I thought it's about time I should try this place. I ordered one of each spinach pinwheel pepperoni pinwheel broccoli pinwheel grandma Sicilian chrustina. I enjoyed all of them. The spinach pin was last one sitting, kinda waiting to be thrown out, I don't know why I ordered it, it was old and burnt, other then that would've been really good. Disappointed about it, $4. I am guessing it was around four dollars each, my bill was $24. They have sitting area in the back. I will definitely go back. If you're around this area pick up a slice or a pie I think you will enjoy it. read more

See all

Located in a shopping plaza. Plenty of free parking. I parked on the side street. Stopped in for a quick pick up I got a slice of grandma pizza. And the slice of chicken Marsala pizza. The grandma slice was thin, crisp, and had a great tomato flavor that didn't overpower the cheese. You could tell the sauce was made with care. The chicken Marsala slice was something different but in a good way. The chicken was tender, and the Marsala sauce gave it this rich, savory flavor you don't usually get on pizza. Crust on both slices was nice, holds up well without being too heavy. Customer service was amazing and they greeted me with care. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Mulberry Pizzeria has great food and service but unfortunately is now closed permanently. read more

Mulberry St. Pizza - Mulberry is Permanently Closed - Pizza Near Me - Jericho, New York

After a fiasco where we unexpectedly had nowhere to leave our car before our 2 week trip, we drove all the way to LI to drop off the car at our friend's driveway. We picked up a Grandma Pie and a Cesar Salad from Mulberry St. Pizza on the way to our friends house. The 3 of us smashed the pizza and the salad. It was great. Very cheesy, super hot. Really hit the spot. Would recommend. read more

Excellent pizzeria the Sicilian pie, grandma pie and regular pizzas are outstanding. The pies were fresh and delicious. The grandma pie and Sicilian was very good. read more

Looks like a pizza joint up front, but serves great dishes in the back dining room. Solid pasta and veal dishes. Complimentary Zeppolis are a bonus! read more

Randomly stopped by for a slice the tomato sauce and the cheese was outstanding as I'm so picky with pizza will definitely be back .

I'm SO sad that Mulberry Pizza closed...it was by far my most favorite pizza ANYWHERE (including NYC!)

This is my local NY Pizzeria on Long Island and they are phenomenal! Love this place for getting my NY Pizza fix close to my house when I have a hankering for good NY pizza and I'm not in the city. They have the second best Grandma Pie I've ever had on Long Island (second only to Umberto's of New Hyde Park which is a pizzeria that is synonymous with Grandma Pie). Also, if you like vodka sauce and you're a fan of Long Island Grandma Pie their Grandma Pie made with vodka sauce is very good and I highly recommend it. Lastly, they have a truly excellent plain cheese slice that stands up well next to many of the delicious slices you can get in Manhattan and Brooklyn (the two NYC boroughs most known for truly delicious NYC pizza). Always fast and efficient and the staff always friendly and helpful. Highly recommended. read more

Mulberry St. Pizza - Excellent plain cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Jericho, New York

See all

My review is only based on their regular slices. They are amazing. Will be coming back!

Great food and great service.....I love this restaurant! Excellent pizza, lasagna and eggplant parmigiana to name just a few!

I hosted lunch with a co-worker of mine. Nat was amazing. Took the order and the pizza and garlic knots and the sauce was not only delicious but hot and so tasty. Our new place to go for company lunches. read more

This place is actually incredible. So hard to find good pizza places these days and this one was INCREDIBLE. Should be 5 stars! Everyone is so nice and welcoming and the pizza is fresh and amazing. GO HERE, you will not be disappointed. Hidden gem for sure! read more

Friendly staff, open late and great selection of slices and pies. Parking can be a little tricky.

Mulberry Street is our go to pizzeria out here in Long Island. We've only ordered pickup (never dined in) from here multiple times but it is still very satisfying. The tomato sauce it perfectly tangy just the way I like it and with the right amount of cheese. They are generous with the toppings if you choose to do that. I do however think their pizza has a little too much crust although that's not even a big deal. I usually like eating pizza crusts, but not from here as I think of it as extra unnecessary calories that's just not worth it (I'm on a fake diet all the time, okay?). Still it is a delicious classic pie. We ordered the linguine with white clam sauce from here once and I thought it was just alright. Overall we will continue to give Mulberry Street our business. I think it serves some fantastic pizza. And quite honestly it's such good pizza that I find no need to try any other pizzerias around the area. read more

Nice old world Italian restaurant. Really good pizza both regular style and Sicilian. Today I tried a calzone. Wow! The best I've ever had. I have tried so many pizzerias and their calzones both in the area and in Queens that I can truly say today's was the best I have ever had. Staff is friendly and very accommodating. If you follow me, you know my number one issue and that is why there's a star missing. Stop in. You will be glad you did. read more

A staple in our rotation. Pizza and food are delicious, and the staff is always super nice.

Ordered here a lot of times already and never disappointed. The pizza is good and service is great. Just ordered delivery for the first time and it came at a decent time! read more

Good pepperoni pizza, Clean, Excellent service, Charges for water, Beer is free ,Simple

literally just came here on a wim because we were on a business trip nearby and wanted NY style pizza and it was so delicious. sausage pizza was unreal, the fresh bread was warm and crispy, and they even threw in some fried dough boys for us that were great. thanks y'all! read more

Mulberry St. Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jericho, New York

I move to California 12 years ago. When I visit my family on Long Island NY I always make a stop for the best pizza. My favorites are the Grandma and Crustina sizes. The brother owners give great service. read more

Mulberry St. Pizza - The best Grandma And Chrustina (tomatoes, mozzarella, roasted red pepper) slices. - Pizza Near Me - Jericho, New York

Amazing italian food on the cheaper side. I was craving pasta so my mom brought me to this place. The bread that came out first was amazing. We ordered two dishes (in the picture) which were also both amazing. I was surprised at how reasonable the prices were for the taste and the amazing service. All of the workers are extremely friendly & helpful. 10/10 would recommend and definitely will be going again read more

Mulberry St. Pizza - Eggplant Rollatine and Seafood Fettucini - Pizza Near Me - Jericho, New York

My friend Art is friends with the owners and he suggested that I give this place a try when I was next on Long Island. I didn't have time to meet up with my friend Art, but I did have time to stop by Mulberry Street for a late night snack. This is why I'm fat. I had two slices, choosing from the ones that were on display behind the glass. The first was served cold, as is appropriate. The Mesclun Salad was very tasty and crisp with a light dressing and some bleu cheese mixed in for bite. Delicious. I had just finished eating that when the second slice arrived, mozzarella, sliced tomatoes and roasted red peppers. Nicely melted from some time in the oven. It had looked awesome on display and it tasted even better on my plate. Great stuff. My only complaint is that their beer selection was a little dismal. They were even out of Heineken so I ended up with a Michelob Ultra. Oh, well. I'd still return and I hope that they'll fix this beer issue. read more

See all

Watch out!! They will overcharge you for your food/drinks. Check your receipt! I called them out when they overcharged me and they said they will re-run the correct amount on my credit card. They re-ran the overcharged amount after I left. When I stopped into the restaurant a week later to request that they resolve this, they said someone will call me to rectify it. After multiple attempts to have them fix this, they never called me or took appropriate action. Crooks! read more

We had some work to do nearby. We had lunch there nearly every day for 3 weeks. Pizza was FABULOUS and I'm New York Italian American! The owners, 2 brothers, are warm and friendly. Can't praise them too much! I just wish jlived closer. read more

See all

Horrible food. My boyfriend and I ordered pizza last night and we got food poisoning. Do not recommend. This is now the second time we ordered from them. The pasta wasn't even edible. The manicotti is pizza sauce. It was gross read more

This is the best pizza on long island! The dough is fantastic, fluffy but crusty in the right places and well seasoned. The sauce has depth of flavor and a richness to it that I haven't seen at other pizzerias. Everyone who works there is super nice and welcoming. My husband and I discovered Mulberry by sheer luck - we just so happened to move nearby. We lived there for 5 years and would get a pie every weekend. We've since moved about 15 minutes away and still come back every week with our kids to get our large cheese pie (lightly baked - makes for a fluffier crust) and garlic knots with a side of sauce. We're going to come back here for the rest of our lives. read more

Take out review Ordered a group lunch. Loved everything. Hot antipasto were all delicious. Stuffed mushroom YUM! last but not least, i loved the Fettucine With Chicken And Prosciutto Alfredo Style. The sauce was thick and flavorful. I was so stuffed and satisfied. read more

Great local spot for some good pizza. Been here couple of times and was not disappointed. Pizza slices were good and the garlic knots were the best. The knots were very flavorful and soaked in olive oil. We liked the pizza slices too. Tried different options and all were good. read more

I have been to this pizza place a number of times, but haven't posted a review. Fortunately, I took notes on at least one dish I ordered for take out, which I will transcribe here. Tale of the ol' tape: Penne alla Vodka Though they give you a large portion size, the pasta was drowning in the sauce, so much so that you'd have extra left over when the penne was gone. I have no problem with that, as the sauce is excellent! Great flavor with a nice tang to it, Mulberry Street makes a solid, extremely tasty and satisfying vodka sauce. Not only that, this dish comes with a dinner roll that has the taste of a biscuit, and is in and of itself excellent as well! I have also had various slices of their specialty pizza, all of which were quite good. read more

Aside from the young girl that tossed the pen at me for me to sign my receipt, I really love the pizza and the gratitude the 2 men gave when leaving. I'm usually really iffy about youngsters working in the food industry because they're usually more careless. Will I order delivery next time? Most likely, that's a yes so I don't have to deal with her again. read more

I came here on a whim needing a quick slice. It was around lunch time. It wasn't crowded, the employees were talking to each other enjoy themselves. I placed my order after they noticed me. He pizza took about 3 minutes to be warmed up in the oven. Not bad. I don't remember exactly but a slice is about $2.75 I think. The pizza itself was horrible. Very salty and almost no sauce. It tastes like cheese on dough with salt. I won't be back. 2 stars, because perhaps the other food items are worth the visit. I wanted pizza and their pizza failed me. If I dined in I would have returned it for a refund read more

Excellent Italian food. A local gem. You won't be disappointed. Pizza is terrific as are their other dishes. read more

Old school family owned pizza place . Excellent pizza and a full restaurant menu . Really enjoy the vibe here , very friendly staff . Reminds me of growing up in Queens . read more

My go to pizzeria! Food is excellent and service is spot on. I always make it a pint to visit when in town.

Although I've lived near here years ago, I never made it in. Today while visiting some family, it showed up on our feed. So we decided to come. There was good parking. We were greeted promptly, we walked inside and found a table for 5. It is spacious. The waiter was great and gave us menu then took our orders efficiently. Some ordered pizza, some fried calamari and some pasta. My nephew says, "the pizza was so good". My daughter says, "the ravioli was great". My sister says, "the zipolines (spell check) were phenomenal". My mom says, " the pizza with vegetables was delicious". I ordered penne with just tomato sauce and I really enjoyed it. The music is on point! Great visit overall, if I'm back I would absolutely consider coming back. read more

Mulberry St. Pizza - Mulberry St - Pizza Near Me - Jericho, New York

Sunday night circa 9pm Bon G. and I wanted to try a new pizza place and Mulberry Street came up. Called and spoke to a very nice Italian Gentlemen and discussed what we wanted to order. We got a half mushroom, half sausage pie and a salad with grated cheese and a couple of peppercinis. Promised in 45 minutes and it showed up in time delivered by a nice young lady with a big smile. The pizza was delicious! wonderful sauce and cheese and plenty of toppings! Crust was outstanding when eaten alone...after eating alll the good stuff....Salad was fresh greens with cucumber, tomato, plenty of grated mozz and the peppercini peppers I requested. We were very pleased with the food and delivery and will certainly try them again in person for dine in. read more

Food: Generic pizza, wasn't anything special. Experience wasn't great. Went there, not that busy. Asked the guy at the counter if they served 'halal' or 'kosher' meat. He didn't know what I meant by it. It felt like he assumed I was asking whether or not they have 'chicken and rice' or something. But I was trying to explain to the guy that 'halal' doesn't mean 'chicken and rice'. 'Halal' and 'kosher' mean that the animal was slaughtered based on the guidelines of certain religions, it's simply raw meat that can be used to make anything. As I was explaining it to the guy, potentially trying to help them grow their business since Hicksville has a lot of people who strictly eat 'halal' meat, the older guy asked the guy I was talking with 'to get back to work'.. even though it wasn't busy. It just felt very rude and they definitely made me feel uncomfortable and not welcomed. I get it, you don't want your employees to have an hour long conversation but it was a 2 min casual conversation about whether or not they offered certain options. If they had an open enough mind, that could help their business tenfold. I, personally, can't stand closed minded business owners and people. It's 2021, worlding is changing. And you are located in an area with a huge amount of people who strictly eat 'halal' meat, what's the harm in trying? You'll gain a lot more customers, all the while maintaining the ones you have. Will not be going back again. Just got a weird, ignorant vibe from the older guy, which may be the owner. read more

They got an amazing bowl of baked ziti which I definitely recommend. If you take leftovers of it home however you'll see it has a lot of oil in it which is kinda gross. read more

Mulberry St. Pizza - baked ziti - Pizza Near Me - Jericho, New York

Pizza was ok.. but their pasta dishes are huge and pretty good! Very good for their price and portions! And linguine white clam sauce is pretty good! read more

Mulberry St. Pizza - Taking a chance on this new spot being new to the area.. let's see how it is - Pizza Near Me - Jericho, New York