias in NY. The best eggplant hero has multiple layers of fried eggplant. In between each layer should be a thin layer of marinara sauce. Top with cheese and stuffed in a good hero bread and then broiled to gooey perfection. It's hard to eat this without burning your mouth because you just can't stop after each bite. The eggplant parm hero at Marios is pretty good, but needs more sauce. They give you 4 layers of eggplant, which is awesome. And there is an ample amount of cheese. If there was more sauce, it would be the holy grail. read more

Marios has the freshest pizza even after 9pm. Everything is fresh, the store os clean and the pizzas keep getting better snd better. They are so cool staying open an extra ten minutes and just made two special slices fresh. They are always generous and friendly. read more

Ordered takeout from Mario's Pizzeria with friends for dinner...placed order online and went to go pick up. Staff was friendly and food ready within 30 minutes. Salad with balsamic vinaigrette for healthy dressing...then adding calories with garlic bread, a whole pie with pepperoni, sausage, peppers and onions (yum), and linguine with clams in white wine sauce. Food was good and everyone filled...it was the right amount for all of us. Have another place on the list for take out in LI... read more

See all

Honestly my favorite place in the area. Quality dough , fresh toppings and friendly smiles all around. Went for the first time a month ago and I've been coming back since read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Salad Pizza Marios Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syosset, New York

As stated, I'm a self proclaimed pizza snob...that being said, as always, I ordered a plain slice and a specialty slice. The plain slice was fine...but just fine. The cheese was melty and the sauce was passable. The specialty slice was basically a "meat lovers" slice. Ample toppings were a nice plus but, as with the plain slice, the sauce was just passable...not great and not bad. All in all, if in the area, it's ok. Just average. read more

Went to meet with my friend, who is a regular and do to some work. The baked ziti was so delicious and customer service was great. I'd highly recommend this place, even though sometimes it's very busy! read more

See all

Just got our pizza, a wonderful Sicilian Vegie pie. My family love it! I wanted to express my gratitude to the chef and the whole team whose skills and service truly made our meal unforgettable. it's one of the best pizzas we ever had and really reminded me that's the reason we get our our pizza here at MARIO'S! Please keep up with the GREAT JOB! David read more

Consistently good pizza - and probably the best pie in the area. Prices are reasonable too.

Very good food. The pizzas are amazing and all of the food has large portions. I've eaten here 3 days in a row.

Okay now this is gas. Last time I tried BBQ chicken, it did not taste good because they put some vinegary bbq sauce but this smoked bbq sauce is valid. Goes perfect w this pizza. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - BBQ Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syosset, New York

Just want to say food is good, but employer and employees are very rude. Girl who answers the phone has no manners and owner didn't give a crap about my complaint. He told me to f myself. Do you want to sorry that place? Think twice and go to a different marios and support them. Not syosset! Nasty people who don't know how to treat customers!!!!! Only reason I have them 1 start is because it wouldn't let me post, Othello they deserve no stars!!! read more

Love them. Order at least once a week and their pizza is the BEST we have found on Long Island!!! Great service and drivers are always the best/great with contact free delivery! Always ask for well done and it comes perfect every time :) read more

Ordered the Grandmas Vodka slice as per my buddy and it was amazing. I'm out here for work a few times a year and I'm definitely adding this is a lunch place of choice! read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Grandmas Vodka Square - Pizza Near Me - Syosset, New York

Mario's house pizza and white pizza are both EXCELLENT! Actually. The best white pizza that I've ever tasted.

This place hasn't disappointed me once. The food is great, and the employees are all nice and very attentive. The place is well kept too.

Place is great! Was in town a week ate here 3 times. Great pizza, great service highly recommend.

Always good food and fresh Smiles everywhere pleases and thank you Very friendly service read more

good pizza but calzone was cold inside but bad service don't come here if your hispanic lol everyome gets service but you i guess even if you came 30 mins before not even napkins or nothing was served so don't come if your hispanic lol read more

THE BEST personal cauliflower crust pizza. Obsessed with the chicken Marsala one. Loaded with chicken and mushrooms. Crispy crust and so tasty! No skimping on toppings here! I work in the area. I've ordered the same from a local place by my house and so disappointed! Not even close to what Mario's of Syosset gives. The chicken francaise one is good too! All their food is delicious plentiful and you get your moneys worth! Next time I have to take a picture and not dig in so fast! read more

This is my daughter's favorite pizza place so I've had the opportunity to try a good variety of their slice selection. All are solid and fresh, but their Grandma slice is my favorite. Just the right amount of basil and tasty sauce, and most importantly the crust is not a greasy mess like I have experienced with other place's Grandma pies. I do not think I have tried any entrees other than baked ziti, so consider this a review for pizza only. Prices are on par for the area, service is always fast and the tables are always clean. read more

See all

Yummy pizza every time! Quick service. Our signature order is the Grandma pie and pepperoni pie. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Pepperoni; Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syosset, New York

Always a good pick. Love their Buffalo pizzas and heroes. An easy night to just relax and order in food.

Have been to mario's Pizzeria several times over the last few months. I have found that the service is always excellent and fast. Pizza has always been good, have had the regular, Sicilian & the grandma styles in the past. One of the nice things about Mario's is if you are staying you pay then sit down and they bring the food too you. That is a very nice service. There dining area is on the large side so generally there is no problem finding a seat. Last night i was in the mood for something other than pizza so i had a Chicken ptarmigan hero to go. Did not call ahead , but only had to wait about 10 minutes , Which is really good. The hero was good, had plenty of cheese and sauce just how i like it. Would recommend Mario's for regular food or pizza. One draw back is that Mario's is in a strip of stores that has very little parking. So far parking has not been a problem for me. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Syosset, New York

Just ordered lunch from here got the thin crust Mario's special personal pizza loaded with so many toppings and so flavorful also got an egg plant slice a side salad and chicken Parmigiana entree and garlic knots highly recommend getting from here anytime read more

See all

I drive by Mario's all the time and never get the chance to eat there. Today was different. We were looking for a lunch/ early dinner, were in the area, so finally gave Mario's a try. We enjoyed a really nice lunch with great service. The spaghetti with meatballs were very good as was the linguini with sausage and peppers. Lunch portions were very ample. The garlic bread and fresh bake Italian bread was also very good. And on this cold day? The after dinner coffee was perfect. One suggestion to management. Please turn up the heat. It was freezing in there! We will be back for dinner. There are many menu items I would like to try. Especially the Branzino and also the Sole Oreganatp. There is also a grilled veggie appetizer that sounded delicious. read more

Peter was great. We (at PM Pediatrics) order from you guys regularly and the food/service is always great- never disappoints! I would highly recommend Mario's to anyone in the Syosset area. Try the grandma slice here, it's one of the best in LI. read more

The pizza is a little soggy but flavor wise it was ok. Good and fast service. Would come back.