Mr. P's Pizza is a Lewes favorite for good reason--the pizza is consistently delicious that keeps people coming back. It's a reliable go-to when you're craving solid pizza done right. That said, be prepared for the crowds. Parking can get tight, and the inside fills up quickly, especially during peak hours. In the summer months, it's extremely busy, and you'll want to call days in advance to place a pickup order - seriously they may say they are too busy to take your order that day so plan ahead. Also worth noting: it's cash only, which can catch first-timers off guard. Despite the logistical challenges, the food makes it worth the effort. If you plan ahead and come prepared, Mr. P's is absolutely worth a visit. read more

We've lived all over and have been so disappointed in both the food scene and specifically pizza here in DE. BUT Mr. P's was great. We decided to finally drive over and try it after an appointment in the area. I'm Gluten Free not by choice and even ordered a second pie to take home! I was really impressed with them immediately asking "Allergy or Preference", it seems like a small detail to others but truly isn't. We'll definitely be back and hope that the quality is still as good. We went mid-afternoon on a weekday and service was great as far as we were concerned. read more

See all

We stopped in on a day trip to Lewes and we were so happy we tried this place before heading back to Cape May on the ferry. We ordered four personal pizzas different varieties. The crust, sauce and toppings were fresh and tasty. The crust had a very pleasing chew - not too thick not too thin. Service was good and our server was very friendly and quick. There is alcohol served as well. It is an extremely casual and family friendly place. Still thinking about the pizza! read more

This is the best pizza in Louis never never get a bad one from them. We enjoy it very much delicious

Pretty laid back and the pizza is decent. Beer selection was nice. This place is better than Grotto pizza

We tried out Mr. P's after seeing a video someone did on Lewes and the pizza looked amazing. Honestly, the pizza was very good. It was the service that was lacking. Our server barely came to our table, and we needed drink refills more than once. The thing that surprised me is there were several people standing around behind the bar doing absolutely nothing at various times while we were there. If this place wants to up their game, their wait staff should watch other server's tables and if the assigned server is busy with something at the time, the other employees should pick up their slack like they do in better serviced restaurants. I mean, a glance at our table would've shown somebody (anybody) that our drinks were out. For what they're charging for pizza, the service needs to be spot on, and it's not. As an aside, and it's not a huge deal, the interior is very dark. They could probably lighten the place up a little. But that's not the deal breaker. I don't know if we will be back. read more

Mr P's Pizza - The outside of the business. - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

See all

I've lived in Lewes now, for 5 years. Read all the good comments about Mr. P's. I could never smell the wood oven. Lotsa 'just ok' pizza places in the area. Recently, I had a contract (close to Mr P) for a month. I had the "2 slice + small soda" lunch 7-8 times the last month. Gotta say, best in the area. Super friendly staff I always get some fresh basil on my slices. Never an issue. Yes. They are the best. read more

Went in and got sat quickly. Waited 10 mins. No server. Finally someone said I'll be with you in a min. Five mins later still nothing. Walked out. Can't comment on the food. But mens bathroom was filthy if that's any indication. read more

I had the displeasure of a slice of pizza at Mr P's today! It was cold raw dough and they would not give me a refund nor would they heat it up! Now I'm sick as a result! I wish I could give it negative Stars! read more

Meh. I wanted to love it but found it to be just ok. We tried to call in an order to pick-up but nobody ever answered. So, we decided to drive over. We put in our order and waited. CASH ONLY. I only carry credit so I had to scrounge for cash before we left the house. I would have tried more, but I only had so much money. The service was pretty gruff. Not quite the Soup Nazi style, but it felt similar. It took a pretty long time for our pizza to come up. About 45 minutes. They said 20. I don't think I would have waited if I knew how long it would take. Particularly since we were waiting. We ordered one Vito (tomato Sauce, shredded whole milk mozzarella, pepperoni, fresh garlic - $15 $18 $20 $25) and one Alla Puttanesca with Goat Cheese (tomato Sauce, shredded whole milk mozzarella, artichokes, capers, black olives, fresh garlic, goat cheese $16 $20 $23 $29). First to the size. The crust on our pizzas was almost three inches wide on each slice. We ordered the medium pizzas which were $18 and $20 respectively. They are supposed to be 13" wide pizzas. But with three inches of crust on each side, there was only about 7" of toppings. Each slice had about 3" of crust and 3.5" of toppings. Maybe we just got bum pizzas but for the money I want more toppings. Good pizza should leave you satisfied. We were full from all the dough but hungry from a lack of toppings. Maybe we just got a pizza maker who likes a super thick and wide crust. It was the same for both pizzas. The toppings were low in flavor and sparse. None of us liked the sauce. The crust was too thick. The crust portion under the toppings was undercooked and floppy and soggy. The portion around the edge was burned and overcooked and thick and it tore up our mouths. I did like that there were lots of locals. Of course, this was off season, but it was still nice. read more

Their pizza is very good, just note that they are a Cash only business, you can't make reservations, must call in your take out order hours in advance if you want it ready at a certain time. Cozy inside with a small bar area. Gets loud sometimes. But a solid pizza place read more

Came here for a slice over Thanksgiving weekend and it didn't disappoint! I sat a the counter with two friend and we each got a slice of pepperoni. It was nice and hot when we got our slices even though they were served out of a case. While we ate our slices we watched them add new pizzas to the rack, which reassured us as to how fresh our slice were. Solid pizza, reasonable and quick! read more

Mr P's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

So let me be fair by saying that I gave them an actual shot. I ordered food at 2:15 in the afternoon and it was ready by 2:30. Shocker, considering that just 2 hours later it would be a three hour wait time for one large and one medium pizza... this is the most disgusting pizza I've ever had. There's no flavor, the dough is not even cooked fully, yet it's somehow burnt to the pits of H E DOUBLE hockey sticks, the ingredients literally fell off of the pizza while you went to pull the slice out. It is burnt, greasy, GROSSSSS!! I'll still drive to Frederica Pizza even though I'm further away. It's sad the Grotto's is better than this place too. We wasted $40 today and the rest of this is going in the trash! read more

See all

An unexpected winner. We left the beach and was heading back to our hotel and decided to randomly stop here since we saw the pizza sign. Turned out to be a great decision. They have good deals - buy a certain amount of slices and it comes with a free soda, etc. Pizza was piping hot, full of flavor and just enjoyable after a full morning in the sun and sand. We sat outside on the benches and ate quickly. Would certainly revisit this beach in the future if we come back. read more

Great pizza. We had the fungi and the quasi vegetarian. Perfect amount of toppings. Really enjoyed the garlic topping! Wood fired, nice melted cheese. Great wings. Got what we ordered service wise. Didn't eat inside soy ambiance was great at home. read more

Good pasta dishes, good service, good prices, really nothing to complain about. Everything tastes fresh and the portion sizes are plentiful. I was not impressed with the soup but that I can forgive because you do not come here for the soup. Their apparent specialty is their wood-fired pizza. The pizza looks great and I watched customers eating it, but it will be something I will be looking to get next time. Otherwise I was pleased with the food and would not mind getting another pasta dish from these folks. read more

Mr P's wood fire pizza is outstanding. Best in the area in our opinion. One of our favorite pizza places anywhere. Service is always reliable and friendly. It's great to watch the pizzas being made from the bar. Great selection of local micro brews to pick from. Place is small but that also works great for service. read more

For the first time ever in my life I threw away almost an entire pizza. I ate one and a half slices but just couldn't stomach the rest. Very doughy, had a nice char in some spots yet somehow tasted very raw. And super super greasy- and it wasn't simply the usual grease of a pepperoni pizza- it was excessive and made the bottom of the pizza totally wet. I am a pizza lover, all shapes, sizes and toppings, but this was simply inedible. read more

Another great location that I can't believe I haven't gone to before!! . Their pizza is delicious & wood-fired. We ordered the classic margarita pizza, and it was fabulous! The crust is slightly hard on the outside but pillowy-soft on the inside, and slightly sweet. The basil was shredded all over - this is great because we constantly ask at pizza places to add extra basil. If you don't like crust (wood fired is yummy & can be dipped in sauce or whatever!), you may not appreciate this pizza as much. The salads were huge - the Greek was tasty and included capers, and my Mom loved the spinach salad. They make their own salad dressing too! The meatball app (3) was tasty too. The marinara and pizza sauce is slightly sweet; my preferences lean toward more tomato or savory, but it was still delicious! They were very professional and friendly. *Note - cash only!! read more

Mr P's Pizza - Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

See all

So happy to be back down Lewes and able to get Mr .P's before the summer crowds. Vito is awesome as usual. Service was great too. Will be back again before the summer months and again in the Fall. Keep up the great taste! read more

Dear Mr P's management.... Please please please put the Fatty Patty monthly special pizza on your permanent menu! It is by far the best pizza I have ever had in my 65 years of life. Pretty please!!!!!!! read more

My family and I have been here multiple times for the Margherita Pizza alone. The dough is delicious and the sauce is different on the Margherita Pizza compared to their standard red sauce. The service is always great and it's a cute little place. read more

Mr P's Pizza - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

The service here was friendly and warm. Our waitress was great. We arrived on a busy Friday night and had a 15 minute wait. Not a problem since they accurately warned us. My vegetable soup was tasty and chock full of fresh veggies. Our veggie pizza was very good.Green salads were fresh. Crust was wood- fired, crisp not burnt. The pizza could have used more cheese and topping though, since the rim of the large pizza extended almost 3" . Some of that area was sauce covered . The crowd was fun. One plus is the range of pizza sizes . read more

The pizza and meatball sub were very good. The service was very slow and it took a long time to get our food (2 slices and a sub).

Great food and service. I seek out great pizza and I just found it! Fried zucchini is good to. Beer list has good variety and the wine pour is great. Lauren is awesome too. read more

This little gem of a place has delicious, wood fired pizza, and a who slew of choices for local craft beers. Our veggie pizza was good... sauce could've had a bit more flavor but the crust made up for it. The variety of beer choices made us very happy. One caveat: they are cash only! But they have an on-site ATM to make it easier for you. We'll be back! Nice to support a family run establishment. read more

Thursday night pizza !! yippee Mr.P's ! we had a delicious pepperoni pizza and spinach salad ! thanks for making dinner for me and my friends after a fun day at the beach ! read more

Great pizza and great service from this place. We had the works pizza and it was worth every penny we paid. The crush was perfect and the toppings were generous. We'll be back on our next trip through Lewes. read more

See all

The is a real deal pizza place. The wood burning brick oven creates near perfect crusts. Toppings are not too ambitious but hit all the usual favorites. Seating is limited and the wait can sometimes be lengthy. Suppose that's the price you pay for delicious pizza. read more

Absolutely love this place. Been coming here every year for 6 years to get the Firecracker Crab pizza the July special. The service is also so great and love what they stand for. Definitely a business worth supporting! read more

Mr P's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

Delicious pizza, fries and side salad. Very friend staff. I've been wanting to try this place for a long time and I finally had the opportunity. Will definitely be back read more

Mr P's Pizza - Woodfired pizza with ricotta cheese and sweet peppers - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

I ordered a X large pizza. The crust was burnt and really thick. The under carriage was under cooked. Really floppy. Had no taste. It was like eating raw dough. Never order again. read more

Very average pizza. Defined pickup time, which is great. But the $8 mozzarella sticks were cold when we picked them up. Pizza crust was burnt on one side and undercooked on the inside. No Wood fired pizza flavor at all. Hopefully it was just a bad night for them, but it was not from them being busy. Best of luck for them going forward.... read more

We are very happy with our experience at Mr. P Pizza & Pasta last Sunday! We were disappointed to find out our usual woodfired pizza place at the beach was having oven trouble and not serving pizza. After researching others in the area, we discovered Mr. P Pizza & Pasta. Service was excellent! Since it was our first time in, the wonderful young lady at the counter took the time to make recommendations and explain the menu to us. We decided on the Margherita and Cheddar and Bacon with white sauce. We sat at the bar to wait and have a drink. A very kind young man offered my boyfriend generous samples when he was having trouble deciding on which beer to try. Ambiance was laid back and most of the patrons appeared to be locals who were there to watch the game. The pizzas were ready in a reasonable amount of time and it was torture having to smell the delicious smells on our drive back to Dover lol As soon as we walked in the door, we both tried a slice and all I can say is WOW! Just the right amount of char on the crust and perfect ratio of toppings and sauce to crust. Mr. P's Pizza blew our former favorite pizza place at the beach out of the water! Based on the great service we received in addition to truly delicious pizza, we will absolutely be back soon! We saw so many delicious options on the menu and can't wait to try them all! Thank you for a wonderful meal. read more

Pizza by the slice is good if you don't mind cold pizza and they won't even slide it back in the oven for 30 seconds

The pizza was pretty good. French fries were brown, cold and limp shoestring fries. (Even though I waited for them to be "freshly cooked".). They were not inexpensive and a real disappointment. Seems the fryer oil needs to be changed as well. read more

Good pizza for take out, but such a weird, politically charged vibe. A hangout for anti-science knuckleheads - - "antivaxxers welcome" sign gives vulnerable people the middle finger. Don't take up a hospital bed if you get sick, dummies. read more

So, I was driving by around 2:45 with a slight hunger and I see a sign saying slices until 3:17. I think to myself ah why not grab a slice of pizza to hold me over until dinner time. I was really impressed with the pie, they make a great wood fired pizza. The dough is fantastic and sauce was sweet and tangy, just right. I had to go back the following days for another lunch special. $6.50, two slices and a small soda. I will be back, next summer. read more

Mr P's Pizza - I did not know they did delivery too. - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

I was on my way to Lewes library and noticed this place as I was driving by. Stopped by on an impulse. Sat at the bar while I waited for take out. The people who work there are super nice. Guy who cooked my pizza showed it off proudly -- that was a hoot. Pizza was really really good. Check it out! read more

Best pizza around GREAT Caesar salad My kids love the funnel fries Great selection of beer Just a great place all around!! waitresses very nice too! Thanks read more