Cancel

Open app

Search

Mr Sticky's

4.7 (86 reviews)
InexpensiveBakeries, Desserts
Closed • 6:30 am - 3:00 pm
Updated 3 weeks ago

Mr Sticky's Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Mr Sticky's

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Regular Cinnamon roll with icing on the side
Ian M.

What a delicious treat Mr Sticky's is - the type of rare gem that delivers above expectations and has you dreaming about it the next day. Pulling up to the small house (shack?) where Mr Sticky's is located, you know you're in for either the best or worst cinnamon buns of your life. By the time you get to the window and speak to the extremely kind women running the stand, you know it'll be great. The sticky bun namesake does not disappoint - here you're getting warm, thick, heavy buns. They're so heavy, in fact, that a half dozen will be served in an extra-tick pizza box, which will be caked in even more sugary goodness. I do think the way to go here is a half dozen or more. I got a single cinnamon roll to try the variety, and it wasn't as warm as the buns. I guarantee it would have been just as delicious if it were part of a half dozen though!

Ben J.

The best sticky buns and cinnamon rolls I have ever had in my life. Absolute perfection. Soft, fluffy dough with just the right chew, a generous swirl of cinnamon-sugar filling, and a gooey, sticky topping that's rich without being overly sweet

Cinnamon Bun Peanut Butter Frosting
Jennifer H.

Sticky buns can't be beat! LARGE, gooey on top w/ generous amount of WHOLE walnuts (not crushed pieces). They are sweet, but not too sweet, which is why I recommend walnut version which helps balance that. Cinnamon buns are 2nd best, but still good alternative. Peanut butter frosting is typical, heavily-sweetened, fluff you'd find on any Mennonite-prepared doughnut, but a nice alternative to cream cheese & glad they have it! Fair prices; small location doesn't allow for much on the spot consumption, but this is something u want to enjoy warmed w/ a little butter at home in your fat clothes.

Menu
Micah C.

The sticky buns here are delicious and huge!! My husband and I ordered two to go after our day trip to Lancaster. We heated them up the next day and they were still really good. Fluffy, sweet, heavenly...highly recommend!

Charles B.

Got my sugar high today and it was well worth it, these buns are absolutely delicious.

LOOK AT THE SIZE OF THOSE THINGS!
Jessica G.

SO. TASTY. I don't know how I had gone 10 months living in Lancaster before I realized that Mr. Sticky's was right across from Costco. I was horrified when I found out this tasty goodness had been a mere stone's throw away from my normal shopping point all this time. Went on a weekday, so I did not have to deal with the tourists and business of the weekend. My friend and I split the half dozen regular sticky buns. The lovely woman behind the counter window handed us a box that weighed a metric ton, and the thick scent of cinnamon filled our piggy nostrils. We went back to the car to eat in shame (and air conditioning). She and I split one and felt nearly on the cusp of stroke from all the sugary, cinnamon goodness. IT WAS SO FLIPPIN GOOD, and I'm not particularly a sweet tooth. The buns stay pretty well for a couple days at least, so we had them with coffee in the morning. I just popped one in the microwave for 15 seconds, and it just as warm and tasty as the day I bought them. I think I could probably way overdo it and then get sick of them and need a sabbatical, but I'm honestly terrified at how many calories I will be consuming in my future. You might need a crane to remove me from my house one day. Just sayin.

The "mini" cinnamon buns! Wow!
Doug B.

You know, every area of the country has a "thing" that's very special. Texas has Kolaches, Florida has Cuban sandwiches, and Lancaster has MR. STICKY! These are the most delicious, gooey, and sticky treats you've reverted tasted. Had the mini cinnamon buns. Wow, wow, and double wow! A little taste of Heaven. Try it, you'll love it!!!

Nick C.

Mr. Sticky's lives up to the positive ratings and high expectations. The sticky buns are amazing! I've brought some to parties and to the office and they are always a hit. Can't beat a bun for breakfast with a cup of coffee either!

Cinnamon bun
Dan P.

It really lived up to my expectations and was cheap too. Drove all the way to Lancaster specifically to try these and they were amazing. That said, the buns at Bird-in-Hand were even better. But Mr Sticky's was still amazing and it is very convenient. If you ever have to drive between Maryland and NYC, don't hesitate to take this route through Lancaster.

Wendy C.

Most delicious sticky bun that I had!! I ordered the regular and the cinnamon sticky buns. It was warm and sweet and melted right in your mouth. They were both delicious! I do wish that they had the mini sticky buns available without having to preorder them. The coffee wasn't great and they had no napkins so we had to go back to the hotel to eat. Like come on... who doesn't make a mess with sticky buns? Definitely give it a try if you're in the area! There is plenty of parking and some benches to sit on and enjoy it warm.

See all

Photo of Bob S.
1
36
22

9 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Marcy P.

Marcy P.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Amy H.
14
22
77

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Mr Sticky's Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Mr Sticky's

You might also consider

Rachel's Cafe & Creperie - Exterior

Rachel's Cafe & Creperie

4.5(559 reviews)
3.0 mi
•$$
20 years in business
Locally owned & operated

Best crepes I've had in my life!! I just went gluten-free and have had a hard time finding good…read morerestaurants for breakfast foods. These ones take the cake! Also helps that the ladies serving us were AMAZING & had the BEST energy ever!! We loved our coffee bucket

My partner and I stopped in for brunch on a recent weekday morning. There was no wait, and we were…read moreseated immediately. Our server was friendly and efficient, and the pace of the service flowed well throughout our meal. The restaurant is clean and cozy and the seating area can accommodate different sizes of dining groups. I ordered the Elvis Crepe from the Sweet Crepes section of the menu and a side of Hash Browns with Southwest sauce. They were both delicious and filling, and it was a good combination of sweet and savory. My partner got a Savory Crepe, which he also enjoyed. The only disappointing part of our meal was the iced lattes. We both ordered different flavors - one Nutella latte and one with strawberry syrup. We couldn't taste any of the flavoring in them at all. Had our server not told us which was which, we would never have been able to tell. They just tasted like plain lattes with no added flavor. Especially disappointing considering you pay extra for the flavored syrups. Overall, a great choice for delicious food and friendly service, but maybe grab your latte later from one of the other many coffee shops in the area.

Photos
Rachel's Cafe & Creperie - Mediterranean Crepe with Cheese Turtle cheesecake crepe Almond milk Cafe Latte

Mediterranean Crepe with Cheese Turtle cheesecake crepe Almond milk Cafe Latte

Rachel's Cafe & Creperie - Mediterranean Crepe with Cheese Turtle cheesecake crepe Almond milk Cafe Latte

Mediterranean Crepe with Cheese Turtle cheesecake crepe Almond milk Cafe Latte

Rachel's Cafe & Creperie - Outdoor seating for all seasons

See all

Outdoor seating for all seasons

Lancaster Cupcake

Lancaster Cupcake

4.4(201 reviews)
2.9 mi
•$$

Stopped by just before closing to satisfy a after dinner dessert craving!…read more The cupcakes were absolutely adorable and tasted just as good as they looked. Unfortunately, their most popular flavor had already sold out, but we ended up trying a few of the vegan options along with the Minion-themed cupcake. The designs were super fun, and the flavors didn't disappoint Since it was right before closing, the service was pretty much what I expected. The staff was still friendly, and we tried to be mindful not to keep them too long The cupcakes are a little on the pricey side for their size, but they're well-made, delicious, and beautifully decorated. Overall, it was a great experience, and I'd definitely recommend stopping by if you're in the mood for a sweet treat!

This is a lovely shop, and the employees are always friendly. They have a nice selection of…read moredelicious flavors, and new flavors rotating in monthly. The cupcakes are beautifully decorated and are fresh and delicious. They seem appropriately priced for the quality. The milkshakes and jar cakes are also delicious. They offer a selection of coffee beverages, but I haven't tried any of those yet. There's both indoor and outdoor seating if you want to enjoy your treat right away. Be sure to sign up for their rewards program so you can earn free cupcakes!

Photos
Lancaster Cupcake - Online ordering

Online ordering

Lancaster Cupcake - Chocolate therapy and a peanut butter

Chocolate therapy and a peanut butter

Lancaster Cupcake - To cute little shop, big flavor options!

See all

To cute little shop, big flavor options!

Mr Sticky's - bakeries - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...