Always a 5 stat trip when you go to Nikki's Custard! Tonight's specials were Peanut Butter Marshmallow.....so good.... they are also serving up a Cold Brew Float that was incredible! If you haven't been to Nikki's they are right there with the best of the best in Lancaster County. Great service, their workers definitely care and put effort into making their ice cream products look great! The shop is small, outside seating only. Great designs and design throughout the place! read more

Nikki's Custard - Cold Brew Float - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

We visit often, and it's a half hour drive! It's so worth it. I'm a big fan of the chocolate custard, but the lemon sorbet is tops, too. I love the various toppings Nikki's offers, and the fact that there's new flavors every week. We are big fans. See you all soon!!! read more

Waze took us the wrong way at first but then we found this place on our own, I mean waze just took us across the street for whatever reason. Anyway the ice cream was good from here, service was good. We were in and out. Cute little place. read more

This soft serve ice cream is overrated. Entry and line up is slightly unwelcoming into the building. Cashless only. Small serving size for cost. Just not my"cup of tea". read more

Really good custard, reminiscent of Culver's. I've had chocolate peanut butter most recently and it was really good. My wife enjoys the dairy free offerings. Flavors are switched up often. Not cheap, but the quality is excellent. read more

Saw a line going around the building and figured I had to give it a shot. Funny thing is, I thought the custard was just ok--a place that only offers three flavors of custard needs to knock it our of the park, and the vanilla scoop I got was merely decent. Definitely benefited from the caramel sauce (which they poked a hole in the ice cream for -- interesting delivery method). On the other hand, the vegan soft serve was fantastic when I tried the sample. I'm actually getting that next time I'm around. Service was fast and friendly, place was super clean. read more

Nikki's Custard - Vanilla custard with graham crumbs - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Honestly, I felt happy when I walked into Nikki's Custard. The employees cheerfully greeted me and asked how they could help. First time in, trying to get the lay of the land. I didn't realize that the soft serve was non-dairy and the custard, from the cartons was the dairy custard. Being used to soft-serve (eventhough they're prob the same), opted for that - a combination of vanilla and a cookie flavor. I inquired, can this be done and was informed it could. Yay! I was asked if I wanted to try the non-dairy and since it looked creamy, decided to give it a go, without trying. I was offered toppings and opted for the chocolate jimmies (my favorite). You know what, the soft-serve non-dairy, tasted just as good as the real mccoy! I deducted one star, because I asked for a swirl of flavors and was promised two flavors, but instead; I received one flavor. read more

Amazing custard and customer service! I got a half and half of the vanilla and chocolate custard with raspberry and marshmallow sauces and Oreo and waffle crisp toppings and I'm in awe! The flavor is amazing and the two people working were so kind and I absolutely love the groovy vibes of the mural outside It may be cold but it's never too cold for custard! read more

What a cute place! Service was fabulous - it was our first time visiting and the staff were very good about explaining our choices. My son had the mango and his GF enjoyed the special of the day - espresso chocolate chip. I had chocolate custard with a dark chocolate topping. Flavor was great and I would get it again unless the daily flavor was intriguing. I will go back again. They do close for a short period of time in February/march...it was mentioned on the menu board. The outdoor seating looked cute, but we visited in January on a rainy day so we just ate in our car. (There's no seating inside.) read more

Nikki's Custard - A small size Chocolate custard with dark chocolate topping after a bite or two was enjoyed - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Came here for the first time and it was a good experience! The ladies working there are very friendly. The custard was super creamy! The flavors they had were chocolate and vanilla and their special flavor was chocolate chip cookie dough (though they were out of it when we got there around 8pm). There is a decent size parking lot. From the looks of it, it was a clean facility. Overall would recommend and will return...with friends! read more

Nikki's Custard - Vanilla custards - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

It was so nice to meet the daughter of the owner. She was super friendly and knowledgeable! She told us the difference between ice cream and custard. Let me say their custard is amazing!! I've tried many different ice creams from all over but this is at the top of the list for custard! We can't wait to come back for the next weekly flavor! read more

Service was excellent. I wanted to tip, but was not allowed to. I was told by one of the workers Dana that they are paid well. Both Dana and Bethany provided exemplary service. Will definitely go back when in Lancaster. The pistachio custard was scrumptious! read more

I did not do my research and I did not know that it was card only. I already ordered my food of the raspberry Oreo custard, and then I was holding my cash and the lady said that they were card only. I started to panic, but she said just to have it. It was really nice. The inside was very clean. I would 100% recommend. The custard tasted very fresh. I thank you. read more

Is you want unique flavored soft served ice cream, Nikki's Custard is the place to go. I was in search for a banana soft served and they happen to have it this week. I'm dieting but whatever. I got a pint to take home because it was so good!!! Banana oat milk soft serve is prob the best soft serve I've had. read more

Nikki's Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Yummy creamy custard with fun flavors to pick from! Nice outdoor atmosphere with some seating and water fountains. And YES the spoon changes color! read more

Nikki's Custard - Vanilla custard + rainbow sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Tried the Cheesecake Custard and was not disappointed, looking forward to trying other flavors next visit!

Oatmilk ice cream is amazing and way better than the whole milk options. Service also amazing.

We were a party of 5 with a toddler and it was all so good and delicious!! Out 1st time there will surely go back weekly! Don't forget to join their membership, we gt a custard free. read more

Wow! The special of the day was Chunky Monkey, and it was DELICIOUS! The staff there are great people, we know a lot of them, they are really nice, and they are helpful when you need it! Now let's talk about the ambiance. The parking lot is a decent size, and it's in an okay place, over by McDonald's. A great place to get business! read more

What a fun atmosphere! My husband and I came here for a spontaneous date night and it did not disappoint. The gal who took our initial order asked us if we have ever visited before and then shared with us all the different options we can choose from. I thought that was so considerate! They have dairy free custard. Let me repeat that again, DAIRY FREE CUSTARD. From one person with tummy issues to another, you have to try it! read more

Nikki's Custard - Exterior of the building - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Very friendly, excellent custard! Newly decorated shop, very cute. Staff was knowledgeable and friendly. Offered a free sample. Flavors will change frequently, with vanilla and chocolate always being offered. The owner even came out to say hello! We ordered vanilla custard with salted caramel and pecans. Our adapted version of a turtle sundae. Sundae was delicious! Will definitely go back. read more

This place is magical--the raspberry/mango swirl sorbet is easily one of the best things I've ever put in my mouth. The only not-perfect thing is that the raspberry/mango combination is not available every day, but I'm very excited to try other flavors whenever I'm in town! I hope their business reaches a point where I can buy pints of my fave flavors whenever I want! read more

Stopped for the first time, went inside, no indoor seating with AC, no public restrooms, a few folding, flimsy, low to the ground benches with umbrellas but still outside in the heat and humidity, heat from the paved surfaces and the side of the building. Custard choices were vanilla, chocolate, and raspberry with chocolate chips which were so many mini chips that it overwhelmed the soft, smooth, creamy custard. A dip plus a double dip cost just under $10. Tried it but would not return even though we really love custard. read more

This is the best ice cream/custard I have EVER eaten!!! It's reasonably priced, served with a smile, and absolutely decadent!